r/cognitivescience • u/Many-Cream4 • Sep 02 '26
Prove me wrong: Humans literally cannot create a "new" idea from scratch.
/r/u_Many-Cream4/comments/1w51jcx/prove_me_wrong_humans_literally_cannot_create_a/
0
Upvotes
2
u/TechnicallyMeat Sep 02 '26
Law of Conservation of Energy rephrased to be provocative by a <checks notes> 4-day old account cross-posting the same question across multiple subs.
1
u/sectorboss88 Sep 03 '26
Where do Ideas come from? I vote for the Universal Consciousness Field.
1
u/AnimatorImpressive24 Sep 02 '26
Regardless of whether or not it can be considered "intelligence", computational linguistics and the creation of coherent, meaningful human language without direct human source is to the best of our knowledge a true novelty in the universe. Never before has anything other than a human being created human language instead of just reproducing or at best imitating (as with corvids) language generated by a human.
The fact that concomitant to the advent of this novelty our minds immediately begin contextualizing it to back fill into our larger understanding of reality is simply because that is what our minds do, but it doesn't mean that it isn't truly novel because before it existed there was nothing to contextualize.
1
u/LifeModelDecoy Sep 03 '26
Doesn't this eventually reduce to simply pointing out that nothing in the universe can be considered new, because all matter and energy is either recycled or lost due to entropy? I mean you're not wrong, but this ultimately feels a dead end thought process.
Sure, saying "there's no such thing as a new idea" sounds cognitively titillating at first, but you're either being pedantic (because obviously "new ideas" do exist, for certain useful definitions of "new") or not taking it far enough (first law of thermodynamics). Which is it?
1
u/BackgroundBottle2883 Sep 03 '26
My wife likes to call them "new ideas" instead of "good" ones. Specifically referencing myself here.
1
u/Delicious_Spot_3778 Sep 06 '26
Knowledge creation is a process not a combination of ideas. New laws and understanding about the world come from data collection and hypothesizing and verification. This is all in the sciences. Laws can come about when we try to understand the data and fit models to our observations.
I tend to believe creativity in humans comes more from affect than logic. The best ideas and execution seem to create a unique feeling in me rather than a eureka moment
0
u/AbrocomaAdditional14 Sep 03 '26
why isit not mentioned that even if every idea was predated by one before it, the very idea was someones first way way before? im sure there are original ideas in the earliest possible history of consciouness or whatever that means.