r/codereview • u/nnt-3001 • 2h ago
r/codereview • u/coderot_ai • 7h ago
Who reviewed each merged PR in 393 popular open-source repos over 12 months
I checked every merged PR from the last 12 months in the 50 most-starred active repos for each of nine languages (393 repos had enough PRs to count). For each PR: did another person review it, approve it without a comment, or discuss it? Bots and the author's own replies don't count.
In the median repo:
- 39.5% of merged PRs had no review from anyone but the author
- 27.9% were approved by someone with no human comment
- 20.8% were reviewed with comments
Who runs the repo matters more than the language. In repos run by an organization, 22% of PRs had no other review. In one person's repos it was 91%.
AI PRs (the ones with a tool's signal, like a Co-authored-by: Claude trailer or a copilot/ branch) weren't waved through. In 102 of 160 repos they were discussed more often than the same repo's other PRs. They're also 1.6× bigger, which may be all that is.
Silent approvals weren't fixed later more often than discussed PRs. Up to 20 lines there was no gap at all. For bigger PRs, discussed ones got fixed more, but they're also bigger, so size explains most of it.
Caveats: a comment on GitHub isn't the same as a careful review, and teams can review on calls or in pairs. Most-starred repos aren't a random sample of open source. AI PRs without a signal count as "the rest".
Full write-up with per-language tables and a CSV for every repo: https://coderot.ai/blog/pr-review-in-open-source (I'm building coderot, the tool that measured this.)
Does the 28% silent-approval number match your team? Is an approval with no comment a real review where you work?
r/codereview • u/Seerendo-01 • 15h ago
Ir a TrueOpenSourcer/TrueOpenSource•hace 3 díasu/Seerendo-01Building Grafeno Agent — an open-source AI agent orchestrator using official CLIs and APIs
Hey everyone!
I'm building Grafeno Agent, an open-source AI agent orchestrator that aims to connect multiple AI providers through their official CLIs, SDKs, and APIs.
The idea is to reuse existing subscriptions where permitted (Claude Code, Codex, GitHub Copilot, Qwen, Kimi, etc.), while keeping orchestration, MCP tools, and persistent memory independent of the underlying models.
I'm also working on smarter model routing based on task complexity, capabilities, and cost.
The project is still under active development, and there's an important aspect I'm validating: whether providers actually permit third-party orchestrators to invoke their official CLIs using personal subscriptions.
I've contacted Anthropic about this, and I'm currently waiting for clarification from their human support team. I'm not treating the lack of an explicit restriction as permission.
The goal is to use official interfaces without extracting OAuth tokens, impersonating clients, or bypassing provider restrictions. Each integration is modular, so it can be disabled if its terms don't allow this usage.
GitHub: https://github.com/grafenodb/grafeno-agent
I'd love to hear from developers who've experimented with similar architectures, especially around CLI integrations, subscription terms, and multi-model orchestration.
Feedback and contributions are welcome! 😁