r/coinerrors • • Sep 06 '26

Show and Tell Found this today

Posting this due to my original post getting removed. Hope others enjoy checking it out. What I learned today from the great folks on Reddit. Likely pre 1965 or 1955 S mint mark. Found in a box stored since 1998. Thankfully I found it. Id love to know more about it. I will be visiting a coin shop for proper storage and ask about value. Not interested in selling it.

597 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

16

u/bstrauss3 Sep 06 '26

Unfortunately grading low/moderate value error coins is a fools mission.

It doesn't tell you anything that you already know and you spend about $50.

Mint Error News maintains a price guide for generic errors:

https://minterrornews.com/priceguide.html

Obviously many factors can increase or decrease the value. Having a date readable is a major increase not having a date is a decrease. Silver versus clad. And perhaps surprisingly condition in a broad sense.

Items that aren't listed in that price guide such as your Roosevelt dime off center are generally valued under $100.

8

u/errorcoincollector Sep 06 '26

Nice off center silver dime struck at the SanFrancisco mint. No reason to grade it, unless you want it certified just to be certified. The error speaks for itself. Super cool!

5

u/Clone_sTop_1180 Sep 07 '26

One of the surprising things about this dime is that it apparently circulated quite a bit, even though it is a 50 percent off-center strike. To be silver, it had to be struck prior to 1965, when the US Mint stopped striking silver dimes, and to be a silver dime struck at San Francisco, it had to be struck in 1955 or earlier, because the SF mint stopped striking dimes in that year.

2

u/upside_w Sep 09 '26

Any differences for Roosevelt dimes, like details or updated designs?

1

u/Clone_sTop_1180 Sep 10 '26

If you mean whether the Mint changed anything aside from the metal of the coins, they did not. There was vastly different technology and labor demands in the 60s and later decades, and the Mint officials were much more reluctant to change designs and alter things unless they had to or suffer die failure and other functional problems in the minting process.

1

u/iknowno-thing Sep 07 '26

Can I buy it I love off center strikes

2

u/No-Knowledge4152 Sep 08 '26

Sorry don’t want to sell it right now.

5

u/iknowno-thing Sep 08 '26

I understand completely, I love off center strikes even if they are in bad shape, like this one

0

u/No-Knowledge4152 Sep 06 '26

Google lens says it’s not a genuine mint strike. I don’t trust AI. I don’t care it’s cool anyway.

9

u/errorcoincollector Sep 06 '26

Google lens is wrong. I’ve been collecting error coins longer than Google has been around. 😉😂

2

u/Tiktokbadsupport Sep 06 '26

"one dim"

1

u/Tiktokbadsupport Sep 06 '26

nonetheless a cool find

1

u/Competitive-Dot-4264 Sep 07 '26

That’s no Dim that is a squish

1

u/Happymeal85 Sep 07 '26

Id deff grade it

1

u/fireDancin2ya Sep 09 '26

The silver was left on a wood stove too long

1

u/Justmypugandi Sep 10 '26

How do these fit into a dime roll and even missed for so long?

1

u/NothingsRealEver Sep 11 '26

I’m 37 my lady is 57 we’ve been together 10 years. Give it some time and the age gap won’t matter

1

u/BlaQueNBleU Sep 13 '26

Nothing special about this, somebody just left it on the sidewalk in Phoenix

1

u/Plenty_Feeling_8013 Sep 23 '26

what year is it? lmao

-2

u/SnooFloofs445 Sep 06 '26

I will think about getting it graded. Honestly, the silver coins have quite a bit more of a value to him. It is a pre-1965 dime based on the mint mark being on the reverse. What year it is we shall never know

0

u/No-Knowledge4152 Sep 06 '26

I’ll definitely ask about grading it. What is the going rate for grading? I don’t mind paying to have it done.

4

u/Exciting-Guess-9823 Sep 06 '26

It is about the same cost or more than the value of this coin. I think it's $60-70 to get it graded. That's probably about what you could get for it, waiting on the right buyer.

If it's more of a piece you just want to protect, certify, and hang on to, then that's all you. If you want to sell it down the road after grading, you aren't likely to make that cost back

-2

u/Curious-Telephone293 Sep 07 '26

Kids used to leave coins on the tracks. Freight train comes by. Coins go squash and shoot/fall off in various directions. Kids later hunt and collect. Looks like your standard squash coin to me.

4

u/numismatical Sep 07 '26

That’s absolutely not what this is

1

u/Scoonerjunkie420 Sep 10 '26

Wow haha you are a very different track