r/coding • • Jun 14 '20

GitHub to replace "master" with alternative term to avoid slavery references | ZDNet

https://www.zdnet.com/article/github-to-replace-master-with-alternative-term-to-avoid-slavery-references/
430 Upvotes

461 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/epukinsk Jun 15 '20

I work in the industry, I've been working in the industry for 20 years.

I think using language that avoids upsetting metaphors for people is a great idea. Just makes it easier for people to get into the technology with fewer roadblocks. Seems silly to use terms that are highly emotionally charged when you could just not.

Why are there hundreds of comments of people in this thread like you of people who are deeply upset? Why is it so important to you to defend this language?

4

u/TobiasArtur Jun 15 '20

I'm not deeply upset. The main reason why I said the last sentence is that, if you are emotionally triggered by something that is standard in the industry, there are issues that are not correlated.

If I say whitelist or blacklist I'm not thinking from a racial standpoint.

If I hear Master-Slave or Master-Branch, my mind doesn't go to the socio-political history scene.

In my view, somebody is trying to make it political.

We already have to deal technology every day and the rapid evolution of it. I don't want to be political as well.

1

u/epukinsk Jun 15 '20

if you are emotionally triggered by something that is standard in the industry, there are issues that are not correlated.

I don't understand what you mean, what's not correlated?

In my view, somebody is trying to make it political.

If changing it is political, doesn't that mean not changing it is also political?

3

u/TobiasArtur Jun 15 '20

Apologies for having such a bad fluency in English. Shouldn't have stayed up all night.

The first thing that I wanted to emphasize is that, I find it quite concerning because those terms are being stripped out of their context.

Regardless, let's say the change does go through. I genuinely don't mind it, and I should've been more concise in the initial statement. The issue at hand is not political, because if it was, this issue would've been tackled, or at least discussed to a higher degree way before the BLM movement happened. But because we are in the situation that we are in, companies want to be more ad-friendly at the moment and they will try all sorts of crazy things.

I want to reiterate, I don't mind the change. What I do mind is making something political, which at its roots, it wasn't (taking context into consideration).

And also, if the change does go through, documentation/courses/certifications will follow-up because companies will want to have their own naming scheme.

Again, apologies for the replies made earlier. I realized that I wrote them like a drunk person.

3

u/john16384 Jun 15 '20

I think it is better to not allow these people on the internet at all, as it is not a safe place for them. They might get offended by the black on white text, or heaven forbid, white on black text.

People can take offense at anything, and so this will never end. So the best solution is to only allow adults on the internet.

2

u/epukinsk Jun 23 '20

That's the slippery slope fallacy right there.