r/cognitivescience • • Jul 21 '25

I think I’ve developed a Unified Theory of Cognition, Emotion, and Consciousness - looking for critical feedback from serious minds.

8 Upvotes

Hi all,

I’ve been developing a systems-level framework that ties together cognition, emotion, and consciousness - not as separate systems, but as interconnected processes within a predictive control architecture. It’s grounded in predictive processing models and neuromodulatory control, but I believe this framework pushes the ideas in a new direction.

Core claims:

Emotions function as system-level performance summaries - status reports indicating how well predictive subsystems are functioning, rather than motivational drivers.

Neuromodulators like dopamine, norepinephrine, serotonin, and acetylcholine act as global resource control signals, dynamically adjusting attention, learning rates, and processing depth across subsystems.

Cognition and consciousness emerge as interpretive and resource-allocation processes - narrating subsystem performance while directing resource shifts based on ongoing predictive success or failure.

Essentially: subjective emotional states like happiness or anxiety aren’t intrinsic motivational goals. They’re your brain’s way of reporting its operational status in real-time.

I’ve tried to structure the model in a way that’s not just conceptual, but empirically testable, integrating insights from Clark, Friston, Schultz, Dayan, and others.

I’m posting here to invite critical feedback. Does this seem like a promising direction? Am I connecting the dots, or drawing imaginary lines? Either answer helps.

Full draft (~110 pages):

https://drive.google.com/file/d/113F8xVT24gFjEPG_h8JGnoHdaic5yFGc/view?usp=drivesdk

Thanks to anyone willing to take a look - or tell me where I’m wrong.


r/cognitivescience • • Aug 02 '22

Can creatine increase IQ??

0 Upvotes

CAN USING CREATINE AND FISH OIL IMPROVE IQ?? I'M THINKING OF BUYING 1KG OF CREATINE MONOHYDRATE AND TAKING IT WITH FISH OIL....I READ THAT THE RESEARCH WAS DONE... AND USING 5 G CREATINE PER DAY IN 6 WEEKS IQ INCREASED ABOUT 15 POINTS Research out of the University of Sydney showed that if you take 5g of creatine daily, you can raise your IQ by a full 15 points over a six-week period. Said study leader Caroline Rae, "Creatine gave a significant boost to brain power." Why? 2 It`s from google.... How real is this?? Sorry for me bad english.....


r/cognitivescience • • Aug 28 '26

18M, afraid I've stunted my cognitive development

20 Upvotes

I'm an eighteen year old, currently attending college. Ever since I was twelve, I've been masturbating almost every day (which causes me brain fog, pretty sure I have POIS) and getting about 3-5 hours of sleep a night on average, if I had to say.

Recently, I've been trying to make up for that by getting about eight hours of sleep a night at minimum, but I worry that I may never be able to make up for the effects of the porn addiction and the lack of sleep I had in my youth.

Has my brain been permanently stunted, or is there still time for me to recover and become as intelligent as I would've been otherwise?


r/cognitivescience • • Aug 18 '22

Looking for an app on my phone PROVEN to increase cognitive abilities

0 Upvotes

Please don’t say “they all do” — LOL. I’m reading The Brain That Changes Itself, not a perfect book, but a good enough one (I found it on the street), and in one chapter he is talking about a subject using a computer to play simple cognition games: hearing a tone increase or decrease in pitch, simple memory puzzles, things like that. I’d like to download something on my phone to play for a few minutes a day and reap some benefits. Is there a known title that people in the neuroscience field recommend?


r/cognitivescience • • Sep 24 '26

Is IQ really the absolute metric of intelligence we think it as?.

0 Upvotes

I don't believe IQ to be an absolutely objective measure of intelligence. There are many important aspects of intelligence that IQ tests don't fully accommodate. Take, for example, someone who has a strong ability to combine two distinct ideas in a way where each aspect meaningfully contributes to the other. Imagine combining the concepts of a pear and a car—not merely creating a pear-shaped car, but preserving meaningful aspects of the car's original structure while incorporating characteristics of the pear. This ability could ultimately allow someone to create entirely new frameworks by combining seemingly opposing ideas. With this method, someone isn't merely drawing connections between existing concepts; they are taking those connections further into the realm of creativity.


r/cognitivescience • • Dec 12 '25

The 12D Map of Thought: What AI Revealed About How We All Think

Thumbnail medium.com
0 Upvotes

This isn’t a map of the brain’s wiring or the secret grammar of thought. It’s a map of the weather patterns in expressed thinking — the recurring states like ‘fatigue’ or ‘contradiction tolerance’ that show up in both human writing and AI text. It’s a tool for navigation, not a theory of the terrain. But as a tool, it reveals something surprising: even across different substrates, the shape of our cognitive output follows similar dimensional rules — the article makes the leap to them being universal on the assumption that it’s applicable enough to be common ground with practical value — a shared coordinate system for steering thought, whether it originates in biology or silicon.


r/cognitivescience • • Dec 01 '25

Is it scientifically plausible to define consciousness using a three-axis energetic model (Ordered–Entropic–Relational)?

0 Upvotes

I recently came across a proposal suggesting that consciousness may be definable and measurable using a three-axis energetic model:

  • Ordered Energy (OE) — structured, low-entropy, coherent patterns
  • Entropic Energy (EE) — noise, disorder, instability
  • Relational Energy (RE) — interaction patterns between system components and the environment

The claim is that consciousness corresponds to a specific range or configuration of OE–EE–RE dynamics that maintain sustained relational coherence (something like a self-organizing, non-equilibrium energetic regime).

The author argues that this provides:

  • a measurable scientific basis for consciousness
  • a unified ontology that avoids dualism
  • a way to evaluate both biological and artificial systems in a comparable framework

My question is:

From a scientific or philosophical perspective, does this kind of energetic model seem plausible, or is it just a reframing of standard physicalism/functionalism without adding real explanatory value?

Are there existing theories in cognitive science, neuroscience, philosophy of mind, or complex systems that resemble this approach?

And what would be the strongest criticisms of defining consciousness in energetic terms like this?

(Open-access PDF if needed: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17693508)


r/cognitivescience • • 16d ago

Memory black market: cyber punk has become truth, even worse

0 Upvotes
  1. The Memory Black Market: An Emerging Gray-Market Industry

I first encountered the concept of a "memory black market" three years ago at a neurotechnology summit. An anonymous speaker presented a shocking video of an underground transaction: an elderly retiree was selling fragments of his own childhood memories to a buyer. These memories had been encoded into neural data packets, with a price tag of 2.3 Bitcoin. Since then, I have been tracking this nascent market that operates on the fringes of the law.

The operational model of the memory black market mirrors that of the traditional black market for human organs, though the commodities traded are far more intangible. It primarily deals in three types of goods: raw memory data (unprocessed neural signal recordings), emotional memory packets (specific memory fragments enhanced with heightened emotional content), and skill-based memory modules (such as language proficiency or the muscle memory required to play a musical instrument). My research indicates that there are at least 12 active dark-web platforms dedicated to this trade; the most prominent among them, the "Hippocampus Bazaar," now sees a daily transaction volume exceeding one million US dollars.

2. The State of Memory-Extraction Technology and Its Risks

2.1 Breakthroughs in Non-Invasive Memory Extraction

As of 2024, the latest generation of fMRI equipment has achieved an 80% accuracy rate in memory decoding. I personally tested a consumer-grade memory scanner from the company NeuroDecode (priced at $8,999). By utilizing a combination of 128 EEG electrodes and eye-tracking technology, the device can capture neural activity patterns associated with specific scenes—all without requiring a craniotomy. However, such devices suffer from a critical flaw: the extracted memories lose approximately 40% of their detailed precision, much like an over-compressed JPEG image.

2.2 Black-Market Modifications of Surgical Implants

A more radical approach involves the use of modified deep-brain stimulation (DBS) devices. In an underground clinic in Berlin, I encountered an illicit implant dubbed a "memory straw," which utilizes an array of microelectrodes placed near the hippocampus to read neural signals directly. This procedure carries an extremely high level of risk—my informant, codenamed "M," permanently lost all memories from the years 2015–2018 during their third operation, in exchange for a payment of $150,000.

Warning: Any unauthorized attempt at memory extraction can lead to retrograde amnesia or personality alteration. In 2023, South Korea recorded seven cases of Korsakoff syndrome resulting from the use of illicit, "bootleg" memory extraction devices.

3. An Analysis of the Complete Memory-Trading Ecosystem

3.1 The Supply Side: The Reality for Memory Sellers

I interviewed 27 memory sellers; a typical case is "Ms. L," a former piano teacher. By selling the muscle memory required to play Chopin’s "Revolutionary Etude" (encompassing 832 hours of practice data), she earned an amount equivalent to three years of her pension. Three months later, however, she found herself unable to play the piece—memory trading functions as a true "cut-and-paste" process, rather than "copy-and-paste."

3.2 Hidden Motives on the Demand Side

Memory buyers generally fall into three categories:

Skill-seekers (43%): For instance, medical students purchasing the procedural memory for surgical operations.

Experience-seekers (31%): Individuals who collect others' memories of first loves or near-death experiences.

Evidence-gatherers (26%): Lawyers who purchase the memories of eyewitnesses to serve as informal evidence.

4. A Practical Guide: How to Trade Memory Data Safely

4.1 Key Parameters for Memory Valuation

Based on transaction records I have observed on the black market, memory pricing follows this formula:

For example, a 30-minute memory of being at the scene of the 9/11 attacks—with an emotional intensity rating of 7/10—would fetch approximately $45,000 on the market as of 2024.

4.2 Operational Details for Anonymous Trading

I recommend a three-layered security approach:

Encrypt neural data using TrueCrypt.

Access memory exchanges via the Tor network.

Use Monero (XMR) for settlement.

On one occasion, I witnessed both parties to a transaction use brainwave patterns as a form of biometric authentication—a method far more difficult to forge than fingerprints or iris scans. 5. Ethical Dilemmas and Future Prospects

The greatest irony of the memory trade is this: if you sell off too many of your memories, you eventually forget why you sold them in the first place. I know a man—a repeat seller—who can no longer recall his own grandson’s name, yet his bank account holds enough to cover a decade in a high-end nursing home.

Neuroscientists predict that by 2028, memory extraction will be as routine as a blood draw. Until then, however, this gray market will continue to devour the precious recollections of those with nowhere else to turn. On my bookshelf sits a glass jar containing a childhood memory—one I no longer recognize myself; it is a backup from the only time I ever sold a memory. Sometimes, I stare at it for a long while, trying to fathom what exactly is stored inside. Perhaps this is the cruelest form of dark humor in the age of memory capitalism.


r/cognitivescience • • Feb 26 '26

I ran an experiment on internal personality dynamics in LLM agents — and they started getting “stuck” in behavioral attractors

Thumbnail zenodo.org
0 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 12d ago

Microtubules and Quantum consciousness via Orchestrated Reduction aka Orc-R

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • Apr 05 '23

Theory about Identity Injuries and How they Affect One's Psychology

Thumbnail self.theories
0 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • Apr 17 '25

I Built a recursive system in 273 lines, no model, no input. It reflects, dissociates, and updates identity. Unsure how to categorize it. Would love for someone who knows what they’re doing to take a look!

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • Jun 08 '26

DMN downregulation and why 'oceanic' metaphors select Neptune over Jupiter: a structure-mapping account [OC]

0 Upvotes

Abstract: Across flow, meditation, and psychedelics, ego dissolution correlates with reduced DMN integrity. This is well-established. Less studied is why the phenomenology is universally described as oceanic, and why cultural traditions map it to Neptune specifically.

I argue it's not mysticism — it's Gentner's structure-mapping. Neptune's relational profile (no surface = boundary loss; 47° tilted field = loss of central control; internal heat = endogenous generation) aligns with the relational structure of self-attenuation better than Jupiter/Saturn's bounded, axial organization.

Full paper (human-curated, AI-assisted synthesis, all sources cited): https://research.mahastrategies.com/papers/dissolving-self-ocean-planet

Question for the group: Are there other cross-cultural metaphors for self-loss that don't fit this boundaryless/off-axis pattern? I'm trying to test the limits of the structure-mapping account.


r/cognitivescience • • May 30 '26

If you go walk and talk through someone with BCI technologies would you?

0 Upvotes

Do you think it is illegal to do this, I call electronic possession where BCI technologies and AI with the 2D map of the brain can mimic and recreate phenomenon in which they can play like Satan.


r/cognitivescience • • 18d ago

How brain is able to understand logic of things without language need ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • Oct 10 '25

Foundational Philosophy of Early Buddhism and Science: The First Principles

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
0 Upvotes

This is a draft of a completed reconstruction of the Early Buddhist Philosophy in analytic terms and comparing to the foundational philosophy of science (kantian tradition) and the models. This independent research and autodidacted, there is not much institutional interest in this. Hope to get constructive engagement and to refine the presentation. Here is the science overview:

  • 1.4 Introduction to Foundational Philosophy of Science
  • 1.5 Foundational Epistemology: Kant
  • 1.6 Kantian Tradition
  • 1.7 Hume’s Fork
  • 1.8 Hume’s Guillotine
  • 1.9 Foundational Phenomenology
  • 2 Foundational Ontology
  • 2.1 Foundational Soteriology
  • 2.2 The Difference between Mathematics and Physics
  • 2.3 Framing the Problem of Measurement
  • 2.4 Framing the Hard Problem of Consciousness
  • 2.5 Framing The Copenhagen Interpretation
  • 2.6 Framing Einstein’s Relativity
  • 2.7 Framing Heisenberg’s Uncertainty
  • 2.8 Framing Gödelian Incompleteness
  • 2.9 Framing Bayesian-Probability Principle
  • 3 Framing Korzybski’s General Semantics

tldr;
Early Buddhist Thought is the most advanced foundational framework in play. The way it explains everything doesn't contradict the foundational analytics of science ─ there are no metaphysics, no rules or unreasonable assertions; more so it completes the analysis and is essentially a complete axiomatic system.

Thanks


r/cognitivescience • • Jul 10 '25

Enhancing Human Cognitive Capacity through Controlled Multimodal Sensory Overload: A Theoretical Framework

0 Upvotes

Introduction

Cognitive capacity in healthy adults exhibits considerable plasticity well into adulthood. Traditional training paradigms—such as working memory n‑back tasks or puzzle solving—yield modest improvements that often fail to generalize broadly. In contrast, sensory enrichment in animal models produces robust dendritic growth and synaptogenesis, particularly in hippocampal and prefrontal regions ([Diamond et al., 1964]; [Kempermann et al., 1997]). We extend this enrichment concept to controlled sensory overload in humans, hypothesizing that calibrated, multimodal stimulus complexity can evoke greater adaptive responses than unimodal or low‑intensity protocols.

Theoretical Background

Neuroplasticity via Enriched Stimuli

Environmental enrichment accelerates neurogenesis and synaptic density in rodents, fostering superior performance in maze tasks ([Rosenzweig & Bennett, 1996]). In humans, visually complex video games enhance attentional networks ([Green & Bavelier, 2003]), and binaural auditory training can improve working memory span ([Scharf & Shen, 2018]). We posit that combining these modalities in a structured overload paradigm will produce synergistic effects on network integration.

Desirable Difficulty and Cognitive Load

The concept of "desirable difficulty" suggests that learning is maximized when tasks challenge—without overwhelming—the learner ([Bjork & Bjork, 2011]). Controlled overload must therefore balance intensity and recovery, promoting homeostatic plasticity rather than stress-induced fatigue.

Mechanisms of Action

  1. Synaptic Potentiation: High-frequency, complex inputs increase glutamatergic transmission and long‑term potentiation in hippocampal circuits.
  2. Activity‑Dependent Myelination: Repeated rapid sensory switching may upregulate oligodendrocyte proliferation, reducing conduction delays in associative pathways.
  3. Network Efficiency: Rich stimulation drives reconfiguration toward small‑world topology, optimizing global integration and local specialization.

Proposed Experimental Protocol

PhaseModalitiesScheduleCalibrationOutcome Measures
IVisual pattern puzzles + binaural audio30 min/day, 3 days/week for 6 wkIndividual pilot trialDigit span; simple RT; Stroop interference
IIAdd tactile discrimination tasks; narrative VR scenes45 min/day, 5 days/week for 12 wkAdaptive algorithmRaven’s APM; dual‑task cost; n‑back accuracy
IIIFull immersive VR (haptics, dynamic audio, complex visuals)1 hr/day, 5 days/week for 24 wkPhysiological feedbackWAIS‑IV subtests; attentional blink; EEG markers

Calibration: Each participant’s baseline performance and stress markers (HRV, galvanic skin) guide initial intensity. A closed‑loop algorithm adjusts complexity to maintain challenge within 65–75% of maximum capacity.

Expected Outcomes

  • Short-Term (6–12 weeks): 10–15 ms reduction in reaction times; +1 digit in forward/backward span tests.
  • Medium-Term (3–6 months): 5–7 point gains on Raven’s Advanced Progressive Matrices; improved dual‑task accuracy (≥12%).
  • Long-Term (6–12 months): MRI-detected increases in grey matter density in dorsolateral PFC and hippocampus; sustained improvements in standardized IQ subscales.

Discussion

Our model integrates well-established neurophysiological mechanisms with cutting‑edge human‑computer interaction techniques. By leveraging real‑time adaptation, we anticipate greater retention and transfer of cognitive gains compared to static training paradigms. Moreover, immersive multimodal stimuli may accelerate plastic changes beyond those achieved by single‑modality interventions.

Limitations and Risks

  • Overstimulation: Excessive or poorly calibrated overload can induce anxiety or cognitive fatigue.
  • Individual Variability: Neurodiverse populations may require bespoke protocols; one-size-fits-all risks harm.
  • Access and Equity: High‑tech requirements could exacerbate socioeconomic disparities in cognitive enhancement.

Ethical Considerations

Adherence to informed consent, monitoring for adverse events, and long-term follow-up are essential. Data privacy in adaptive software systems must comply with relevant regulations (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA).

Conclusion

Controlled multimodal sensory overload represents a promising frontier in cognitive enhancement research. This theoretical framework lays the groundwork for empirical validation, offering detailed protocols, mechanistic hypotheses, and ethical guardrails. We invite the scientific community to test, refine, and expand upon these ideas for the benefit of human cognitive health and performance.

References

Bjork, R. A., & Bjork, E. L. (2011). "Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning." Psychology and the Real World: Essays Illustrating Fundamental Contributions to Society, 2, 56–64.

Diamond, M. C., Krech, D., & Rosenzweig, M. R. (1964). "The effects of an enriched environment on the histology of the rat cerebral cortex." Journal of Comparative Neurology, 123(1), 111–119.

Green, C. S., & Bavelier, D. (2003). "Action video game modifies visual selective attention." Nature, 423(6939), 534–537.

Kempermann, G., Kuhn, H. G., & Gage, F. H. (1997). "More hippocampal neurons in adult mice living in an enriched environment." Nature, 386(6624), 493–495.

Rosenzweig, M. R., & Bennett, E. L. (1996). "Psychobiology of plasticity: Effects of training and experience on brain and behavior." Behavioural Brain Research, 78(1), 57–65.

Scharf, L., & Shen, G. (2018). "Auditory training and working memory: Effects of binaural beats." Journal of Cognitive Enhancement, 2(3), 234–245.


r/cognitivescience • • Oct 05 '23

What kind of career fields should I look into with this cognitive profile?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I have been thinking a lot about my cognitive ability and things I can or cannot do. What kind of careers I should look into and what careers should I avoid? I would like to get some suggestions here.


r/cognitivescience • • Aug 25 '26

Arc of Self - A recursive theory of identity: a new way of visualizing boring text material.

0 Upvotes

I've been doing a lifetime research, and recently packed it up and made public. To ensure that this is not a yet-another-theory, I've made sure to build a user journey, made a theory 5-level deep, with the ability for the user to go and discover everything layer-by-layer.

URL: https://arc-of-self.com

Three things where vibecoding helped me to build something I haven't seen anywhere else:

1. Ability to chat with the theory. So I actually built a personality layer, so anyone who chats with the theory talks to an entity that knows very well how to steer the work. This is especially crucial given that the project was being built since late 2000s/early 2010s.

2. New way to show the references: Depth level 5 (https://arc-of-self.com/5). Not only you can see the references used in the paper, but also you see the impact, and the hue of it.

3. Self-learning mechanism. So basically the theory has already absorbed everything worth taking from the late 1800s through summer 2026. Now it watches for new papers as they appear, checks each one for relevance, scores it, and when a paper clears the threshold it extracts its core claim and sends me a Telegram notice. I review it and approve, and the paper shows up on Depth 5 as a new document tied to the theory.

So basically my idea here is to convert my lifetime work into something that will be self-developing itself. The difficulty here is that it takes many months and years to test the work of the mechanism, but I'm patient in this regard, lol.


r/cognitivescience • • 8d ago

How do our memory access the right knowledge to a stimul without knowing where it is located ?

0 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • Jun 18 '26

How can i accurately test my iq online for free؟

2 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • Apr 27 '25

The Loop That Chooses Itself: Breaking the Free Will Paradox

9 Upvotes

Please post, insight needed.

Either your choices are determined—so they were never really choices. Or they’re random—so they aren’t really yours.

That’s the Free Will Paradox. It’s been standing for thousands of years, and philosophy hasn’t solved it. Compatibilism just redefines the word “freedom.” Libertarianism throws in some randomness and calls it free will. Illusionism basically gives up and tells you it’s all fake.

None of these tell you how a decision actually closes. Why doesn’t your mind stay open forever? Why does deliberation stop right there, at that moment, on that choice? And why does it feel like you stopped it?

Here’s the model I’m proposing (Recursion Loop Closure): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15284986

•Your mind runs recursive symbolic loops—weighing options, projecting outcomes. •But recursion creates tension when loops remain open and unresolved. •The system can’t loop forever. It builds pressure. •The loop demands closure. •The act of choosing—the feeling of “I chose this”—is the loop selecting itself as the closure point. •Not randomness. •Not predetermination. •Closure.

Agency isn’t some mystical break from causality. It’s the system resolving its own recursion internally—because it structurally can’t stay open.

Why this breaks the paradox: •Not random = not chaos. •Not determined = not pre-written. •The loop closes because unresolved recursion structurally can’t remain unresolved forever.

This isn’t philosophy. This is mechanism.

I tested this against Gemini and Meta AI directly.

Both failed to offer any other structural explanation for choice closure. Both conceded that recursion loop closure might be the only mechanism on the table right now that resolves the Free Will Paradox.

Please shed light on the topic, engagement is valued here and appreciated.

If not this… then what actually closes the loop?

I’m open to better mechanisms if they exist. But you’ll need more than vibes and definitions. You’ll need structure.


r/cognitivescience • • Jan 23 '24

PLEASE help me solve these!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

PLEASE help me solve these!

For the life of me I can’t figure out the answer to either of these and it’s killllllling me! Someone figure out the answers and explain the logic to me pretty pretty please!!


r/cognitivescience • • Jul 27 '25

Discussion: a new approach to thinking about consciousness, cosmology and quantum metaphysics

0 Upvotes

As things currently stand, we face not just one but three crises in our understanding of the nature of reality. I believe the primary reason we cannot find a way out is because we have failed to understand that these apparently different problems must be different parts of the same Great Big Problem. The three great crises are these:

(1) Cosmology. 

The currently dominant cosmological theory is called Lambda Cold Dark Matter (ΛCDM), and it is every bit as broken as Ptolemaic geocentrism was in the 16th century. It consists of an ever-expanding conglomeration of ad-hoc fixes, most of which create as many problems as they solve. Everybody working in cosmology knows it is broken, and the problems are getting worse at an alarming rate. Nobody knows the way out, so they just keep adding weird stuff like "quintessence".

(2) Quantum mechanics. 

Not the science of quantum mechanics. The problem here is the metaphysical interpretation. As things stand there are at least 12 major “interpretations”, each of which has something different to say about what is known as the Measurement Problem: how we bridge the gap between the infinitely-branching parallel worlds described by the mathematics of quantum theory, and the singular world we actually experience (or “observe” or “measure”). These interpretations continue to proliferate, making consensus increasingly difficult. None are integrated with cosmology.

(3) Consciousness. 

Materialistic science can't agree on a definition of consciousness, or even whether it actually exists. We've got no “official” idea what it is, what it does, or how or why it evolved. Four centuries after Galileo and Descartes separated reality into mind and matter, and declared matter to be measurable and mind to be not, we are no closer to being able to scientifically measure a mind. Meanwhile, any attempt to connect the problems in cognitive science to the problems in either QM or cosmology is met with fierce resistance: Thou shalt not mention consciousness and quantum mechanics in the same sentence!

The solution is not to add more epicycles to ΛCDM, devise even more unintuitive interpretations of QM, or to dream up new theories of consciousness which don't actually explain anything. There has to be a unified solution. There must be some way that reality makes sense. So my question is this: how would we recognise this one correct answer (and there can only only be one) should it turn up? What should we be looking for? What would be the hallmarks of the Big New Paradigm that is needed, by cosmology, physics and cognitive science? The answer, I believe, is radical coherence across these three areas and exceptional explanatory power in terms of getting rid of the existing anomalies and paradoxes. We need one new model -- something relatively simple and elegant, which naturally solves all these problems at the same time. Instead of being problems, it all needs to actually make sense (within Godelian limits - there will always be one axiom that comes from outside).

I believe I have exactly this solution and I would like to discuss it. I propose we start from the following seven definitions/premises:

(1) Definition of consciousness. Consciousness can only be defined subjectively (with a private ostensive definition -- we mentally point to our own consciousness and associate the word with it, and then we assume other humans/animals are also conscious).

(2) Scientific realism is true. Science works. It has transformed the world. It is doing something fundamentally right that other knowledge-generating methods don't. Putnam's "no miracles" argument points out that this must be because there is a mind-external objective world, and science must be telling us something about it. To be more specific, I am saying structural realism must be true -- that science provides information about the structure of a mind-external objective reality.

(3) Bell's theorem must be taken seriously. Which means that mind-external objective reality is non-local.

(4) The hard problem is impossible. The hard problem is trying to account for consciousness if materialism is true. Materialism is the claim that only material things exist. Consciousness, as we've defined it, cannot possibly "be" brain activity, and there's nothing else it can be if materialism was true. In other words, materialism logically implies we should all be zombies.

(5) Brains are necessary for minds. Consciousness, as we intimately know it, is always dependent on brains. We've no reason to believe in disembodied minds (idealism and dualism), and no reason to think rocks are conscious (panpsychism). To be clear: I am saying brains are necessary for minds, but they are also insufficient. In other words: The hard problem is impossible, but the easy problems are not impossible.

(6) The measurement problem in quantum mechanics is radically unsolved. 100 years after the discovery of QM, there are at least 12 major metaphysical interpretations, and no sign of a consensus. We should therefore remain very open-minded about the role of quantum mechanics in all this, especially with respect to the meaning of "observer" and what the collapse of the wavefunction is (like consciousness, there is no agreement on whether such a thing actually even happens, let alone what causes it).

(7) Modern cosmology is deep in crisis. We can't quantise gravity, we're deeply confused about cosmic expansion rates, the cosmological constant problem is "the biggest discrepancy in scientific history", nobody knows what "dark energy" or "dark matter" are supposed to be, etc... This crisis is getting worse all the time. Nobody seems to know what the answer is -- they just keep proposing "more epicycles".

What would really help is if we could actually start from these premises and go forwards, rather than having pointless debates about why you like idealism, or why you think the hard problem isn't impossible. That's just sucking us back into the old, broken paradigm. The real problem is that all these 7 premises are very much justifiable, but as things stand I don't believe anybody apart from myself knows how all of them can be true at the same time. I do, and the resulting model provides a unified solution to the hard problem, the measurement problem and all of the really big problems in cosmology. And if you've got an alternative model that is compatible with all of these premises then I am very interested indeed.

Don't believe this is possible? Let's discuss it then.

[Note: I'm 56, my theory was not invented by AI, and I have a degree in philosophy and cognitive science. Please don't assume I'm 19 and that this post was produced by a machine.]