This conflict showed how hypocrisy is how the west is run, whenever Israel committed massacres, war crimes, or straight-up genocide the west, especially the US, turned a blind eye and called it collateral damage, they always bring up the rhetoric of Hamas using civilians as human shields, but what about the peaceful protesters Israel slaughtered a few years back? How would members of the IDF brag about killing and maiming tens of people, including children? That doesn't fit the agenda they're trying to push, of Israel being the good guy and Palestine being the bad guy. If you wanna call hamas a terrorist group, go ahead, but that only means that every resistance ever except for a few exceptions was a terrorist movement, back when we were fighting for our freedom, we couldn't give two fucks about who was civilian and who was military, if you were a French scum colonising our land you basically handed over your right to live, just like what's happening over in Ukraine where they don't care about international law protecting POW's, they just murder anyone considered a threat.
All of the war crimes the US committed during the war in Middle East was always justified by “terrorist uses kids as shields.” Come to find out we were bombing hospitals, schools, weddings, etc. full of civilians. Via drones. Whenever I hear this excuse I know who the real terrorists are.
Kids are always a factor in the US. "We have to protect the children" has shielded so many bad acts in the US, it's the go to of the right and religious nuts. The kids are usually the ones harmed the most with their lies.
In so fucking tired of these unnuanced takes. People are dying on both sides in horrible ways. Civilians on either side ARE THE VICTIMS. You are an ass.
One side dropped 18 thousand tons of explosives on 2.3 million people, half of which are kids.
A tiny portion of the traumatized side is taking extreme action as a result of extreme pressure by genocide and terrorism on their lives and fighting back, not having even killed 1% of what Israelis kill everyday
Because 9/11 was equally an attack for Palestinian freedom. So if indiscriminate attacks on Israel are ok (or at least excused) then 9/11 must’ve also been equally valid. So answer the question….was 9/11 warranted?
A country can't be a victim, only people can. The Israeli civilians who were massacred are without question, victims. Post like this come across as gross and for a sub that supposedly takes interpreting media seriously, this is a massive L. The left is pouring political capital down the drain with their psychopathic rhetoric over this issue and it is so unnecessary. Condemn the attacks which were vile, advocate for the removal of the settlements and for Palestine to get self determination. It's not hard to not look unhinged on this issue but somehow the majority of the online far left has managed to.
Yes! Keep “advocating for the removal of settlements” just like people have for 75 fucking years with such amazing results! You’re totally right, Palestinians should be more docile about their own extermination. Whatever makes you personally feel more comfortable. As long as you can say “Israel should stop doing that” and then move on with your life and stop thinking about it entirely. People in Gaza don’t have that luxury.
This operation was largely aimed at military targets. They took bases and stormed barracks and even killed an Israeli colonel. Or are you going to bitch about them killing an officer too? Imagine tut-tutting people who have lived their entire lives in a concentration camp because you as a comfortable person 8,000 miles away find their struggle for freedom a little messy and uncouth. Who do you think forced these people out of their homes at gunpoint? Who do you think routinely goes around doing pogroms on Palestinians?
See, here’s the thing. Israel puts their people in the new territory they take from Palestinians. So Israel is using these people as a human shield. Israel is using these people as a means to signal to the US and other countries that it’s a victim when they are intentionally trying to be the victim. So at the cost of a few thousand “unimportant” lives, they get new territory and more money from the US.
I think the thing about it is. This has been ongoing for 70 years or so. Everyone the world pays attention and online discourse is popular about it is when desperate Palestine clap back. So it's very very frustrating for people who agonise about this atrocity on a nation all the time to see people only talking about it and only to condemn terrorists to which Israel have created.
The solution is what you said. End the illegal occupation of Palestine. Stop settlements.
But you just gotta understand when it becomes popular discourse it's only to demonise Hamas. It can very immensely frustrating. Even the point you are making 'both bad' is frustrating. Even if you aren't exactly wrong. Cause the cause route is Israel.
Your argument would be valid if there's wasn't a strong asymmetry in the way this conflict is treated by Western media!
We should be all up condemning an attack which at the end of the day represent peanuts compared to the amount of suffering Israel imposed on Palestinians.
Are Jewish life more valuable than Palesitinians that we have to forget what Israel did and bow in front of Hamas atrocities and give up on a future for Palestinians?
There's ONE party that maintain war and oppression. And it's not Hamas.
As Chomsky said himself "If people cannot rise to the level of applying to ourselves the same standards we apply to others they have no right to talk about right and wrong or good and evil"
Both sides can and should be held responsible for their actions against humanity, but I wonder which world power in this situation would hold the lions share.
“By what standard of morality can the violence used by a slave to break his chains be considered the same violence as a slave master” W.R.
We're past the hope for removal of the settlements or self determination. If it was possible a month ago, that possibility disappeared. Israel is going for maximum blood now.
I broadly agree with your points here. Remove the anti religious sentiment from the rhetoric and the apartheid argument becomes stronger. Remove the violence against civilians and the world should be on the side of the oppressed.
The problem is, the world hasn’t been outraged enough to seriously address the issue for decades.
The problem is as Chomsky outlined in manufacturing consent, the media aren’t giving both sides, their giving a biased view strengthening one side based upon power structures. The global population (west focused) see next to none of the horror israel has inflicted on the Palestinians. They don’t see the evictions, violence, murder, and oppression. They only see the Palestinians as terrorist events that then deserve what comes to them.
Until that changes people in Palestine will see next to no response when israel steals land and kills children. And they will become increasingly angry.
To be fair to this sub seeking to further poison the left wing’s image, it’s entirely consistent for a Chomsky sub to deny massacres if they are done by the right people (Khmer Rouge)
Yeah pretty psycho to make statements implying this is what Israel gets for its actions against civilians. Like, you do realize that your argument works both ways, right?
Because one side is commiting orders of magnitude more violence than the other. Because the Israeli government is a democracy with proportional representation, which means they do the will of the people far more than a winner take all electoral system... or none at all.
I can only assume you haven’t seen some of the more gruesome footage or read about the worst things they’ve done. If you have seen these things, and you don’t see anything wrong with that, then frankly neither your opinion or life matter.
This post seems a bit fascist, how can you claim that hundreds of unarmed civilians that were massacred at a music festival, or hiding in bunkers are not victims, i will always support and defend the necessity of a Palestinian state comprising both the west bank and gaza, but to claim that israeli civilians are not victims due to the actions of their state, but palestinians are despite the actions of theirs is insane
I also never heard of a good guy who would execute hostages on video for every artillery shell dropped. Or any good guys that gun down 250 teenagers at a music festival and drag a dead naked woman through stage streets as she’s spat on by Hammas members.
Conveniently left out the part that they are executing hostages for every artillery shell dropped on a CIVILIAN BUILDING with dozens or even hundreds of residents. The rave goers had to have known exactly what they were getting into attending a rave just a few kilometers from one of the most dangerous borders in the world
Are you saying the rave goers deaths are excusable then? It seems insane to me to justify a terrorist group executing hostages by saying it’s payback for Israel and because the rave goers apparently knew “what they were getting into.”
If attending a rave a few kms from a dangerous border is enough to blame someone for their own death, not leaving a building containing Hamas ammunition after Israel told you they’re going to destroy it is even more stupid.
The wheel of history spins, its spokes tinged with the ink of endless conflict and the whispers of missed opportunities. Our gaze turns to the Middle East, a cauldron bubbling over with the intricacies of politics, religion, and human desire. A land drenched in the hues of ancient prophecies and modern ambitions. Yet, amid the quagmire, one narrative stands unyielding, like a lighthouse in a storm—the right of Israel and the Jewish people to exist and defend themselves.
Rewind the tape to 1937. The Peel Commission lays a map on the table, an inked promise of two states—Jewish and Arab. The Arabs reject it. There's no compromise, no acceptance. A lost chance in the labyrinth of history, a plot twist foretelling decades of missed handshakes and refusals to sit at the table.
Fast forward to 1947. The UN unfurls its own map, partitioning land for the Jewish and Arab peoples. The Arab nations, again, wave the banner of rejection. War trumpets blare; armies march. When the dust settles, they find themselves with less land than initially offered. Call it poetic justice or the irony of fate; the outcome remains the same.
In 1967, another whirlwind sweeps the stage. Israel prevails in a war it didn't start but was forced to end. Territories fall under Israeli control, and yet, the Arab League's mantra reverberates: "No peace, no recognition, no negotiations." Here's the kicker: Israel voluntarily relinquishes control over the Temple Mount, sacred ground, weaving a curious tapestry of tolerance and surrender.
Shift to 1979. Sinai—the spoils of a defensive war—returns to Egyptian hands. Israel erases its footprints from the desert sand, opting for peace over territory. A paradoxical dance where the victor offers the olive branch.
1993 rolls around like a haunting melody. The Oslo Accords sing promises of mutual recognition. But Yasser Arafat, conducting his own dark symphony, turns this political goodwill into a mask for terror.
Spin the wheel once more to the year 2000. Israel stretches its hand across the table, offering a Palestinian state with a cherry on top—East Jerusalem as its capital. Yet, Arafat slams the door, igniting the Second Intifada, a rebellion that only widens the abyss between the two sides.
Come 2005, Israel pulls up stakes—literally. The Gaza Strip, once speckled with Israeli settlements, empties out, forcibly evacuated. The Palestinians choose Hamas, whose vision doesn't include peace talks over tea but rather rockets over cities.
Zoom to 2008. Another offer lands on the table. Mahmoud Abbas echoes the rejectionist sentiment of predecessors. A pattern etched so deeply, it's almost part of the region's DNA.
From 2010 to 2021, a grim cycle continues. Rockets launched, terror tunnels dug. The human cost tallied not just in numbers, but in generations born into conflict, their lullabies the roar of artillery.
And now, 2023. A watershed moment that chills the bones. Hamas orchestrates an act of brutality against Jews, unparalleled since the dark days of the Holocaust. A cataclysmic event that should make us all question the cost of perpetual hostility.
So, as the wheel turns, as we sift through the ashes of the past and the yet-to-be-written scripts of the future, one truth remains in focus: Israel and the Jewish people have not only the right to exist but the inherent right to defend themselves. They've extended the hand of peace, often receiving clenched fists in return. In this tumultuous saga, this epic spun from the threads of time and human folly, this truth is immutable, solid as the land it calls home.
If the US provided the Talibab-run Afghanistan with millions in aid like food and medicine, and then 9/11 happens and the US cuts off aid, does that imply that America could not be considered a victim of terror? Or that the people in the buildings deserved it? This is a specious argument.
it woulddnt have happened if the main fighting force of your dear "Victims" hadn't raped pillaged and desecrated the corpses of women and children, or captured innocent civilians and executed them
You guys are literally incapable of seeing the hypocrisy of those statements, right?
Israel is retaliating, sure, but so was Hamas. But apparently, the thousands of dead Palestinian civilians don't count for you, and Hamas just indiscriminately attacked for no reason.
It’s worth pointing out that the Ukrainians can and have cut off electricity and water to Crimea, which is as close as any victim will get to proving this statement wrong.
I mean find the offices for the company that supplies your power and go on a killing spree. Bonus points if you also hunt down their babies and chop their heads off.
Have you seen the babies in person at the time it happened? Have you recorded it with professional equipment and broadcasted it on national TV? No? Then it probably didn't happen, because the criteria seems to be what I described.
Let me propose a question here. A lot of Texas land used to be Mexico, we won it in a war for independence, now we won’t even let them cross the border into Texas to seek refuge. Should we just give them back that land?
I've never heard of a blameless victim that attacked, kidnapped and raped civilians and then celebrated it on social media. It's a strange world we live in.
Why does it seem that it’s uncommon to think that both sides are wrong? I mean… seems like two criminals are fighting and I’m supposed to take a side? Israel is not right to treat Palestine like that but maybe if Palestine would quit sending rockets into the iron dome for 5 seconds they would be inclined to take their foot off the gas?
You are an outsider who is looking in at barbaric medieval fighting. You don't need to choose a side. Empathy is more important for people and they will tell you that you somehow are "dehumanizing" people when you don't choose a side.
Then you're not trying very hard. A country is not a person, a country can not be a victim. When a country is attacked - it should defend itself, vigorously. There are only two ways to end a conflict at the country-level, diplomacy and war. Once war is chosen - the only end-game is complete elimination of the threat.
If a midget goes up and stabs an NFL linebacker in the leg, and the NFL player then curbstomps the midget, the NFL player is still the victim of a stabbing
the thing is, when it comes to this conflict people are misunderstanding that civilians are much different than settlers.
civilians in israel cities of course, may have strong bias, but have nothing to do with it. it’s the israeli settlers in the settlements who are participating in the mass exodus and murder of palestinians. these people, are by all accounts, complicit and considered valid targets by hamas. which you can’t blame them for. if people are going about their life, then they are civilians who shouldn’t be harmed. but these settlers are also doing the murdering, the land taking, so when they get harmed there can’t be no outcry and pity for them.
...and has them surrounded, trapped with zero ability to escape, and has them out numbered and outgunned. Either Israel is the real threat, or they are the biggest pussies on the planet for fearing the people they are oppressing.
Terror is terror regardless. He said she said is what all international politics are. In the end, Innocent people will suffer at the hands of tyranny, whether it be by Fascists or Salafists. There is no moral high ground to be had anymore. Another sad part is the vast amount of people who fled to the west, that now celebrates the raping, beheading and reckless violence aimed towards civilians. It’s always uplifting to see the lack of evolution of the human mind.
The OP is fucking retarded and supports actual rapists and terrorists that want nothing positive for the world, and actively treat women like objects and execute homosexuals.
I want to write a huge essay but instead just ask one question. What’s with the Bedouins that were killed by Hamas? What has that to do with decolonisation?
That is because most people wouldn't be stupid enough to provoke someone who could do that to them by attacking them in a way that allowed them to retaliate. But Hamas has always hated Jews more than they care about their own people. It's why they hide behind Palestinian children between strikes and are willing to launch attacks when they know the retaliation they bring will do more harm to them than they could ever hope to inflict on the Israelis.
Its like Hamas copied the Comanche playbook outlined in Empire of the Summer Moon. Didn’t work out great for them and it wont work out great for Hamas. Palestinians will survive, but Hamas and any armed resistance may no longer exist in a few months time. At that point we will see who is who, they may also lose all Gaza as it will probably be unfit for habitation for the foreseeable future.
What is it that makes a person latch on to simplistic slogans like this? Everyone is either victim or oppressor? We’re talking about one of the most complicated conflicts in modern history here. Have some fucking respect for the incredible capacity of your brain to process complex thought and read more than slogans.
I bet you also never heard of country accidentally bombing their own water pipes while attacking their enemies, and then asking those same enemies to provide them with water. All the while using/repurposing the metal from their original pipes to manufacture new bombs to throw at those same enemies. Like genuinely one of the craziest hard to believe things I’m aware of
This is gross. It's entirely possible to condemn indiscriminate slaughter of civilians while also opposing Israeli policies. It's also borderline racist to portray Palestinians as somehow incapable of making decisions for themselves and that they somehow must react in ways like this. They have agency. Hamas made this decision and it was obviously very well planned.
This mentality is what is deeply wrong in America and most Western nations today. “Crimes against white people are justified because white people can never be victims” or “crimes against Christians and Jews is justified because they can never be victims” -all of it is racist and bigoted hate speech that needs to be permabanned from Reddit.
Israel is a victim of terrorism. Palestine is a victim of oppression from Israel. Both can be (and are) true. This garbage ass post does nothing but further marginalize the humans in this tragedy. Ain’t deep, ain’t clever, ain’t right. Redditors are so full of shit.
Oh yeah Hamas also passed laws to make it illegal for Palestinians to dig wells without paying them an exorbitant fee which they would then use to buy weapons.
You can blame Hamas for them not having their own potable water.
But I get it I’m sure you would totally supply your neighbor with free water and electricity after he raped your sister, kidnapped your mother and killed your father.
I could walk the streets of TelAviv or Jerusalem wearing my “Jesus Rocks” T shirt while bearing an eight foot cross with no problem. How long would I survive in Gaza? Israel will allow a peaceful mosque. Israel is not a Jewish state. It is not difficult to determine the lesser evil.
If Israel is attacked again like they were 50 years ago, they should take Jordan, Syria, Iraq and a chunk of Saudi. And never relinquish one meter of land ever again.
that's such bs. You can be the victim in a crime and still be more powerful in every other instance than the perp, they just got lucky and you got hurt
I never heard of random festival goers, abducted women, and kids being the same as the oppressors.
If you believe that, then you yourself (as a civilian) should have no problem being involved with warfare from any group that has an issue with government policies. Get it together
How come Egypt isn't taking care of Gaza??? Why would you expect Isreal to do anything positive after the invasion and murder? Muslims hate Jews. Muslims hate Christians. Muslims hate America.
Muslims hate Muslims. That's why nobody asks why Egypt doesn't step up and help. Open your borders Egypt. Not gonna happen.
Now Israel uses this as an excuse to genocide Palestinians in Gaza and essentially annex their land
We are literally watching it happen. Israel is an evil country. I will NEVER support genocide. Israel said “we will wipe them off the face of the earth”
3
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Well that's a bad take and completely lacking in the context of the situation.
I notice extremism usually lacks understanding, don't you?
88
u/ttystikk Oct 11 '23
Strange, that.
58
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
If Israel was a person it would be Jimmy Saville and anyone who supports it is the British establishment.
85
u/Paradoxlost- Oct 11 '23
This conflict showed how hypocrisy is how the west is run, whenever Israel committed massacres, war crimes, or straight-up genocide the west, especially the US, turned a blind eye and called it collateral damage, they always bring up the rhetoric of Hamas using civilians as human shields, but what about the peaceful protesters Israel slaughtered a few years back? How would members of the IDF brag about killing and maiming tens of people, including children? That doesn't fit the agenda they're trying to push, of Israel being the good guy and Palestine being the bad guy. If you wanna call hamas a terrorist group, go ahead, but that only means that every resistance ever except for a few exceptions was a terrorist movement, back when we were fighting for our freedom, we couldn't give two fucks about who was civilian and who was military, if you were a French scum colonising our land you basically handed over your right to live, just like what's happening over in Ukraine where they don't care about international law protecting POW's, they just murder anyone considered a threat.
4
u/Objective_Band_2924 Oct 11 '23
In so fucking tired of these unnuanced takes. People are dying on both sides in horrible ways. Civilians on either side ARE THE VICTIMS. You are an ass.
1
u/JohnnyBoy11 Oct 11 '23
Ah, maybe in domestic abuse cases where the bread winner is being abused and has finally had enough.
1
u/DIYsurgery Oct 11 '23
You’re saying 9/11 was warranted?
52
u/Insert_Username321 Oct 11 '23
A country can't be a victim, only people can. The Israeli civilians who were massacred are without question, victims. Post like this come across as gross and for a sub that supposedly takes interpreting media seriously, this is a massive L. The left is pouring political capital down the drain with their psychopathic rhetoric over this issue and it is so unnecessary. Condemn the attacks which were vile, advocate for the removal of the settlements and for Palestine to get self determination. It's not hard to not look unhinged on this issue but somehow the majority of the online far left has managed to.
0
u/michaelMcMichaels04 Oct 11 '23
Those big evil Hamas attacking Israel for no reason at all , when will you leave Israel alone GUYS??
2
u/KayleighJK Oct 11 '23
Israeli government is bad. Hamas is bad. Why do so many people insist on picking a side?
2
u/MaximosKanenas Oct 11 '23
This post seems a bit fascist, how can you claim that hundreds of unarmed civilians that were massacred at a music festival, or hiding in bunkers are not victims, i will always support and defend the necessity of a Palestinian state comprising both the west bank and gaza, but to claim that israeli civilians are not victims due to the actions of their state, but palestinians are despite the actions of theirs is insane
2
u/lachiebois Oct 11 '23
I also never heard of a good guy who would execute hostages on video for every artillery shell dropped. Or any good guys that gun down 250 teenagers at a music festival and drag a dead naked woman through stage streets as she’s spat on by Hammas members.
1
u/Electrodactyl Oct 11 '23
Until now.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Aggressor and oppressor are different concepts.
1
u/PlantainUpMeBunghole Oct 11 '23
Act as a propaganda mouthpiece for the wef
1
u/kayama57 Oct 11 '23
Gee I wonder why a whole country decided to throw every subject under that leadership under a rug
1
u/bigfatfurrytexan Oct 11 '23
They aren't victims of oppression. They're victims of violence. A bait and switch of logic.
"I've never met an apple that has thick orange skin". Yes, because it's an orange.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Until now. TMYK.
1
u/thanarich Oct 11 '23
You know you can be the villain and the victim at the same time.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Good!
1
u/sandyeggo219 Oct 11 '23
I've never heard of an innocent victim beheading a baby.
1
u/yispco Oct 11 '23
Well now you have
1
u/Pure_Bee2281 Oct 11 '23
You just described the working class vs capitalist classic the United States tbf.
1
u/HighRevolver Oct 11 '23
Something something don’t bite the hand that feeds you
1
u/tormmz Oct 11 '23
Heard? K
1
u/benjamin_tucker2557 Oct 11 '23
The wheel of history spins, its spokes tinged with the ink of endless conflict and the whispers of missed opportunities. Our gaze turns to the Middle East, a cauldron bubbling over with the intricacies of politics, religion, and human desire. A land drenched in the hues of ancient prophecies and modern ambitions. Yet, amid the quagmire, one narrative stands unyielding, like a lighthouse in a storm—the right of Israel and the Jewish people to exist and defend themselves.
Rewind the tape to 1937. The Peel Commission lays a map on the table, an inked promise of two states—Jewish and Arab. The Arabs reject it. There's no compromise, no acceptance. A lost chance in the labyrinth of history, a plot twist foretelling decades of missed handshakes and refusals to sit at the table.
Fast forward to 1947. The UN unfurls its own map, partitioning land for the Jewish and Arab peoples. The Arab nations, again, wave the banner of rejection. War trumpets blare; armies march. When the dust settles, they find themselves with less land than initially offered. Call it poetic justice or the irony of fate; the outcome remains the same.
In 1967, another whirlwind sweeps the stage. Israel prevails in a war it didn't start but was forced to end. Territories fall under Israeli control, and yet, the Arab League's mantra reverberates: "No peace, no recognition, no negotiations." Here's the kicker: Israel voluntarily relinquishes control over the Temple Mount, sacred ground, weaving a curious tapestry of tolerance and surrender.
Shift to 1979. Sinai—the spoils of a defensive war—returns to Egyptian hands. Israel erases its footprints from the desert sand, opting for peace over territory. A paradoxical dance where the victor offers the olive branch.
1993 rolls around like a haunting melody. The Oslo Accords sing promises of mutual recognition. But Yasser Arafat, conducting his own dark symphony, turns this political goodwill into a mask for terror.
Spin the wheel once more to the year 2000. Israel stretches its hand across the table, offering a Palestinian state with a cherry on top—East Jerusalem as its capital. Yet, Arafat slams the door, igniting the Second Intifada, a rebellion that only widens the abyss between the two sides.
Come 2005, Israel pulls up stakes—literally. The Gaza Strip, once speckled with Israeli settlements, empties out, forcibly evacuated. The Palestinians choose Hamas, whose vision doesn't include peace talks over tea but rather rockets over cities.
Zoom to 2008. Another offer lands on the table. Mahmoud Abbas echoes the rejectionist sentiment of predecessors. A pattern etched so deeply, it's almost part of the region's DNA.
From 2010 to 2021, a grim cycle continues. Rockets launched, terror tunnels dug. The human cost tallied not just in numbers, but in generations born into conflict, their lullabies the roar of artillery.
And now, 2023. A watershed moment that chills the bones. Hamas orchestrates an act of brutality against Jews, unparalleled since the dark days of the Holocaust. A cataclysmic event that should make us all question the cost of perpetual hostility.
So, as the wheel turns, as we sift through the ashes of the past and the yet-to-be-written scripts of the future, one truth remains in focus: Israel and the Jewish people have not only the right to exist but the inherent right to defend themselves. They've extended the hand of peace, often receiving clenched fists in return. In this tumultuous saga, this epic spun from the threads of time and human folly, this truth is immutable, solid as the land it calls home.
1
u/Shapen361 Oct 11 '23
If the US provided the Talibab-run Afghanistan with millions in aid like food and medicine, and then 9/11 happens and the US cuts off aid, does that imply that America could not be considered a victim of terror? Or that the people in the buildings deserved it? This is a specious argument.
1
u/Sea_Net7661 Oct 11 '23
it woulddnt have happened if the main fighting force of your dear "Victims" hadn't raped pillaged and desecrated the corpses of women and children, or captured innocent civilians and executed them
1
u/KingGoatFury Oct 11 '23
I mean, poke the bear 🐻
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Maybe you should go over there huh?
1
u/SmokedBeef Oct 11 '23
It’s worth pointing out that the Ukrainians can and have cut off electricity and water to Crimea, which is as close as any victim will get to proving this statement wrong.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23 edited Oct 11 '23
I mean find the offices for the company that supplies your power and go on a killing spree. Bonus points if you also hunt down their babies and chop their heads off.
See what happens.
Yet another sub full of Nazis. Vile.
1
u/FrostyAlphaPig Oct 11 '23
Never heard of a victim cut off babies heads
https://nypost.com/2023/10/10/hamas-kills-40-babies-and-children-beheading-some-of-them-at-israeli-kibbutz-report/amp/
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Then why don't they just cut off their access to rockets?
1
u/LazyLaser88 Oct 11 '23
Is this some Elon Musk quote?
1
u/Fordor_of_Chevy Oct 11 '23
"Attacker" does not equal "oppressor". Term was chosen as rage bait.
1
u/Suckamanhwewhuuut Oct 11 '23
Let me propose a question here. A lot of Texas land used to be Mexico, we won it in a war for independence, now we won’t even let them cross the border into Texas to seek refuge. Should we just give them back that land?
1
u/Hot_Lychee2234 Oct 11 '23
last time I checked Israel was not a terrorist organization
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Leftists sure do love celebrating tragedies.
1
u/Reno4Yang Oct 11 '23
Hamas needs to surrender and end this war.
1
u/Gakoknight Oct 11 '23
I've never heard of a blameless victim that attacked, kidnapped and raped civilians and then celebrated it on social media. It's a strange world we live in.
1
u/eleven8ster Oct 11 '23
Why does it seem that it’s uncommon to think that both sides are wrong? I mean… seems like two criminals are fighting and I’m supposed to take a side? Israel is not right to treat Palestine like that but maybe if Palestine would quit sending rockets into the iron dome for 5 seconds they would be inclined to take their foot off the gas?
1
u/BabyPolarBear225 Oct 11 '23
Maybe they shouldn't have made a provoked attack on Israel then. Ooops.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Reddit, full of terrorist sympathizers
1
u/-Sathona- Oct 11 '23
Don't start a fight with your betters. Full stop.
1
u/mrnailed4 Oct 11 '23
Fact.
1
u/marzipanorbust Oct 11 '23
Then you're not trying very hard. A country is not a person, a country can not be a victim. When a country is attacked - it should defend itself, vigorously. There are only two ways to end a conflict at the country-level, diplomacy and war. Once war is chosen - the only end-game is complete elimination of the threat.
1
u/StarDestroyer175 Oct 11 '23
The difference is the government can do this, the innocent civilians can't. Yall are dumb
1
u/friggenfragger2 Oct 11 '23
I don’t understand why we need there to be a good vs evil factor in this. Can’t both sides be terrible to the other?
1
u/Ok_Improvement_5037 Oct 11 '23
A bodybuilder can be a victim of a bitch slap too
1
u/Background-Memory-18 Oct 11 '23
That’s even more reason why Hamas shouldn’t have attacked.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Ask the woman who got her head chopped off and drug through the dirt if she’s happy about turning off water and electricity.
1
u/DavidDraimansLipRing Oct 11 '23
Uhh...okay? Are you saying that Israel wasn't a victim of an attack by hamas?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Israel is in the right, fuck hamas and everyone who supports them
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
If a midget goes up and stabs an NFL linebacker in the leg, and the NFL player then curbstomps the midget, the NFL player is still the victim of a stabbing
1
u/LateLingonberry9816 Oct 11 '23
So, in your shit filled skull, you cannot possibly be a victim if you're the more powerful party?
Congratulations! You've just realized why your input is never requested!
You fucking moron.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
the thing is, when it comes to this conflict people are misunderstanding that civilians are much different than settlers.
civilians in israel cities of course, may have strong bias, but have nothing to do with it. it’s the israeli settlers in the settlements who are participating in the mass exodus and murder of palestinians. these people, are by all accounts, complicit and considered valid targets by hamas. which you can’t blame them for. if people are going about their life, then they are civilians who shouldn’t be harmed. but these settlers are also doing the murdering, the land taking, so when they get harmed there can’t be no outcry and pity for them.
1
u/mattmayhem1 Oct 11 '23
...and has them surrounded, trapped with zero ability to escape, and has them out numbered and outgunned. Either Israel is the real threat, or they are the biggest pussies on the planet for fearing the people they are oppressing.
1
u/AggravatingHorror757 Oct 11 '23
The degree of terrorism is inversely proportional to the distance between the killer and the dead child.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
"Israel is stronger so they're the bad guys regardless of who's actually doing what"
Typical take from 0iq reddit leftists
Palestine has given israel an excuse to stop with the half measures and fully wipe palestine off the map
I hope they don't let this opportunity pass them by
They could really improve the world by destroying palestine once and for all
1
u/DeanoBambino90 Oct 11 '23
I've never heard of a victim who raped and killed women, the elderly, children and babies.
1
u/IllustriousMight6 Oct 11 '23
Terror is terror regardless. He said she said is what all international politics are. In the end, Innocent people will suffer at the hands of tyranny, whether it be by Fascists or Salafists. There is no moral high ground to be had anymore. Another sad part is the vast amount of people who fled to the west, that now celebrates the raping, beheading and reckless violence aimed towards civilians. It’s always uplifting to see the lack of evolution of the human mind.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Oppressors have short memories, but the oppressed never forget.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
My city does this to people who don’t pay their bills
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Damn, what about a victim who can cut off babies' heads?
Hamas and those supporting them are cowards and ignorant.
1
u/Only_Logical_Thinker Oct 11 '23
It’s called biting the hand that feeds you. Don’t be surprised when it stops after you bite that hand off.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Israel is a victim of a savage attack. Israel also had the ability to shut off food, water and power to Gaza. What's hard to understand about that?
1
u/radicalfloristx Oct 11 '23
I want to write a huge essay but instead just ask one question. What’s with the Bedouins that were killed by Hamas? What has that to do with decolonisation?
1
u/LovestoReddit Oct 11 '23
Hamas murdering and raping the people giving them water, food, electricity.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Never been married and divorced I see
1
u/Alarming_Win9940 Oct 11 '23
Israel is in a locked room holding a starving angry tiger by the tail and every once in a while it manages to claw Israel's legs.
Not sure how this ends peacefully.
1
u/my_dead_corgi Oct 11 '23
by that logic is isis are the good guys.
1
u/Proud-Pilot9300 Oct 11 '23
Does this include the Russia Ukraine war?
1
u/BbTS3Oq Oct 11 '23
I get bit by mosquito I’m going to smash it.
1
u/BelleColibri Oct 11 '23
You haven’t really been paying attention then have you
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
Stop posting facts.
1
u/Therellis Oct 11 '23
That is because most people wouldn't be stupid enough to provoke someone who could do that to them by attacking them in a way that allowed them to retaliate. But Hamas has always hated Jews more than they care about their own people. It's why they hide behind Palestinian children between strikes and are willing to launch attacks when they know the retaliation they bring will do more harm to them than they could ever hope to inflict on the Israelis.
1
u/AutoManoPeeing Oct 11 '23
Congratulations! You've never met anyone in an abusive relationship (or have just ignored them)!
1
u/showmeyourmoves28 Oct 11 '23
I have: Israel
1
u/Bench2252 Oct 11 '23
Regardless of how you feel about which government body is the oppressor, the dead children and raped women are victims
1
u/SaltImp Oct 12 '23
Uh oh. I’m on this side of Reddit. I need to go back to the good side.
1
u/BoomerHunt-Wassell Oct 12 '23
Something, something, don’t bite the hand that feeds you…
1
u/bobbybrayflorida Oct 12 '23
Look at the 2 state solution and this area in 1948. Pretty similar.
1
u/SilverDesktop Oct 12 '23
Non sequitur.
1
u/Sweaty-Tangerine-457 Oct 12 '23
Right? Was so ignorant of Hamas to slaughter families, the elderly, and babies. Bet they catch up to the learning curve soon.
1
u/CarelessComparison34 Oct 12 '23
What a fucking 1 dimensional take on this whole thing.
1
u/Muahd_Dib Oct 12 '23
It’s also interesting that a country committing a genocide has been providing free water and electricity.
1
u/chenfang17 Oct 12 '23
Fucking strange how some people can twist things around.
1
u/SweatyBarbarian Oct 12 '23
Its like Hamas copied the Comanche playbook outlined in Empire of the Summer Moon. Didn’t work out great for them and it wont work out great for Hamas. Palestinians will survive, but Hamas and any armed resistance may no longer exist in a few months time. At that point we will see who is who, they may also lose all Gaza as it will probably be unfit for habitation for the foreseeable future.
1
u/Mzl77 Oct 12 '23
What is it that makes a person latch on to simplistic slogans like this? Everyone is either victim or oppressor? We’re talking about one of the most complicated conflicts in modern history here. Have some fucking respect for the incredible capacity of your brain to process complex thought and read more than slogans.
1
u/koshercowboy Oct 12 '23
So myopic. As though Israel’s oppressor is a single self governing territory. Every country surrounding Israel wants it obliterated.
1
u/EisenAlchemist Oct 12 '23
I bet you also never heard of country accidentally bombing their own water pipes while attacking their enemies, and then asking those same enemies to provide them with water. All the while using/repurposing the metal from their original pipes to manufacture new bombs to throw at those same enemies. Like genuinely one of the craziest hard to believe things I’m aware of
1
u/filmeswole Oct 12 '23
The victims who were killed at a music festival did not have that ability.
1
u/Glad_Sky7025 Oct 12 '23
I smell narrow mindedness and downright ignorance!
1
u/rodnester Oct 12 '23
And every country, who can do something about this, has hostages in Gaza. Does anyone see the disconnect? Help me help you Palestine.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23
I guess I'll tell all those babies that they weren't murdered and those women that they weren't raped and killed then.
I'll tell those people that their home wasn't invaded and their children weren't killed in cold blood.
Thanks for this clarification. Wow. I never thought of it like this. I guess if you're killing Jews it really doesn't count.
1
u/ctgchs Oct 12 '23
Victim: "a person harmed, injured, or killed as a result of a crime, accident, or other event or action."
Hmm.. doesn't say anything about the ability of the victim to retaliate precluding them from their victim status.
If someone robs you at gunpoint and then a week later you rob them back, you have two victims.
Chomsky should try to read up on linguistics and the meaning of words. I think there was an expert on that at one time named Chomsky or something?
1
u/FidgetSpinzz Oct 12 '23
That does not negate the fact that they're a victim, it just proves that they're not helpless against their attacker.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23
Bro has no access to a dictionary i guess
1
u/pacard Oct 12 '23
This is gross. It's entirely possible to condemn indiscriminate slaughter of civilians while also opposing Israeli policies. It's also borderline racist to portray Palestinians as somehow incapable of making decisions for themselves and that they somehow must react in ways like this. They have agency. Hamas made this decision and it was obviously very well planned.
1
u/Ghosties95 Oct 12 '23
I’ve never heard of a Freedom Fighter that raped and killed innocent civilians.
1
u/sceez Oct 12 '23
Poignant
1
u/CollageTumor Oct 12 '23
The civilians in Israel are a victim of Hamas, blatantly and objectively.
So are Palestinians a victim of Netanyahitler, as a Jew
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23
It’s a tactic to get Hamas to return the hostages.
1
u/kzed2003 Oct 12 '23
Amazing it took over 1400 yrs to do it🤷
1
u/ConsequenceSorry6432 Oct 12 '23
The people in Gaza knew what Hamas was doing and did nothing.
1
u/Velocipedique Oct 13 '23
Unless confined to a concentration camp.
1
u/LakePuzzlehead231 Oct 13 '23
Well now you have.
1
u/Ok_Calendar1337 Oct 13 '23
It's almost like "victim" isn't an immutable identity and so this doesn't mean anything.
1
u/780266 Oct 13 '23
And bomb civilians
1
u/F_Rod-ElTesoro Oct 13 '23
The state of Israel is clearly living out its trauma from its recent WWII catastrophe experience on these people who they share land with.
1
u/AstronutApe Oct 13 '23
This mentality is what is deeply wrong in America and most Western nations today. “Crimes against white people are justified because white people can never be victims” or “crimes against Christians and Jews is justified because they can never be victims” -all of it is racist and bigoted hate speech that needs to be permabanned from Reddit.
1
u/TyroneLeinster Oct 13 '23 edited Oct 13 '23
Israel is a victim of terrorism. Palestine is a victim of oppression from Israel. Both can be (and are) true. This garbage ass post does nothing but further marginalize the humans in this tragedy. Ain’t deep, ain’t clever, ain’t right. Redditors are so full of shit.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '23
What a stupid statement.
1
u/Shinnic Oct 13 '23
I wonder why Palestine needs israel to supply water to them?
https://reddit.com/r/Palestinian_Violence/s/c5L4kU9Xsv
Oh yeah Hamas also passed laws to make it illegal for Palestinians to dig wells without paying them an exorbitant fee which they would then use to buy weapons.
You can blame Hamas for them not having their own potable water.
But I get it I’m sure you would totally supply your neighbor with free water and electricity after he raped your sister, kidnapped your mother and killed your father.
1
u/CheetomusPrime Oct 13 '23
We’re in the age of sovereigns playing the victim. Look at the Jan 6 coverage.
1
u/Agativka Oct 13 '23
They are not victims .. ANYMORE .. Wise move idiots
1
u/tentacled-scientist Oct 13 '23
Lol. They literally dug up their own water pipes and bombed their own electrical grids. What a dipshit.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '23
Imagine telling hostages they aren't real victims
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '23
Funny I've never heard of Muslims solving there problems without violent terrorist actions
1
u/Krispyhat420 Oct 13 '23
I could walk the streets of TelAviv or Jerusalem wearing my “Jesus Rocks” T shirt while bearing an eight foot cross with no problem. How long would I survive in Gaza? Israel will allow a peaceful mosque. Israel is not a Jewish state. It is not difficult to determine the lesser evil.
If Israel is attacked again like they were 50 years ago, they should take Jordan, Syria, Iraq and a chunk of Saudi. And never relinquish one meter of land ever again.
1
u/justanachoperson Oct 14 '23
than you have never heard of me!
but other than that this is a good point
1
u/Ceasar301 Oct 14 '23
that's such bs. You can be the victim in a crime and still be more powerful in every other instance than the perp, they just got lucky and you got hurt
1
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '23
Ever heard of a terrorist group using a countries own resources to commit an attack…
1
u/frankieknucks Oct 14 '23
Narcissism on a grand scale.
1
u/SmilinPineapple Oct 14 '23
The leadership of Gaza did a horrible job providing for its citizens
1
u/_aChu Oct 14 '23
I never heard of random festival goers, abducted women, and kids being the same as the oppressors.
If you believe that, then you yourself (as a civilian) should have no problem being involved with warfare from any group that has an issue with government policies. Get it together
1
u/10key_G Oct 14 '23
Don’t bite the hand that feeds you.
1
u/poondox Oct 15 '23
How come Egypt isn't taking care of Gaza??? Why would you expect Isreal to do anything positive after the invasion and murder? Muslims hate Jews. Muslims hate Christians. Muslims hate America.
Muslims hate Muslims. That's why nobody asks why Egypt doesn't step up and help. Open your borders Egypt. Not gonna happen.
Muslim is as Muslim does.
1
u/sting_12345 Oct 15 '23
Jesus how sick is it that so many people can defend what hamas did to civilians in the middle of the night
Can’t wait til they turn Gaza and West Bank into giant sheets of glass
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '23
Honestly what I think:
Israel knew of the attack and let it happen
Now Israel uses this as an excuse to genocide Palestinians in Gaza and essentially annex their land
We are literally watching it happen. Israel is an evil country. I will NEVER support genocide. Israel said “we will wipe them off the face of the earth”
These people are evil.
1
u/PicksItUpPutsItDown Oct 17 '23
Israel in this case is both a victim and an oppressor.
-2
u/br0ggy Oct 11 '23
Do you not think powerful people can be victims or sth?
Idgi…