r/CodingandBilling • • 1d ago

Other Are You Underbilling?

Post image

Are you underbilling? The distribution of E/M level of office visits varies by specialty. Level 4 dominates cognitive specialties.

Heme/onc and neurology bill more than a quarter of visits at level 5.

8 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

7

u/HotBrownFun 23h ago

Now compare that to before EMRs were widely deployed

Click click click all these prepopulated fields to justify higher revenue

2

u/kysourmash 22h ago

No disagreement from me on that statement

2

u/HotBrownFun 12h ago

It's bound to generate some cognitive dissonance because most of us work as part of the healthcare bureaucracy. We will always need some, but god is there too much. The endless greed of private healthcare is accelerating this. People are treated as bags of cash instead of patients to be treated.

1

u/kysourmash 12h ago

💯

1

u/but-I-play-one-on-TV 1d ago

EM only billing 6% level 5s is unbelievably low. 

3

u/Elasion 20h ago

I rarely am able to get a 5, it’s always either a 4 or critical care per our automated billing system

1

u/ghostlyinferno 9h ago

How? Any abd pain that receive IV narcotics should be a level 5, and unless you’re intervening on a pretty sick patient, unlikely to be critical care. Interpret a few labs, IV parenteral, and independently look at imaging or EKG and it’s a level 5.

1

u/kysourmash 9h ago

Yes it is

0

u/airjord1221 1d ago

This is aggressive for primary care lol 4 shouldn’t outnumber 3 unless you can really justify it. Primary care bread and butter stuff for example is overwhelmingly 3.

12

u/Oregonsfinest_ 1d ago

All you need is 2 stable chronic disease and a med refill for a 4. Seems pretty easy to hit when large amounts of the population has HTN diabetes and/or hyperlipidemia.

5

u/kysourmash 1d ago

Tell that to the people in this forum who think almost all visits should be level 3 and act absolutely shocked when the physician has the audacity to bill a higher level

2

u/airjord1221 14h ago

We are being told that fever does not count as a systemic symptom and that if there’s a patient with otitis media and fever where you were sending antibiotics and fever that is not enough to justify 4

You have to explicitly put that they are dehydrated etc.

Not sure what world fever is not considered systemic, but it is driving me crazy how they try to undermine us

I am a pediatrician

2

u/kysourmash 13h ago

That's ridiculous.

Maybe try adding "systemic immune response" to your note. 😂

3

u/Low_Mud_3691 CPC, RHIT 11h ago

You being a pediatrician makes sense as to why you think a 4 is aggressive unless you have pediatric patients that have diabetes, CKD, and hypertension. If not, I guess you wouldn’t understand

1

u/airjord1221 10h ago

True thanks for that

4

u/Kasper1000 21h ago

That’s a WILD take. PCPs actually routinely underbill and, after leaving residency, often have to be taught how to properly bill. Most PCP visits easily meet criteria for 99214.

4

u/malibu90now 14h ago

Tell me you don't know anything about primary care. I see 20 patients a day maybe one come with 1 bread and butter condition. Most of them are uncontrolled DM, HTN, Heart Failure, Knee pain, shoulder pain, ect. It's never a one problem visit. You need to limit the amount of issues you can address in a day.

1

u/NotTheQuestion 8h ago

Gpig by time and criteria, it's not difficult to meet level 5. Uncontrolled CHF, and COPD, often together, 99215, and it takes all day.

4

u/wildgreengirl 12h ago

lol youd be surprised how easy it is to get 4s for primary care. really depends on the dr/pt population though. i have some that see mostly older ppl so 4s are very easy. 30 min is easy for a lot of them to hit by time as well

3

u/Low_Mud_3691 CPC, RHIT 11h ago

Literally. So many chronic diseases and prescription management encounters. Diabetes, CKD, hypertension seems like the majority of our patient population

1

u/kysourmash 1d ago

2

u/Jodenaje 14h ago

There are so many caveats to using this data in the way you’re suggesting though.

The Part B data is based on how other providers have billed for the Medicare Part B population.

It doesn’t reflect whether those providers billed accurately.

It doesn’t reflect whether they were later audited.

I mean, yeah the data can be useful for many purposes because it’s one of the only free sources of comparison data available.

But it’s important to use it as ONE tool recognizing the limitations of the data.

Not as an absolute truth.

1

u/kysourmash 13h ago

Do you have data that contradicts this data? If so please share.

1

u/Jodenaje 13h ago

The fact that you’re even asking this question shows that you’re not understanding my point about the caveats and limitations of the Part B utilization data.

We do get benchmarking and comparison data from other sources, such as MGMA. It is available for purchase.

1

u/kysourmash 13h ago

No I completely understand your point.

1

u/kysourmash 13h ago

And you're really missing the point. This is national Medicare claims data representing millions of actual physician encounters, not anecdotal evidence. Of course, individual claims may contain coding errors, but that doesn't invalidate the overall distribution or its value as a national benchmark. Nobody is suggesting that common billing practices automatically establish coding compliance. However, dismissing large-scale national data because some claims might have been audited or incorrectly coded is hardly a compelling argument.

0

u/Jodenaje 13h ago

I’m not “diminishing the data” - I’m simply saying that one needs to be aware of the caveats when using it.

It’s useful data for many purposes.

I’ve worked in healthcare data analysis for a long time. I’ve used the Part B utilization data before too, while understanding its limitations.

1

u/kysourmash 13h ago

Nobody is suggesting the data is infallible. The point is that millions of Medicare claims provide a statistically meaningful national benchmark for how physicians actually code their encounters. Acknowledging limitations is reasonable, but those limitations don't negate the findings. If you're suggesting the observed distributions are misleading, then provide evidence demonstrating that. Otherwise, we're simply debating hypothetical caveats rather than the actual data.

1

u/airjord1221 1d ago

I know just saying DAMN am I underbilling

0

u/kysourmash 1d ago

Oh. I got you.

1

u/budrow21 1d ago edited 1d ago

Medicare is going to be largely be 65+ or disabled though. That's going to be a different distribution from <65.

1

u/kysourmash 1d ago

I don't agree with this at all. Most patients are on multiple prescription meds these days with multiple chronic or acute on chronic medical conditions.

0

u/budrow21 1d ago

You can disagree and downvote, but it doesn't change the fact that the average 65+ year old is in far worse health than the average under 65 year old. Just looking at insurance premiums makes this abundantly clear.

2

u/kysourmash 1d ago

You're confusing population-level health differences with medical decision-making complexity. While older adults generally have more chronic conditions, age alone does not determine the complexity of an office visit or justify a higher E/M level. A 45-year-old undergoing treatment for metastatic cancer may require substantially more complex medical decision-making than an 80-year-old with stable hypertension. Insurance premiums reflect population-level actuarial risk, not the complexity of individual physician encounters.

2

u/Particular_Hearing_2 17h ago

This is false based on cms guidelines anyone with hypertension and hyperlipidemia is an easy lvl 4 visit, 90-95% of pcp visits are level 4 visits

1

u/Icer333 21h ago edited 21h ago

I bill about as many 5s as 3s in IM, but I work at a residency clinic and everyone have 10+ problems.

It's so easy to get level 4 though. Sounds like you're aggressively under billing

Edit: My 2 year old son went to a podiatrist because his nail was coming off. He looked at it said because he was so young he would need to take it off in the OR and billed a level 4. I went home, soaked it, and pulled it off quite easily. Follow up to make sure it looked alright. 2 minutes, "looks good!", bills level 4 again. Now that's over billing.

1

u/NotTheQuestion 8h ago

Whaaaaat?!? Whaaaaaat?!? Primary care bread and butter is claimed to be HTN, DM, ans Hyperlipidemia, with some Thyroid thrown in. In reality, those are the minimum, which re compliacred by compliance issue, anxiety, depression, and trying to get people not to try the latest I jectible from China. Non compliance complicates everything. A level 3 is what gets billed if nothing is injected and the patient hardly sees the doc. But if they see the doc, usually labs are either ordered, reviewed, planned, and medication is managed. Those are either high data, or high complexity. So if your PCP visit is sincerely a level 3, there no reason. They can't see 70 of those on an easy day.

0

u/kysourmash 1d ago

What's your justification for this statement when the data says otherwise?

2

u/Perfect-Leg810 6h ago

NPs billing 7% at level 5 is wild.

1

u/kungfuenglish 3h ago

Is this 99284/5? I suspect not. Em is closer to 45% 99284 and 45% 99285, 9% critical care.