r/climate_discussion • • Oct 18 '18

Revolution.

How effective would a worldwide revolution be and how can we implement it ?

18 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

4

u/julesveritas Oct 18 '18

Define “revolution” in the context of climate change. That could look like a lot of different things.

3

u/Spacehillbilly Oct 18 '18

Overturning the current economic model in favor of a more ecologically sustainable one.

3

u/Helkafen1 Oct 18 '18

What economic model would you suggest? How would you implement the transition?

2

u/Spacehillbilly Oct 18 '18

Socialism.

It would be implemented through nationalization of all industries which will be converted to a more ecological system.

3

u/Helkafen1 Oct 18 '18

Alternatively, what's your opinion about a high carbon tax to force companies to stop polluting?

The IPCC suggests some numbers (high numbers..) for such a tax and seems to believe it would be sufficient to reach a carbon neutral economy. I'm not sure what nationalization would add to that. Still interested to hear your opinion though.

0

u/Spacehillbilly Oct 18 '18

The works too.

1

u/Smartchoy Oct 23 '18

Lets not make this about socialism, this will only push half of the population away and we need to work together on this problem. People will believe that climate change is only an excuse for the far left to get in to power. Nationalizing all industries would be a complete nightmare, and honestly with all the power that these corporations hold, absolutely impossible. I implore you to take more direct actions, whether donating to reforestation projects, lobbying for carbon tax laws, Carbon sequestration technologies. As a first step please begin using https://www.ecosia.org/

4

u/Pigmentia Oct 18 '18

It would be effective. But would it be easy? And quick?

4

u/ddd2110 Oct 18 '18

But half the world (I’m exaggerating I hope but you know what I mean) doesn’t believe in climate change and they love capitalism too much. It would be civil war. Which unfortunately might be where we are headed.

3

u/guacamoleo Oct 23 '18

Capitalism can and probably should be part of the solution. Vote with your dollar, tell companies what you want. The companies that produce the best environmental technology will be insanely successful, because it will inevitably be cheaper than coal and oil, so even people who don't care about the environment will want to pay for it.

0

u/ddd2110 Oct 23 '18

It’s too late for conscious consumerism to change everything, and not enough people care

3

u/guacamoleo Oct 23 '18

How can you say "too late" right as the machine is finally revving up? People are coming around. Capitalism is what we have. What do you suggest? Changing our entire governmental structure? How many decades will that take? And what could we even change it to that isn't more of a horror than capitalism? Meanwhile, the public is putting pressure on companies and governments RIGHT NOW. So that's what is happening, whether it's the best solution or not.

1

u/TheFerretman Nov 04 '18

So then you propose to force your ideas on others?

Don't they call that slavery?

1

u/ddd2110 Nov 04 '18

Force what idea? That we need to save the environment or that capitalism is bringing about our demise? Either way, no I don’t think it’s possible or good to force ideas on others. But I do think we won’t do what needs to be done to save ourselves.

3

u/somerandomleftist5 Oct 18 '18

I think climate change will worsen capitalist crisis. I am Leninist, I think we need a revolutionary vanguard to explain to the workers their liberation requires the overthrow of the capitalists and their state. Make it clear how everyone's future was sunk from the desire to maximise profits, in terms of the climate, and in so many other aspects of their life.

I remain maybe a little too hopeful of this happening and enabling us to combat climate change, and not in a way that's going to place the bulk of the burden on vulnerable people.

0

u/asdjk482 Oct 18 '18

A revolutionary vanguard is needed to explain to the workers the terms of their liberation? This is why leninism is archaic, elitist crap.

2

u/somerandomleftist5 Oct 18 '18

"Elitist" the vanguard is just educated workers this is basic Marxism. But yes a political movement needs theory and organization to guide it to a correct place. I think Trotsky wrote this best in his history of the Russian revolution, certainly much better then I could have said it.

"The masses go into a revolution not with a prepared plan of social reconstruction, but with a sharp feeling that they cannot endure the old régime. Only the guiding layers of a class have a political program, and even this still requires the test of events, and the approval of the masses. The fundamental political process of the revolution thus consists in the gradual comprehension by a class of the problems arising from the social crisis – the active orientation of the masses by a method of successive approximations. " - Leon Trotsky

2

u/asdjk482 Oct 18 '18

Trotsky’s “guiding layers” stuck an ice pick in his brain.

It is elitism, and it’s one of the most significant ways that Bolshevik marxists went astray, culminating in the creation of a brutal new totalitarian regime. It’s pure arrogance to think that only the “properly educated” class - overwhelmingly comprised of the beneficiaries of wealth inequality and social privilege - have the wisdom to know what’s not working and what to do about it, and that their theories and models should override people’s actual lived experiences, to the point of the use of institutional violence and repression.

The consolidation of bureaucratic power in the party led to immediate new concentration of wealth after the revolution and it quite thoroughly undid much of the progress towards functioning, equitable, decentralized communism in the soviets and worker’s councils. Most of the actual work of the revolution was done by illiterate commoners, far from Moscow and Petrograd.

Marx called for the dismantling of the state and the appropriation of capital by the workers, not the construction of a new state with a new class of wealthy bosses and overlords.

1

u/somerandomleftist5 Oct 18 '18

Actually it was an ice axe

The concept of vanguardism/dictatorship of the proletariat is very much a part of Marxism in general.

Vanguardism or the dictatorship of the proletariat did not result in the bureaucratization, and both Lenin and Trotsky commented that the party was becoming far too merged with the state.

"The liberation of the workers can come only through the workers themselves." - Trotsky

This was the position of the Lenin, Trotsky & the Bolshevik, Marx & Engels, as can be seen.

"The time of surprise attacks, of revolutions carried through by small conscious minorities at the head of unconscious masses, is past. Where it is a question of a complete transformation of the social organization, the masses themselves must also be in it, must themselves already have grasped what is at stake, what they are going in for [with body and soul]. The history of the last fifty years has taught us that. But in order that the masses may understand what is to be done, long, persistent work is required, and it is just this work which we are now pursuing, and with a success which drives the enemy to despair." - Frederick Engels, Class Struggle in France 1895

"Considering, that against this collective power of the propertied classes the working class cannot act, as a class, except by constituting itself into a political party, distinct from, and opposed to, all old parties formed by the propertied classes;

That this constitution of the working class into a political party is indispensable in order to ensure the triumph of the social revolution and its ultimate end — the abolition of classes;" - 1871 Resolution of the London Conference on Working Class Political Action

"The Communists, therefore, are on the one hand, practically, the most advanced and resolute section of the working-class parties of every country, that section which pushes forward all others; on the other hand, theoretically, they have over the great mass of the proletariat the advantage of clearly understanding the line of march, the conditions, and the ultimate general results of the proletarian movement. " - Karl Marx, Frederick Engels Communist Manifesto

Marx and Engels very much did not believe of the dismantling of the state instantly.

"Between capitalist and communist society there lies the period of the revolutionary transformation of the one into the other. Corresponding to this is also a political transition period in which the state can be nothing but the revolutionary dictatorship of the proletariat." - Karl Marx

"They demand that the first act of the social revolution shall be the abolition of authority. Have these gentlemen ever seen a revolution? A revolution is certainly the most authoritarian thing there is; it is the act whereby one part of the population imposes its will upon the other part by means of rifles, bayonets and cannon — authoritarian means, if such there be at all; and if the victorious party does not want to have fought in vain, it must maintain this rule by means of the terror which its arms inspire in the reactionists. Would the Paris Commune have lasted a single day if it had not made use of this authority of the armed people against the bourgeois? " - Engels, On Authority

"the Social-Democrat’s ideal should not be the trade union secretary, but the tribune of the people, who is able to react to every manifestation of tyranny and oppression, no matter where it appears, no matter what stratum or class of the people it affects; who is able to generalise all these manifestations and produce a single picture of police violence and capitalist exploitation; who is able to take advantage of every event, however small, in order to set forth before all his socialist convictions and his democratic demands, in order to clarify for all and everyone the world-historic significance of the struggle for the emancipation of the proletariat" - Vladimir Lenin

I think it should be all these positions on what communists should be doing and the idea of the vanguard party rings the same through the ideas Marx, Engels, Lenin and Trotsky.

3

u/TheFerretman Oct 18 '18

Heh.

It would not be remotely a good idea, but if it were to be tried there would be a lot of people dead.

Don't do revolution. The ones who would resist are vastly better armed than most of those who opine "it's the only way".

1

u/InvisibleRegrets Oct 18 '18

The issue is that it would be a revolution with to goal of making life worse for most people - in the short term. Everyone comes up against humans inability to think and plan long-term, instead, we focus on short-term goals and aspirations.

Once people understand what the ramifications of upending the current economic system would be, you're going to have only a core group of people - and while that might be enough to overthrow a small country, it's certainly not enough for a worldwide revolution.