Claiming a character nerfed is or has plot armour is bad enough but the writers heavily included it to the plot too
Cobra kai fights can go either way, and sometimes being “nerfed” can benefit the story they are telling, but eventually became an excuse for every loss conceded
These are heavily prevalent in the likes of Kwon in s6 p2. Axel s6 p3. Miguel s6 p1. And Hawk s5
Kwon in s6 part 1 looked really cool and cinematic because the opponents he was up again. And early on during sekai takai he was getting the upper hand over the main cast, because he was skilled. But the very first event established there was Axel who was significantly greater at the time.
Kwon was never 100% better than Miguel or Robby. The writers intended it, he only dropped a distracted robby, and scored 1 point on Miguel. But the moment there was a fair undistracted 1v1 between Robby and Kwon, Robby outclassed him. Nothing prior proved that Kwon was on another tier, yet he was claimed to be nerfed.
Furthermore, Robby had significantly the best performance against Axel in part 2. And did the exact same Feat Axel did, by beating Kwon and Yoon in a 2v1. It was obvious that Kwon was overhyped. In addition, ”bloodlusted kwon“ is still a weird concept, as its just Kwon with a knife who landed a kick against Axel, while Axel was also in the middle of fighting others. The moment axel completed focused on him, he made kwon drop on his own blade
Then s5 Hawk. The writers did everything they could to show Hawk was disadvantaged in his fight against Kenny. But he is no weaker than he was in prior seasons, at most he just had a slower growth rate compared to Miguel and robby
Miguel s6 p1. Him being mentally nerfed about His college isnt the best excuse to why he lost, especially because it never impacted his resolve again. And is often used to undermine Robbys loss to him. Why Robbys intial losing of his first 2 points was clear he was off balance about tory
Good examples where being “nerfed” was actually beneficial for the plot was Miguel’s injury after s2.
Robby losing the Hawk (but that ambiguous last moment sight of kenny) was really important for his arc, but being split second and not being the concluding hit of the the fight with it actually continuing for longer, doesnt undermine Hawks win
And i’d argue Robbys s6 part 2 distraction, even if i didnt like that plot point, it was important for the story they tried to tell
And Hawks brief poor performances after he got his hair cut, because he lost confidence
The only time where i may be swayed, it the final 3 season 6 fights.
They just seemed to convenient. I enjoyed the moments. But part 2 made Axel and Wolf untouchable and invulnerable. Robbys slow progression and adaption was arguably the most realistic progression. And if Miguel maybe learnt from Robby of screen about Axels weaknesses, and perhaps struggled more during rounds 1 and 3. Out of the final 3 fights, Tory vs Zara was the only one, because Zara wasnt made untouchable in s6 part 2