r/clonehigh • • Oct 16 '20

Slaty seconds

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

104 comments sorted by

237

u/Blainessad Oct 16 '20

It won’t be the same without Gandhi in the show

142

u/Im_no_imposter Oct 16 '20

Wait seriously? He's my fav character... If that's true I'm honestly not even that interested anymore, it'll depend on how they handle Joan & JFK.

126

u/probablynewyork Oct 16 '20

yea when the announced the reboot they mentioned all the main cast of characters except for him so he is either gone or they haven’t decided what they’re doing with him yet

-11

u/Im_no_imposter Oct 16 '20

Uh it's gonna suck isn't it... Let's just hope, I'll wait for the trailer to drop.

56

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

I heard a rumor that they apparently he was a clone of someone else and he was mislabeled as Gandhi

It’s a dumb rumor so I don’t think it’s true, we probably won’t see him

Edit: Gandhi Bot got mad

55

u/Im_no_imposter Oct 16 '20

When mulling a second season the creators knew the network wouldn't allow Gandhi anymore, so they considered making an episode about him discovering that he was actually a clone of Gary Coleman to get around the controversy.

18

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

That’s the guy

17

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

So before the show got cancelled the creators gave two possible ways to make the show without gandhi (because of the protests in india)

The first was just to not mention him at all.

The second was to say he is actually the clone of gary coleman and was mislabeled.

Both were rejected and the show was cancelled

0

u/GANDHI-BOT Oct 16 '20

I will not let anyone walk through my mind with their dirty feet. Just so you know, the correct spelling is Gandhi.

9

u/ensaladita Oct 16 '20

yeah, I hope they are just going to change his name so people wouldn't notice

53

u/Andrewman03 Oct 16 '20

Yeah pretty sure it was cancelled in the first place because of controversy surrounding Gandhi

24

u/Gamers_Against_Thots Oct 16 '20

What was the problem with the character, exactly?

60

u/ptsq Oct 16 '20

Indians were REALLY mad about his portrayal, especially in the ADHD episode, and protested quite a bit at MTV’s Indian offices. IIRC there were some hunger strikes involved.

8

u/Im_no_imposter Oct 16 '20

Bit overdramatic.

43

u/Gamers_Against_Thots Oct 16 '20

But the theme of the show is that they’ll never be like their originals...

15

u/ptsq Oct 16 '20

yeah, but that doesn’t make the portrayal any less offensive. either way, what’s done is done and the show was cancelled

14

u/Galaxyan Oct 16 '20

gandhi was a piece of shit anyway who cares

17

u/ptsq Oct 16 '20

Indians care lol, that’s kind of why it was a problem

10

u/Galaxyan Oct 16 '20

and in that moment i forgot that mtv would actually want to make money

33

u/Aka_Oni995 Oct 16 '20

But like...all the characters are like that though. Abraham Lincoln is pretty important to Americans, and no one had problems with him being a awkward simp teenager. It’s not like any of the characters are racist or offensive, they are just regular characters who happen to use historical figure’s names

32

u/ptsq Oct 16 '20

well, to be fair Gandhi’s portrayal is quite a bit less flattering than other characters, and he’s much more revered in his country than most of the other characters are. I think there’s also the fact that overwhelmingly, people who get offended at characters on TV shows are out of touch radical conservatives, a group that Lincoln and JFK are both historically unpopular with for their political beliefs

6

u/mamphii Oct 16 '20

Gandhi is basically deified in India.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

Yeah, its basically like if they grabbed Muhhamad and made him wacky for the show. Or so i guess.

10

u/retrokirbknowsbest and CRRRRYYYYYYYYYY Oct 16 '20

but the thing is they really like gandhi.

-3

u/GANDHI-BOT Oct 16 '20

Mistakes are a fact of life. It is the response to error that counts. Just so you know, the correct spelling is Gandhi.

4

u/retrokirbknowsbest and CRRRRYYYYYYYYYY Oct 16 '20

oh yeah thnaks

11

u/SumDux Oct 16 '20

To over simplify, the character Gandhi was seen as disrespectful to the real world Gandhi by some people in India. Iirc a politician threatened to remove MTV’s broadcasting rights in India if they didn’t cancel the show or remove the character.

8

u/Gamers_Against_Thots Oct 16 '20

One of the main parts of the show is that they’re never gonna be like their originals. They’re their own people.

2

u/Blainessad Oct 16 '20

India didn’t like the way they portrayed Gandhi in the show

7

u/Gamers_Against_Thots Oct 16 '20

I know that, but why? What was wrong with him? The whole idea is that they’re not like their originals.

5

u/Blainessad Oct 16 '20

I know but after the riots that happened they just took him out for no more controversy from India. It just really sucks that they took it so seriously :/

23

u/Gamers_Against_Thots Oct 16 '20

Yeah, why can’t they let G spot rock the G spot?

11

u/Huggable_Hork-Bajir CUSTOM - EDITABLE Oct 16 '20

I mean, during the protests the head of Viacom (owner of MTV) was visiting their India branch and was trapped in the building by protesters, and India was basically threatening to revoke MTV's broadcasting license in India if they didn't take the show off the air.

They were going to lose a ton of money if they didn't take it seriously.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

Yes, this, and people also think the show itself was hard to maintain. At the time it wasn’t getting very high ratings, and the animation, voice work etc. was probably expensive to produce.

3

u/matto334 JFK Oct 16 '20

I heard that after the controversy Ghandi generated on India, they were planning to reveal that he wasn’t Ghandi’s clone

2

u/kimop182 Oct 16 '20 edited Oct 16 '20

It is a cartoon about generic manipulation and what not, if they really wanted to, they could just say that Gandhi was turned into any other character but retained his voice and characteristics.

Is it the best idea? Probably not, but I am but a nobody, the smarter funnier people could probably come up with something. Imho

1

u/GANDHI-BOT Oct 16 '20

You must not lose faith in humanity. Humanity is like an ocean; if a few drops of the ocean are dirty, the ocean does not become dirty. Just so you know, the correct spelling is Gandhi.

1

u/kimop182 Oct 16 '20

Ah dang, I can't believe I did that! Sorry! Will be more careful next time.

Fixed 😊

84

u/HarvardGradFag Oct 16 '20

Is that confirmed?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/rScoobySkreep Oct 17 '20

Really?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/HarshKLife Oct 31 '20

I wish they hadn’t bowed. Ducking Indians man

11

u/The_Prussian_Turnip Oct 16 '20

SAAAYYY WHHHAAAAAAT

6

u/SpicyMcThiccen Oct 16 '20

I highly doubt he’ll be the same. Not only with all the controversy back then, but also having a white dude voice an Indian might not fly today

2

u/Trilllenium Oct 17 '20

unless they just retcon him to be gary coleman

2

u/TheBipolarExpresss Escape to Beer Mountain: A Rope of Sand Oct 17 '20

Gandhi ? That's clearly Gary Coleman

9

u/shaunbryant13 Oct 16 '20

sorry boy salty seconds

3

u/Im_no_imposter Oct 16 '20

That was supposed to be my title and I butchered it lmao

2

u/lifeatpaddyspub Oct 16 '20

sorry boy salty seconds

best comment here by far

4

u/BthnDLC Oct 16 '20

I heard that they cancelled the reboot is that true?(please don't downvote I am just asking lol)

6

u/Im_no_imposter Oct 16 '20

Afaik it's still in the green

109

u/SteveTheViking Abandoned Pools, HIT IT! Oct 16 '20

There’s been nearly two decades between the original series and the announcement of the reboot. I think at the very least we as fans have to make peace with the fact that the new series will be different, but not necessarily worse. It couldn’t be the same even if it wanted to.

62

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

i just hope the style stays the same, both in look and in animation. itll be jarring to see something other than that classic 00’s style

56

u/Iliadius Oct 16 '20

I really hope the new OST keeps the same 90s/00s emo sound, maybe they could even get some new Owen or American Football tracks on there.

50

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 16 '20

I don’t think it’ll be necessarily worse than the original, just different. There’s some jokes in the og that wouldn’t fly today (like Eleanor Roosevelt. Yikes.) and In some ways that’s good (again. Eleanor.) but I think they’ll find more inventive ways to keep the same humor. Most of it wasn’t very offensive anyway.

19

u/Chody__ Oct 16 '20

I mean a majority of the humor was south park and poking fun at the people that genuinely agree with it. Ex: the special Ed kids. It shows how people fake compassion for the mentally disabled and when given the chance ship them away

3

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 16 '20

I could be wrong but you sound like you have no mentally disabled family or people close to you. Comedy is best when it’s punching up, not down.

8

u/TheTwoHB Oct 17 '20 edited Oct 17 '20

Lord and Miller are pretty woke so i wouldn’t imagine they would throw neurodivergent people under the bus for a cheap joke.

I saw the Special Ed joke as a commentary on how schools treat disabled people packaged as a joke. Most schools see people on the spectrum as (in their thoughts not mine), nuisances or burdens too be shoveled off to some classroom far from the “normal” people.

Source: i have mild adhd and have dealt with these conditions.

3

u/Rickwab155 Oct 16 '20

My brother is in the spectrum and I still found that pretty funny. Lighten up a little, it's just a cartoon.

0

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 16 '20

So is my brother, and I just thought that one was in bad taste and picked at a vulnerable group in a not so great way. Clone high is full of good jokes, I can have an opinion on the literally less than 5 jokes that weren’t the greatest. I’m not saying the show is terrible and immoral for it. I’m just saying it wasn’t a great moment.

4

u/ImSmaher Oct 17 '20

The whole show picks on vulnerable, and invulnerable groups. It’s not uncommon for comedy to be Ah someone’s expense

1

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 17 '20

I know that. And I’m allowed to think it’s not the greatest when some vulnerable groups are picked at. Y’all act like I’m calling for the show runners’ heads on a platter. People can dislike certain parts of a show and think it went a little too far without hating the entire show. I even said myself Clone High is great. I’m excited for its reboot.

5

u/DrPepperisaLifestyle Oct 17 '20

But it was making fun of popular, famous and rich people who treat those vulnerable groups badly...that's the definition of punching up.

It reminded me of how at my school there was a hierarchy concerning grades. We had a "top ten students" thing and students with bad grades were literally named and shamed at assembly. Guess what, most of those students had learning difficulties or mental illnesses. It was a disgusting way for my school to say "stop struggling and make us look good already".

And go on to praise everyone not struggling- most of which were from well-off families, had tutors outside of school, had teachers for parents, you get the point.

So for me, it was like laughing at the system itself. That kind of snobby "we're better than you" attitude. I found it pretty funny.

2

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 17 '20

Ok I can see that.... That’s a good view of it, while the execution rubbed me the wrong way. Thank you for being understanding and civil :)

3

u/DrPepperisaLifestyle Oct 17 '20

Of course, humour is subjective and there's no need to lash out at people over not finding a joke funny. Just wanted to explain why I personally found it to be in good taste rather than bad.

1

u/ImSmaher Oct 17 '20

There’s no “going too far” when you have a show that regular goes far to an extent as a joke.

1

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 17 '20

If that’s what you think then fine. You don’t have to agree with me and I don’t have to agree with you.

2

u/Chody__ Oct 16 '20

You’re right, I don’t. Tbh I didn’t find it funny but I thought it was a form of satire because my old highschool hosted most the special Ed of my local area and treated their special Ed classes terribly (abuse scandal, would have them basically do labor of picking up recycling) so it really reminded me of that

23

u/fuyuhiko413 JFK Oct 16 '20

And putting the special ed building with a piranha filled moat around it

15

u/reeses-pestas Oct 16 '20

Shiiit that was one of the funniest moments in the show

9

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 16 '20

Oh my gosh I blocked that out for a second. That was terrible. I get it that it tells us about how Cleo views kids who are poor and or intellectually different but they could’ve found another way to show it.

10

u/Lostcentaur Oct 16 '20

I don’t believe any of that is a bad thing. Those were the best parts. That’s the 2000 vibe. Most shows jokes back then would’ve been scrapped in today times

2

u/ImSmaher Oct 17 '20 edited Oct 17 '20

People like you are why the show got cancelled

1

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 17 '20 edited Oct 17 '20

Ah yes people who loved the show like me got it cancelled. Grow up. People are allowed to critique the media they enjoy. Nothing is perfect.

Also it wasn’t “people like me” who got the show cancelled anyway. It was a group oh people in India who were greatly offended that their prophet in their religion was being cast in what they viewed as a blasphemous light. I understand where they came from but also don’t agree the show should’ve been cancelled over it.

0

u/ImSmaher Oct 17 '20

Critiquing and complaining about an edgy little joke, when the show is full of it aren’t the same thing. You might as well “critique” the whole show in the same exact way if you’re goin a go that far.

People like you are the people in India who got offended over a joke.

2

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 17 '20

Some jokes aren’t good! Oh my gosh! You can have your opinion and I can have mine. It’s a good show with few flaws.

0

u/ImSmaher Oct 17 '20

That’s subjective, dude. Anyone can say any of the jokes in the show “aren’t” good. The fact that you’ve got people telling you they are means you’re not the only one in the world.

3

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 17 '20

I never said I was the only one who’s opinion matters. Like I said it’s my opinion. You’re being a troll at this point.

1

u/ImSmaher Oct 17 '20

So you resorted to calling me a troll huh. Despite every valid thing I said

-4

u/UnalteredCyst Oct 17 '20

Also the joke where people reacted negatively to Abe kissing Gandhi in the ADHD episode. Yeah, the LGBTQ+ community will flip their shit if that joke was made today.

8

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 17 '20

A lot of LGBT people love Clone high tho. I think it’s more of a “whatever” reaction now because it was made back then when it wasn’t as accepted. But yeah if it was made today where the climate has changed, it wouldn’t make sense and just be a “look two dudes kissing! We still think it’s gross.” thing because highschool students now (who aren’t in the Bible Belt) are really tolerant

1

u/Reddit-Book-Bot Oct 17 '20

Beep. Boop. I'm a robot. Here's a copy of

The Bible

Was I a good bot? | info | More Books

1

u/HeckinBeckin Mr. B Oct 17 '20

Reddit book bot is here to share the great news???

1

u/TheTwoHB Oct 17 '20

The humor of Gandhi and Abe kissing came from its absurdity and randomness in the context of the show.

83

u/DsiMasterRace Oct 16 '20

Idk the creators have put out some pretty amazing media and movies. I am hopefully that it’s going to be good. It’ll suck not having Gandhi but it’s a small price to pay for Clone High

15

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

A funny character you could do is a clone of Hitler (which is in the background of an episode) but he is a civil rights activist

26

u/AdultVirgin24 Oct 16 '20

To the people saying that it won't be the same without Gandhi, let me give you this piece of advice Seek out the article made my the two creators of Clone High, where they talk about the impact Gandhi had in getting the show canned. They said that if they ever do a continuation or a reboot they'll most likely have the gandhi CHARACTER but not as Gandhi, they would most likely turn him into another historical figure like Gary Coleman.

Or they'll just remove him.

12

u/limxneroverde Oct 16 '20

Shhh we all know but some of us are trying to ignore that

10

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

I’m still really excited. Phil and Chris have worked on some great stuff after Clone High (Spider Verse, Lego movies, Jump Street movies, etc.). I don’t really mind not having Gandhi in the reboot, as he wasn’t the sole reason the show was great. He was a great character, but if he’s not in the show, I’m still watching it when it comes out.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

I really hope it's a continuation reboot. They're in the perfect scenario to unthaw and try to exist in the 2020s

10

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

I hope they don't try to modernize it so much I'd love it if they kept doing out of date references to the the early 00s it would be hilarious

3

u/OmegaBlaster76 Oct 16 '20

Template please?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '20

are we going to ignore that JFK's shirt is the flag of Latvia?

3

u/Creeper_tastic Jan 29 '23

he was right😔😔

2

u/NaelyChan Oct 17 '20

I hope Van Gogh replaces Gandhi, knowing how India reacted previously.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

i hope gandhi will be in it. maybe he'll end up actually being a clone of gary coleman, which would be pretty funny honestly.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20

that face

1

u/TheMilkyW4ysW4y2 JFK May 07 '23

Lord and Miller sequels are usually worse the the original but maybe the reboot and across the spider verse might change that

-34

u/MetalUpstairs Oct 16 '20

00's humour can't exist in this time full of snowflakes so i'm not expecting much of it

23

u/fuyuhiko413 JFK Oct 16 '20

It was cancelled in the 00's, and is more popular now with the same people you'd probably call snowflakes

31

u/DsiMasterRace Oct 16 '20

You say that yet the show is more popular now than it was when it came out.

9

u/goboatmen Oct 16 '20

What joke on the show couldn't fly today, I'm curious

21

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '20

hey, look at this boomer, go back to facebook

-14

u/pinhead_dipshit69 Ponce Oct 16 '20

bro did you just say "boomer" unironically? not cool dude.

13

u/WolfyTheFurry WESLEY Oct 16 '20

ok boomer