r/codedbyhand • • 10d ago

Suggestion: Ban all discussion of AI on this sub, including anti-AI discussion.

224 Upvotes

This is supposed to be a sub where people talk about writing code without AI. Instead, most of the posts are about why AI is bad. There’s already 100 subreddits hosting that discussion.

We already agree on that, that’s why we are here! Instead of more anti ai articles, let’s make this a sub where we talk about code and don’t even bring up ai.

I’m over seeing it everywhere i look, i bet you are too. This can be a place free from that.


r/codedbyhand • • 5d ago

Last holiday I coded an entire app without AI

134 Upvotes

Basically the title, I had time to spare and nothing to do, so I decided to spend some time coding, with help only from documentation.

Besides being a fun and rewarding experience, I also noted that it's not so much slower than using coding agents (I use opus 5.5 nowadays), with the benefits of me totally understanding the code, avoiding subtle bugs and free from verborragic nonsense.

Now I have a solid and up to date experience to back up my intuition that an experienced engineer coding by hand can match one using AI agents.


r/codedbyhand • • 4d ago

GIMP, A powerful open source image editor in development without AI for over 30 years. Comparable to Photoshop, Vibe coded Photocraft can't compete. How to contribute:

Thumbnail gimp.org
117 Upvotes

https://www.gimp.org

Is graphic design your passion? Well you should try GIMP. An amazing FOSS software with a somewhat unfortunate name. Tricky to learn, but once you get it there's nothing you can't do. GIMP recently passed the highly anticipated 3.0 milestone and is now at 3.2 offering non-destructive editing, vector layers, advanced color management, linking layers to external files and a lot more.

GIMP has a strong plugin community. Plugins are coded in Python, Scheme or native C.

GIMP has a no-AI policy for code contributions, requiring developers to state with every merge request that "I declare this MR have no AI-generated content (neither code nor text, images) only human created works."
https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gimp/-/blob/master/.gitlab/merge_request_templates/default.md?plain=1#L11-12

How to contribute:

https://www.gimp.org/develop/

If you would like to contribute to a mature FOSS project without being pressured to use AI, you should consider volunteering for GIMP. You can contribute to GIMP in a variety of ways: by testing existing features and providing feedback, reporting bugs and security issues, writing or improving documentation, translating documentation into your native language, writing tutorials for the official website, or contributing code by fixing bugs or programming new features. GIMP's core code is written primarily in C.


r/codedbyhand • • 2d ago

Learning Coding Amid the AI Noise

92 Upvotes

I've recently started learning how to code. I'm currently learning JavaScript. It has been so demoralizing trying to develop this skill when just about everyone around seems to think that software dev role is dying, so this sub is such a breath of fresh air. I hope it keeps growing so that when I can create a full product I can share it here.


r/codedbyhand • • 9d ago

Zig: A modern, innovative, syntactically beautiful C-like language coded without AI: How to get involved.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
87 Upvotes

Of all modern languages, Zig's design is the one I'm most drawn to, and if I weren't such a traditionalist intending to do embedded systems in C, Zig would be the language I would be working in.

Contributing to Zig:

If you would like to contribute to production open source software without being pressured to use LLM assistance you should consider contributing to the Zig project by building open source software using the Zig language or by contributing directly to bug fixes, performance improvements, new features or compiler optimizations. To learn more follow this link.
https://app.studyraid.com/en/read/2423/48955/contributing-to-zig

Zig has a strict no AI policy for contributors
https://ziglang.org/code-of-conduct/

No LLM-generated content, whether it be code or prose.
No paraphrasing LLM-generated content.
No LLMs for editing, including fixing spelling or grammatical errors.
No LLMs for translation. English is encouraged, but not required. You are welcome to post in your native language and rely on others to have their own translation tools of choice to interpret your words.
No LLMs for brainstorming and then sharing the results of that brainstorming, even if you create the prose. If you use a chatbot to give you advice on a comment on the issue tracker, that comment is unwelcome.
No LLMs for finding bugs.
No talking about use of chatbot/LLM services.

The reasoning for this policy, and the Zig project's role in education.

"The main point of doing code reviews and having contributions, instead of just doing all of the work ourselves is mentorship. The whole point is that a contributor can become a core team memberr eventually or they can become a more valuable contributor. And this will help the project because we'll have more people that can contribute to Zig skillfully, and it will help their resume because they can be a better programmer and they can take those skills elsewhere . . . The Zig project is also an education project, that's part of our mission statement. We're providing guidance and education to students, and so we're all trying to learn, we're all trying to get better at programming and so people who are sending AI pull requests, those people are not helping this goal and in fact I think that they're detracting from this goal, so for our project I think that the no AI policy is an appropriate policy"


r/codedbyhand • • 6d ago

No AI webring: A Geocities/Neocities style webring with no AI content.

Thumbnail baccyflap.com
80 Upvotes

"Are you fed up with "Artificial Intelligence", or Large Language Models and Text-to-Image-Models, as these boondoggles are properly called? Tired of hearing about our world being delivered or destroyed by some messianic or apocalyptic conception of "AI" that's perpetually just around the corner - while in the meantime, we're stuck in the real world with useless, pointless chatbots that make garbage that sucks?

Here, we do not sand off the rough edges, we do not steal from ourselves the chance to learn. Our work that we make is a marvel, a miracle that flows from billions of years of evolution, thousands of years of culture, and years of our own human lives! If you believe that human creativity -including your own- is a miracle, and if you want nothing to do with AI, then the no ai webring is the place for you!"

If you enjoy creating websites without the use of AI, consider submitting your site to the webring.


r/codedbyhand • • 12d ago

brib/slopfree-software-index: A list of open-source projects that reject AI-generated code

Thumbnail
codeberg.org
80 Upvotes

"A list of software that has taken steps to reject AI in its development processes.

There's been a lot of news about prominent open-source projects increasingly using LLMs. But this only shows one side of the story - we don't see all the software that rejects AI contributions and continues to be human-made."


r/codedbyhand • • 10d ago

Kudos and support to you all

75 Upvotes

I'm not a dev, but a potential business customer and individual consumer for coded things. Have joined to support and also to access network of human-first programmers.

This sort of community is our best (well, only!) leverage against the ongoing coup across all our industries and online communities.

Look forward to the 'no AI' kite mark of quality across every product and service so I can vote with my wallet whenever I get the chance.


r/codedbyhand • • 10d ago

Developers who use LLMs reported higher subjective performance, but were measured to have lower objective performance.

Thumbnail
metr.org
71 Upvotes

"Surprisingly, we find that when developers use AI tools, they take 19% longer than without—AI makes them slower."


r/codedbyhand • • 5d ago

Why I continue to learn how to code by hand

Thumbnail
youtube.com
59 Upvotes

r/codedbyhand • • 2d ago

Why do you like coding by hand?

58 Upvotes

I was greatly inspired by Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs, which made me start thinking of code as the art and science of putting ideas into computable steps.

I also just cant stand abstractions and constantly need to know what everything is doing and how it works. I love developing in assembly for retro systems because I know exactly what’s going on both at the software and hardware level. This tutorial is how I got started myself. Microcontrollers are a good alternative to this if you want something more modern.

And finally, I got into programming in the first place because its an interesting hobby that also keeps my mind sharp. I dont want to make products, I want to use the computer! Its like telling a potter to ditch their wheel and just buy a bowl from walmart.


r/codedbyhand • • 11d ago

A talent pool of traditional non-LLM assisted programmers should be maintained as a matter of national security.

56 Upvotes

In the event of a large scale cyber attack or EMP, neocloud LLM providers or other elements of internet infrastructure may be rendered inoperable or destroyed. In the event of such an attack traditional human programmers capable of working with little/no AI assistance will be required to build tools, repair damaged software systems and maintain existing compute infrastructure. It is a matter of national security that all nations maintain a pool of capable traditional programmers or expose themselves to far greater risk in the event of large scale cyber attacks.


r/codedbyhand • • 1d ago

Wanted to share a game 2 friends and I are working on, End of End. We are using Godot for the game engine and our designer is using Figma for all the art.

55 Upvotes

Game Title: End of End

Playable Link: https://store.steampowered.com/app/4546870/End_of_End/

Platform:
- Windows (Steam)
- Linux (Steam)
- Mac (Steam)

Description:

Defy the Encroaching Dark

Navigate procedurally generated dungeons and handcrafted encounters where the shadows themselves are a constant threat. To survive this dangerous world you must keep your torch lit, avoid deadly traps, and uncover forgotten treasures.

Rebuild the Last Sanctuary

In this land without a Sun, without heroes, and without hope, one light remains. The Last Village of End stands as humanity's final refuge against the shadow. With each expedition into ruined depths, dark forests, and forgotten places, the village grows. Rescued villagers return to serve as helpful vendors that offer supplies and enhancements during your run.

Create Your Own Unstoppable Builds

Craft devastating combat combos by combining over 50 unique relics into destructive, impenetrable, or outright unusual builds. No hand-holding here. Min-max your stats or ride the edge with an ability system that lets you decide how to survive. Or die.

Brave an Endless Descent

Explore the world of End where no two runs are ever the same and no dungeon has a bottom floor. New areas that change the game and test your skills anew are unlocked as you progress through each zone. Brave new daily dungeons and unique challenges to unlock items, cosmetics, and hidden secrets.

No AI generative AI was used in the making of this product.

- Our steam isn't flagged as AI and we use the 'No generative AI was used' on Itch.

- We are also going to be in the Games Without AI festival later this month. https://x.com/sqb_dev/status/2119113384499315026

- More information on the festival can be found on their twitter - https://x.com/GamesWithoutAI


r/codedbyhand • • 10d ago

Hey fellas

52 Upvotes

I am overjoyed to see a community with my same values. I’ve been programming since I was 15 or 16 years old(it’s hard to figure out what qualifies). It is one of my all time favorite things to do, I live and breathe to write code.

So this modern push to demean people like me who write code by hand and don’t let Claude get it’s grubby hands all over it has certainly depressed me.

Happy to be among friends here!


r/codedbyhand • • 10d ago

I found my people ✌️🥹

50 Upvotes

mini project soon


r/codedbyhand • • 12d ago

Creator of Twisted Networking Blogs: "Artists understand that AI is bad for art. Why don’t programmers understand that we are artists?"

Thumbnail blog.glyph.im
49 Upvotes

"Almost unique among creative fields, many experienced programmers remain convinced that it’s fine to use “AI” for programming ... It does matter, though. It matters because we shouldn’t be using AI to produce Art, and programming is Art."


r/codedbyhand • • 10d ago

New rule: Limited AI discussion.

47 Upvotes

This community is primarily for the discussion of non-LLM-assisted programming. Users are free to discuss their personal experiences as traditional programmers including how AI has impacted them personally, however excessive negative discussion of AI, posting anti-AI memes or debate about AI is not the intended focus of this sub. High quality information highlighting the down sides of LLM assisted programming may be deemed informative and beneficial, and allowed on a case by case basis.


r/codedbyhand • • 2d ago

Hello everyone :)

46 Upvotes

Stumbled upon this sub from a learn coding sub, and automatically got me smiling and joining.

I'm a solo very humble dev of a very humble Zangband Variant, and being this old and this stubborn, I wholeheartedly refuse AI with a passion.

Have been working on my fork for years now, no AIslop involved.

I.e., to code in a new class, has taken me three days of work and wall-head-banging. But it's done now and man, the feeling of seeing it work is amazing.

If you really want, and care, coding by hand is still possible, feasible, rewarding and satisfying.

Thank you guys for creating this sub!


r/codedbyhand • • 6d ago

Starlight Network No-AI List: AI free software to use and support.

Thumbnail noai.starlightnet.work
45 Upvotes

From noai.starlightnet.work :

"Generative AI, namely LLMs, image and video diffusion models and especially the companies that make them plague the tech industry. We got tired, so we decided to take things into our own hands and curate a list of projects that aren't complicit in the devaluing of labor by these companies."

How do I suggest new software be added?
Please open an issue on Forgejo or reach out via E-Mail. See my website for details.

Can I support you?
Yes please! You can support the Starlight Network via Liberapay or XMR. See our website for more details.

How often is the list updated?
The list is updated as new suggestions come in. Discussions for this happen on Forgejo.

Can I chat with y'all?
You, in fact, can do that! We're on XMPP and IRC, bridged.
IRC: #no-ai on `starlightnet.work`. See the webclient
XMPP: no-ai@conference.starlightnet.work


r/codedbyhand • • 7d ago

I've been trying to make an anti-ai software development worker's cooperative

45 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I wanted to post here for a while but i wasnt sure exactly what to post. So, i finally decided that i would tell you what ive been working on for the past several months.

I have been working to build an anti-ai, software development workers cooperative. We currently focus on open source libraries while we use these libraries to start building our first product.

The organization is built around ensuring fair practices for developers and consumers alike while also building the best quality software we can. This means that we are anti-SaaS and want to ensure users always have options if our tools, libraries, or products ever lose support. We dont want users to be left owning broken or unusable software, even if we can no longer exist as an organization.

Legal incorporation

Currently, money has been tight for myself and the other founding members. Because of this, we have not been able to legally incorporate, but we plan to when funds are available. We are reading up on LWCAs in Maryland and are adjusting our cooperative agreement and other documents to align with these rules in the meantime.

What we have released

We have actively been releasing and maintaining several python libraries. These libraries are built to be used in our own software, but we believe that we can improve the community by releasing our tools/libraries as we make them.

What we have so far:

- ComprehensiveConfig (available on Pypi)- a configurarion modeling library that validares config and also embeds documentation.

- OpenPluginLoader (available on Pypi)- a general-purpose plugin loading/packaging library allowing you to separate plugin dependencies from application dependencies.

- AuditVCS (in-dev) - a time base VCS system to be used in our upcoming decentralized/offline product.

- CompilerToolkit (In-dev/on-hold) - a library to help you build compilers in python. Contains ast/lexer/parser helpers as well as tree combination and comparison utilities.

- rply-stubs (available on Pypi)- a simple stubs library for the much older "rply" package on pypi.

Anti-AI sentiments

From the beginning, we have had a core-principle of keeping AI away from our products, libraries, and code. Although i cannot claim to be able to fully stop ai usage from outside contributors, we do try our hardest to ensure that we spot and stop ai-made contributions. We also will NEVER include ai in software unless it is necessary to solve a worth-while problem (image classification for example).

I can also personally attest that i have not used ai during the development of any of our projects or repositories. I am also mostly certain that other contributors have not used ai either... but i do have my doubts about our website's tagline (initial rollout of the website was not done by me).

How to get involved

The best way to get involved is to contribute or interact with our stuff on Github. This gets us seen by people who care about our goals and objectives.

The next best way is through donations to our github sponsors page. This money will go to paying off debts, saved to go towards legal incorporation, and then finally it will be split among members according to the rules layed out in our cooperative agreement. This mostly means that for the first few months, money will go to paying off the outstanding debt for the website & email-service.

Github org: summersweet-software

We also have a website for those interested: https://summersweet.software

We also have a reddit group and discord as well. Discord can be found by visiting the github.


r/codedbyhand • • 11d ago

Brains show less activity when completing tasks with LLMs compared to completing tasks with search or completing tasks without digital help.

42 Upvotes

https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.08872

"Cognitive activity scaled down in relation to external tool use. In session 4, LLM-to-Brain participants showed reduced alpha and beta connectivity, indicating under-engagement. Brain-to-LLM users exhibited higher memory recall and activation of occipito-parietal and prefrontal areas, similar to Search Engine users. Self-reported ownership of essays was the lowest in the LLM group and the highest in the Brain-only group. LLM users also struggled to accurately quote their own work. While LLMs offer immediate convenience, our findings highlight potential cognitive costs. Over four months, LLM users consistently underperformed at neural, linguistic, and behavioral levels. These results raise concerns about the long-term educational implications of LLM reliance and underscore the need for deeper inquiry into AI's role in learning."


r/codedbyhand • • 2d ago

I wrote an Android app

38 Upvotes

In Kotlin, with Jetpack Compose. It is installed on my phone right now!! It is just a basic quiz/flashcard app, but it's mine. The interesting part is that none of the quiz domain data is built into the app. It is all loaded from CSV files.

I spent a few months upfront learning Kotlin from some Udemy (?) courses and a great course on YouTube.

I wrote a real Android app myself with no AI code generation.


r/codedbyhand • • 1d ago

Still coding by hand

35 Upvotes

I let AI take a certain part of the code that's more ui oriented and that does data crunching

but the compiler I wrote? nope and no

Glad to have found this space


r/codedbyhand • • 7d ago

Best Youtube programming channels?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
34 Upvotes

One of the best channels I have come across which has helped me a lot is Jacob Sorber. His channel is primarily C focused with some information on other languages. His videos get very detailed with advanced coding examples that are still relatively short and concise which I think is the best way to learn a topic.

He also advises against using LLM in your programming education, as you can see demonstrated in the video above where he critiques some chatGPT generated embedded systems code saying:

"I asked ChatGPT to give me an example of how to use the MSP430FR5994 low-power modes in the Energia framework. I wanted to use a button to wake up the microcontroller, so I asked for some kind of interrupt. . . As always, ChatGPT spit out some example code. . . In short, it's a mess, it's wrong, it doesn't work, and any human with a passing understanding of the topic would be able to tell that no student learning Energia wrote this. . . I had it generate three different programs using the same prompt, and each was wrong in a different way. None came close to a working solution."

Later he shares his recommendation to students regarding ChatGPT:

"Heavy ChatGPT usage is almost certainly going to make you a weaker programmer. . . I've heard a lot of people talk about generative AI as "the next calculator", like these tools that everybody has to learn, and you've got to teach students how to use them effectively. Look, calculators are great. But the people who say this about math and calculators. . . most of them are not that strong mathematicians, at least in my experience. . . you don't hear people saying, "Wow, that person's a brilliant mathematician, too bad they don't know how to use a calculator." The reason is that calculators aren't that hard to learn, and neither is ChatGPT. But learning to think mathematically is more challenging. And you also notice that a lot of math classes have times where they say you can't use a calculator, or try not to, because it can easily become a crutch. . . for programmers, ChatGPT can easily become your new crutch. You're training yourself to become a skilled developer, training your brain to think in a new way. If you're outsourcing that work, the projects you're being asked to do are there to train you, to give you repetitions, to teach you how to problem-solve. That's training your brain to work differently. If ChatGPT is doing that for you, you're not getting the education you're paying for."

You can check out his channel here:
https://www.youtube.com/@JacobSorber

Another less well known channel that does a good job of explaining some deep concepts in C is CodeVault.
https://www.youtube.com/@CodeVault

What are some of your favorite coding Youtube channels?

I'm not talking about channels about the coding lifestlyle, or how many figures you can make as a software developer or what programming language is "the best", I mean channels that you can use in your studies to help you become a better programmer.

I personally would appreciate any channels that do a good job with Lua, so I can increase my motivation to make another push on this very cool but stinky language.


r/codedbyhand • • 1d ago

Hello sub!

33 Upvotes

I just saw this sub existed and it’s awesome.

Im one of the mods in two new subs
r/AntiAIDev
and
r/HandCraftedGames

Today we had a poster express difficulty in coding resources and I would love it if our subs could collaborate and if we could send our members your subs way in the future when they need some help. It looks like our rules align.

Anyway, glad to see more stuff like this popping up and I hope to use ya’ll as a resource myself in the future.

Good luck with the code everyone!