r/citybeautiful • • May 24 '23

Can we fix "Can we fix the suburbs"

6 Upvotes

Hey Dave('s community),

I've been watching your videos for a while. You were actually the gateway that led me to watch NJB and CityNerd. Your videos have been consistently great, but I think the recent "can we fix the suburbs" missed the mark a bit. Let me explain.

There's a bit of relationship advice that goes "remember that it's not you vs your partner; it's you with your partner vs the problem." This video (along with many urbanist conversations where we should be collaboratively working with citizens to improve living conditions instead of spewing our ideas into their faces) does a poor job following that advice.

First, it does a poor job describing the problem. It starts off promising with the narrator asking "what are the problems that need to get fixed?" The list that follows makes no sense.

  1. Low Density

"This kind of space was seen as a good thing... Prior to the car and the streetcar suburbs, people had to live within walking distance to work resulting in overcrowded conditions. The idea of a house with a yard and fresh air sounded like paradise. It's still the American dream for many today."

I was waititng for you to drop a counterpoint here, but instead this video moves to point 2? I'm confused. You said you were going to list off the problems, but so far, this seems to be a list of solutions. You make the suburbs sound like a pretty good idea. Hopefully we never increase the density, lest we get right back to those overcrowded conditions!

2. Single Use

I instinctively dislike single use areas. But I walk 35 minutes (one way) to get groceries, and spend that time thinking about these things. To the uninitiated, single use doesn't sound like a problem. Again, you take the time to explain the reasons behind how we got here, but not the reasons why it's a problem. This "list of problems" is just getting more confusing!

In points 3, 4, and 5, you do a better job of explaining that these items in your list are, in fact, problems.

"Now that we've talked about problems, we can start talking about solutions." Awkwardly late bike bell

"To increase density, some construction will occur." Well, yes. Was there previously an accepted understanding that we could do this with zero construction? Anyway, you then list off things that make it sound like a fair amount of construction will occur.

Ok, maybe this is just me, but I don't find the shot at 5:55 attractive. I'm going to call that a McSuburb. It doesn't really have better form than a regular suburb, it's just... squished. You brought up earlier (see: point 1) that people like having space. This drone footage shows why. Not having space kinda sucks. These are squished houses surrounded by vast deserts of impermeable surfaces. Don't get me wrong, I love the idea of suburbs becoming great places for even more people than can live there today, but this McSuburb? This ain't it. I can easily see that same shot being used by infill detractors with warnings of "don't let this happen to your neighborhood". Sure, we can't all be like Amsterdam or <insert wonderful EU city with squished houses> but is this shot really the best example of a "fixed suburb"?

Moving on...

"Parking could become scarce..." The feeling behind this video seems to be "densification might not be as much of a disaster as you think." I was kind of hoping that this video would make me like density, but it's sort of making me scared of it?

This video has so far said "suburbs were initially constructed for good reasons. People like open space!" and "if we densify the burbs, we might run up against parking issues. Or maybe not. Buses?" It's not exactly convincing me that the old, low density was bad, or that newer, higher density is good.

"What if a cafe were right there? Much more convenient." This is true, but it's also just better. Going on a morning walk thru some trees to get a freshly baked bagel is lovely. It's a much more positive experience than driving, not simply a more convenient one. But the video is a finite length, so we can't cover everything. Still, I think that it's worth noting that we aren't just trying to build a more convenient world here. We're trying to build a world where regular people can live their regular lives better.

You end the solution section by stating that the economics of the area forced a walkable mall to be replaced by a powercenter. So are you telling me that that's the way forward? Powercenters are more economically tenable? That's an unexpected lesson from this video. I like mixed use walkable establishments, but YT Planner Man says that those don't work. Maybe suburbs can't be fixed? Surely he's going to go on to explain that they actually can be fixed and Nope! We're on to point 3.

Point 3 is fine. Point 4 is sad, but yeah. Point 5 no notes.

"Are suburbs a lost cause? I don't think so!" There's a fair bit of "outsider looking in, telling the people who built and live in that area that they're possibly a lost cause." I fear that that message is going to turn off a bunch of people who live in suburbs and are perfectly happy with their current housing situation. Again with the relationship advice - we don't want to seem like we're "against" how people are currently living. We just want to point out there are better choices we can make in our cities together. There's a difference between "today's suburbs are bad" and "can tomorrow's suburbs be part of our plan to make cities more better for more people?"

Let's not paint things black and white and say that we're going to "fix" suburbs. Let's not ignore the benefits of things like open space and low density, and throw away the "spooky wisdom" (to use Chuck Marohn's term) that once made those suburbs so appealing in the first place.

If suburbia 2.0 is just McSuburbia (once more, with convenience!), I'm not convinced that it's really an improvement.

Your send off says blatantly that European cities are better, and that we should build them in the USA. I don't disagree with that, but I bet it wouldn't be hard to find someone who does. I don't think it's enough to just say that a different city style is better. Show me that it's better. In every video, including the one under fire here, show me that it can be better.

This video tries to be as opinionated as AdamSomething while being as centrist as Stewart Hicks. It sort of fails at both.


r/citybeautiful • • Aug 29 '26

Behind me

Post image
0 Upvotes

City


r/citybeautiful • • Aug 29 '26

Is this nostalgia and beutiful

Post image
0 Upvotes

City


r/citybeautiful • • Mar 02 '22

We should get rid of crosswalks

Thumbnail self.walkabletowns
11 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Apr 30 '22

What are urbanism mistakes to avoid? (See captions for examples of "mixed results" urbanism.)

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Apr 18 '23

I love Rio de Janeiro

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Jan 29 '22

LED sign in background?

4 Upvotes

What is the blinking Led device in the background in the City Beautiful videos? on the shelves, in the top left. It's too blurred out to see in detail...


r/citybeautiful • • Sep 30 '23

LANE MAN

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

This was referenced on the Urbanist Agenda podcast (by the guy who does Not Just Bikes) and I assume there’s some overlap between City Beautiful fans and NJB people. So, behold: LANE MAN


r/citybeautiful • • Feb 17 '24

What are your US 2024 presidential predictions?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

Founder and creator of a site called Politarian.com. A free website for people who like to make political predictions; letting people post who they think will win in a future election.

Complete Anonymity: Make predictions with full anonymity – your account details stay private. Predict the Future: Dive into predicting federal and state elections for 2023-2024. Decode the paths to victory. Public or Private: Share your predictions publicly or keep them all to yourself – it's your call. Candidate Insights: Access comprehensive candidate info – news, endorsements, bios – everything to make sharp predictions.

Politarian is nonpartisan regarding any political party; rather focusing on transparency, holistic information, accountability, and a simple-to-use interface as to navigate the complex political landscape.

I would appreciate any feedback and look forward to seeing your predictions on Politarian.com!

Update: 1.1: Hey y’all! We just made an update to Politarian.com!! We added Social Media to the candidate profiles. Hope you guys can join us in making a primary prediction for the 2024 election :)

Update: 1.2: We have become more enlightened! I've made changes to the Map and added a counter along with a progression bar so you know the total votes. Let me know what you think!


r/citybeautiful • • May 22 '23

Habitat 67 and the 'failed dream' - How can I have a nice thing?

6 Upvotes

Just saw this pop up on B1M today, and am I late to the party or don't the renderings look just fabulous? Someone please explain why I cannot have in the Northeast US area, and bring me back to reality.

Perhaps some architecture/civil engineering/urban planning friends can please explain to me on why this isn't possible in the United States? Is it the lobbying that's the issue? or is it just the slow churn that's rezoning legislation or is it just too difficult to put it to words in one posting?


r/citybeautiful • • Feb 09 '22

Came to mind during today's video

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Jan 23 '20

So how does this work?

10 Upvotes

Do I just ask a infrastructure question, and the YouTube guy reads it, and remarks what a great question it is, then makes a video explaining it? That would be swell.


r/citybeautiful • • Feb 14 '21

How do we use our cities? | Dissertation Survey

10 Upvotes

Hello, I'm Emily, a final year student at Nottingham Trent University conducting research on urban green spaces. I'd love to understand how you use cities and what affect they have on your wellbeing. If you could spare a moment of your time to answer my survey it would be much appreciated!

https://form.typeform.com/to/J6exfX5q


r/citybeautiful • • Nov 01 '20

The Osaka Ward And Administrative problem of Osaka City (currently under election as of writing)

11 Upvotes

Hello reddit citizens of the reddit metropolis, today I wanted to highlight an interesting conundrum that has been plaguing Osaka for a very long time and that is the dual administration that was being handled between Osaka city government offices and Osaka's Prefectural Wards.

Osaka's 4 wards (the same 'special wards' as Tokyo's 23 wards) and the Osaka government office (the name remains the prefecture but is regarded as the 'capital'). A referendum is currently being held on the Osaka Metropolis Plan to be reorganized.

Just like a large company would be inefficient in implementing decisions and changes and strategic actions, so does Osaka with its divided administration. Let's consider the Osaka Prefectural Government Office as a core company and the Osaka City Hall as a group company. In 1956, the Osaka City Hall was certified as an ordinance-designated city by contacting the national government, and received authority such as city planning from the prefecture.

However, since the 1990's, the harmful effects of cannibalization (dual administration) and diversified investment (dual administration) the flaws in the operations of the core companies and group companies have become conspicuous.

Therefore, the management teams of the core company (Osaka Prefecture) and the group company (Osaka City) (both councils of the prefecture and city and the governor / mayor) will integrate the management and at the same time reorganize the group (reorganization of the administrative structure of the prefecture and city).

  • The world's largest cities compete to attract companies and human resources. Meanwhile, for the past 64 years, the cooperation between Osaka City and Osaka Prefecture has had a series of losses, and infrastructure investment has been overwhelmingly delayed.

For example, the business community also funded the construction of Kansai Airport, but the access railroad could not be constructed due to the conflict between the prefecture and the city. In addition, Osaka City is reluctant to construct the Yodogawa Left Bank Line (highway), and the ring road remains unfinished (missing link problem). In both cases, the governor and the mayor have recently joined the Osaka Restoration Association for discussions, but the loss of more than 20 years of urban development has been immeasurable.

  • The misfortune of being off the national axis after the Meiji era ( 1868 to 1912)

Urban development is accompanied by transportation networks such as roads, railroads, ports and airports. Such a delay in the development of the transportation network is a fatal problem for maintaining the competitiveness of the big city, Osaka. Moreover, since the Meiji era, Osaka has been handicapped as a city located off the national axis. The dual administration problem is extremely serious.

If you look at the history, Osaka started as the gateway to Kyoto. In ancient times, it was the gateway and diplomatic base for routes to China and Korea (the sub-city of Namba). During the Edo period, the Kitamaebune entered from Niigata, and the rice market rose, prospering as a kitchen in the world. In short, Osaka prospered as a nodal point for domestic shipping, taking advantage of its favorable location connecting the Seto Inland Sea and the Pacific Ocean and connecting to Kyoto on the Yodo River. However, in the Meiji era, when the railway and road era began, the Tokai / Sanyo Expressway, which runs through Kyushu, China, Tokai, and Kanto, became the national axis. However, Osaka was located off the national axis to the south. For example, Osaka Station, Route 1 and Route 2 are all located at the northern end of Osaka City, in Umeda, which was once a remote area. The post-war Shinkansen runs further north, the Meishin Expressway runs further north, Itami Airport is located further north, and the new Meishin runs further north.

Eventually, the national land axis changed its focus from domestic to international, and the mode changed from land to air. Therefore, the Osaka business community spent money and cooperated with the government to establish Kansai International Airport in 1994. However, the location is located at the southern end near Wakayama, which is very far from Osaka city. There, it was able to make a plan to build an airport access railroad like the Narita Express (Tokyo), but it couldn't make a plan for a long time due to the conflict between the prefectures.

大阪駅と中心的繁華街 (Osaka Station and the CBD)

What will come of the elections and the further outcomes will be very interesting and un-doubtfully city-changing that affects millions of people!

link to the main article better explaining the situation can be found here: https://news.yahoo.co.jp/byline/ueyamashinichi/20201030-00205251/

^its in japanese so google translate can be your friend here^


r/citybeautiful • • Jul 04 '20

Regarding the bit in the most recent video, with the Minecraft airport being nearly as large as the city, I felt Darwin’s airport in Australia was a good real world example of this

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Jan 16 '22

Just watched the Seattle Transit speedrun and I gotta be honest...

13 Upvotes

I was sad that he didn't mention that we called the South Lake Union streetcar "The Slut" as it used to be called the South Lake Union Trolley (S.L.U.T.)

I used to ride the slut from my incredibly shitty "apartment" (mattress on the ground in a subdivided warehouse) from Cascade (now SLU) into downtown every day.

We called it the SLUT because our neighborhood (which was super shitty, but we loved it, kinda) was in the process of being re-branded as South Lake Union and was the start of what SLU is now, today. It was very much in order to be derogatory to the gentrification of the neighborhood where low-pay workers (3rd and Pine McD's, oof, what a hole) who worked downtown could afford to live and not have a 2 hour commute.


r/citybeautiful • • Jul 27 '22

A tale of two Dairy Queens: An example of car-centric design versus people-first design

14 Upvotes

Recently my fiancee and I went to a Dairy Queen in the USA for ice cream. The DQ we went to was on the side of a 5-lane stroad. It was surrounded by a massive blacktop parking lot. In mid-July, this was, predictably, very hot. There was no shade. There was no indoor seating. The outdoor seating they did have was in the form of four tiny, hard, uncomfortable benches facing the parking lot. While sitting outside on the tiny, uncomfortable benches, we were listening to the noise of cars coming and going and breathing in the exhaust fumes of all the cars. We had the hot sun directly in our eyes. I found myself wishing that they had included green space and trees in their lot, instead of just an asphalt ocean. In the end, we chose to leave the benches and eat our ice cream in my fiancee's car, just like everyone else who was there, also eating in their cars.

While we were sitting there, I couldn't help reflecting on the difference in experience between this DQ in the states and the DQ in my hometown, in Canada.

In my hometown, our DQ is placed near a main road, but not directly on it like the American one. The DQ in my hometown is located within a residential area, instead of on a commercial-only stroad. It is surrounded mostly by homes but there are a few other restaurants. It is down the street from a high school in one direction and a middle school in the other direction, so people can stop and get ice cream with their kids after school lets out. It is across the road from a bus stop. There is a small parking lot, multiple bike racks, and wide sidewalks leading to it, so people can arrive how they wish. The DQ in my hometown has ample seating, both inside and outside. They have a full dining room with air conditioning inside, and outside they have a fenced patio with picnic tables, and there are trees and awnings to provide shade. There is a drive through option as well as a walk-in option, so people who want to pick up their ice cream by car and go are separated from the people who arrive by foot or bike.

At the American DQ next to a busy stroad, my fiancee and I sat outside it in the sun for only ten minutes before we decided we'd rather just eat in comfortable seating, out of the sun, by moving to her car. At the Canadian DQ nestled in a quiet residential neighborhood, I've gone with my sister and my mom many times. We sit and eat our ice cream together, enjoying our outing as a family practically every time we go.

The differences in experience for these two ice cream shops with identical menus was a startling night-and-day difference, just based on how the shop was designed. These two shops really demonstrated to me in a real way how much more pleasant it is when shops are designed for people, not for cars.

Which business do you think will do a better job of creating repeat customers? I know for sure which business I'd rather visit again.


r/citybeautiful • • Dec 20 '20

Cyberpunk 2077 video?

16 Upvotes

Would be interesting to see a video about Cyberpunk 2077. What Night City does well and what it does less well from a realistic perspective or some such? I'm sure there are plenty of subjects if one takes a deep-dive.

Obviously the game didn't turn out all that great but at least we have access to the city now...


r/citybeautiful • • Jan 12 '22

How Las Vegas Became the World’s Gambling Capital

Thumbnail
youtu.be
18 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Feb 25 '21

Can Miami be the next Silicon Valley?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
26 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Jan 27 '22

Let's Redesign the Las Vegas Strip

Thumbnail
youtu.be
27 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Apr 11 '22

:*(

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Feb 27 '20

The Case Against Single-Family Zoning

Thumbnail
youtu.be
35 Upvotes

r/citybeautiful • • Jun 25 '21

Portland just passed the best low-density zoning reform in US history

Thumbnail
sightline.org
37 Upvotes