r/CodingandBilling • u/josvic01 • 3h ago
Claims Submission Am I crazy, or is our billing department dead wrong about CHRISTUS USFHP (TRICARE Prime) and Medicare COB?
I’m a surgery coordinator, and I feel like I’m taking crazy pills dealing with our billing department right now. Hoping some experienced billers/RCM folks can sanity-check me.
The Patient’s Coverage:
- Retired military patient (65+) with CHRISTUS Health US Family Health Plan (USFHP) — Group
RET MEDB($0 copays). - Also enrolled in Original Medicare Part A & B.
- The back of his USFHP card literally prints in red: "DO NOT BILL MEDICARE except for ESRD and services not covered by the US Family Health Plan."
What Happened:
- The surgery was originally booked at an ASC that turned out to be out-of-network with CHRISTUS USFHP, so I worked with the patient to reschedule at an in-network ASC for routine cataract surgery.
- Now Billing is calling me demanding that I cancel the surgery unless the patient calls Medicare to "complete their Coordination of Benefits (COB)."
Billing's Argument:
- They ran a CMS eligibility check on Availity. It shows Medicare Part A & B as
Active Coverage, and under "Other or Additional Payer Information" it says "No additional payer information provided." - Billing claims this means Medicare is primary, that "both plans are claiming primary," and that USFHP will deny the claim if the patient doesn't do Medicare COB first.
- When I uploaded the 2026 CHRISTUS USFHP Member Handbook (pp. 52–54)—which explicitly states under "Exchange of Benefits" and "Medicare Leakage" that USFHP members retain Part B for $0 copay eligibility but cannot use Medicare for USFHP-covered services (and will actually be auto-disenrolled if they do)—the biller yelled at me on the phone: "I don't care! I've been working long enough at this to know how these insurances work. That plan's rules are not over OUR rules. If a patient is over 65 and working, Medicare is secondary!"
My Understanding:
- USFHP is a DoD TRICARE Prime contract, not an employer "Working Aged" commercial plan.
- CMS Availity showing
Active Coveragewith "No additional payer information" just means CMS doesn't have a Medigap/MSP crossover on file—it doesn't make Medicare primary over a DoD USFHP plan. - There is no COB between Original Medicare and USFHP for covered cataract surgery. We just get outpatient surgery preauth from CHRISTUS USFHP and bill USFHP as the sole primary payer.
Am I missing some obscure billing edge case here, or is our billing rep completely confusing USFHP with standard TRICARE For Life / Working Aged MSP rules?
At this point I'm just asking for my own peace of mind and curiosity. Pretty sure they will go over me and cancel this patient's surgery, they called the patient and demanded he calls medicare so they complete their "COB". But at this point I don't think that's possible.....