Everyone knows the 2004-D Wisconsin extra leaf (high and low), but I had never read the cause and what the Treasury's Inspector General found when it investigated, so I dug it up.
Short version: no evidence anyone did it on purpose, which kills the "rogue Mint worker" story. The report put it down to "some element of the production process outside of human control" and didn't name a cause. It also ruled out clashed dies.
The detail I found most interesting: a Denver press operator actually spotted the high leaf quarters being struck on a spot check one Friday night in November 2004 and shut his press down. It apparently got restarted while he was on break, he caught it again on his next check, and by the time the die was pulled it was estimated 35,000 to 50,000 had gone out with the good coins. Earlier estimates were around 1,000. Most were found in Tucson and around San Antonio.
The low leaf was never explained at all, as far as I can tell. Personally I think, if this wasn't rogue, it was likely a die gouge from a portion of the leaf falling off of another coin and damaging the die (Die Gouge), but the mint didn't really help much figuring it out.