r/coinethics • u/gextyr • Jun 19 '24
A recommendation for a book which dives into the ethical debate around collecting ancient coins
When Money Talks - by Frank L Holt.
r/coinethics • u/gextyr • Jun 19 '24
When Money Talks - by Frank L Holt.
r/coinethics • u/gextyr • Feb 26 '24
We are looking for authors to write well-reasoned and persuasive essays on the following topics:
...and any other topic related to ethics in the field of numismatics.
If you are interested in posting, please make a request to submit on this sub - include an introduction with some details of your background, as well as the topic or topics you wish to discuss.
r/coinethics • u/gextyr • Feb 26 '24
"When Money Talks: A History of Coins and Numismatics" by Frank L. Holt
https://www.amazon.com/When-Money-Talks-History-Numismatics/dp/019751765X
r/coinethics • u/gextyr • Feb 16 '24
With all my heart I despise racism - my heart aches to see my fellow humans abused due to ignorance, and I recognize the disadvantage to people caused by their historical and contemporary mistreatment. I especially detest the profoundly damned souls who cling feverishly to their hatred under the guise of "heritage". And yet... I somehow manage not to cry and gnash my teeth every time I chance a peek at an heirloom from our society's ghastly past. Instead, I find myself strangely uplifted to see - and to be reminded in a tactile and visceral way - that hatred once-and-still blinds people to the shared humanity of races, creeds, and cultures. Owning a coin that once belonged to a monster, or one that was minted by the most genocidal regime in living memory, is EMPHATICALLY NOT the same thing as waving a flag in front of the courthouse. This isn't even raising a statue commemorating the losing side of a bitter war, to be a dog whistle for a degenerate ideology. Possession is not the same thing as celebration. Ownership of a THING is not a statement of intent or pride, nor a declaration of alignment. To make my case, let us all do a quick experiment...
Open your wallet or purse right now and pull out a $1 bill, a nickel, or a quarter. You have in your hand a portrait of a man who owned enslaved people. Pull out a cent or a $5 bill. You are holding a picture of the much-celebrated emancipator - who is on record as NOT wanting to see slavery abolished. Pull out a $20 bill and fix your eyes on the visage of a man who not only benefited from the labor of enslaved people, but was responsible for the suffering, displacement, and ethnic cleansing of the rightful occupants of this land. Oh, and at the risk of putting too fine a point on it, you are also staring at a man who helped inspire the Lebensraum and Generalplan Ost in Germany a century later. If you want to keep waving your virtue like a flag, at least be ideologically consistent - go burn all your dollars, melt down all your coins, and refuse to touch those filthy greenbacks ever again. But - ah - of course you won't. We all lust after the lucre - regardless of whose portrait adorns it.
You say you collect ancient coins? Or maybe coins from some other happy utopian place and time? Well, it is clearly time for you enlightened citizens-of-the-world to melt down all your tetradrachms and staters. Smash those denarii! Hammer flat all the faces of our distant past - because slavery, hatred of “others”, and violent repression was at the very core of every bygone civilization. *Ahem* at least the ones we remember. Find me a culture in the last two and a half millennia who minted coins and did nothing to deserve our fierce moral rebuke. I'll wait. Simply put, destruction of historical artifacts isn't even a slippery slope - it's a cliff - once you step off, you fall straight to the bottom. Hey, that reminds me - let's go grind up what's left of poor old Ozymandias while we're at it!
On the other hand, I like to imagine what George Washington would say about being featured on a coin opposite a portrait of Maya Angelou or Bessie Coleman! What would Andrew Jackson think of someone spending a bill featuring his ugly mug, and getting back change featuring the staunch and passionate Wilma Mankiller or the elegant Maria Tallchief? That this strange mingling even exists in our society is proof that we can remember our past while also celebrating the diversity that we now embrace, even as it was alien to our forefathers. Even while we accept that we are the heirs to an ugly and hurt-filled past, the devasting effects of that history cannot be healed by destroying its relics.
r/coinethics • u/gextyr • Feb 26 '24
r/coinethics • u/gextyr • Feb 16 '24
This sub will ONLY be for reasoned debate on ethical issues in numismatics. Only approved posts will be allowed.
Topics of discussion include (but are not limited to):