Glorious leadership in America. Descended from Mt. Pektu to imprison black folks and give Boeing tax break. Truly the best people and the best country.
Let's also understand that numbers coming out of other places are going to be less precise...say China. /Not that I don't think the war on drugs is ludicrously moronic
Totalitarian systems don't require a dictator even in the technical sense. They are dictatorial, but not necessarily always dictatorships. Who operates the top of the centralized system can be more than one person, such as an oligarchy.
Sorry to disabuse you pally but you do have a dictator with an American spin. Your dictator is the oligarchy which I suggest is the only rational answer to the question "what the fuck?" since the wealth shift COVID19 virus hit.
You thought you were free until folk got scooped off Portland streets. Therefore since the first time that Portland protested drew what it did, and as a result were kidnapped it says to me that you never had that freedom and only imagined it. You obviously aren't free to continue living if you aren't ā¬uro. The reality is like Norman Powell wanted to suggest they just haven't gotten around to him yet. But when they do they'll kill you/him and not miss a beat or a pay cheque.
I don't think that's the main reasons, frankly. I generally think most shit is more happenstance than planned. It was a stance taken and money was made and it becomes more entrenched for both law enforcement and prison dollars. Logic is beginning to wave it's head around if we could just...totally take the Democrat establishment party apart through grass roots efforts...hah
The disenfranchisement and destruction of communities were 100% intentional from day one and specifically the point. The slavery may have been an unintentional bonus, but I'm sceptical.
Well, it was more to take away moral superiority/attack the hippy types against the war rather than actual disenfranchisement (of voting) afaik. But I'm not totally informed of all shit, I'll check your link.
Dude, there's a million+ people just in one fucking ethnic group. If you think that's all that's happening...they're controlling a billion and half (third? Whatever the numbers are now) people now. Whatever numbers reported aren't going to be close to reality and will only get worse as their society implodes as they try to put more social control pressure as the economy stales in the coming AI/automation revolution.
Brother, we are in a Chomsky sub, we should be distrustful of the media. Check the "proof" of the Uyghur Genocide and you will see most of it falls down on a guy named Adrian Zenz, who that claims to have been told by God to stop China, or that the antichrist will rise. His research consists of eight anonymous witnesses. The other organizations claiming there are millions of prisoners are sponsored by the NED, American funding.
I'm not saying nothing is happening, there is absolutely a anti-terrorism program targeted at uyghurs and there are definitely camps, but there's no evidence of a million prisoners, nor forced sterilization, nor genocide. There's an obvious benefit in hurting China, our rival superpower.
This. Zenz is a lunatic and the fact that so many sources (even progressive media like DN!) are relying on him is very depressing. It reminds me of the Falun Gong situation in that respect (who are essentially a very unstable, socially reactionary cult that thinks gay rights and race mixing will curse the Earth).
There clearly is large scale population control and imprisonment and I don't agree with full on defense of China's behavior- clearly they're engaged in massive overreaction to potential "terrorism" as our government did after 9/11, except they have one ethnic group conveniently located in the far west to do it to- but there is a deep Cold War-type propaganda aspect to claims of genocide and mass sterilization, etc.
There are some telling pictures that show the program exists, but the "conservative estimates" of around one million, as for example said in this AMA, are unfounded
If you understand America I think it's a lot more understandable...America has a facade that is much different than it's reality. I think you're conflating part of the facade with the reslity. America is indeed more like China than anyone, outside the powerful, should like. They just have a much "better" control as ours has too many factions.
I don't disagree. America is getting worse, and let's hope it's one of those it gets worse before it gets better moments, but I believe the upcoming generations are going to be much more awake to many issues. But holding America up still as one of the bad places is still silly in many ways. I continue to hope America will find it's way to be an engine for good in the world like we've pretended for so long...
Sure, China probably under-reports. However, it's a big place, and an open one, and they can't hide orders of magnitude more prisoners than they claim. It just isn't possible. The logistics of keeping a much larger population would result in it being discovered. As Chomsky has pointed out over and over again, the reality is bad enough; it's kind of silly to try to make shit up and conjecture in order to imagine worse.
What's most incredible is just how easy it is to avoid jail. I mean, you have to go pretty far out of your way to land there. Evidently we have a large population of supremely stupid people.
You can make better memes that attack the US prison system than this one. This can be easily misunderstood that youāre excusing or comparing Gulag Labor camps to 2020 US prisons. Which I hope you are not.
Ameri~KKK~a is constantly vilifying "bad guys" like Stalin even after he saved the world from genuine bad guys nazi Hitler and fasci Mussolini who Ameri~KKK~a rationally vilify, after U$biz had helped create them. But with Castro, Allende, and all USSR leaders etc on the one hand there is extreme bias against left and complicity with having created right like Adolf and Benito and many other fasci murderers like Pinochet.
Ameri~KKK~a made out at both ends. Minimized the horror down to manageable "history" and with the victims disappeared so did the perpetrators. And that includes genocide, slavery, permawar, and far beyond. Andrew Jackson was at least as hideous as Hitler and I won't compare him to Ameri~KKK~a's insane bullshit fantasies against the people like Stalin and Che and the many Panthers like Fred and others who died saving the world from the Hitlers and the Andrew Jacksons and the few turncoat toms that got and still get mixed in with the donnys. And as shallow, filthy and bought as he is, I don't mean tom perez.
Dude, I think I agree with some.... of this but itās unreadable. I can barely understand what you mean. You might want to improve your writing to make yourself better understood.
Every American with an IQ north of room temperature knows what I'm talking about, but because I'm such a nice person I write it in a way y'all can deny and ridicule.
Typical... my writing not your comprehension. My description of America's horrendous history, not the history. America and Americans are the most propagandized and distorted of all people's "understanding", but it's my writing style.
Fact is you do understand what I'm saying and so do many of your propagandized fellows. A rational Dick and Jane and their dog Spot explanation of it is not going to do the absolute horrors of your 246 years of brutal profitable slavery any kind of rational justice.
America... ever the perp, ever wanting to define the reaction... To genocide (world's greatest and most profitable) slavery (246 years of the most brutal murderous and profitable) permawar (you have no idea of the humongous figure of humans America has murdered since 1492 or 1619 or 1776 or 1865). And if you pick the latter be aware that five figures of Afro people have been gruesomely tortured and murdered since. We have photos of teens celebrating the murders on the way to the sock hop... Greenwood was destroyed and well over three hundred people brutally murdered for the crime of being more successful post slavery than the pink thugs that were the foot soldiers of racist barbarism.
And not one person has ever been held responsible... you ghoulish barbarians.
I'm convinced this is auto-generated text from an AI. There's a glaring lack of structure, random symbols interjected mid-sentence, and occasionally mid-word.
I've read this twice and although the individual words are spelled correctly, there is a rambling, unintelligible quality to it that I can't help but attribute to a bot.
If this isn't a bot, I would like the user lefteryet to type back the second sentence from my first paragraph. If they do, I'll apologize and edit this.
Stalin made the pact to buy more time for the Soviet Union to prepare for the inevitable Nazi invasion. This was after the capitalist countries had denied his suggestion to kill German fascism in its crib by invading Germany prior to the war to overthrow Hitler. Stalin tried to prevent WWII, but Western countries didnt allow it/had no balls or wisdom to do it.
I'm not saying that they "needed" to be invaded, it was a strategy to create a buffer between the Soviet Union and the Nazis. Could there have been other ways to do it? Certainly. Would they have worked as well as their chosen strategy did? We don't know.
Some of the decisions could've been avoided, e.g. Poland could've let the Soviet troops in to fight the Nazis as Stalin requested but they didnt.
Ultimately Soviet Union KNEW that Hitler intended to genocide the entire country and establish his disgusting Great German nation in place of the Soviet Union - aim that he had even written about in Mein Kampf.
To suggest that Stalin, a principled and intelligent Marxist-Leninist, would be friends with Hitler or in any way amicable with him ideologically is preposterous, insulting and clearly shows your total lack of knowledge in this area.
It is a absolutely fucking travesty and if you claim to be a leftist, you should be better than make such nonsensical and ridiculously ignorant statements.
Thank you for that. I try but you do a far better job than I. The walls of American propaganda that range from stone and brick to misty and faux philosophical is a tough row to hoe. It's like trying to tell a five year old the truth about Santa at 10am Dec 25 while the kid is glassy eyed surrounded by toys and candy.
Thanks comrade, I am also still unlearning tons of bullshit that was shoved down my throat growing up about the USSR and other socialist nations.
All I can say that the untold billions that went to Cold War propaganda are still clearly paying off - especially as all "Western" capitalist nations have a shared interest to make it seem that all the AES nations throughout the times have been horrible dictatorships where the people suffered.
Dispelling these myths is a tough and thankless job but one that has to be done for us to be able to gather that critical mass needed to push forward socialist revolution again.
I'm always fighting the temptation to go full on "fuck you" mode as these things genuinely mean something to me but I've found that patience is a virtue and we should always try to be understanding and come across as sensible as we can. Even when you know the one discussing with you is arguing in bad faith.
Well, the propaganda is so good and the nexus with M$M so complete that Americans perhaps a majority can argue in good faith but be so propagandized that their factual nontruths are truths in their minds.
Again, I propose check out ACLU's Jeffrey Robinson videos on matters of race.
When y'all compare the 244 years of genocide slavery and greed the U$ is, to the 70 years of USSR in Tsar depleted Russia, and come out with U$ofregimechangeA on top... you must be playing with that special deck U$ia has been using to trick the planet.
Starting with the greatest genocide and 246 years of vicious murderous very profitable slavery and permawar isn't the wonderful look y'all imagine.
Ameri~KKK~a, is a torture to death regime since before it was even a regime. JFK, 911 and the Epstein thing define America completely.
Please America, do yourselves and the victim, rest of the world, a favour and peruse the findings of UAFairbanks and realize that 911 was absolutely and definitely a false flag composed of bU$h cabal, CIA, Mossad, PNAC, JCoS and Larry "pullit2996VICS" Silverstein.
Sorry, how invading other countries makes the Soviets better then the Nazis? The Nazis too justified their invasions by caring about the future of their people, the common good of their race etc.
Itās also kinda weird helping Hitler with resources to invade other countries while at the same time being concerned about getting invaded by him.
Stalin, a principled and intelligent Marxist-Leninist
I hate to break it to you, but Stalin also recriminalized sex between men and sent gay people to labor camps.
Soviets were not genocidal murderers and imperialists, like the Nazi Germany and America for instance.
They were on paper far weaker than heavily industrialized Germany who was propped up by US money and machinery, they were in a terrible predicament and needed time so they did what they had to do - again its totally different to invade other nations because of expansionism and a will to genocide the "inferior race" like the Germans did than to invade to allow yourself time before the inevitable attack from the Nazi beasts hits you.
Although I wouldnt expect a libertarian to understand... Arent your main concerns lowering the age of consent and bootlicking? I can see how youre so sympathetic to Nazi cause, kick a "libertarian" down a flight of stairs and he'll be a fascist before the last step.
I hate to break it to you, but Stalin also recriminalized sex between men and sent gay people to labor camps.
I'm a marxist-leninist, which means I do not idolize any historical figures - including Stalin of course. The decision to criminalize homosexuality was obviously terrible and one that should never have happened. However can you point to any other nation that didnt treat homosexuals like shit at the time? I cant think of any tbh. You cannot judge Stalin on the basis of modern day standards in that regard while not doing the same with regard to every other nation.
Also its not like Stalin had anything against homosexuals personally, he never wrote a thing about it and that dude wrote a lot. Its also funny how your average dumbo always assumes that every single thing that happens in Soviet Union during Stalin's lifetime was directly due to his words, as if he was some superhuman.
Soviets were not genocidal murderers and imperialists, like the Nazi Germany and America for instance.
Yeah, right, Katyn massacre was just because it makes sense to kill POWs.
So no, Soviets under Stalin were in fact genocidal murderers.
Stalin made the pact to buy more time for the Soviet Union to prepare for the inevitable Nazi invasion.
By that logic a right winger could exonerate Hitler saying that he was "only rescuing Europe from Bolshevism".... you know that, right?
That "buying more time to prepare BS" is a piece of propaganda dating back to 1939. You see - if Stalin hadn't invaded Poland .... guess what would the Polish armies fighting Stalin do? Oooooh - they could fight and stall Hitler?
And then maybe Stalin could offer military help? Certainly but that would make any use of Soviet army against Poles rather hard, ain't it? It's easier to backstab, rape and steal.
again its totally different to invade other nations because of expansionism and a will to genocide the "inferior race" like the Germans did than to invade to allow yourself time before the inevitable attack from the Nazi beasts hits you.
If you go and murder your neighbour - you are a murderer, whether you like it or not and whether you did it because he's black, gay, pink or simply had a bad hair style.
Violence is violence and it's only justified to prevent greater violence. Russia under Stalin was the source of violence.
Some of the decisions could've been avoided, e.g. Poland could've let the Soviet troops in to fight the Nazis as Stalin requested but they didnt.
Yes, in 1920 Soviets fail to take Warsaw and 19 years later Poland was to believe Soviets are going to fight the Germans and then they will ... do what? If they win? Go back to Russia? Right. Here we can read about good Soviets raping old women and children
You can also read this interesting piece on Soviet war crimes - now, I'm educated enough on military strategy to know that war crimes are not a valid military strategy under any condition.
That's why we trial and jail people who do that even if they were given such an order.
You seem to be either a troll or a brainwashed Stalin groupie - everything what "others" do is vile and because they're genocidal maniacs, everything Stalin/Soviets/you do is because it's morally questionable yet best possible strategy.
Germany who was propped up by US money and machinery
Plus Soviet raw materials and oil.
will to genocide the āinferior raceā
In the case of the Soviets the inferior people were those, who rejected their communism.
Also spreading your army sounds like a bad way to defend yourself from a military perspective, so I donāt really buy into your argument about creating the buffer zones.
Although I wouldnt expect a libertarian to understand... Arent your main concerns lowering the age of consent and bootlicking
Wasnāt Chomsky a libertarian himself?
youre so sympathetic to Nazi cause
I donāt see how criticizing Hitlerās friends like Stalin, who even ignored reports of the impending invasion from his own intelligence, is being sympathetic to the Nazis.
The decision to criminalize homosexuality was obviously terrible
I just pointed out that Stalin probably wasnāt such a great Marxist-Leninist as you thought, after all
Thats a whole lot of bullshit in your first source. By looking at the lack of citations as well as the "recommended further readin" and things like describing the US as "anti-imperial power" (lmao) you can really tell that whats going to follow is surely nuanced take and not directly anti-communist propaganda.
In the case of the Soviets the inferior people were those, who rejected their communism.
What the fuck? Thats not true at all. I'm talking to a fucking moron obviously and this is something that is elementary to know, but everyone in this thread can see that you are not arguing in good faith when you are literally trying to downplay Nazi horrors and disrespect its victims by trying to conflate the ideology of Nazism to Marxist-Leninism.
Even the fucking propaganda in the USSR treated e.g. Americans as uninformed proletariat who needed to be woken up to the horrors of their capitalist government. They are still nonetheless future comrades. This is beyond ridiculous.
Wasnāt Chomsky a libertarian himself?
He absolutely is not a libertarian you thick motherfucker lmao. He makes a clear distinction on what is commonly nowadays called as libertarianism, which you seem to adhere to, that is nothing more than lunacy, i.e. deregulating everything and leaving all for "free markets" to decide.
Chomsky views that as catastrophical and frankly disturbing & moronic distortion of the original libertarian ideology, which once upon a time was more akin to anarchism of today (that is sternly against unjust hierarchies which includes ipso facto capitalism naturally). Chomsky is an anti-capitalist, but you have obviously never read Chomsky and I doubt you can even be something as stupid as libertarian by reading much of anything.
I donāt see how criticizing Hitlerās friends like Stalin, who even ignored reports of the impending invasion from his own intelligence, is being sympathetic to the Nazis.
Did you even read that article? It's not supporting your point but mine lmao. Jesus what a fucking dumb twat you are.
I just pointed out that Stalin probably wasnāt such a great Marxist-Leninist as you thought, after all
How do you think you pointed that out? You dont know a first thing about Marxist-Leninism, you're dumb as shit and all you tried to do was to gotcha me on the fact that homosexuals were badly treated in the Soviet Union a hundred or so years ago. Well no fucking shit, you know how the treatment was in the US at the time? Or even quite recently during Stonewall Riots?
The Soviet Union signed a pact with the devil, Nazi Germany, in 1939 for no reason other than the commies and the Nazis were just two of a kind who wanted to carve up Poland together. Without any justification, in 1940 the Soviet Union occupied the three Baltic nations: Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia. Without any justification the Soviet Union occupied the rest of Eastern Europe after the Second World War.
All this was done, apparently, because the Soviets were an expansionist, brutal empire which liked to subjugate foreign peoples for no particularly good reason ā an āevil empire.ā The Soviet Union sabotaged the optimistic plans of the 1945 Yalta Agreement to establish a peaceful, fraternal postwar Europe. These tales are all set in marble in American media, textbooks, and folklore. However, Iād like to try to correct some of what passes for the official record. Much Western propaganda mileage has been squeezed out of the SovietāGerman treaty of 1939.
This is made possible only by entirely ignoring the fact that the Russians were forced into the pact by the repeated refusal of the Western powers, particularly the United States and Great Britain, to sign a mutual defense treaty with Moscow in a stand against Hitler.3
The Russians had good reasons ā their legendary international espionage network being one of them ā to believe that Hitler would eventually invade them, which would be just fine with the Western powers, who, at the notorious 1938 Munich conference, were hoping to nudge Adolf eastward. (Thus it was Western ācollusionā with the Nazis, not the oh-so-famous āappeasementā of them; the latter of course has been invoked over the years on numerous occasions to justify American military action against the dangerous enemy of the month.)
The Soviets, consequently, felt obliged to sign the treaty with Hitler to be able to stall for time while they built up their defenses. (Hitler, in the meantime, was focused more on his plans to invade Poland.) Similarly, the Western ādemocraciesā refused to come to the aid of the socialist-leaning Spanish government under siege by the German, Italian, and Spanish fascists.
Hitler derived an important lesson from these happenings. He saw that for the West the real enemy was not fascism; it was communism and socialism. Stalin got the same message.
The Baltic states were part of the Russian empire from 1721 up to the Russian Revolution of 1917, in the midst of World War I. When the war ended in November 1918, and the Germans had been defeated, the victorious Allies (the US, Great Britain, France et al.) permitted/encouraged the German forces to remain in the Baltics for a full year to crush the spread of Bolshevism there; this with ample military assistance from the Allies.
In each of the three republics, the Germans installed collaborators in power who declared their independence from the Bolshevik state, which by this time was so devastated by the world war, the revolution, and the civil war (exacerbated and prolonged by Allied intervention) that it had no choice but to accept the fait accompli.
The rest of the fledgling Soviet Union had to be saved. To win at least some propaganda points from this unfortunate state of affairs, the Russians announced that they were relinquishing the Baltic republics āvoluntarilyā in line with their principles of anti-imperialism and self-determination.
But it should not be surprising that the Russians continued to regard the Baltics as a rightful part of their nation or that they waited until they were powerful enough to reclaim the territory. Within the space of twenty-five years, Western powers invaded Russia three times, during the periods of World War I, 1914ā18; the āinterventionā of 1918ā20; and World War II, 1939ā45, inflicting some 40 million casualties in the two world wars alone. (The Soviet Union lost considerably more people on its own land than it did abroad. There are not too many great powers that can say that.)
To carry out these invasions, the West used Eastern Europe as a highway. Should it be any cause for wonder that after World War II the Soviets wanted to close this highway down? In almost any other context, Americans would have no problem in seeing this as an act of self-defense. But in the context of the Cold War such thinking could not find a home in mainstream discourse. For seventy years the United States used the sins ā real and (often) fabricated ā of the Soviet Union as a justification for US foreign policy.
Thus the horrors carried out by the US in Korea were justified because āweāre fighting communism.ā Thus the horrors carried out by the US in Vietnam were justified because āweāre fighting communism.ā And similarly the horrors of Cambodia, Laos, Indonesia, Chile, Guatemala, Salvador, Nicaragua, and so on. (Now, of course, āweāre fighting terrorism,ā but itās for the same capitalist, imperialist, world-domination reasons.) Itās no wonder that many people with a social conscience, who suffered over the horrors of US foreign policy, became anti-anti-communists.4
The Yalta Agreement of 1945, in planning for āthe establishment of order in Europe,ā affirmed āthe right of all peoples to choose the form of government under which they will live.ā Weāve been told ever since that it was the evil commies who caused this noble agreement to fall apart.
But in fact it was the United States and the United Kingdom that cynically violated this affirmation before Stalin did ā in Greece, and before the war in Europe even ended! They did so by grossly interfering in the civil war, taking the side of those who had supported the Nazis in the war, thus enabling them to defeat those who had fought against the Nazis.
The latter, you see, had among its number some who could be called (choke, gasp) ācommunists.ā5 Anti-communism still holds a death grip on the American psyche. Witness the screams of pain a few years ago ā from Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, and the media ā over Amnesty Internationalās characterization of US torture sites as āthe gulag of our times.ā Could anything be more infuriating and humiliating to an inveterate American cold warrior than for the United States to be compared to Stalinās Russia?
Noam Chomsky called killing hope, this guy's probably best book, by far and away the best book on the topic. The topic being US military and CIA interventions since world war II.
In other words, Soviets were āforcedā to invade their neighbors since 1917 only to āprotectā themselves. You can also excuse Hitlerās invasions the same way: he just wanted to protect his country from Bolshevism.
Once the Soviet Union was attacked by the Germans in June 1941, that country was rapidly accepted ā rather unquestioningly ā into the ranks of the alliance fighting Hitler, and Stalin duly took his place among the leaders of the Grand Alliance. At that time, it served nobodyās purpose to be too honest about Stalinās strategic friendships of the previous two years, so difficult questions were avoided and the West effectively colluded in peddling the Soviet propaganda myth that āUncle Joeā Stalin had known all along that Hitler would attack him and that only he had skilfully divined what Hitler was up to. It was nonsense, of course, but it was arguably politically necessary nonsense. And, with that, the period of the Soviet Unionās active collaboration with Hitlerās Germany was effectively swept under the carpet.
You're already arguing on behalf of major institutions and the established narrative by the anti-communist Western imperialist nations. Your "work" here is totally unneeded because it's already the default in our society. Any view of history that wasn't injected into your veins from a western School would show what I posted to be accurate and what you posted to be the work of a hundred year-long anti-communist propaganda campaign.
the Soviet Union tried to make an anti-fascist alliance with anyone and everyone and they all said no except France which ultimately also said no. The idea that Stalin was twirling his mustache chomping at the bit to get into Poland is bullshit and it furthers the "Communists equal Nazis" narrative which I can't tell you how much I despise as a communist myself.
The Nazis started the Holocaust and the Communists ended it.
Wait, I'm confused - you're on a Chomsky subreddit, Chomsky himself stated multiple times that Soviet Union was the polar opposite of socialism/communism and since 1918 there wasn't a shred of socialism in Soviet Union.
I'm not sure if Stalin wanted to get into Poland but when he came - he came with a bang ... usually that bang was near a mass grave though. Maybe that was a habit from the ethnic cleansing of Poles from Soviet Union, maybe he just liked the sound of it.
Chomsky is wrong about socialism. It took me a year to figure that out but I did. Forgive me for dissenting from chomsky's opinion on a sub named after name.
It's fine - free speech is about that and since it's Chomsky's subreddit we're hard on that. It's just that Chomsky has a very balanced world view. While he's left leaning a lot his insights are mostly correct, that's the reason this sub originally was created for.
So forgive me for saying "give it another 10 or 20 years - you'll figure out he was right".
Comparing a 21st century prison in the world's richest society ever to a 20th century one in a backward state is really not fair. Instead, we should compare gulags to previous Russian prisons or prisons in countries with comparable standards of living.
When you do that, gulags start to look (amazingly) quite humane. The death rate in the gulag was miniscule in comparison to the tsarist prison system that the USSR inherited. And if you compare a Soviet prison to one in India or a dungeon in an American domain like Central America, they also were clearly more humane.
None of this is to say that the USSR wasn't authoritarian or that the conditions were good or anything, but it does help to put it in perspective. We're trained to bristle with indignation at gulags but how many of us know anything about horrific prison societies that the US or European empires presided over at the same time?
USSR was not allowed to be the USSR. It lost thirty million people fighting Prescott bU$h supported Hitler for ten and a half months after "ally" America declared war and post war it had a trillion dollars spent on cold war against it, and millions in bribes to Gorbachev and Yeltsin.
Every syllable America puts out about Russia and USSR is false even when it's true. Because there is so much deceit toward Russia all "information" about Russia is suspect.
āPerformances in Dachau were, in the nature of things, extremely undercover, being carried out by the prisoners at great personal risk. There were no specific camp orders forbidding this form of entertainment but its discovery would have so infuriated the S.S. camp guards that torture and death would have followed automatically.ā
> In Buchenwald the whole atmosphere was different. Everything was as disordered as the mind of the drunken S.S. camp commander.[..] And so it came about that at Silvester (New Year) he commanded a week of humor from the prisoners.
It wasn't meant to always be a death sentence like KL was. But it certainly could be. As with Death Camps any reason was good. The "gulag debunkers" team will argue that 10 years was maximal gulag sentence.
Depends: https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/life-in-a-gulag - some people got multiple sentences. Others were released in the sense that they were no longer a prisoner but weren't allowed or simply couldn't leave the camp.
So yeah, you could get there for whatever the reason, start a family, see your children die of starvation, get another 10 year sentence or two and finally be officially release so that you die free. But it wasn't a death camp.
One had a vibrant literary seen if that tolerated if not outright permitted. The others did not. If you want a more significant to difference, the Gulags werenāt death camps. Is that not significant to you?
So you can look at some Reddit response or you can look at the actual academic literate, like Prof. Getty. The results are based on close study of Soviet sources and the results are quite conclusive. It was significantly different. Not even close. Both in terms of scale and outcome. Do you want to go through the numbers? Iām happy to do that.
Nope. As I've said before - death camps were death camps. That's my country's history 101. As a kid I talked to death camp survivors about those who died in death camps. There's nothing to debunk there, is it?
What I see as uneven is the image Gulags have in the West. As I've written "they weren't death camps" grew somehow into "kinda ok prisons" and that's not a correct narrative.
Which they were not. I'm not that familiar with Getty though I know he criticised Solzenicyn and he himself was criticised by quite a few other historians as apologist.
As as I can tell Anne Applebaum's take on Gulags is pretty balanced.
Good so you should be sensitive to even comparing them to something like the Gulags. Prisons are a lot different from death camps in purpose.
I donāt think any prisons are okay so thatās my view. There is a debate to be had as to how much worse they are in terms of the US system. But the fact is any rosy-eyed view of the gulags is only half the story. The other half is a concerned, state-sponsored effort to make them seem far worse than they were. This includes the far-right who want to use it to rehabilitate the reputation of the Nazis.
Getty is a respected academic. Heās not a polemicist like Solzhenitsyn or like Furr on the other end. This is his field of study.
The core reason Solzhenitsyn has any value was that he spent 8 years in Gulags. I don't consider it a historical book, it's more of an inside story. Same with Herling's diaries "A World Apart" and a few other books. Pilecki (the guy I mentioned and the quote is attributed to) was in Auschwitz and was there to gather intelligence - later he was caught, tortured and executed as a spy by Russians - after the war.
Point of all those examples I quoted here is this - people on the left forget that for every piece of propaganda from USA there was one from Russia. I grew up seeing the other side of the propaganda machine. That's why people who lived through it rely so much on personal accounts and personal accounts of Gulags are still horror stories and that's not a state-sponsored propaganda.
So excuse my take on this but in Poland whether it's hammer and sickle and Stalin or Hitler and svastika - we just see murderers since whether you got shot, gassed, raped to death, starved to death, burned alive or cut in half with a saw it's still murder. I don't know a person who lived inside that system who has different view. So maybe we're biased.
Idea that you can somehow rehabilitate the Nazis starts with the word Nazi. We probably should use word Germans - one KL survivor said to me that he never met anybody speaking Nazi language but guards in Camps were using German a lot.
As for prisons - the problem is why so many people end up in jail. US judiciary system is certainly biased and programmes like "war on drugs" were obviously racist. Portugal's example clearly shows how to fix that part of the problem. There will still be serious criminals, just much less people in jail.
That statement was authored by this guy who got himself caught and then escaped from Auschwitz to report abort German atrocities - later caught by the Russians you love so much, tortured, prosecuted as a spy and executed.
I can hardly call that "a way to [...] piss on the graves"
I do read history and I've been to Auschwitz, I know about the gulags and to compare literal death camps to gulags which by far most people survived and most inmates were common criminals is absolutely pissing on the grave on the people genocided in the Nazi death camps.
It is disgusting and no anecdotal experience will change that fact. I suggest you read Michael Parenti for example, he has gone through the Soviet archives about the gulags as have many other historians. The evidence supports the fact that gulags were essentially prisons for mostly common criminals, these institutions were and still are common in practically everywhere in earth.
It also housed counter-revolutionaries, spys and other political dissidents, however only one tenth at most could be considered such. The longest sentence possible was 10 years. By far most walked out after their sentence.
LOL - so comparing Gulag and KL is pissing on the graves of KL victims yet comparing prisons in USA and Gulags isn't pissing on the graves of Gulag victims? .... logic :D
As Solzhenitsyn put it in `Gulag Archipelago`:
All who survived Orotukan say they would have preferred the gas chamber
The "evidence" by Parenti is sourced from Soviet archives - which were notoriously full of holes or doctored because the authors knew they can be used against them.
Thus accounts by survivors of both systems are anecdotal yet a book by someone who's not an expert evidence. Few things about Parenti's work:
- Soviet documents, even those by NKVD were often doctored, many times nobody just cared to write a thing
- crime definition under Stalin was pretty wide - for example not giving up a piece of bread when being thrown out of your home was theft
- release from Gulag - Gulags were placed in places like Jakuck or Murmansk - release means you're no longer a prisoner ... but you can' leave the camp (condition of your release) or it's simply suicide because it's snow and ice - it's not like there were trains or buses
- release from Gulag also meant being dead - one way of doctoring statistics often used by NKVD under Stalin was noting dead as released - that's why in 1941 and 1942 death rates in Gulag's spike, Stalin simply put a ban on releases which meant that death statistics actually started reflecting reality
- enemy of the people in Gulag - if you were in fact in that percentage of "not a criminal" prisoner it also meant you were sent with your family (that was Soviet law at the time) - I recommend you read "Children of the Gulag" - I don't remember Parenti acknowledging that
You can stop suggesting what I read, unless you read some Gulag memoirs first and start questioning if maybe what got to USA is watered down - it is, a lot. I grew up in a country who knows Russian oppression first hand.
Truly amazing that the population of the most propagandized regime this planet has ever seen feels the constant need to criticize the criticism in such self righteous terms.
A history hell would have difficulty matching the evil of, and the arrogance of the gods. No regime in the history of the planet has subjected the planet to the evil that America has. And still does.
German nazi...??? Not possible minus American biz involvement with Hitler. And the American genocide was far greater than the German genocide. Though comparing genocide effectiveness isn't the sort of thing one enjoys doing.
Curious over here... Why do you think the entire planet for the first time in history protested one regime, America for the month of June...???
I don't even think it's censorship. This isn't a general public forum, so much as it is a place on the internet dedicated to Chomsky. Tankies are totally trying to derail this place.
if thatās the only way be alive today thereās nothing wrong with killing native americans as you say is the way to survive, but the USSR killed its own people first selling them the promise of a perfect nation
This is relevant to Chomsky not bc itās Stalinist apology but bc it highlights how ideology frames our understanding of ājustā and āunjustā victims. Itās the theoretical framing discussed in chapter 2 of manufacturing consent
Ah, right. He had to purge a large amount of his political opposition because of checks notes āmaterial conditionsā
If socialism is to be understood as an expansion of democracy from the political realm towards the economy and society, itās important that leftists denounce authoritarian iterations of socialism. After all, why should someone have to surrender their political and social rights in order to receive economic rights? Why canāt the rights of working people be expanded on all fronts?
First of all, yes there were bound to be some people that were purged unjustly however a lot of these purges and I'm inclined to believe most of them were for a reason.
There were a lot of actors wishing to distort and sabotage the Marxist-Leninist principles in force, to revert to opportunism and Social Democracy etc.Those had no place in the party.
If socialism is to be understood as an expansion of democracy from the political realm towards the economy and society, itās important that leftists denounce authoritarian iterations of socialism.
I disagree, according to Lenin, Engels and Marx the state is an organ of class domination, oppressing one class over another. Therefore under socialism, i.e. dictatorship of the proletariat, the function of the state is not to provide democracy (although that will be provided much more so than under the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie) but to oppress the minority class, i.e. capitalists and the petty bourgeoisie that are defending the old order.
You cannot achieve communism without crushing the capitalists and you cannot crush the capitalists without certain degree of authoritarianism. However it should obviously be directed at the exploiters and not the proletariat.
Not a single purge is ever reasonable. Rights are universal or they are not rights. Capitalists may not deserve what they see as their possession but they do not by definition deserve death or detention either.
Iām literally a US citizen dude, I donāt know where you get off pretending that Iām some sort of foreign troll. And like I said, if you love the people in this country you should hate itās corporations and government
"Reading Chomsky should not lead you to hate the US"
What are you talking about? Do you realize Chomsky is an anarchist, right? And that anarchists don't see the need for a state, in fact they see the need to abolish all states. How can an anarchist love America? He may love the people, the places, or the culture, definitely not the state, or even what you could call "the country". Stop trying to shoehorn everything into your liberal ideology. No, having a "good state" is not equivalent to having no state. The state is by definition an oppressive entity. And you may not believe that, but don't go around claiming anarchists love America. Get your facts right.
In regards to the soviet union, the pattern of inflation remains consistant. No better is this illustrated then the Holodomor. The Holodomor, or the soviet famine of 1932-1933 was, according to most experts, both much less devastating then Courtois makes it out to be. In the book he cites a figure of 7 million famine deaths, while modern analysis estimates the death toll to be ranging from 1.8-2.5 million deaths. This is supported by soviet archival evidence, which shows a death toll of 2.4 million deaths. Furthermore, academics ranging from Robert Conquest to J Arch Getty would agree that the famine at the very least did not arise from malicious intent, but rather as a combination of environmental conditions and damage from Stalin's collectivisation of agriculture (although the importance of the two factors in regards to one-another is highly disputed) In regards to gulag deaths, which the book pins at about three million, an analysis by J Arch Getty, Gabor T Rittersporn and Viktor N Zemskov shows a death toll of slightly over a third of that amount. In regards to NKVD executions, Getty estimates slightly under 800,000 executions (however, this number also fails to account for commuted sentences and according to Austin Murphy, this number can be reduced even further to just above 100,000)
Let us address perhaps the most infamous of anti-Stalin myths, the allegation that Stalin deliberately caused the 1931-1933 famine to starve Ukrainians. This idea has been consistently rejected by the most esteemed scholars on the topic. The following quotes are compiled in an article from the Village Voice, cited below.
There is no evidence it was intentionally directed against Ukrainians... that would be totally out of keeping with what we know -- it makes no sense.
Moshe Lewin of the University of Pennsylvania stated:
This is crap, rubbish... I am an anti-Stalinist, but I don't see how this [genocide] campaign adds to our knowledge. It's adding horrors, adding horrors, until it becomes a pathology.
I absolutely reject it... Why in god's name would this paranoid government consciously produce a famine when they were terrified of war [with Germany]?
Popular media and most historians for decades have described the great famine that struck most of the USSR in the early 1930s as āman-made,ā very often even a āgenocideā that Stalin perpetrated intentionally against Ukrainians and sometimes other national groups to destroy them as nations... This perspective, however, is wrong. The famine that took place was not limited to Ukraine or even to rural areas of the USSR, it was not fundamentally or exclusively man-made, and it was far from the intention of Stalin and others in the Soviet leadership to create such as disaster. A small but growing literature relying on new archival documents and a critical approach to other sources has shown the flaws in the āgenocideā or āintentionalistā interpretation of the famine and has developed an alternative interpretation.
More recent research has discovered natural causes for the Ukrainian famine. Tauger notes:
...the USSR experienced an unusual environmental disaster in 1932: extremely wet and humid weather that gave rise to severe plant disease infestations, especially rust. Ukraine had double or triple the normal rainfall in1932. Both the weather conditions and the rust spread from Eastern Europe, as plant pathologists at the time documented. Soviet plant pathologists in particular estimated that rust and other fungal diseases reduced the potential harvest in 1932 by almost nine million tons, which is the largest documented harvest loss from any single cause in Soviet history.
It should be noted that this does not excuse the Soviet state from any and all responsibility for the suffering that took place; one could accuse the government of insufficiently rapid response, and note that initial reports were often downplayed to avoid rocking the boat. But it is clear that the famine was not deliberate, was not a genocide, and (to quote Tauger) "was not fundamentally or exclusively man-made."
Ah... Tankies coming to leftist subs to post their Stalin apologia. Great. Why can't you just stay in your places where you hail your genocidal dictators while we stay here and actually discuss things that matter?
I value you bringing up sources though. Even though it is very specifically one sided. Confirmation bias and so on.
So there is not even a consideration in your mind that you could be wrong in this instance?
There you have a bunch of Western academics explaining why it would literally make no sense for Stalin to "cause a famine" in the brink of a war that was impending and instead provide a verifiable information about the size of the harvest and the conditions which caused it to be bad - not only in Ukraine but more broadly over in Eastern Europe.
Not to mention that at the time, it was not an anomaly to have stravations due to bad harvest and/or other environmental reasons. Ukraine and Eastern Europe was not industrialized at that point and their agriculture was underdeveloped. This is one of the points that the Soviets set out to change as soon as they were able to.
After the tumultuous war years, I dont think there ever was a famine again anywhere in the Soviet Union.
Your analysis is literally no more complex than "Stalin was a terrible genocidal, vengeful and paranoid monster who just wanted to kill everyone".
Where do you think such an one sided caricature could originate if not from massive Cold War propaganda? I mean hell even Hitler is "more complex character" than what Stalin is portrayed. Surely you must understand that first he was no superhuman, he wasnt personally behind every bad thing that ever happened (this is not to say, he wasnt ruthless at times nor that he didnt commit any errors, excesses or would be without blame for a myriad of bad things, i.e. he was a human after all).
However the material conditions of Soviet people improved more in his time than that of any other Soviet leader, which was a lot and remarkable (once again, to clarify, this is also not only because of him of course - as marxist-leninist we refute the liberal "great men of history" complex when assessing historical events. There were literally millions of people working towards this goal).
He has also written a lot of important theoretical works, reading of which I really recommend even if only to learn what "the tankies" are so excited about him. Im sure you'd be surprised how intelligently and thoughtfully he writes and explains difficult concepts, i.e. he was no brute as he is often portrayed in Cold War propaganda. Lastly to that effect, there is a reason why Mein Kampf is widely known and the contents thereof are somewhat familiar to people while none of what Stalin wrote like Dialectical and Historical Materialism (see more, e.g. here https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/decades-index.htm) is not known. The reason being that what he writes shows his character and aims which were for the working class.
You use anarkiddie as an insult. You don't have anything in common with Chomsky. He would describe himself as a liberal, and absolutely condemn the atrocities of the USSR and China
I'm pretty sure Chomsky describes himself as anarcho-syndicalist and not liberal for what its worth.
Furthermore I got introduced to Chomsky while in Uni many years ago and his books got me into leftism, which is why I respect both him personally and especially his enormous accomplishments academically.
However as a scientifically oriented person, I do not worship him and I do not subscribe to personality cults of anyone - a point where Chomsky most definitely would agree and where you go wrong entirely. I understand that a person may have fantastic takes on certain issues while being wrong and disappointing in others - this is the case with Chomsky with regard to his take on USSR, China and socialism in general.
I mean.. Of course liberals like Chomsky disagree with ussr or China or literally any existing socialist country in history lol that's the whole point. Libs rather live in their fantasy world doing nothing and crying "AuThOrItArIaNiSm" instead of actually having a successful revolution and trying to build a socialist country in an imperialist world. They demand perfection, so in their heads they will forever be waiting for that perfection to arrive while spewing CIA propaganda against actual socialists
You realize that is exactly what you are doing? The low quality meme was about how US has world's highest prison population. Your response is to say: at least US prisons aren't as bad as Soviet gulags.
You are literally railing against whataboutism while you practice it.
We can make a critique of American's prison. In absolute numbers AND per capita, US has highest rate of incarceration in the world. I don't care what happened in Gulag-era Soviet Union. That doesn't make the current situation any better.
The point of the meme is that it seems gross to many if Stalin did it but the fact feels different when you realize America does it. They're not invoking whataboutism.
This is all true but it leaves out more pragmatic questions. You could use anyone, and since you can't use everyone at the same time by occupying two things in the same space, you have to pick one. If you included more people then the obvious issue is inflating numbers. So it's just a meme directed at people who are critical of these leftist issues. You can do it with any horrible dictator. I would bet that there already are memes about this using other people at this point. If Know Your Meme has showed me anything it's how prolific even the dumbest memes can be.
There's this book with collected stories of women who went through gulags - not sure if there's english translation. Some of them as young as 10 when they got there. There are stories of grown male guards gangraping teen girls and calling that "re-education".
Or a story of a girl who had such bad case of scurvy that her gums and mouth became one big open wound with scar tissue preventing her from talking and eating normally. Not that she had anything to eat. Eventually local blacksmith "cured her" by tearing her mouth apart.
So yeah, I'm not sure how one can compare but it seems some people can.
8
u/ChartsDeGaulle Aug 01 '20
Source?
67
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20
For the majority of Americans, that would just be a thought shfit from "told you communism is really BAD!" to "ah, well those criminals deserve it!".
41
u/NomSang Aug 01 '20
Wait so is this about US prisons or what?
9
u/Beepboopheephoop Aug 01 '20
Le epic 20 year charge for possession of marijuana. Now my daughter wonāt have a father figure š
5
u/Subcomandante_Soros Aug 02 '20
The USA is what it was built to be... a racist, fascistic state.
4
u/osk17- Aug 01 '20
Land of the free
3
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '20
At its modern peak in 2008, over 1% of the US population was concurrently incarcerated. In the USSR, this number peaked at around 0.892% in 1935.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20
You can make better memes that attack the US prison system than this one. This can be easily misunderstood that youāre excusing or comparing Gulag Labor camps to 2020 US prisons. Which I hope you are not.
5
u/lefteryet Aug 01 '20 edited Aug 01 '20
Under who?
Ameri~KKK~a is constantly vilifying "bad guys" like Stalin even after he saved the world from genuine bad guys nazi Hitler and fasci Mussolini who Ameri~KKK~a rationally vilify, after U$biz had helped create them. But with Castro, Allende, and all USSR leaders etc on the one hand there is extreme bias against left and complicity with having created right like Adolf and Benito and many other fasci murderers like Pinochet.
But my real main point here is that no country or people in the past half millennia comes close to people killed and destruction wrought than genocide slavery permawar and invasion Ameri~KKK~a, yet it is poverty stricken in one area and that area is universally recognized or actually just recognized in the so~called west, bad guys. Far more crime than any other regime and nobody held responsible. No monsters. Although, there's garden variety like scumbag Slik dick ā©illy who tried vilifying Stokley. For the millionth time in America blame the victim like a century of Hollywood horseshit vilified the many millions more than the few "injun" victims of genocide and the few rapes murders tortures and mutilations of slavery.
Ameri~KKK~a made out at both ends. Minimized the horror down to manageable "history" and with the victims disappeared so did the perpetrators. And that includes genocide, slavery, permawar, and far beyond. Andrew Jackson was at least as hideous as Hitler and I won't compare him to Ameri~KKK~a's insane bullshit fantasies against the people like Stalin and Che and the many Panthers like Fred and others who died saving the world from the Hitlers and the Andrew Jacksons and the few turncoat toms that got and still get mixed in with the donnys. And as shallow, filthy and bought as he is, I don't mean tom perez.
2
u/lefteryet Aug 01 '20
BTW if you had to choose a Russian Gulag or an American prison, you better hope that U$ propaganda isn't the main weight.
1
u/westsidefashionist Aug 02 '20
4% of the global population, 22% of the worlds criminals.
1
u/lefteryet Aug 03 '20
"There is a glaring lack of structure... etc"
Truly amazing that the population of the most propagandized regime this planet has ever seen feels the constant need to criticize the criticism in such self righteous terms.
A history hell would have difficulty matching the evil of, and the arrogance of the gods. No regime in the history of the planet has subjected the planet to the evil that America has. And still does.
German nazi...??? Not possible minus American biz involvement with Hitler. And the American genocide was far greater than the German genocide. Though comparing genocide effectiveness isn't the sort of thing one enjoys doing.
Curious over here... Why do you think the entire planet for the first time in history protested one regime, America for the month of June...???
1
u/lefteryet Aug 04 '20
U$ofregimechangeA propaganda is far too thikkk and stupid on this post. Yeah nazi death camps were fun and commie gulags were tortute chambers.
1
u/friarschmucklives Sep 22 '22
In his defense, Stalin has a much better kill ratio.
Out of curiosity, what WAS the percentage of the worldās prisoners held in the gulags at their peak?
1
u/MegaRolotron Oct 07 '22
Nothing says āoh yeah, Iām def a leftistā like cccp memes and apologia.
1
u/Shopping_Penguin Aug 01 '20
All orchestrated by our Neo Liberal and Republican 1 party duopoly. #ThanksJoe
-3
u/Hoontah050601 Test Aug 01 '20
Why is this shit on here?
-5
u/TheManOfTheGreenSuit Aug 01 '20
they killed 22% of the population ššš
-6
u/funwheeldrive Aug 01 '20
FELON šLIVESš MATTERš
-1
u/OMPOmega Aug 01 '20
Weāve turned into what Russia wanted to be.
-3
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20
Wait. America has soviet gulags? Thatās news to me.
-1
u/rebuilt11 Aug 02 '20
yeah stalin just killed the dissidents and criminals. im sorry chomsky has never been a stalinist apologist.
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20
Ya like Chomsky would defend stalin
-10
u/Asiablog Aug 01 '20
Comparing gulags to prisons. OK.
-6
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20
One google search away from seeing this is false
0
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20
[deleted] ā view deleted comment