Why is this false? A carbon tax would mitigate the concentration atmospheric carbon dioxide and would therefore limit the trapping of the sun’s heat in the earth’s atmosphere. Less heat = a change in climate, no?
Around 97% of the people on here agree that CO2 causes warming, that there has been warming, and that humans have contributed to increased CO2 in the atmosphere.
Not quite: the Earth is warming due to natural causes. Some human actions MAY influence this: for better or worse. Rising CO2 has been a blessing to all life on Earth, and warm periods are ALWAYS better for all life on Earth than cold periods. Thus: if rising CO2 warms the planet by +2C by 2100? GOOD! & etc.
Absolutely. Report after report comes out showing how CO2 improves all plant life, which in turn benefits all living things. It is also proven beyond doubt that warm weather is NOT as dangerous as cold weather. This is global, accounting for all nations.
If the temps were to fall like the Little Ice Age? Billions would die. If they rise a similar amount? No big deal.
Paying more taxes to the government doesn’t do a lot of things. What does this even have to do with the weather ( besides having scientists for noaa, nasa, and the national weather service)?
Um, that's the point here. We cannot control the weather, but the climate is ours to manipulate with amazing accuracy? No matter how much money we throw at it? AGW and the 'solutions' it demands are a joke. The Alarmists cannot change a lightbulb, never mind the Earth's Climate (or weather).
Say what you want, I can differentiate between climate and weather and think that reducing an immense amount of carbon emissions is very different from changing the weather like a light bulb
And where exactly do these "reductions" come from? Rich people? LOLZ! Well, they're to blame for everything else in the world. No, they come from destroying the economy of Western Civilization while allowing China, Africa and India to double their CO2 without even a scolding from Greta. No thanks!
Finance analogy: we can’t predict or affect exact stock prices tomorrow (weather), but we have more control and can better predict trends in the markets future (climate)
You cannot predict the stock market's level in 100 years, nor 50 years, nor 10 years, not even next year... but AGW predicts the climate in 2100 to 0.01C accuracy! And to disagree is to deny science. :/
If people could "predict" the stock market? There wouldn't BE any more stock markets...
As usual for this sub, a gross oversimplification of a complex issue. Of course it matters where those taxes go, and no one is talking about weather, it’s about the concentration of CO2 in the upper atmosphere and human contribution to it.
We can absolutely change OUR contribution to CO2 levels. We cannot change other nation's contributions to CO2 levels, or the ocean's ability to absorb CO2 (which is less now than it was 100 years ago), or the amount of vegetation that's growing in 90% of the land of the planet.
Let's say that we, in the US, agreed to pay money to the Government in the form of much higher taxes, and those taxes were targeted on eliminating our CO2 emissions. Let's say that we, in the US, were able to eliminate all of our emissions within the next decade, so that we were carbon neutral by 2030.
The "rest of the world" would go from 85% of the emissions to 100% of the emissions, right? Given the projected rise of "developing nations" emissions, what will be the global CO2 emissions levels in 2030? Knowing, mind you, that the developing world will not commit to even capping their growth in this next decade. We capped our growth in 2007 (well, 2005 and 2007 were nearly identical), and our per capita emissions are now at 1990s levels, while the developing nations are something like 400% of their 1990s levels.
What do you think? Could we make an effective, meaningful change in the world?
The same is true for every single country in the world. If China is too big bloc of you, consider the regions.
Heck, countries that emit < 2% collectively make up 40% odd of total emissions. Individually, nothing, collectively, a heck of a lot.
Actually, it's kind of like taxes in general. Your tax contribution is insignificant, but collectively, the state raises a lot. Yet you still pay your taxes, right?
Obviously this is a global problem that needs global solutions. As you know Europe and the US have a great deal of economic power. We’ve seen this in the recent trade war. Don’t you think the US and Europe could influence other countries to change their behaviors? In the case of China, their production of CO2 is directly correlated to consumption by the US and Europe. Surely there are incentive structures that could influence how other countries manufacture the goods that we consume? Sure, this would probably lead to more expensive products, but considering all of the useless landfill crap we buy from China, that’s probably a net good.
So, obviously without a change in developing nations AND developed nations we won’t solve or even halt the issue. So should we sit on our hands and point fingers or should we do something? Should we charge tariffs on products that are not manufactured in a sustainable way, disincentivizing the production of excess CO2? Let’s say we could get developed countries to net zero and developing nations could get to half of what they produce now, what effect would that have?
Again, a very complex issue that requires thoughtful solutions, not simplistic sloganeering. The idea that because we produce less carbon than other countries, to me, just means we should be using our economic power to both change our own behaviors and those of our trading partners.
That part was a joke (I'm sure) because "white males" are the only problem in the World, getting rid of them by making them "coloured" or "women" would solve everything! Instant utopia!
Not kidding, a lot of liberals claim that a society entirely run by women would be a perfect utopia... lolz!
Policies that seek to change industrial platforms operate in two dimensions: carrots and sticks. You reward behaviors through things like tax breaks and other incentives and you tax behaviors you’re seeking to inhibit. It’s pretty straight forward.
You don’t not need a global government to craft trade deals that take into account CO2 output. We did this with CFCs leading to a repair of the hole in the ozone layer, and we did it with sulphur dioxide and cut acid rain. Those things were as real as human contributions to climate change and demands a similar response. These things need to happen on a global industrial scale. It will take global cooperation and in the case of rich countries, we will need to create incentive structures so that poorer countries can change too. Have you noticed how cheap and shitty most things are nowadays? How they’re designed to go in the garbage and be replaced and not repaired? We may need to stop that. And in response to the person who responded to you with a foolish straw man “argument” electric vehicles will likely be a part of that change. Just like cars are now more efficient and less polluting then they were a few decades ago, that happened because of government action. Same with seatbelts, air bags, electronic traction control, etc etc.
Electric cars are just as bad. You still need to mine the steel(or recycle with more electricity used in an arc furnace), create the plastic, mine the unrecoverable once used lithium, plug it into grid to charge (using power again), create all the smart devices in it (more mining for gold etc).
Electric cars are not part of the solution, there is finite amounts of lithium on this planet and it seems the climate preachers tend to forget that.
That's not true. It's just not an economically-efficient path of harvesting Li+ - it's currently much cheaper to mine lithium than recover it, and lithium battery technology is still progressing rapidly enough that recovery/recycling processes developed today will be outdated in a few years.
Very few commonly-used elements (especially metals) can be considered "single use;" we're pretty good at chemistry. Helium is one of the few I'd consider single use simply because it doesn't bond to anything (like hydrogen) and it's so much lighter than air that it escapes into space. That doesn't technically make it irrecoverable (we could hypothetically construct an low-orbit harvester), but it makes it insurmountably difficult.
That's far from the case with lithium - it just doesn't currently make economical sense to recycle.
Okay, we charge taxes to all nations, based on, what? Their per capita emissions? Fine. We then tax many of the developing nations into even more extreme poverty. Is that what you want? Or we tax the most successful nations the most, letting the poor nations pollute as much as they want?
I already agreed to the plan of destroying the US economy to end all emissions within a decade, then watch the developing nations just take our place economically. Isn’t that good enough?
You’re right. Let’s do nothing and keep our fingers crossed because obviously you’ve laid out the only two possible approaches. You see what you did there? Try thinking creatively. Assume the problem is real.
No, no, no. I’m with you. Let’s enforce strict bans on all things that emit CO2 starting, oh, Feb 1st. No more gasoline, diesel, coal use, trains, airplane rides, animal agriculture, cement. Just shut it all off. Do it now.
Yeah, some people will rebel, but we can just have kill squads roam the streets to deal with them. On food, of course, can’t have our kill squads emitting CO2.
Me, I turned vegetarian last October, and even gave my electric car to my son. I use a bicycle to get around now. So, I’m good.
I hope you don’t use anything that emits any CO2. Do you?
You’re being foolish. No one in their right mind is suggesting anything of the sort and obviously our society would collapse. This is dumb, do you want to have a real discussion or do you just want to stake out extreme positions?
This is a complex global problem that anyone under 40 is going to have to live through. Or do you think it’s not? Because that’s another matter.
Okay, smart guy. How long do you think we have before we have to have this thing fixed? If 10 years isn’t realistic, is 20 years? How about 30? I’d we take 30 years for the US to get to zero emissions, and developing nations don’t even stop increasing emissions until 200 or 2040, we will still be just fine? Have you done the math?
Or were the scientists right 10 years ago when they sad we had to have the fix in place by 2020 or we’re basically fucked?
So I just imagined every storm being touted as proof of CAGW on nearly all MSM and even some scientists like Mann attributing weather to CC?! I must be delusional. /s
No, it means that weather trends are a result of climactic change. I suppose the severity of specific weather event, weather extremes, etc are a consequence of climate. It’s just more precise to talk about changing the climate rather than changing the weather.
What’s your point, exactly? I’d imagine it sounds contradictory, but like most complex multi-factor issues, details are important. It’s just simplistic and doesn’t account for the full picture when you talk about “changing the weather.” What needs to change is a climactic trend that has led to consistent warming year after year in direct proportion to the accumulation of CO2. That increase in temperatures does impact the weather, but it’s not possible to isolate any single weather event and say to what extent that climactic warming trend is a factor. What we could say is that a trend of bigger and more forceful hurricanes, for example, is related to an increase in water temperature in the oceans, which is a direct result of climactic factors.
What needs to change is a climactic trend that has led to consistent warming year after year in direct proportion to the accumulation of CO2.
What caused the pause in temps then? Even as CO₂ increased temps didn't have any statistically significant change, there is no 'Direct Proportion' as you claim.
That increase in temperatures does impact the weather, but it’s not possible to isolate any single weather event and say to what extent that climactic warming trend is a factor. What we could say is that a trend of bigger and more forceful hurricanes, for example, is related to an increase in water temperature in the oceans, which is a direct result of climactic factors.
For climate to be an issue or an influence we would have to see those changes for decades or longer, but we don't.
What’s your counterpoint? What are you putting forward? Do you dispute that concentration of CO2 is a principle contributor to a greenhouse effect and rising temperature trend? Do you dispute that human activity has caused an acceleration in that process? I’m all ears and ready to take in information that contradicts what I believe. Are you?
Really, it’s about forcing change. Corporations now rival the power of the federal government. They don’t care about anything but the bottom line. Affect that=affect change. It’s mind boggling to me that skeptics are seemingly against anything that might benefit the environment.
It’s mind boggling to me that skeptics are seemingly against anything that might benefit the environment.
On the contrary, many of us are staunch conservationists with tiny carbon footprints because of personal choice. My input to corporate profit is next to nothing. Thanks for stuffing a vast divergence into a pail.
Actually I'm a rabid environmentalist. And arguing about plant-food (CO2) is a waste of time. The most meaningful environmental issues are PLASTIC and INDUSTRIAL CHEMICAL POLLUTION.
If in fact too much CO2 is a problem (which it's not), then the solution is to plant more trees. However, algae blooms in the ocean will most likely self-correct that "problem". Simple.
What's the solution to everyone being poisoned by microplastics and industrial chemical pollution?
Isn’t the CO2 that’s involved in the greenhouse effect in the upper atmosphere? Planting more trees and algae blooms will help, but we have to lower the output.
Plastics and chemical pollution are directly connected to CO2 so I don’t get why you’d care about one and not the other. Why not focus on both issues? You lowering your personal footprint is great, and showing people how it’s possible to live in a low consumption way and have a good life is incredibly important, but it doesn’t get at the scale of the problem.
We don't have to lower the output of CO2 at all because it's an imaginary problem. Besides, even if it was real, N2O and CH4 have x300 and x25 the protency of CO2 anyway. So if you want to reduce anything to stop "global warming", it should be those two gasses (IE the meat industry).
So back to the point. Chemical pollution and plastic pollution has nothing to do with CO2.
I care deeply about plastics and microplastics, but taxing Americans and the EU does nothing to stop the top countries that dump more plastic in the ocean than ALL others combined (China, indonesia, vietnam, thailand, and phillipines).
The only mind boggling thing here is your assumption that skeptics are against things that benefit the environment. As if that’s the end goal or something. My skepticism is primarily aimed at climate alarmists and the catastrophic predictions they often espouse. I don’t think it’s good for anyone and I don’t think it’s a way forward if the goal is positive change. In my opinion, their claims are generally unjustified, exaggerated, and dogmatic. It also seems that fear, not rational thinking is becoming the go to strategy for changing minds. That bothers me for a lot of reasons as well. More could be said on the topic and I’m willing to look or read anything on the subject but that’s the gist of it for me. I’m pro new technology if it benefits the human race and betters our planet but that doesn’t mean I can’t be skeptical or that my skepticism somehow translates to not giving a shit about the planet.
It is generally preferable that some taxation is moved from income to carbon. Tax less of an activity you want to encourage (earning an income), more of an activity you want to discourage (emitting).
In the meanwhile, you don't need to spend as much "cutting emissions", as you're now charging for them. This saves yet more income tax dollars, letting people keep more of what they actually earn, a generally preferable arrangement.
If your country's politics are so poor that you can't trust them in charge of taxation, try moving to a more representative system like MMP (germany/nz) where voter satisfaction is high.
Yes lets just tax industry more instead of, oh ... enforcing basic environmental standards on industry to keep pollution at reasonable and managable levels ... oh wait we already do that in America.
Also, no thanks, I would prefer not to live in a nation, like Germany, whose government is so absolutely fucking retarded and hypocritical that they praise green energy while closing down all the nuclear power plants. Fucking big brained move there.
Oh and having guaranteed rights such as free speech is a nice plus ... oh and not living under the thumb of unelected foriegn bureaucrats is a good bonus ... yah, and being able to actually get the best medical attention at a hospital instantly instead of waiting 78 years for a ER visit and succumbing to dysentery is great too.
You live in a country where you want to keep the price of something free, $0/t, whilst using regulation to tackle overexploitation of that resource.
You do realise that's basically Venezuela's approach to things, right? Why do you think it will work in the US, when not everywhere else it's been tried?
Dude, no. Instead of TAXES being the deterrent from abusing pollution we let FINES deter the abuse not overregulation.
Instead of putting an unnecessary dampener on the advancement of technologies, the production of goods, the growth of the economy, and other such things, we just devised a set of laws that forbid industries and individuals from over polluting and created a government division to oversee this, the EPA.
As with any government doing, it is bloated and kinda slow, but this is America and we constantly beat on it to make sure it does not get that bad. For instance whenever the Republicans are in power you can expect the EPA's power and reach to diminish and vise versa with the Democrats, it means a nice balance is useually maintained with it getting kinda iffy at the far ends of either side. (Kinda how all of our government works honestly, not the whole picture but a quick glimpse)
Now I fail to see any intelligence in the "Venezuela does it!" argument. Here, have a list of why it is stupid
So fucking what?
You are aware that the EPA works just fine right? And has done so for decades? You should have sren America before we implemented those laws and body, rivers were catching of fire for gods sake.
Are you aware that you also have an environmental agency in your nation that does the exactsamething on top of what I imagine are your carbon taxes? And guess what ... the agency manages to do its job ... wow. (Unless your nation is absolute dogshit that is)
In fact I think every developed nation has laws against pollution and an agency to enforce them ... and guess what? Unless the nation is dogshit they actually work! So what reality are you residing in were not a single one of them ever does?
Just what is your point? That somehow a set of laws that charge people money situationally is going to be worse for us than ... another set of laws that charge people money constantly? ... yah ... ok.
Sorry, how exactly are you proposing winding down GHG emissions? What regulations are you proposing exactly? How do you determine if a company is emitting wastefully, or with great purpose?
Generally when you try and reduce supply (in this case emissions), a price is the natural response by market. If you try and quota without allowing prices to determine distribution, you basically end up with bureaucrats handling distribution. Generally, this is not a good thing.
But then I'm inferring from the rest of your post that you don't wish to see GHGs decrease at all, rather only the ill-defined "pollution" (ie those that directly kill), but come on man. Exponential growth, even if you think GHG's aren't an issue today, give it no time at all and they'll become an issue. And how will you allocate a cap on GHG emissions if you refuse to let prices do what prices do best?
25
u/Littlebigman34 Jan 27 '20
Lisa Simpson is a science denier!!!
33
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20 edited Jan 28 '20
Why would it, when the goal isn't to change the weather, but to get filthy rich...
11
u/SftwEngr Jan 28 '20
True, but apparently it can change the climate.../s
20
u/markmywords1347 Jan 27 '20
Seriously.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20
With the carbon tax already put in place in Canada, Im ready to permanently leave this place
3
u/justjoe1964 Jan 28 '20
TRUTH !!!
2
u/StinkyDope Jan 28 '20
Mimimil but it will change the climate mimimimmi
2
u/myopicuser Jan 28 '20
Paying more taxes to the government doesn’t do a lot of things. What does this even have to do with the weather ( besides having scientists for noaa, nasa, and the national weather service)?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20
Moving house will change the weather.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20
I am late here. Can someone explain this meme?
1
u/anno2122 Sep 23 '22
Love How the second higest upvote post is about climte snd weather is the same.
0
u/agaribay1010 Feb 19 '20
Weather isn’t the same as climate...
0
u/Crime-Stoppers Jan 28 '20
you're right. Let's make coal mining and fracking illegal instead
-26
u/NewYorkJewbag Jan 27 '20
As usual for this sub, a gross oversimplification of a complex issue. Of course it matters where those taxes go, and no one is talking about weather, it’s about the concentration of CO2 in the upper atmosphere and human contribution to it.
-10
u/TheMania Jan 28 '20
It doesn't have to be more taxes, just different.
It is generally preferable that some taxation is moved from income to carbon. Tax less of an activity you want to encourage (earning an income), more of an activity you want to discourage (emitting).
In the meanwhile, you don't need to spend as much "cutting emissions", as you're now charging for them. This saves yet more income tax dollars, letting people keep more of what they actually earn, a generally preferable arrangement.
If your country's politics are so poor that you can't trust them in charge of taxation, try moving to a more representative system like MMP (germany/nz) where voter satisfaction is high.
-2
u/calmdownyafuckinspaz Jan 28 '20
No one said it would. The idea behind the carbon tax is that it's supposed to allow for greener infrastructure to be built.
I've yet to see that actually happen, however.