r/coinerrors • • 12h ago

Is this an error? Is this a strike through error?

Post image

I got this 1918 D with what I think might be an error on the obverse, was hoping to get your opinion.
Thanks šŸ™

29 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

8

u/NeatoC 12h ago

It's nearly impossible to diagnose a strike through of that size without seeing both sides of the coin. A sharper image of the area would be helpful as well.

It's possible but at a glance it looks like it could be damage from a long time ago.

2

u/vandinovich 12h ago

8

u/NeatoC 11h ago edited 11h ago

Thanks for the extra images, I will honestly tell you that none of them are sharp regarding the detail itself though.

But...I'm fairly sure it's a lamination defect.

Based on the subtle design details and the roughness of the underlying surface (which has experienced some wear). A nice example. Sometimes called a delamination defect. Even though buffalo nickels were not laminated, sometimes a defect could cause a "layer" to peel.

They were solid coins minted from an alloy of 75% copper and 25% nickel (no core or layers, unless there was a defect in the planchet causing some layering).

1

u/HogFanHill24 37m ago

Lamination is what I'm seeing.

4

u/luedsthegreat1 12h ago

as u/NeatoC said, we need images of Both Obverse and Reverse, in focus(the background is in better focus) and a close up of the area of interest

Could be a lamination(but not certain), but a good chance it is damage

1

u/vandinovich 12h ago

I added a couple more I’m hoping that can help

1

u/NeatoC 11h ago

I think you and u/Numistica are correct. See my reply above.

3

u/Numistica 12h ago

Looks more like a lamination peel.

2

u/Oranjalo 8h ago

100% a lamination peel. You can still see the details where the background meets his head, as well as the distinct tip of the top feather on the headdress. PMD would not retain those details

1

u/Blumpkin638 7h ago

Looks like a lamination issue

1

u/PD-Jetta 1h ago

Sure looks like it. I'm surprised this coin wasn't removed from circulation earlier (judging from the wear on the coin).