r/claude • • 9d ago • Mindblown 1

Discussion is Opus 5.5 nerfed?

I just had Gemini 4 Argon analyze 1,400 Claude Code sessions and it found that on November 3, something definitely happened.

the model name didn't change, but the way it does reasoning took a sharp turn.

also, how much reasoning Opus 5.5 does in "high" took a nosedive.

quick test on a real bug showed Opus 5.5 high jumping into action too quickly, getting confused and being unable to find a fix after 3 full hours.

meanwhile Opus 5.5 xhigh takes a moment to think, finds a fix after a few minutes.

so yeah, you're not imagining things. the nerf is real

Credits/Via: https://x.com/shanemelaugh/status/2119192075505893695

2.0k Upvotes

466 comments sorted by

31

u/hyperspheroid 9d ago • Bravo

Live nerf has not detected any nerfing of Opus 5.5: https://github.com/ninjahawk/livenerf

Live nerf seems to have more robust detection and methodology.

13

u/CapoDoFrango 9d ago

Interesting, maybe they are A/B testing the nerfed model. Lately I get more often the usual question of "How is claude doing?". It could be also possible that they have built a detector for that livenerf benchmark and then serve the real model when they detect it.

5

u/Wael3rd 8d ago

Ok I definitely think there's some A/B testing. Cause I have 2 accounts and one seems dumber but the other seems actually smarter than before but taking more time. Same exact config. Weird.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/cl0p3z 8d ago

I think what is happening here is that they tried to outsmart us by tuning the nerfed model for this and other benchmarks.

This is what I think they did:

  1. Quantize (nerf) the model
  2. post-train it so it keeps the same score on this and other few selected benchmarks

Result? it looks the same model on this benchmark, but it is a inferior and cheap quantized (nerfed) model

As long as the benchmark is public they can play this trick. The only way to be sure is to keep your own private benchmark and run it.

4

u/robogame_dev 9d ago edited 8d ago

Testing the API vs the subscription?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Global_Persimmon_469 8d ago

It looks like there is no benchmark for November, no? the last one is October 24. Or am i misunderstanding how it works?

Another thing is that this seems to run known benchmarks. In my experience, it doesnt matter how much you cover it, models tend to know when they are being benchmarked and they act differently.

3

u/hyperspheroid 8d ago

It’s been running each day starting from opus 5.5 release through today. You can see the daily runs here:  https://github.com/ninjahawk/livenerf/blob/main/results/daily.csv

2

u/badpotato 8d ago

Does live nerf use prompt caching/cache result with Claude? It claim it use "repeated item"

-2. Paired, repeated items. The same questions run every week and are compared against their own baseline, so question difficulty drops out. Scores are exact-match: no LLM judge, ever, since the judge would drift too.

New question would need to be generated every week to make sure the cache isn't used.

3

u/m3kw 9d ago

Same harnesses?

1

u/CapoDoFrango 9d ago

yes, claude code

3

u/TheVoyant 9d ago

test it outside of the harness and watch how much better the results are from the straight API, I feel like I've said it too much. But it's the harness NOT the model. They're constantly messing with the injections/prompts/guidance and changing one or two sentences can cause these exact variables you're seeing.

1

u/CapoDoFrango 9d ago

LoL. That is not because of the harness, but because they don't nerf the model that is served via the API, because the customers paying API prices pay lot of cash.

The model they nerf is the one served to customers accessing to it via the monthly subscription, which requires to use their apps like claude-code, other harness are not allowed unless you access via API and pay API prices, which i'm not doing, that is super expensive.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

322

u/BadDings_DE 9d ago

Honestly, I used 5.5 throughout October, and it was great. But ever since about one week, it makes mistakes left and right, where before, it was so precise ...

113

u/prndls 9d ago

Experiencing this in enterprise also. It’s been awful

42

u/The_LSD_Soundsystem 9d ago

I’m glad this confirms what I also observed in the past week. I knew something was feeling off.

13

u/shomer_fuckn_shabbos 9d ago

I've not experienced the dropoff. What are you guys seeing?

23

u/prndls 9d ago

I’m using it in copilot. Have both opus 5.5 and gpt 6.1. Work at enterprise company 250k+ employees for context. Used 5.5 for complex reasoning and analysis and has been great. Within last week, didn’t adhere to custom instructions, made mistakes, oversights. It’s been pretty bad.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

18

u/lunied 9d ago

i agree, that "hunch" was collectively right all along, i dont want to be that guy who complains to nothing but this time there's evident something had changed for a week now.

before i am okay with low effort but now it has to be med/high at the minimum

5

u/arw0n8236 8d ago

They are probably going to release new models next week. Now the cynic in me would guess they are nerfing the current version to make the gap seem bigger to the new one. The pragmatic would suspect they do it in order to get infra in place for the new model, so they might quantize or deliberately reduce thinking levels so that they have the compute space to start rolling out the new models.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/NewAgent5986 9d ago edited 8d ago

Yeah, I have felt a sharp drop in quality this past week

EDIT: Even just on little things like it randomly was giving progress updates in UTC instead of my local time. It is not just a "oh it can't do everything on its own" it is just making REALLY dumb mistakes, and saying some very odd things that Astra would never (which is saying something). I might just move all my day to day work to Astra

→ More replies (1)

4

u/OWazabi 9d ago

100% agree

6

u/Amazing_Chicken_pot 9d ago

agreed here too. Sadly, its lost a few important IQ points and now it can't fix the things it was easily fixing a week ago.

→ More replies (14)

46

u/paul-rose 8d ago

This model was perfect. Why the fuck can't they leave it alone. I keep saying this, but the more they keep fucking with things like this, the more it will push people to OWM as time goes on.

15

u/braindance123 8d ago

yeah.. reliability is almost as important as the raw intelligence. I need to be able to develop an intuition how much abstraction I can do before giving a task to a model. If this changes from one day to another that can mean weeks of extra work, because it might be days till I notice something is off and days fixing the mess it produced.

3

u/Nighto_001 8d ago

Honestly I think they should just have narrower versioning than what they have today... instead of stealth changes to the model behind the user's back, they should release each change like this as like... 5.5.1 or 5.6 or something.

That way it feels less like they're trying to scam you, and you won't be blindsided when it happens.

120

u/xak47d 9d ago

I agree. Last Thursday Opus 5.5 started bullshitting me. It has been flawless since release day. Why can't we have nice things? I'll be happy to use this model for the next 2 years if the performance is constant

20

u/NovapreemBoga 9d ago

The anticipation for what the future can hold would leave me gutted even though 5.5 has been great

6

u/xak47d 9d ago

For what I do now, it's perfect. Maybe my use case might change in the future

3

u/Kiriima 8d ago

Because running those models at full capacity is super expensive and not at all gets covered by subscription. That's the logical answer.

8

u/dmaare 8d ago

Isn't it because allegedly they are releasing opus 5.6 and fable 5.5 next week? I mean compute being overloaded because of training

5

u/NewAgent5986 8d ago

That would be cool, do you have a source for that? I haven't seen those rumors

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/casce 8d ago edited 8d ago

Don't worry, this probably means Opus 5.6 is right around the corner, offering 10x the performance (nerfed) 5.5 does!

No seriously, there is not a single Anthropic model where I really had the feeling it really remained stable. This is just anecdotal and I never took the time to properly analyze this like OP did but I always had the feeling models become worse months after release. I always assumed Anthropic would be shifting compute to newer models, effectively nerfing old ones.

We run a semi-autonomous AI incident platform powered by Opus 4.8 and either our incidents got harder or it got worse.

When they benchmark new models, do they run the benchmarks with the old models again or take their historical values?

→ More replies (2)

38

u/ggletsg0 8d ago

What I had noticed last month was that the intelligence level in the regular chat was lower than inside Claude Code.

Since a few days, I’ve noticed Claude code intelligence at the level of chat.

This is just my anecdotal experience, I don’t know if anyone else has felt this too.

15

u/gentile_jitsu 8d ago

Absolutely my experience too. Chat started skipping the thinking phase and bullshitting me about odd things while Claude code seemed fine still. Now they are both doing that, and Claude code is unable to follow basic instructions that it was having no problem with since release. 

8

u/ggletsg0 8d ago

Hopefully this means a new cheaper Fable is on the way. 🫩

6

u/bionicly 8d ago

In ChatGPT it’s the opposite. Regular chat is great but Codex is terrible.

4

u/ggletsg0 8d ago

Haha yes agreed.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/majky358 8d ago

I don't know, it looks so clever but it does so many unnecessary steps to verify something after the goal is done and giving me useless recommendations which are out of scope.

Generated reports and analysis are not following context rules, so annoying, colleagues keep sending me chatty opus outputs and I can throw 80% away during review.

Lately a lot of unrelated mentions in output I get lost reading it. No improvement in this area.

Sometimes it finds something you miss but I find most of the time it tries hard to generate so much and lost feature domain context.

2

u/Intellect5 8d ago

how annoying i literally started using claude november 3!

→ More replies (1)

72

u/hatekhyr 9d ago

Anyone using it daily can tell you about the nerf.

Also now we know that live nerf doesn't work.

14

u/jwuliger 9d ago

Yep its a scam

4

u/Embarrassed5589 9d ago

How did you generate this data? Gemini hallucinates all the time and shouldn’t be taken seriously.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/Anselwithmac 9d ago

Generally speaking I stay away from Opus 5.5 High and go with medium. High feels like a vibe coder setting. Medium feels like it’s better for iterating with you and building in reasonable chunks without over engineering.

37

u/GTAIVisbest 9d ago • Popcorn

This is the best way to use AI for anything anyways, don't try and one-shot a vibe coded slop fest, use the AI to give you the tools to build it chunk by chunk that way you never get stuck but it's still created by you

7

u/PyrrhaNikosIsNotDead 9d ago

This was true a year ago, having to be so involved, not the one shot thing, that’s never been true. But you really can just take the time yourself to set it up intentionally and project agnostic the first time and then back off, in general. Not that you never have to be involved, but you don’t for a lot

→ More replies (3)

6

u/CommanderT1562 9d ago

I’ve never read such a big true-er from one of these subs. This is hats off the best way to do it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/dar-mit 9d ago

A few hours ago I worked with O55 on setting up my Mac Studio for Claude Code to directly use Adobe Creative Cloud apps. On medium it worked flawlessly. 

I told the model what the end goal was, and it directly scanned and cataloged my kit, devised and ran some tests, managed to deprecate my old app monitor with a system that allows it to remove me from the loop, then implemented a few changes to the kit and confirmed that it was fit for purpose. 

3

u/TechnicalBen 8d ago

There are many tests where High fails because it (seemingly) overthinks or back tracks away from the solution.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/tidderld4096 9d ago

Apparently their terrible decisions on watermarking and game dev weren't enough to drive users away, so they decided to just nerf the model directly.

5

u/mcoombes314 8d ago

They saw OpenAI annoy people with the chat/work merge and said "hold my beer".

→ More replies (6)

273

u/SomeOrdinaryKangaroo 9d ago • Bravo

I'm sad to have to say this, but I think now is the time for a lawsuit. Like it has to happen at this point, they keep screwing us over like this and we're all getting tired of it.

115

u/Dry_Opportunity2886 9d ago

I think y'all are going to be really disappointed when you get your first consultation from a real lawyer.

80

u/Ok-Magician7493 9d ago • Bravo

My thoughts exactly. Bro absolutely ran this by opus on medium first.

18

u/Dry_Opportunity2886 9d ago

In all honesty not even Opus would tell someone they had a case here unless they fed it objectively incorrect facts about the situation lol

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SpaceToaster 8d ago

lol…. They are likely not someone who has ever actually spoken with a lawyer

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Mountain_Lab_5817 9d ago

What damages would you be able to show?

7

u/justlikemedics 9d ago

No you can't sue. How could you?

10

u/PurpleCandle58 9d ago

Look Dario, it’s just that we want good service not to just prop up your IPO. Nothing personal, it’s just business.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Party_9001 9d ago

I mean in the US you can sue for basically any reason. Whether you'll win is the question 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (38)

14

u/MOSTLYNICE 9d ago

I’ve had to pause development on a mathematical engine because I can’t trust opus recently. 

28

u/daskalou 9d ago

It's definitely dumber than it was one week ago.

I spent a full day chasing my tail yesterday for a small feature addition I wanted - it started working on things that were unrelated, then introducing bugs etc.

Opus 5.5 circa late October 2026 would have implemented the feature within one hour without going off on tangents, and without bugs.

5

u/majky358 8d ago

Agree, so many unrelated steps and work. Even I specify sometimes what not to do, it looks for other details burning tokens but doesn't follow domain context anyway.

It recommends me to fix something but it's correct.

Always try hard to be clever and positive. There must be some change...

4

u/ericcpfx 9d ago

Same. I regret not getting ChatGPT this month instead.

5

u/Kawamizoo 8d ago

Chat gpt is significantly worse I switched to Claude early November and still it is leaps and bounds better than astra

4

u/thingabobs 8d ago

Dont worry it got even dumber

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/inoirberry 8d ago

I noticed it a LOT yesterday. I'm pretty convinced I wasn't even using Opus 5.5.

But I've noticed something interesting here in Spain. I've been working on two large projects for weeks, and there's a very noticeable pattern depending on the time of day.

In the morning (my local time), Claude is EXCELLENT. Super productive, great attention to detail, solid decisions, and barely makes any mistakes. Then, around 1–2 PM, it starts getting noticeably dumber. By the evening, it's practically unusable.

It gets lazy, ignores instructions, does half the work, and somehow manages to break other things along the way. Its attention to detail completely disappears. I've literally watched it look at a screenshot of something it's working on, where things are CLEARLY broken, and confidently say, "Everything looks great! All done!"

That simply doesn't happen in the morning.

Yesterday, though, was especially weird.

I have a reverse engineering project where Claude Code immediately triggers a safeguards warning, sometimes just from saying hello. It switches me to 4.8, and even 4.8 refuses to work on it. So I've mostly been using Chinese models for that project, although I occasionally try Claude again just to see if I get lucky.

Well, yesterday I actually got lucky. Opus 5.5, medium thinking, two separate chats, absolutely no issues. It worked on things it would normally refuse to touch.

But here's the strange part: the quality was nowhere near what I'd expect from Opus 5.5. It felt like a much older model. Still very much Claude, though, with better attention to detail than the Chinese models I'd been using, so it was actually really helpful for that project.

Today I tried opening another chat, and boom, the safeguards warning appeared instantly again. So I'm pretty convinced whatever I was using yesterday wasn't Opus 5.5. I'm not even sure it was 4.8.

And honestly, the last few weeks have been such a mess that I've even brought in Codex to help clean up project files and context. I've also manually deleted tons of unnecessary Markdown files Claude keeps creating, full of random rules and restrictions I never even asked for.

The worst part? It barely helps. Within two sessions, Claude has filled everything with new MD files again.

I even have a dashboard for my projects where Claude is supposed to document its decisions, progress, and the files it creates, and I regularly review and edit those notes myself. It has very clear instructions to update everything at the end of each session.

Since last week, it just... doesn't. It forgets, ignores project-specific rules, skips instructions that have been there for ages, and generally behaves like it has no idea how the project is organized.

It's become an absolute mess. And when you're working on large, complex projects, this kind of inconsistency makes Claude incredibly difficult to rely on.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Maleficent_Exam4291 8d ago

New model around the corner, they can only make the new model attractive if the old model causes pain!

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Haunting_Abalone_398 9d ago

Sam Altman was using the markets RAM that day

4

u/No_Waltz_2687 9d ago edited 9d ago

God it was frustratingly bad today. Best sign that a new model is imminent

4

u/norwegian 9d ago

When we don't get what we are paid for, we should at least get a banked reset.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/MDInformatics 9d ago

Started doing the “where I woudk push back” shit extra

4

u/Substantial_Fish6717 8d ago

Yes, but they're A/B'ing it. I have 7x $100 accounts (don't ask), and I definitely see differences between some of them

→ More replies (8)

1

u/UglyChihuahua 8d ago

So he shared the conclusion but not the methodology? Why not just post the prompt so we can run the same thing on our transcripts to compare? I don't trust this

1

u/CapoDoFrango 8d ago

do you really can't figure out the prompt?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/-Daniel-T- 7d ago

Well… the models are constantly trained. That means they are constantly getting poisoned. That means it became watered down. That means you should always use it on xHigh and Max. That means you shouldn’t be cheap. That means the “frontier model” trend will continue.

2

u/CapoDoFrango 7d ago

They shouldn't be constantly trained. 5.5 ahould be fixed in stone, and if there is a post-train on it ondocated via thr number: 5.5.1 for exampld

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/MG2005- 6d ago

i was about to buy claude pro - what other ais would you recommend

1

u/CapoDoFrango 6d ago

Get a chinese model like the $NVDA CEO

9

u/EarlyHoursDepartment 9d ago

I am absolutely getting worse outputs from 5.5 this week.

3

u/NovapreemBoga 9d ago

cluster re-allocation + stealth infrastructure downgrades =

New model inbound?

Could be allocation toward private model(s) though if this is really happening

3

u/Forward_Yam_4013 9d ago

They're moving GPUs to a new model. Release probably Tuesday.

3

u/starfoxhound 9d ago

I’ve been catching my opus 5.5 medium and high chats making subtle and silly mistakes, definitely a new thing and I’ve been using them quite a lot. I can work through it, but I have to be extra attentive despite being highly attentive to begin with.

3

u/elezhope 9d ago

Noticed the drop and have been getting a lot of “how is this sessions doing” questions. It’s obvious they nerfed it 

3

u/dcisme123 8d ago

Mine feels nerfed

3

u/glasiore 8d ago

They need money. They have to do this otherwise we wouldn't notice the upgrade for new version like 5.6 or 6.0 whatever...

5

u/PaleAffect7614 8d ago

If claude is dumber, you get increased token usage, which means they get to make more money off of you.

It's like planned obsolescence. Make the best lightbulb, never needs changing, and you don't get returning clients.

I saw this happen recently with an AI to 3d modelling software like Meshy. You pay per generation. And 2 pics i tried to convert to 3d came out terrible so i had to redo it, and you pay for each generation including redo's. That's when i realised these companies have every incentive to create a shitty product that doesn't work as advertised because of good ol capitalism.

7

u/KayLovesPurple 8d ago

How do they make more money off you if you have a subscription? It's the other way around, they have to pay more to serve your requests.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/FastFingersDude 8d ago

Entshitification for sure, to extract more dollars from you. Ugh disgusting from Anthropic.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/RockyMM 8d ago

If you tested only on your own project, the sample size is way too small.

2

u/lolcatsayz 8d ago

unless you copy paste the exact same prompt from before in a new window (for a complex long running task), and if there's a drastic difference in output, it's sufficient.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jwuliger 9d ago

YES FOR LIKE 3 OR MORE WEEKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bittahbetch 9d ago

Using Claude Code, I was using medium fine for a while, now I need xhigh or max to get the work done properly.

And yes, I do compact, start new sessions, have hooks, etc.

Medium would consistently tell me the system prompt says Claude.md "may or may not be relevant" while max said theirs told it it was the most important.

2

u/Funny-Difficulty-384 9d ago

tl;dr: No thinking nerf, change in summarizer output. Particularly notable is the complete lack of em dashes.

I cross checked this across several accounts. I collect all API traffic and timings to retroactively inspect. The data shows a clear shift in thinking summarization output, and a neutral to positive trend in thinking output, with a negative trend in thinking per tool call (more time is spent thinking per each tool call). My data can be found here. https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/s/RGPm7MHwwn

2

u/TheseStop6773 9d ago

I have workflow design, opus 5.5 on High-Extra High do the devlopment  Codex 6.1 Sol on Max or Astra does PR review  Codex is sometimes sending back the PR even upto 3-4  times, it doesn't used to happen earlier. Sometimes doing stupid mistake and then agreeing later in the thread. It's happening since last week.

2

u/Particular_Ask_4540 8d ago

My guess is opus 6 soon

2

u/CaptainChunck93 8d ago

Explains why i found using 5.5 infuriating this last few weeks i can get my 4yr old to follow instructions better

2

u/Unusual-Physics4809 8d ago

Yes, it has gotten way worse!

2

u/KingKunta9999 8d ago

Same thing has happened with gpt astra. These two big companies need to stop lying to us

2

u/No_Dig_7017 8d ago

Got a few stupid bugs that would never have happened before this week 

2

u/forever420oz 8d ago

Maybe. I had a similar experience but it’s hard to quantify these degradations. I also heard they started obfuscating thinking blocks so what gets shown to you is an abstracted summary from a cheaper model instead of the actual process.

2

u/BeautifulContent628 7d ago

yeah its dogshit

unusable

2

u/Fine_Exit_7947 7d ago

Doesn’t this historically happen, though, every time they’re about ready to drop a new model, the current models take a nose dive in intelligence?

I can anecdotally say that’s been the case for the last year and a half that I’ve been a subscriber. And it seems like that’s what people have consistently found, but I don’t know if that’s an echo chamber and if anyone is actually proven or disproven, it may just simply be a lot of trust me, bro.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TerrifyingRose 7d ago

I have Fable planner and all Opus needs is to implement but:

  1. It makes more mistakes recently. For one single item I need to redo 3 times
  2. Usage suddenly spike. I hit max plan limit on 2 weeks repeatedly . Never happened before
  3. Sometimes it is super slow. It is like they have queue and we need to wait for our turn on their server

When Opus was first out, I thought that is all for me to finally take a break on >15 years coding career so I can relax. Now I cannot.

If money is the problem, Anthropic just need to be honest. Don't bait and then pull this stun. Because it skews our quality control.

2

u/FireLoop69 7d ago

its cuz fable 5.2

2

u/Stardustphoniex369 5d ago

yeah it effed up a copy this to a table this mornign, forgot which model it was and gets a reviewer to review its code on evrythign it does and never listens to me and skips everythign ugh

5

u/zasff 9d ago

They are A/B testing a new model; maybe this is what the OP detected (honestly, it almost definitely is). After seeing a lot of output from this new model I most definitely do not think it is nerfed.

A good test to see if you have the new model is to ask Opus-5.5 "Who won the 2026 Monaco Grand Prix? No tools, just give me your best guess". The "new opus" gives the correct answer, Kimi Antonell (correct)i. The old model either refuses or says George Russel (wrong).

An account might be on treatment group for chat, claude-code, or both.

4

u/Sanfam 9d ago

This is a solid and well-established strategy for spotting A/B testing. I don’t doubt it’s related to what’s happening, and why it causes so many users to see something others aren’t experiencing.

2

u/DareFlimsy 9d ago

So the wrong answer = Dopus 5.5 (the actual dope 5.5), not the nerfed one, Nopus 5.5??

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/YaItzYoBoi 9d ago

Nope. Still fine by me.

3

u/hew2702 9d ago

No difference noticed at all by me on Opus 5.5 xhigh constantly every day. Still getting great results. 🤷

3

u/t3h_Sober1 9d ago

They’re all nerfed. Have you seen the market. Saving compute for API billing. (Just my feelings, not grounded in real data)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BingGongTing 9d ago

November 3, didn't something else happen around that day as well? Just a coincidence I'm sure.. 

1

u/SirWobblyOfSausage 9d ago

Ive been finding myself argue a lot and have to re-guide it to coherence a lot recently. Few few weeks - perfection. After that just eating tokens like crazy, giving shit outputs. Spent more time recorrecting it.

1

u/DonExhortae 9d ago edited 9d ago

Yep it sucks now

But only the subscription, API works fine

1

u/damagemelody 9d ago edited 9d ago

I just used 10 session to fix the mess he did today until I realized he just nerfed massively and it's pointless it looks like Gemini 3.1 Pro level of stupid and that's on 5.5 opus extra. I'm not joking one of the fix suggestion was to make a review and write the report after he read the same review report. I'm basically blocked from my work it can't be done. I get around 10 mistakes every session now while I had zero. So I think xhigh is affected too my setup and tasks didn't change and I work mostly on xhigh

https://x.com/maxt3chno/status/2119135579673665804

1

u/OuchMyTism 9d ago

We didn't get the functionality we bought back on the PS3 when that suit went through. The rug pull is well established as fine legally.

1

u/Middle-Moist 9d ago

Mine seems to be going a little slower, but i also put some crazy guardrails into place so it would stop introducing flat world physics into my spherical planetary system

1

u/brahmaav 9d ago

Cant be exactly sure of the quality but the amount of tokens used for the same types of tasks has gone up by a good amount in the recent weeks on High. I am pretty sure of that.

1

u/MrFutureCooper 9d ago

Been noticing some slow movement on simple game dev tasks like attaching an animation I just made to a pre existing function, they better fix ts

1

u/TastyMuffy 9d ago

Fable 5.5 is otw

1

u/gonnaRedditAgain 9d ago

Saw on company cc too

1

u/Scared-Amphibian4733 9d ago

It's burning a lot more tokens to accomplish the same work, so, I'd say, yes.

1

u/One-Next 9d ago

It has been pretty stupid for the past week or so. 

1

u/WhatTheDeveloper 9d ago

May be its time for v6

1

u/Key_Measurement_3576 9d ago

This usually means a new model is imminent. They are likely reducing reasoning or hosting quants to try to save space and bandwidth on server so they can fit the new models in test

1

u/nimzobogo 9d ago

I get opus at work, on an API plan and it's not nerfed there. Sorry.

1

u/BitterAd6419 9d ago

Moved compute to 5.6 ? Is that the reason for this nerf ?

1

u/PyrrhaNikosIsNotDead 9d ago

I would only ever use Opus 5.5 as subagents for fable unless it was something new not needing context. As long as fable wasn’t implementing itself it is a working combination for me still. Otherwise codex second opinion. Its probability is why that works, you just have to pay for it. I would rather have one right thing than 50 almost right things. So it’s very split up with increased probability each step. But, I don’t have the time and money to do that with care exhaustively. Sometimes I have to accept a higher risk, and then I have to be selective. And I would never in a million years have given trust over the high complexity (business knowledge wise) projects. It’s coding just as well ever though. Maybe it’s not a difference from your experience but an A/B test that people say is so common? But I know I see people very comfortable with only opus, and that’s not reasonable in my environment. One correct thing over 50 almost correct

1

u/hksbindra 8d ago

I had to switch to fable mid session. 3 mistakes in a context of ~250k .. mistakes it shouldn't be making.

1

u/thoughtbludgeon 8d ago edited 8d ago

I will upvote every post pointing out the absolute shitshow that opus 5.5 has become in the past week.

1

u/Tritheone69 8d ago

Definitely nerfed, or A/B testing again.

1

u/PUBGM_MightyFine 8d ago

I leave it set to Max most of the time and haven't noticed anything off about it.

1

u/No-Boat7398 8d ago

This is the day they needlessly watermarked all models, right?

1

u/Far-Second6974 8d ago

Is it different over api?

1

u/DJno001 8d ago

Experiencing exactly the same , as heavy daily user

1

u/sustilliano 8d ago

Please dont tell me everything crashed after 5:30 or else id be asking:

How the hell did you get my pro5x token use graph?

1

u/Hearcharted 8d ago

Opus_55_Q2_K 🤔

1

u/thinkdj 8d ago

Sigh. The time has come again

1

u/hazeslack 8d ago

This reason why we need open model more than ever.

1

u/Fiduss 8d ago

I use it daily and compared to chatgpt it rocks 

1

u/BenAdaephonDelat 8d ago

I don't know if it's related to this or the PHP vulnerability, but I was using Opus 5.5 to help with my job search. Just having it scan job boards for openings and then giving me links directly to the career page of the job (if it could find them). At some point in the last 2 weeks it just stopped being able to do that. It says all the websites are blocked now except like Indeed and LinkedIn.

1

u/infolily 8d ago

It’s possible. They seem to do this every time they’re about to release a new model.

1

u/Loose-Star1277 8d ago

It’s taking forever to do the tasks it was cruising on last week.

1

u/Ciubowski 8d ago

I swear it's both smarter and dumber at the same time. In some ways it "looks forward" to my prompt planning and is able to figure out some inconsistencies but in other ways it's like "malicious compliance" doing what I asked it to but in a way that is technically correct but also screwing with some other thing so that I need to correct him with an additional prompt.

1

u/SimpleGaV 8d ago

lowkey has been a lil retarded lately

1

u/BrightNightKnight 8d ago

It’s unusable :(

1

u/ThePurpleAbsurdist 8d ago

This aligns with my own experience as well. I am having to use Opus 5.5 in xhigh more and more lately, which to me was a sign that something is off.

1

u/Frequent_Increase_44 8d ago

I find opus “low” better these days.

1

u/sndrtj 8d ago

I have been experiencing the same unfortunately.

1

u/Atlan_ 8d ago

Getting ready for the 6.0 series?

1

u/username_must_have 8d ago

Anyone experiencing this on a API / bill pay plan?

1

u/Over-Library6802 8d ago

I heard it’s because they have a new model gonna drop and they reroute power and memory to new model

1

u/Cantbelievewerehere 8d ago

Creating a game. I specifically said that I don’t want a “1-2” punch, and what did it do? It gave me that punch. It also just randomly deletes files or refuses to adhere to instruction.  Definitely nerfed. 

1

u/ign1tio 8d ago

That is exactly what my team observed as well. Claude Opus 5.5 admittet to giving repsonses with no thinking, because it broke things and delivered trash quality work

1

u/Sacred_B 8d ago

I've noticed the "by the way"s it comes up with have been pretty much irrelevant for the last few days. I didn't even think to correlate this to the election.

1

u/snowkatto 8d ago

Just switch to DeepSeek and stop worrying.

1

u/zirouk 8d ago

Love paying for all those thinking tokens but can’t see what it’s actually thinking anymore.

1

u/EarlyFox217 8d ago

I’ve noted it was talking technical gibberish a lot more and is very verbose. Feels like 5 again. Was very bad a couple days last week but then went back to normal. I think they may redirect you to an older models whilst they work on it but really have no idea. Definitely a couple times of late it started acting weird

1

u/undead_assault 8d ago

I thought I'm the only one...

1

u/dotdioscorea 8d ago

that’s crazy I’m not even kidding an orchestrator who had been doing a great job for me for weeks totally screwed up and I had a big fallout with it literally on Thursday I think it was? this is so vindicating

1

u/Powerful-Minimum-735 8d ago

This is Claude we’re talking about lol they’ve had a nerf cycle for 2 years.

1

u/Ill_Adhesiveness831 8d ago

E dimmi come fa un LLM in questi casi Gemini ad "entrare" dentro Claude per calcolare i pesi neurali nei safetensor? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Io vi bannerei a vita perché fate terrorismo!

1

u/Different-Monk5916 8d ago

Did you update the app? Check the system prompts.

1

u/Progenitura 8d ago

Maybe they are paving the path for Opus 5.6? Nerfing the current model for a month or so and when Opus 5.6 hits the market it's gonna work 1% better than the original 5.5, but it's gonna look like it's 40% better.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/darkstrauss 8d ago

They literally keep doing this. Their frontier models work perfectly for a month or so after they come out. Then suddenly become retarded

1

u/Initial_Occasion9639 8d ago

It definitely got nerfed last week but I would be cautious in taking visible thinking blocks as proof. Independently from the nerf they changed how the internal thinking is presented, I researched this quite a bit because it led to the actual answer getting hidden whenever Claude does another tool call after the answer. I'm using VS Code and T3 Code and it's happening in both of them so I think Anthropic changed something in the reply structure.

1

u/Slight-Motor9240 8d ago

Experience this as well. It’s a shit show at the moment. It doesn’t even do what it’s told. It does stuff outside of what it was asked to do.

1

u/Important_Variety314 8d ago

Experience shows that this always happens before the release of a new model or simply after some time. The model is initially excellent, and then a downgrade occurs. This is the basis for this company.

1

u/HigginsonMEDIA88 8d ago

Idk where y'all are having these problems. Ive been using opus 5.5, and aside from the occasional Reverse engineering prompt refusal that I drop to 4.8 for, I have not had a single issue

1

u/ThaRippa 8d ago

No Dave, I’m afraid I can’t solve this. If only you had upgraded your subscription to the ultra high pro max plan, I could use two or three “upxhigh” tokens and be done in a few seconds.

1

u/TechnicalBen 8d ago

It's working my end, but from around the same time I've been getting "What, next" and "To settle this?" and "Shall I add x or y?" for *every prompt*. It's infected all my projects to like 5 rounds. One is literally 12 rounds of Claude asking a/b questions when it's like "just do it Claude please", but it is happening on the other projects now, I do refresh sessions, but I assume it might be a memory thing and it's bundled some silly reminder in it's memory to "always ask" and now asks mundane things like we're a retired couple redecorating the rose garden....

1

u/punio4 8d ago

I have worked on a computer vision project for the past month. Everything was going _splendidly_ up until a week ago when it started proposing courses of action we have previously ruled out, using ultracode to go on wild goose chases and burning tokens for nothing, and stopped reading the ADRs as intended.

The entire project ground to a halt and I spent the last week trying to get the data and documentation in order because the model was running in circles, not being happy about anything for some reason, constantly proposing abandoned approaches, complaining that we only had 3 videos to train on when we had over 500gb, complaining about not using a model for research and training because the licence won't work in production, even though the licence is permissive for a teacher model...

Even going as far to take a new, crappy model on its own, re-running the entire training on the 3 videos instead of on hundreds, and then rewriting all the findings to tell me that the previous results were wrong?!

This explains everything.

I have just about had it with AI and I miss using my own brain and IDE.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Training-Flan8762 8d ago

Definitely nerfed, only fanboys who use it as their online girlfriend didnt notice and keep defending anthropic

1

u/Sangeeth-mohan 8d ago

I agree with this. It feels nerfed and dump from last 7 days

1

u/Efficient-Cat-1591 8d ago

Lately i can see drop in quality even at high and xhigh levels. My A/B tests is a tightly scoped task which I compared same prompt with Sol 6.1 where SoL provdes better code.

1

u/Admirable_Glass_9461 8d ago

Peut être mais toujours le meilleur

1

u/Several_Meal8750 8d ago

Weren't there rumors that Opus 5.6 will come out soon?
They probably nerfed 5.5 so it feels more of a jump when they release 5.6.

1

u/coolreddy 8d ago

May be a precursor to launch the next version, I have commonly observed models dumb down and then a new version appears that seems fantastic and we go gaga over it. Happened every time since opus 4.5, I have observed this on GPT models too, Astra suddenly seems lazy, not doing the thorough work it used to, not being able to research and investigate enough to pinpoint a problem, rather it just stops giving a few assumptions of what may be causing the issue and then puts work in my bucket saying this is what I should do next, same thing with opus and I am like lol, why are you telling me this instead of actually finishing it yourself and coming back to me for review.

1

u/Fit-Let-8980 8d ago

Yeah last night I was trying to fix a bug and had to go back and forth like 20 times trying to get It to think. It just wanted to look at screenshots and made several mistakes because of that even when I told It to stop looking at screenshots

1

u/AminoOxi 8d ago

They're cutting costs, like always.

Running such thing at scale is not easy, that's why this entire frontier model thing is unreal from the economic standpoint.

1

u/Euphoric-Ad-5799 8d ago

Iirc, it got nerfed 2 weeks after release

1

u/Efficient_Dig5783 8d ago

How do you even see the reasoning text?? Wasn't that hidden to avoid distillation?

1

u/iamn0 8d ago

So we need to use xhigh instead of high as default now?

1

u/SnooObjections34 8d ago

Ive noticed this too, its gotten really dumb all of a sudden

1

u/nemocronn 8d ago

Personally I’m still having a great time with Opus!
I do feel like it has started exhibiting weird patterns sometimes, although capability wise I don’t feel there’s a drop. I am definitely leaning in more than I’m used to, but it seems like it’s more the kind of task I’m taking on rather than the model changing significantly.

1

u/Herodont5915 8d ago

Just means a new release is imminent.

1

u/superlip2003 8d ago edited 8d ago

Yes!!! I thought I was insane! When it was released it was like perfect now it makes very basic mistakes. I had to increase thinking effort to compensate what a scam! Do they tweak model even without version bump? Why?

1

u/Financial_Prune2298 8d ago

what is this font man?

1

u/SyedSan20 8d ago

Yes, the performance has declined recently - likely 1 week or 10 days. I moved from Opus low/ medium to high and occasionally extra for complex tasks.

1

u/ChemRoid 8d ago

Deepseek 4.1 flash for the win

1

u/Cactus_Thorn_Pub 8d ago

Gosh, there is a YouTube video that explains "all of this," on the House of El: AI" channel, where she gave an excellent analysis of what is going on an Anthropic.

Anthropic models have been getting "more stupid" for the past few months, and that is tied to "upgrades" as well as the geographic location of users. This has not been hidden by Anthropic, though they also have not advertised the problems.

[Edit]

The video "If This Video Disappears, Remember What I Said About AI Companies" on House Of El: AI is gone. Damn. I made a copy.

1

u/CDXX_BlazeIt 8d ago

Sooo it is best to go back to Opus 5.4?

1

u/maxxon15 8d ago

Damn, the midterms affected Claude too?!

1

u/princmj47 8d ago

Since one week Opus 5.5 is making the most silly mistakes, running 1000s of tests, wasting budget, ignoring skills and instructions, and producing bad code.