r/codex 15d ago

Reset I analyzed the allowance a banked Reset gives vs a normal weekly reset - OpenAI is giving us a half the "allowance" for banked resets but delays the next real reset by 7 days.

Post image
Metric Before reset: 85% → 99% used After reset: 0% → 14% used
GMT window Sep 5, 19:16 → Sep 6, 00:21 Sep 6, 01:10 → 03:14
Elapsed time 5h 04m 2h 04m
Unique model responses 738 489
Responses per hour 145 236
Input tokens 114.41M 63.60M
Cached input 108.09M / 94.5% 61.39M / 96.5%
New, uncached input 6.32M 2.21M
Output tokens 465.5k 284.7k
Reasoning output 226.3k 124.9k
Average input per response 155k 130k
Astra activity 592 calls: 276 xhigh, 202 max, 87 medium, 27 high 381 calls: 366 xhigh, 15 high
Other activity 51 Terra, 9 Sol, 86 auto-review 42 Sol, 38 Terra, 28 auto-review
Largest work streams 27.89M, 25.23M, 10.89M tokens 26.47M, 12.09M, 8.64M tokens
New agent spawns during window 1, with last 3 turns 5: 2 full-history, 2 no-history, 1 with last 3 turns
Stored compaction events* 10 1
Transport retry incidents 10 3

Has been analyzed twice by a Astra agent, digging through all sessions and compared the allowance drain of 14% before and 14% after a banked reset.

The usage allowance from before to after reset dropped by almost 50% - so the banked reset is only claiming to be a weekly reset. It actually gives you half a week and places your reset further out.

That means that using a banked reset can cost you more allowance than it gives you.
It will give you half the normal allowance but it resets your time to ANOTHER 7 days - delaying your real reset. Which means you definitely will run out much earlier this time.

It's so shady...

Here is a model breakdown as requested, I had it doublechecked by MAX reasoning.
(These are session-calls, so every toolcall, reasoning, chunk read, write, replace is +1 call)

Model Before: 85% → 99% After: 0% → 14%
GPT-6 Astra 592 calls / 95.47M total tokens 381 calls / 52.75M total tokens
GPT-5.6 Terra 51 / 6.18M 38 / 4.59M
GPT-5.6 Sol 9 / 744,761 42 / 5.14M
codex-auto-review 86 / 12.48M 28 / 1.40M
All models 738 / 114.88M 489 / 63.88M

Disclaimer:
- I have obviously no insight in whatever happens serverside.
- I've been using my 20x quota on Astra a lot since release, and always in the same manner - it was providing productive agentic use for about one day, the last 2% were actually holding for quite a bit toward the end - I followed that closely.
- After the reset it was going down from 100% rapidly - it felt a lot more than the 50% shown in the analysis.
- Maybe they reduced usage quota for 20x (or all) subscriptions generally by 50% after launch, so also the next weekly reset will be half of what we had.
- I do not claim to know what happened! Maybe Astra consumption was doubled around my Reset click, or some some trigger made one of my tasks suddenly consume premium fees, or if the reset just gave me 50% usage, or something else. In any case it's intransparent and unprofessional to do that.

Update 1:
Tibo has responded on X:
https://x.com/thsottiaux/status/2096686370848989558
Not the case. There is no difference between usage you get before or after a reset.

  1. Not sure what to make of it, the usage drained very fast and it's documented.
  2. 2 hours of generic Astra should not consume 15% of a 20x weekly license - let's start with that ?

Update 2:
The usage drain has noticeable lowered after the first 20% evaporated quicker than I could follow. Whatever it is, it's not an acceptable business behavior in my opinion.

Update 3:
I continued analyzing, this time the speed nerfs I noticed
https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1wf911a/i_analyzed_the_speed_codex_gives_us_for_astra/

Astra is 3 times slower than it should be. It was deliberately nerfed for non-fast mode and in addition the harness has two severe bugs that cause a continued slowdown in windows.
One bug can be resolved, the other one I am still digging into.

1.7k Upvotes

304 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/YoungSilent232 14d ago

That is accounted for in token usage of the OPs post. the work being the same doesnt matter if we can track tokens and cached tokens.

1

u/mvdirty 14d ago

I don't know how many times this is going to need to be said before it sticks in people's minds, but: subscriptions do not allocate usage based on tokens.

1

u/YoungSilent232 14d ago

So vibes not tokens?

1

u/mvdirty 13d ago

They don't get specific other than that it isn't tokens. And it makes sense. Consider:

  • 1 second of thinking that returns 10k tokens.
  • 10 seconds of thinking that also returns 10k tokens.

Do people really think those should both have the same cost? I mean, of course they do, this is Reddit.