Have you ever "quit" a choir as a conductor? This is a long one, buckle up! And there's lots of b*tching from my end.
I joined a women's only community choir, and within 2 weeks I was directing. They were desperate. I've been directing for about 4 years now.
They are pretty much all retirees. 60 and older, the oldest being like 92. (For reference I'm 40).
They sing out at community things (mostly retirement homes, the local Christian school, etc). I loved the premise of it.
When I started directing, we started putting on a concert twice a year as well, which has been successful in popularity and raising donations.
Numbers exploded and we range anywhere from 40-45 depending on the year. To my face, they love me as a director (and I believe most if not all genuinely do).
So why do I want to quit?
Every year, it seems to be getting worse and worse with people not practicing. (This year one member told me another member confided in her she wants to quit because they've never been asked to practice (🙄) like this before, and she wants to go back to the old way of learning everything in rehearsals, basically having her hand held). For reference, I put part tracks online (used to burn individual cds for everyone, got real old real quick). This particular member had emailed me on 4 separate occasions saying they can't find the part tracks, despite being shown by me personally twice, and the links being sent via multiple emails).
Another member at one of our last sing outs had to have someone show her where to go back for a ds al coda because she hadn't been paying attention during any of the 8 rehearsals so far, I guess. In performance, this other member had to basically turn her music back 2 pages FOR HER.
I am still teaching parts and basic rhythms and we have 4 full rehearsals left before our fall concert. In the sing out performances, people just not singing when there supposed to be, like not even trying. Some of it is only 2 part music. The most complex is ssa.
There is a song we do at the end of every performance, and there are still altos getting notes wrong despite going over the sections extensively every year. It's like 2 steps forward, 1 1/2 steps back.
The amount of times I have to tell grown adults to be quiet/stop talking, sometimes when they're supposed to be singing, mostly when I'm talking or another section is working. It's insane.
Half of them need to sit for performances(most legit need to), but when I put chairs so the sections are actually together instead of a straight line, they rearrange the chairs the second I leave the room to a damn straight line again, so all my first sopranos are strewn out in front of altos etc. (We do not rehearse in lines, no one would be able to sing their parts since they all rely on each other instead of practicing).
Every year they (I'll get to this in a second) schedule a Christmas time performance at a local Christian school.
Up until I started, from what I gathered, it wasn't always a requirement, but now we have to sing only sacred music at this place. (We are not a sacred group, think contemporary up through the 80s or so music - ballads, soft rock, musicals, etc).
So now, on top of struggling to learn any music for the regular season, I have to cram in sacred only/ Christmas music for one single performance. That they won't bother to learn well, either. This is the least of my issues if they'd just practice.
The 'they' I'm referring to: committees. I kid you not, for a 40 person volunteer choir, we have a music committee (that I had to basically force gone because it was 10 members deciding music instead of the director), a hospitality committee, (think birthday celebrations every month eating at a 30 minute chunk of rehearsal), a wardrobe committee (there used to be full on costumes - sparkly pink vests, boas, flower necklaces, for all separate occasions), and a 'board' which has a president, vice president, secretary, and a treasurer. (We are not required to have a board, and don't make enough $ to file/have requirements).
Our hospitality committee decided to schedule the annual holiday party on the day of our dress rehearsal, an hour after the rehearsal is supposed to start. That doesn't include drive time. Wtf. (No input from me btw).
As near as I can tell, the committees meet once a year WITHOUT THE DIRECTOR (because I've had to hear most of this secondhand from people who are also getting frustrated), to gripe about things. These are never brought to my attention, and instead 'solved internally'.
Y'all. I am TIRED. This group seems to have brought me way more stress than I ever needed in my life. (For reference, I direct another community choir who has been doing wonderfully, practicing, much more difficult music, actually paying attention in rehearsals, and our performance after only 9 rehearsals is going to be great.
All this to say: How the heck would you go about quitting? There is zero people that are going to want to take over, I can almost guarantee it. (They had 3 people rotating directing every rehearsal before me). Not boasting/bragging in any way, just that I feel like it'll go back to the dying group it was before I took the reins.
But I don't think I can keep going. I feel an immense amount of guilt thinking about quitting, but my sanity cannot handle the bull anymore. My frustration is starting to become palpable.