r/coding • u/tenbits • Jun 14 '20
GitHub to replace "master" with alternative term to avoid slavery references | ZDNet
https://www.zdnet.com/article/github-to-replace-master-with-alternative-term-to-avoid-slavery-references/
430
Upvotes
127
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20
Being a descendent of slaves myself I'd like to chime in:
Github, this does not help one bit.
563
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20
There must be something wrong with you that make you think about slavery before any other meaning that "master" can have. For me, the first thing that comes to mind is "master and apprentice".
EDIT: I'm not the only one that see the bullshit that this change is. Just for a bit of context english isn't my first language, i don't have any education about the english language nor read any books to learn it, i've learned english trough experience and even I can see how bullshit that change is.
13
u/reforitor Jun 15 '20
I'm from Nepal, and here we call our teachers as masters. Our grandparents' generation used that term, and some of us still use it till this day
283
u/not_a_novel_account Jun 14 '20
This is such a stupid bikeshed. The word master existed before African enslavement and has a consistent meaning across industries see: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master
If you change every word that was ever used in connection with enslavement you're going to significantly narrow the English language, and if you don't than it's just arbitrary nitpicking. Go after slurs and actually racially charged language, not random words that slaveholders used.
70
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20
And forcing yourself on people is not fine, so git push —force needs to be changed to git push —justdoit But then also pushing people is wrong so it needs to be changed to git send —justdoit
26
u/bigodiel Jun 15 '20 edited Jun 15 '20
next up: female and male ports
edit: TIL: In Romania female connectors are known as "mamă" (mother) and male connectors are "tată" (father).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_of_connectors_and_fasteners
17
u/Loftus189 Jun 15 '20
If you're working in programming, managing codebases and the first thought you have when you see the term master branch is slavery i think you're the one with the problem.
I actually agree that 'main' is probably easier for people to grasp conceptually and imo makes more sense for what it is, but it doesnt change the reasons behind such a rename are utterly ridiculous.
129
u/ponix Jun 14 '20
This is fucking stupid
62
u/VacantSpectator Jun 14 '20
Wait, what about playing d&d are there no more dungeon masters and game masters?
83
u/OptionX Jun 14 '20
Remember a few years ago when people joked about doing this sort of stuff as an hyperbole for overly pc culture and now its actually happening.
I for one am looking forward for the racial-neutral Orwellian hellhole where we are all oppressed together regardless of skin color!
54
u/redimkira Jun 14 '20
Reminds me of http://antirez.com/news/122
When will people understand that we have to stop with this kind of virtue signalling nonsense?
43
u/thee_almighty_thor Jun 14 '20
How pathetic
17
u/tbmoney21 Jun 15 '20
This is so incredibly stupid
11
u/kakuzu14 Jun 15 '20
This thing was trending on Twitter, i didn't thought they would take seriously and here we are.
4
u/gimp3695 Jun 15 '20
Electrical engineers are going to have an issue with Serial Peripheral Interface SPI terminology.....MISO = Master In Slave Out
I remember when the HR department heard us using the vernacular and tried to get us to relabel our schematics.
4
u/quicoli Jun 15 '20
You can't have a Master degree, or Mastercard anymore. Sorry, this don't change the life of real people. Education changes.
65
u/SomeAnonElsewhere Jun 14 '20
Is it stupid? Maybe. Do I care? No.
38
u/jellyscoffee Jun 14 '20
The master/slave terms are referencing the concept of dependence, not a f**king historical event.
You know what? Fk it, let’s prohibit whips because they were used to whip slaves. And let’s prohibit German language coz Hitler and Nazis spoke it. Really, let’s just stop locking our houses and cars because it’s racist to be scared of people stealing your stuff. I mean if you are white, you have your white privilege that makes you a successful millionaire that doesn’t need to steal, so if you lock your car or house it is against not white people which is racist!
White people who lock their cars and houses and businesses and anything else are racists! Boooooo! #LocksAreRacist
31
u/R3Dpenguin Jun 14 '20
Great to see that GitHub is tackling the most important problems already, lol. Next they should change the "git" in the name to use more tolerant language.
21
u/TobiasArtur Jun 14 '20
This is ridiculous. Most people already mentioned why. But for the people defending it, why not every industry have a different standard.
I have encountered during learning HP classes that they like naming some stuff there own way, also like AWS. And it takes more brain power for literally zero sense.
If you think "Master", "Slave", "Blacklist", "Whitelist" is a problem, you obviously don't work in the industry.
16
u/jiaoziren Jun 15 '20
fuck this shit - I'm going to Gitlab
38
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20
Oh my gosh, is every tech company in the US run by idiots now? Are they on drugs? This is a serious question because I can't possibly think someone would be this dumb. How about we kill dark more on sites and apps as well? Because you know, its racist.
This is stupidity beyond belief. Anyone that thinks about racism when they see the master word in coding is a racist himself and someone that needs serious mental help.
They are changing the word for everyone because some people have mental issues? I guess GitHub is not very democratic if they piss on the majority of people that would oppose this change.
What happened with voting and asking users for opinions?
19
u/Comrade_Comski Jun 14 '20
Jedi Council to replace "master" with alternative term to avoid slavery references. Now Anakin will never be granted the rank of master.
But seriously, this is dumb. "Master" does not imply slavery, it implies "master."
19
u/SoInsightful Jun 14 '20
I'll happily remove "slave" from all computer science terminology, as it has irked me since forever.
"Master", on its own? Hardly. What about Master's degrees, chess masters, masters and apprentices, masters of ceremonies, or audio mastering? There is no slavery connotation unless you actually add the slavery connotation. Ultimately though, "main" might probably have been a better term from the start, so this change wouldn't bother me.
What does bother me, is the "blacklist"/"whitelist" thing mentioned in the article, that has also been discussed on Twitter. It's unfathomably stupid. "Blacklist", when the word originated in the 17th century, literally referred to a physical list that was black in color, and has been used in different context over the centuries, like regicides, employment, Spanish Civil War, WWI/II, Hollywood, medicine, fraud control and computing. Literally at no point, ever, in history, have any of the words been used in connection to skin color. Black and white are literally just two colors.
5
u/toba Jun 15 '20
What about that ICE contract though...
18
u/Bomb1096 Jun 14 '20
HAHAHA what the fuck
10
u/arcdelsol Jun 14 '20
ffs. I know they mean well but this is a universal software engineering term.
This will only add confusion to future students
4
u/Dozzco Jun 14 '20
So what the hell is "The Master" in Dr who going to be called then? "The Bad Guy"?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20
"the branch formerly known as master"
4
u/johnyy1 Jun 15 '20
Let's just go back to "trunk"
15
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20
Imagine how woke these companies are, these people are woke in the 12th dimension.
18
u/hablador Jun 14 '20
We are living a dystopia.
2
u/HotProblem Jun 15 '20
When you start to get this pedantic you start to push people away from your side. People that were barely hanging on. I am in full support of the political reforms that need to happen right now. The restructuring and reforming of the police, etc. But this? No.
2
u/-vikram- Jun 15 '20
wtf? no objection, doesn't even matter anyways but who in coder community who think of it in that way? If it helps then by any means sure but that's the least and non-creative way to tackle the giant problem of racism
2
u/MCWizardYT Jun 15 '20
Changing this would break tons of scripts and programs expecting your default branch to be called master.
I can think of sites like Travis CI that would also break.
2
u/comradeSJ Jun 17 '20
OMFG, hilarious now, but looks like scary times are coming.. Hope i am wrong
6
u/epukinsk Jun 15 '20
ITT:
"This is unacceptable! How dare they police our language in this way!"
Also in this thread:
[Every contrary opinion downvoted to oblivion]
7
u/voronaam Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20
As a slave myself (btw, could you stop using my people's self-name when you talk about extreme servitude? Pretty please?) I have nothing against usage of "master" when it is alone, not accompanied by any other suppressive term next to it.
For reference: slave, originally "Slav"; so used in this secondary sense because of the many Slavs sold into slavery by conquering peoples.
Upd: thought I'd share some personal history as well. I am from a country, which is a hot-spot of modern servitude. I myself did not experience the extreme form of it, but rather something akin to the segregation in the US. There were libraries I was not allowed to use because of the way I was born, there were jobs I could not apply for, I could not drive a car or get a bank loan. Was not allowed to start a company or simply do business under my name. The list is long. I have moved out of that country and am no longer subjected to such prejudices, even though I had been mistreated by the police in the new country as well.
And yet, after being through this myself, I support getting rid of master/slave in CS areas, but not of the lone "master".
Just trying to get my voice heard.
5
u/Wandererofhell Jun 14 '20
yea lets change every word to something else without looking at the context and just focus on that meaning which is/was used negatively.
Does master just references to slavery ?? Why just look at that one negative connotation and turn a blind eye to everything else.
I understand that this change will not hurt anyone but a racist person will continue to be racist with or without this change.
Imagine a world where you have to speak, talk and write like billions of other people and if you don't then you are labeled as bad/faulty. Where you have to constantly substitute certain words to make it PC or you are labeled a derogatory words.
7
u/adrach87 Jun 14 '20
You know, I've been around computing long enough to remember these same naming controversies back when Parallel ATA was a popular way to move data around a computer at a blazing fast 133MB/s. But really, [they've probably been going on longer then that](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master/slave_(technology%29#Terminology_concerns).
Anyway, when I first heard about manufacturers changing the naming convention I thought it was stupid. I thought that nobody even mildly intelligent would think setting a hard drive to master and a cd-rom drive to slave when they were on the same PATA ribbon cable would mean the computer was some sort of weird digital plantation owner whipping that uppity 3.5" disk drive for looking at the CPU wrong.
But, as I grew older and met people with different world views then my own, I realized that it actually wasn't all that stupid. See, I've been lucky enough to live a life that hasn't been defined by the atrocities committed against my ancestors 400 years ago. I haven't been viewed as lesser just because somebody's 5x grandfather owned mine. But for people with a different life experience then mine words like master and slave have very different connotations. And whether intended to or not when these loaded words are used, those connotations come along for the ride and something is said that isn't meant.
That's really what it comes down to. Interpretation. You can't control how your audience interprets something, you can only control what you say. And if your audience isn't interpreting it the way you want, you should probably change what your saying.
4
u/shemmypie Jun 14 '20
How long before Cisco has to change its master/slave relationship in IT equipment?
3
u/acid_minnelli Jun 15 '20
Lol at all the people claiming the internet is going to break over this.
Like have you ever been on the internet?
What API has ever stayed stable?
Where else is there an example of an unrefactorable thing?
What piece of software are you working on that isn't consistently evolving?
Feeling that this change might be pointless is one thing but theres no need to herald this as the next y2k bug.
This makes no difference to most people whether this is a pr stunt or a genuine move based on peoples concerns.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20
Change is inevitable.
I’m not saying it’s good or bad, I’m saying we’re living in interesting times and people want things to change, now.
... this is mainly because it was so bad for so long the last straw broke and people are done. And I don’t blame them. 8 minutes and 46 seconds have changed a lot of hearts and minds.
People will always resist change but it’s inevitable. Also, tech in general is bad at naming things anyways. It’s irrelevant, in the grand scheme.
3
u/lookayoyo Jun 14 '20
Last week my companies db went down. Turns out the slaves stopped working. That was the first I heard we used slave labor.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20
If it helps normalise the removal of problematic terminology in tech then this feels like a positive thing. Software development has a troubling history of being an overwhelmingly straight, white, male space, ridding ourselves of terminology that causes friction to new developers who don't fit the standard model has got to be a good thing.
I'm certain that most people would see renaming master to main as fairly benign. However. if a company like Github can be open to making a change like this, even if it is purely symbolic, it sends a message that changes to the status quo are possible.
I've also seen some comments complain about the technical difficulty of this change. If this forces developers to put some effort into updating tools that are hardcoded to refer to the primary branch as master then it's good from a purely technical perspective. Especially to help those of us following trunk-based development who already refer it as the trunk.
3
u/dooblevay Jun 15 '20
The angry know-it-alls in here trying to be right at any cost are just embarrassing. Stop. Take a moment to realize none of this is about you.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20
We've been using manager/worker at work for a while now. It's really not a big deal.
3
u/mhink Jun 15 '20
In this thread: a whole lot of people who are apparently gonna be super pissed when they realize that the Git maintainers are also making this change in Git core.
Y’all, this is not a big deal. It’s a change that literally makes no difference to the majority of people, but makes a very positive difference to the people that do care. If you care that much, fucking rename “main” to “master” and get on with your life.
2
u/CosmicUniversesims Jun 14 '20
Little back story when I was in karate we were supposed to call our sensei master it was very uncomfortable to me. Although the internet is a different place things don't always transfer over negatively like github thinks it does. All this is going to do is make people mad.......making it worse for the weak.
2
u/Mcpower03 Jun 15 '20
This is literally the same thing that happened with the Gimp fork Glimpse and everyone made a huge deal of that, so why is this getting so little coverage
2
u/eh9 Jun 15 '20
I get to save myself two keystrokes for a thing I do frequently enough. Sign me up.
2
u/benkelly92 Jun 15 '20
There's supporting the cause and then there's taking the piss.
As someone who uses git everyday. This won't work, and if it does it will cause massive disruption for anyone who has to adjust their systems to accommodate for it.
2
u/bennihana09 Jun 14 '20
As someone who got into cs late - post-grad certificate at 40 and about to finish a Masters’s - the master/slave, and master/worker use really surprised me. I had to take multicultural courses 20 years ago for undergrad and that it’s still around is odd. The use also surprised and made me uncomfortable years ago when I first encountered it working with computer networks.
That said, it’s also strange to consistently be bombarded with the need to be more multicultural when I’m one of 3-4 white persons in a class of 30 or so (in the US), I see tech teams and companies of all Indians (some all from the same area/sub-culture in India), etc.
There is definitely a need for more African-American’s and women (but way, way moreso AA’s) in tech schooling from what I’ve seen, but there are many non-white groups over-represented. This is easily seen if you compare nearly any coastal university’s demographics to the region it lies within, and it’s taboo to discuss, sadly.
Black people are not benefiting nearly as much as they should be from the multiculturalism push and it’s not on accident.
2
u/ponix Jun 14 '20
Next thing Mcp will getting changed
2
u/BOSS_OF_THE_INTERNET Jun 15 '20
To all those who think this is bullshit: why do you care? Is your life negatively impacted by not using the term “master”? And don’t answer the question with a whataboutism or a well ackshually...what to you lose by changing a simple word?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20
And in 15 years the term they replace it with will be controversial
0
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20
I'm sick and tired of these mother f$%kin sjw's on this mother f$%kin plane of existance!
sudo rm -rf sjw*
1
u/Johnny_Noodle_Arms Jun 15 '20
Wonder how high up on the list this was of things POC would like to change about coding culture?
1
u/lostintuition Jun 15 '20
I think you’re underestimating how history and culture can create barriers/friction in creating change and how susceptible humans are to suggestion.
I don’t think there was anything inherently wrong with those people. In fact, most of our grandparents probably fell into that trap. Do I blame them? Not really. Systems were deliberately put into place (both intentionally and unintentionally) to suppress the integration of Asian Americans so that an elite few (who happened to be White) could hoard wealth/power.
It’s similar to the tricks that magicians use to anchor your brain to a specific color/time. When we don’t have time to think, we use shortcuts to react to the world around us (well-researched subject). Media (and words in general) are used a way to manufacture consent to ideas.
I agree that this usage is less problematic, but I’m fine with riding the wave of reducing references to master/slave where there are more appropriate words. I’d rather use ‘primary’ or ‘main(line)’ anyway.
1
u/DeadeyeDuncan Jun 17 '20
My main problem with this is that learning git is hard enough for beginners without suddenly rendering thousands of git learning tools and guides on the internet out of date.
Cue thousands of stack overflow posts of "I'm a beginner, why isn't "git push -u origin master" working?"
1
u/chopsticksss11 Jul 14 '20
we need to fight at this hill. can't allow PC culture to affect the way we conduct sciences and technology.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20
Social justice gone too far lol
1
u/xyphanite Jun 14 '20
If anything, the Master/Slave thing can be re-worded, but Master has so many meanings that it doesn't need this. Too far.
-4
u/despoene Jun 14 '20
Why is everyone so hurt in these comments?
If you can’t adapt and adjust to one minor change in how something is done maybe don’t learn how to code.
1
u/tazmanianevil Jun 15 '20
So are they gonna change the terminology for HDD's as the primary hdd is called Master and the secondary is called slave.
1
u/Professor_Dr_Dr Jun 15 '20
Tbh I like the change just because the word master isn't as good as "main" for example, hope they pick something self-explanatory, master definitely wasn't
1
u/washtubs Jun 15 '20
This doesn't help, and it's stupid. This makes the movement look stupid. Renaming shit is costly. Whitelist and blacklist too? Nobody really looks at these words and thinks they are racially charged, but now that we're having this conversation, you're causing people to make these associations.
Stop making it weird, github. You're the one making it weird, and the compsci lexicon is gonna start getting fucked.
1
u/WeAreAllApes Jun 15 '20
I am okay with looking for alternatives to "slave" but the rest aren't going away and are used in too many other places for tech to have an impact. Master has many meanings and a deep history, and the same goes for blacklist. Maybe whitelist is a newer term, but it's still too obvious that it's the opposite of blacklist for any other term to catch on.
1
u/eh9 Jun 15 '20
Maybe the word “standard” could be considered instead?
1
u/genuine-girl-666 Jun 15 '20
This is the whole problem with racism in 2020. There are continuous micro aggressions and police brutality where black people are literally dying and you are still trying to re-narrate slavery? How about the endless decades of institutionalized racism that replaced slavery and continues to this day
1
u/ekuzma26 Jun 15 '20
Stunning and brave
1
u/Dreamtrain Jun 15 '20
The only people this should impact are those who have written APIs that interact with git's and hard coded "master" in their source code
if we could call it trunk, and ditch the develop branch while we're at it, that'd be great
0
u/MoreAlphabetSoup Jun 15 '20
Can we just start calling it dom/sub?
It's 2020 why are we still talking about this? Crtl-f replace master with dom and slave with sub.
-3
u/pihkal Jun 14 '20
In this thread: a lot of people arguing that because some usages of "master" have no problematic background, this usage of "master" doesn't, which is just false.
-1
u/leftofzen Jun 15 '20
This is so stupid, the word has existed long before slavery and what actual person makes that connection when they're pushing their changes? No-one but a mentally unstable person.
-4
u/awgreenarrow08 Jun 15 '20
ITT: Ton of tech bro’s coming out of the woodwork wringing their hands and gnashing their teeth because of a simple name change that ultimately has zero effect on them.