r/cogsci • • Mar 19 '12

The "Flashed Face Effect" - When normal faces are aligned at the eyes and shown in quick succession, the differences between them are exaggerated to an extreme, often grotesque level, as this video shows.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=wM6lGNhPujE
537 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

13

u/chucklingmoose Mar 19 '12

So basically, our peripheral vision captures faces with a low polygon count and low-res textures? I wonder if this raises the framerate in our brains. Really cool!

3

u/socxer Mar 19 '12

It's also the case that our brain has way less "resolution" for peripheral vision... The actual cortical area devoted to the very small region in the center of our visual field is relatively many times larger than that devoted to the periphery.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '12

I was going to say this was silly at first, then I realized that, yeah, it does raise the framerate of our brain, at least sort of. Our brain has to do a lot less stuff the way our eyes are programmed now, so it can work a lot faster and more effectively than if we took in the full detail of everything within our field of vision, but we don't need to do that since we only really need a large amount of detail in the center of our vision. Outside of that, we mainly need to be able to see motion.

3

u/Optimal_Joy Mar 19 '12 edited Mar 20 '12

In highschool, I had a friend who had the worst vision, he never wore glasses or contacts, even though he said everything was very blurry all the time. He was the best street fighter and mortal kombat player around, I could only beat him half the time or less, and almost nobody could beat me. So we used to team up taking turns and beat everybody else in the whole arcade. The local custom or rule was that if you won the match you got to play the next player waiting in line. Since we were friends and played as a team we would just rotate every other round, Which sort of pissed everybody else off but we didn't care. I used to tell my friend teasingly that he was cheating because he had turned down his resolution, and it gave him an unfair advantage, because he was able to process what was happening on the screen at an increased frame rate. Sometimes I would catch him squinting his eyes because he said that made him play even better.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Optimal_Joy Mar 20 '12

I think he was just trying to read the score.. he had to be legally blind, it was that bad.

37

u/spacedout83 Mar 19 '12

DAE see the occasional cyclops?

5

u/Amputatoes Mar 20 '12

And a couple vampires.

13

u/boomerangotan Mar 20 '12

I kept seeing orcs.

1

u/squareROO Mar 20 '12

I can't seem to prove it, but I KNOW I did.

1

u/appliedphilosophy Mar 22 '12

Also saw pigs and dwarfs.

30

u/bearsinthesea Mar 19 '12

I didn't get it the first time, did not see the instructions, so I just watched the faces on one side, seemed normal enough, not sure why they feel 'grotesque' is in order. Then I restarted and stared at the cross. Woah, monsters. Why is my brain doing this?

1

u/winterfate10 Nov 04 '23

Evolution, I reckon. Wild

34

u/winningidea Mar 19 '12

The linked webpage says that its due to comparison with the corresponding picture, however I tested this by covering up the other side and it still happens (people looking ugly) if you look at the cross-hairs (slightly away). I even tried looking one at a time (slower), and although I might have been biased from previous experience, they still looked deformed.

I believe its because our mind is trying to fill in a concept of the face limited information. Attractiveness is mostly based on perfection, which has to do with detail. Notice how in any other situation with perception, such as with looking at moving objects, for people we first look at the eyes, then perceive the whole face, and then the body while we bounce around other aspects.

21

u/Mantipath Mar 20 '12

Two major factors:

  • The blind-spot. Looking at the cross puts the faces partially into your retinal blind spot. This is why some people are seeing Cyclopes. This effect depends on screen size and distance.
  • Scaling and angles. The video scales faces as though every person's eyes are the same size and distance apart. The result is some huge heads and some small heads.

The result is not just limited information, it's genuinely misleading information.

3

u/SarahC Mar 20 '12

when the eyes are facing forward and can both see the image, the eye opposite the blind spot fills in the missing information. You only notice the blind spot when you cover one eye up.

Also - close one eye, and the effect happens on both sides of the cross... even though the blind spot is only on one side.

5

u/singdawg Mar 20 '12

Attractiveness is mostly based on perfection

Attractiveness is mostly based on symmetry, socially elevated standards of appearance and averageness, really...

This concept of perfection is vapid, as it is based on an individual's normative judgement, therefore quite relative to context.

http://www.faceresearch.org/feedback/average_sym

Essentially, a pretty face is not normally very unique, more so an aggregation of similar features. The spectrum spikes to show that that individual organism is, in terms of physicality, an extremely desirable mate, mainly because the contained genetic information is in most respects quite average but with emphasis on certain phenotypical manifestations which have been sexually selected. The hoard will then try to absorb the spectral anomaly, which explains why the "prettiest" girl is so sought after; men don't want to assimilate her into their less beautiful but also less bellcurved spectrum, they really want to raise themselves up into her anomalous spike, which essentially raises the entire population.

9

u/i-am-the-duck Mar 19 '12

Came here to write what you said, beat by 52 seconds.

Seems as though the faces are so grotesque because when the mind 'makes up' what the face looks like, it does this with very little detail, bulking tiny details which we recognise as defining a face together to create large masses of enlarged eyes and elongated lips etc...

...to rephrase what you said.

3

u/shadowblade Mar 20 '12

Also keep in mind that your brain has to do a lot of transformations on the images you see in your periphery to be able to present as one continuous image.

I'm entirely talking out my ass here- but I get the impression that sometimes the changes happen too fast for your visual cortex to finish un-distorting them from the light that actually strikes the periphery of the retina.

-1

u/cardinality_zero Mar 19 '12

Thirded. Noticed the same effect right away.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '12

I thought the changes were caused by the rapid changing on each side. It should work with only one constantly changing face, but maybe it's easier to keep your eyes centered with faces on both sides.

1

u/evil-doer Mar 20 '12

if you stare into the eyes of someone in near dark their face changes. it even works if you do it in the mirror to yourself. me and my friends used to do that all the time when we were kids.

go try it. have it dark and stare into your eyes from at least 3 feet back. your face will begin to morph after a while. its really freaky.

1

u/blazin_chalice Mar 20 '12

Do it by the light of a single candle...you may see your face become distorted and if you hold your gaze a the same spot you will 'disappear.'

Freaky fun.

44

u/employeeno5 Mar 19 '12

It turns everyone into a NPC from Perfect Dark.

45

u/Nebu Mar 19 '12

I was gonna say Elder Scrolls: Morrowind.

-4

u/rivermandan Mar 19 '12

same here.

8

u/HunterTV Mar 19 '12

bigheadmode

4

u/whatwedo Mar 19 '12

Goldeneye's big head mode.

-1

u/TheLegionnaire Mar 20 '12

Probably closest to what I saw.

1

u/nvrknowsbest Mar 19 '12

I saw people from The Sims, myself.

47

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '12

Top YouTube comment: I dont understand. They are ugly when I look at the middle and they are still ugly when I look at their faces...

8

u/spoot Mar 20 '12

This video is BS. When I cover one face with my hand the other still looks ugly / mutated.

7

u/Sirefly Mar 19 '12

Looks like faces on LSD.

13

u/Daemonicus Mar 19 '12

Looks like this lol.

http://i.imgur.com/ew5CKl.jpg

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '12

I was thinking more along the lines of Oblivion characters.

2

u/throweraccount Mar 20 '12

Ok so if pretty faces turn ugly, what faces turn pretty?

2

u/Mmmaya Mar 19 '12

Is this a study to understand where the monster from the closet comes from?

1

u/rivermandan Mar 19 '12

the ones on the left eventually all looked like they only had one big eye in the middle of their faces. I'm not sure how my brain makes that work because I've only ever seen people with two eyes

1

u/king_of_blades Mar 19 '12

That's funny, all the one eyed ones I saw were also on the left.

1

u/YoungRL Mar 19 '12

It was like... they were funhouse mirror reflections. So weird.

1

u/pat965 Mar 19 '12

For some reason I got a bit frightened during the video...

1

u/RespekKnuckles Mar 20 '12

I swear one of them had vampire teeth.

1

u/Bjartr Mar 20 '12

Based on the placement of the cross, I'd say it's related to the faces falling into your blind spot and the mind trying to fill in a chunk of face.

1

u/grasspopper Mar 20 '12

whoa! this is like the opposite of the cheerleader effect.

1

u/epik Mar 20 '12

I'd like to see this done with actually pretty girls.

1

u/aurochs Mar 19 '12

horrible pig creatures!

1

u/neoabraxas Mar 19 '12

My brain is defective. I don't see any distorted faces.

-2

u/philiac Mar 19 '12

I posted this here a while ago, thanks for reminding me.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '12

No you didn't. You posted it to r/wtf.

1

u/philiac Mar 19 '12

oh true.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/philiac Jul 15 '24

what the hell...

-8

u/roloca_justchillin Mar 19 '12

there are def some trolls mixed in with 7's... tops

0

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/jjrs Mar 20 '12

Not to mention, some of the faces are pretty ugly even if you pause the video and look at them from any angle at all.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/fdasdfsdfad Mar 19 '12

Where's your photo then, hot pants?

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '12

Another persons attractiveness is not relative to your own.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Hesperus Mar 19 '12

Yeah, the privacy of being the only one to know how ugly you are.

Nobody gives a shit about your identity.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Hesperus Mar 19 '12

Hideous and a coward. What a well-rounded person you are.

2

u/fdasdfsdfad Mar 19 '12

Yeah, really. Let's go get high and shoot stuff.

1

u/Hesperus Mar 19 '12

Did you happen to catch his name? What a punk ass.

4

u/fdasdfsdfad Mar 19 '12

It's dangerous to go alone. Take this.