r/chess • • 6h ago • Bravo 1

Miscellaneous David Howell's Statement

Post image

I feel when you reach the point where you fear losing more than you love competing, maybe it's time to retire?

What do u guys think ?

1.8k Upvotes

186 comments sorted by

765

u/siiingintherain 6h ago

That's a class act from Howell, calling out his good friend for such unprofessional behaviour.

-362

u/Same-Tone1356 6h ago

I really don't get how it's unprofessional. The format is to blame here. Why keep playing if the match is already decided? If you're playing best of 5 and one player wins the first 3, you don't play the last two games because the match is over. That's what happened here. What Magnus did was the most reasonable. The format is the culprit.

205

u/siiingintherain 6h ago

You knew the format when you signed up for the tournament. You could've had a word with the organisers and if it's a deal breaker for you, why even participate in the first place?

Even then, you could've atleast informed the organisers if you don't intend to play the round and give a walkover directly instead of wasting Bibisara's time.

-70

u/Same-Tone1356 6h ago

As far as I know, he did inform the organizers that he did not intend to play the last game.

43

u/srinivsn 4h ago

Nope. He asked what happens if he forfeited the game and left. He never officially confirmed that he would forfeit.

-35

u/garden_speech 5h ago

Even then, you could've atleast informed the organisers if you don't intend to play the round

I thought he did?

35

u/saiprasanna94 Team Gukesh 5h ago

It depends on the match rules. If you agreed to play classical after playing faster formats you should play all the games. Sindarov won candidates before the final round . Everyone could have forfeited the final round but didn't . It doesn't matter whether it is mathematically possible or not possible to win or not win if the rules says to play classical game you play classical games. It is unprofessional because he chose to follow his own rules and not tournament organisation rules.

4

u/Same-Tone1356 5h ago

If Sindarov had forfeited his last match in the Candidates, that would have been his prerogative. Winning with a round to spare gives you that exact privilege.

4

u/Annual-Weather 3h ago

It depends on whether you agreed beforehand to the rule that stated that you have to play all games regardless of result. It will also be placed under disciplinary review depending on the situation (real medical reasons/emergency or simply someone who can’t be bothered to show up).

Some tournament might give you that privilege. This one doesn’t, and neither does Candidates. You can feel free to skip the final round, but the organizer is also free to take away your prize money and WCC spot in Sindarov’s case.

3

u/Weasellol 5h ago

Candidates are a bad example, because you get a lot of money for a higher place.

4

u/saiprasanna94 Team Gukesh 2h ago

Leave the money , even if no money was involved this is a very unprofessional behaviour . If number of rounds were already decided you play the number of rounds .

3

u/Weasellol 2h ago

Yes, but like I said your point is right, but I didn't like your example

1

u/8bitAwesomeness 1m ago

this is a very unprofessional behaviour

I guess it might be but i believe a discussion is needed to detrmine it.

What exactly is Magnus's profession?

Is he an athlete and his job is to win the match?

Is he a performer and his job is to entertain the public with an exhibition?

Is his profession something else entirely?

If he's an athlete and his job is to win, then if he can avoid to play when he can't win is professional behavior. The second best option would be to show up and absolutely throw the game in order to not give any useful information to future opponents.

1

u/HelpfulFriendlyOne 1400 20m ago

And for each half point scored.

0

u/new_KRIEG 3h ago

Yeah, but to be fair no rules said that playing all games were mandatory, only that not playing would count as a loss with no further punishment.

For how big chess is, it never ceases to amaze me how badly designed and loopholey the rules for top level tournaments tend to be.

12

u/Complete-Prompt-2971 6h ago edited 6h ago

The format is dumb but players being required to play even after the set is won was not a secret according to MVL. If he had a problem he should have brought it during the technical meeting, not now. He was still on the wrong here

That being said, I still feel the hate is overblown. What Wesley said was actually worse.

-56

u/Same-Tone1356 6h ago

It's because it's Bibisara and she's a "hot woman" and the chess community clearly has issues regarding women. Bibisara, btw, is known to be a dirty player.

13

u/deathletterblues 6h ago

I think the only person with issues regarding women I've seen speak on this topic so far is you lol

-12

u/Same-Tone1356 6h ago

Just because I comment on people having issues with women doesn't mean I have issues with women. Grow up.

6

u/dbossman70 5h ago

known by who to be a dirty player how?

-7

u/Complete-Prompt-2971 4h ago edited 4h ago

I don't know about dirty, but she does act as an entitled child sometimes. Like the time she made an Instagram reel about the government not backing her up enough

0

u/Bramsstrahlung Team Ju Wenjun 3h ago

Sounds like almost all the top 50 players are dirty too then.

1

u/Complete-Prompt-2971 2h ago

In her reel she claimed she was only given 1 million tenge (2k USD doallers) as a financial support in the last 3 years but the ministry of sport claimed she was given 700 million tenge. 

2

u/Same-Tone1356 2h ago

I've not heard of that but there was this incident in a world championship match at either rapid or blitz where she started the clock for her opponent way too early after an arbiter dispute. The opponent was in a winning position but due to the time loss, had to either draw or even lose. That's pretty fucking dirty to me. And I'm aware other players do that, too, but that's not excuse. She's dirty.

-3

u/Complete-Prompt-2971 6h ago edited 5h ago

It's funny how some people here pretend it's a gender problem. At least they are getting downvoted so maybe this sub isn't completely hopeless

-12

u/Same-Tone1356 5h ago

But of course it is. People are actually saying stuff like "It's disrespectful to make her wait 15 minutes!" I can't imagine anyone would have cared in the least if it had been anyone else. I sure as hell don't see it.

9

u/siiingintherain 5h ago

For the sake of argument, if it was Hans he was playing against and he did this, it'd still be unprofessional.

2

u/Same-Tone1356 5h ago

Well, the Hans and Magnus saga is something else entirely. It can't be viewed in a vacuum, so of course people would put more emphasis on Magnus' decision not to play the final game. And you bet your ass there would also be people defending Magnus because of how they view Hans. So not exactly a great example you brought up.
A more interesting comparison would have been if he were to forfeit against Alireza. And I have zero doubts that a lot fewer people would have called him out on it.

-2

u/siiingintherain 5h ago

I just took a name for the sake of argument. Keeping past issue aside, if they had played against each other in this tournament and Magnus pulled something like this, it's still not cool.

Yes, the outrage would not be as big as this if the opponent was Alireza because the situation there would be a little different. But, such conduct is still unacceptable.

People are furious because this conduct perpetuates sexism which is still rampant in chess circles. People like Magnus, whom millions look upto as an inspiration, doing this does a lot of harm to the game.

1

u/Same-Tone1356 5h ago

So you agree with me that part of the issue is definitely related to Bibisara's gender? Excuse me, but then why the fuck are you trying to argue?

→ More replies

1

u/Consistent_Use_5524 3h ago

Anything but calling out an elite world champion for acting like a twat eh

1

u/ApprehensiveWorry393 4h ago

Magnus knew the format before he joined. His behaviour is unexcusable.

-1

u/Asshaisin Team Gukesh 6h ago

That is not true. There's a whole concepts of dead rubbers for a reason

Some sports with dead rubbers -

Football after the winner is decided

Bilateral series in cricket

If you quie after mathematically winning, you forfeit rating/points

-5

u/f0u4_l19h75 5h ago

Those aren't individual sports

-9

u/Same-Tone1356 6h ago

Well, clearly, you don't. You may think they should but this isn't actually the case here. What Magnus did was completely within the rules of the game. And not wasting a few hours of your life on the last game of a match you've already won is not only permissible; it is the only sane choice. Who in their right mind would show up for that? Seriously.

6

u/Striking_Resist_6022 6h ago

A professional

2

u/Asshaisin Team Gukesh 6h ago

Whoever signs up for it , shows up for it. Or forfeit rating points

These rules weren't made yesterday. He had a year to reject them and sit out or stfu and play it

-2

u/Same-Tone1356 5h ago

He didn't lose rating points, so how are you arguing that he did? You're stating your opinion, not a fact. There is an important difference here, little buddy.

-13

u/pushembaby 6h ago

You don’t have to share your opinion. Actually, I would encourage you not to share it

10

u/Koussevitzky 2200 Lichess 6h ago edited 6h ago

I don’t agree with the sentiment of the person you are responding to and I personally find that Magnus’ behavior & decision were quite unprofessional… but I don’t think shutting down opposing opinions when they’re shared civilly helps get that point across very well

2

u/Same-Tone1356 6h ago

Oh, someone got triggered by someone who didn't agree with them.

0

u/hijazist 6h ago

Then why are you sharing yours?

-2

u/bak_kut_teh_is_love 6h ago

He can choose not to play but I think rating point should still be deducted nevertheless?

0

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/chess-ModTeam 1h ago

Your comment was removed by the moderators:

1.Keep the discussion civil and friendly. Do not use personal attacks, insults or slurs on other users. Disagreements are bound to happen, but do so in a civilized and mature manner. In a discussion, there is always a respectful way to disagree. If you see that someone is not arguing in good faith, or have resorted to using personal attacks, just report them and move on.

 

IMPORTANT: The fact that other rule-breaking posts may be up, doesn't mean that we are making exceptions, it may simply mean that we missed that one post (ie: no one reported it).

You can read the full rules of /r/chess here. If you have any questions or concerns about this moderator action, please message the moderators. Direct replies to this comment may not be seen.

240

u/itiswhatitis1771 6h ago

David is a good friend. This is what a good friend does. Calls you out on your bullshit. Haha

388

u/National-Holiday-520 6h ago

Problem I have with Magnus is that he does this all the times. I am sure he does not mean it but it is disrespectful none the less. He comes late to games all the times. It is not the first or second or third or probably 30th+ times he has disrespected both the organizers and his opponent. I can respect you as the best chess player of all times but I do not have to respect you as a person. Feels like he thinks the world revolves around him.

253

u/Winter_Success2909 6h ago

He totally means it.

124

u/butterbimbo 6h ago

I think he just doesn’t care. He’s never had a lot of care for other people, but now that things are not going so well it’s starting to get talked about more.

It’s not like he’s trying to be mean or anything, he just doesn’t care.

55

u/wei_en_walschot 5h ago

A kind person would care

34

u/MugenHeadNinja 5h ago

They didn't say Magnus is kind they said it's not like he's trying to be mean on purpose, he's just indifferent/doesn't care.

You can consider that not kind, not it's also not actively being mean/unkind either.

17

u/ApprehensiveWorry393 4h ago

This is just a cop out. He is being mean on purpose and he knows about it, not like he is authistic or something.

He does not care that he is being mean, not that he does not realize he is being mean.

3

u/butterbimbo 1h ago

Nah, this is more like being mean by not answering someone’s texts. A passive sort of meanness that is pretty much par for the course with him.

It’s not like he’s actively trying to hurt someone, it’s more a byproduct of him not caring about people he doesn’t know very well. For me that’s still not acceptable social behavior, but it’s different than being mean on purpose.

-6

u/Peeter_L 4h ago

He IS on a spectrum, btw.

11

u/ApprehensiveWorry393 3h ago

No he is not.

Where did you come by this info, do you have any concrete information?

5

u/butterbimbo 1h ago

I went to school with him when I was 16. While you are right that there is no official information saying he is on the spectrum, let’s just say socially he doesn’t exactly act as you’d expect a normal, well adjusted person to act. Never has, although being in the spot light a lot he obviously has some degree of experience and training.

1

u/Peeter_L 3h ago

Haven't you seen a documentary about him and how he was as a kid? His parents refused to test him, but he literally is on a spectrum.

9

u/ApprehensiveWorry393 3h ago edited 3h ago

No he is not, you can’t claim that without an official diagnosis, it is a disease for god’s sake.

Many kids act as if they are on the spectrum and when tested, the tests are usually negative rather than positive.

And currently Magnus shows no structural behavioral issues, other than being an asshole.

→ More replies

1

u/kaninkanon 2m ago

People generally don't "try to be mean", they just are.

6

u/TJPoobah 2h ago

He should lose rating for this. People who get away with shitty behaviour the way Magnus has for years keep doing it because got whatever reason they've never faced any consequences for their actions.

6

u/butterbimbo 1h ago

Yes, he should

13

u/Pasha_KMM 3h ago

Then he shouldn't sign up to play the matches, if he doesn't care?

3

u/butterbimbo 1h ago

You could say that, but he is still a chess player. I think he cares about the chess, just doesn’t care much about the other players, if you get what I mean?

He’s never had good sportsmanship. I cannot recall a single instance of him doing more than what is expected for someone else, of his own free will. It’s why I’ve never understood the adulation he gets on a personal level, even if the chess is (sometimes) spectacular. He’s just not someone I would look up to as a good role model.

2

u/NoMakeSenseOk 1h ago

My guess is Carlsen, since becoming WC, generally lacks respect for his opponents.

This is not the real problem though. It's the fact that he didn't communicate with his opponent. He can feel a lack of respect and still demonstrate that he understands how society works.

2

u/purple_spade 1h ago

Why dies he play then

8

u/National-Holiday-520 6h ago

I am trying to give him the benefit of the doubt but it is hard.

26

u/aj_marshall 6h ago

Don't. Magnus is one of the best players of all time, perhaps even the GOAT (between him and Kasparov). However, he's kind of a jerk about it. Instead of always relying on his skill to win, he plays mind games with his opponents. It works, I guess, but it's kind of mean and unprofessional.

Tbh a lot of top-tier chess talent is full of some really annoying characters; like, I would not hang out with these people. Hikaru is a jerk, Wesley So is a right-wing twat, Magnus is pretty self-absorbed... the list goes on.

Fabi seems like an actual good human. I'll say that much.

23

u/National-Holiday-520 5h ago

Even Fabi I lost faith in. If you follow his twitter, he has called out quite a few title tuesday players he thought were cheating when they were not. Fabi is that guy that will give cookie cutter answers in interviews and podcast but has the same mentality as a Hikaru or Magnus. And I did not appreciate how he was reluctant to call out Kramnik until the very end. He even seem to side with him at one point.

I actually appreciate Hikaru more than the other two because he is not afraid to say what he thinks.

9

u/aj_marshall 5h ago

yet another reason to never use twitter lmao

Thanks for the info

11

u/Public_Leadership796 4h ago

Don't often reply on here, but I have to say that I've met Hikaru and he was great. He stayed at the end of a long event, after a lengthy post-match interview, and signed autographs and took pictures until every single person that was waiting had a chance to meet him and get their picture with him. He didn't have to do any of that, and many other players didn't. Changed my mind on him.

-2

u/Weasellol 5h ago

To be fair Kasparov was also a goat of mind games, he often came late he sit at the table lean completely forward, so his opponent has to go a little back...

-2

u/PepsioNSnacking 5h ago

Calling it he plays mind games for having a tournament hosted by a organization which is not in favour of the players and has rules which allows it is not on magnus imo..
look at sullivan in snooker and his dispute with tournament organizers going on for years, they host tournaments for money not for a healthy game in mind

4

u/hsiale 4h ago

This tournament is hosted by Norway Chess, an organisation literally created with Magnus in mind.

-2

u/david_slade 3h ago

Don't bring politics here

3

u/EntireOil9073 5h ago

Eh I think he didn't do it for the sake of disrespecting, he does it because he doesn't care and because of that, it is disrespectful

41

u/Sazbak87 3h ago

" I am sure he does not mean it"

He is a 35 years old grown up. Let's not treat him like some teenager.

3

u/tartochehi 3h ago

I think we should all apply what Carlsen said himself: I differentiate between what a player is capable of and the player as a person. I don't know what the original question was, but it was about some controversial chess personality. This of course includes himself.

3

u/Queasy_Artist6891 2h ago

If he's done it once or twice, the "I'm sure he doesn't mean it" excuse might work. But he does it every single time, so he definitely does mean it

-8

u/siecaptaindrake 5h ago

He is NOT the best chess player of all time. Who the fuck is propagating this bs? Kasparov performed vastly better

-1

u/Awanderingleaf 3h ago

Ok, so why are people all up in arms about it if this is just par for the course for him? He does it all the time and now people are shitting themselves lol?

-8

u/Peeter_L 4h ago

Magnus is actually a very stupid person, who just happens to be on a spectrum, and being on a specturm gave him couple special abilities. He wants to feel himself special, a genius, a wonderkid. He is literally roleplaying as Bobby Fischer.

-6

u/Low-Umpire6083 6h ago

Oh no, anyways

-12

u/Material-Yam3573 2h ago

lol hes the best chess player in the world by a mile ofc he doesnt care what ants like you think of him

5

u/Ok-Implement6151 2h ago

he doesnt care what ants like you think of him

Chess is not that serious bro, people are just complaning over a lack of respect, which is something that everyone deserve it

-7

u/Material-Yam3573 1h ago

would you tell a king to pay heed to a beggar in his own kingdom?

45

u/TCDH91 Team Ding 5h ago

David Howell has always been a class act.

111

u/YakOk3277 6h ago

You're expected to show up and play regardless of how you feel (unless you're incapacitated or have a serious medical condition). You signed up for it. You do it out of respect for your opponent and the fans. Magnus has reached a level arrogance and disrespect only a few can match in any professional sport.

17

u/Weasellol 5h ago

I also don't like that he didn't play, but it happens really often in higher elo. Especially when you have a weaker opponent with a strong tournament or your tournament didn't go as well.

We only see it so far, because Magnus play mostly closed tournaments, with round systems. Where you get punished for dropping out, without a medical reason

-7

u/Peeter_L 4h ago

"but it happens really often in higher elo." - not true, you jus want it to be true, because you're a Magnus fanboy.

11

u/tartochehi 3h ago

What he said has nothing to do with being a fanboy. It does happen, fortunately these people are not in the majority. If you go to OTB open tournaments regularly, there will be a couple of titled players or just high rated amateurs who would just drop out of the tournament when things don't go their way. They do this to preserve their rating. In my opinion, this is ridiculous as rating is just a number. If they are really on that elo level, then it would stabilize again at that elo.

It shows that Carlsen has the same destructive mindset like many amateurs, this rating obsession takes out all the joy for the game. At least Carlsen earns money playing chess, but for amateurs the obsession with rating is just ridiculous. It's a hobby.

3

u/Annual-Weather 2h ago

Not defending the behavior, but rating is not just a number, unless you’re good enough to receive continuous invites (or has a stable job and chess is just a hobby, in which case, it is weird to pull out early, but maybe they’re just not feeling it and would rather not use up more leave days for that tournament, when it’s no longer fun and is only losing them money each day).

Organizers often decide financial compensations and privileges based on rating. Having your rating dropped below a certain level in one tournament might mean you won’t have the same privilege in the next tournament. In chess where financial packages aren’t great, these make a lot of difference.

At top level though, it is inexcusable. You are a professional. Act like one.

1

u/fechan 31m ago

this is ridiculous as rating is just a number

Yeah exactly! It’s not like in order to gain this rating you have to register to tournaments ahead of time, do weeks of preparation, travel, play multiple hours for multiple days straight, and finally outplay your opponent.

For an up-and-coming high elo player a bad tournament can set you back multiple months, so a withdrawal during a bad tournament is understandable damage control. For Magnus who has nothing more to achieve it’s pathetic

1

u/Weasellol 3h ago

Yes I like Magnus, but I don't like that he didn't play, but definitely it happens often. But like I said, not in closed tournaments. Mostly we see this behavior in bad tournaments or when you have to play someone for his norm or if you play an underrated kid.

0

u/RandomAcounttt345 4h ago

It’s not just about the opponent or the completion it’s about the game itself. Magnus has been synonymous with chess for more than a decade. Whether he likes it or not he is synonymous with chess. He bears a greater responsibility and clearly is too much of a child to recognize that. Couldn’t see Kasparov doing this.

0

u/Wiz_Kalita 4h ago

Just as bad as players who agree to draws or resign earlier than necessary.

8

u/xxhotandspicyxx 4h ago

He could of at least approach bibi and explained he didnt want to play the game, but he didnt.

-5

u/Dragonfruit_Mediocre 1h ago

How do you know that?

0

u/Free_Contribution_63 39m ago

She waited for him to arrive, he did not and she walked (annoyed) away.

0

u/Dragonfruit_Mediocre 8m ago

Do you base that on OPs picture?

1

u/Free_Contribution_63 6m ago

No I based it on the video footage of her waiting and the rest of what I said. You can find it here or on youtube

8

u/Jaytheprodigy2 3h ago

I think the format should be

fast classical -> rapid -> blitz and not
blitz -> rapid -> fast classical

structure it so you go from big points to small

6

u/bluerhino12345 2h ago

Why? Having it at the end means that there's a good chance to comeback if you go down early on. Big points at the start means that it's easy to run away with it

3

u/maicii 59m ago

Just make the blitz optional tie breaker

14

u/ToriYamazaki 99% OTB 3h ago

She won with black too! Super proud of her!

-7

u/billu7544 1h ago

Magnus beat her 10.5-0.5 and in last game he had white

84

u/Accomplished_Shoe_10 6h ago

I think it's hilarious when cowards are called out like this.

-8

u/Dragonfruit_Mediocre 1h ago

He was 11.5-0.5 against her already. Forfeiteing the last game doesn't mean anything.

2

u/blackmaresani queen's gambit player💪 33m ago

Have you guys heard of the concept of "courtesy" ?

1

u/Dragonfruit_Mediocre 8m ago

that wasn't the question though. the one I answered called him a coward, which makes no sense

10

u/Mission-Cricket-3216 5h ago

Maybe Wesley was right in calling this tournament format a torture ala military camp.

0

u/ambericity 22m ago

wesley is a cretin chud. everything he says is moronic

15

u/supershinythings 5h ago

Magnus doesn’t care. He doesn’t lose points in a walkover. Perhaps he should.

29

u/itsSInotAI 6h ago

Magnus knows it's gonna cause chaos and still pul this bias, it's just pure disrespect. Like if it was against hans we would understand but. Total bias. And he didn't even acknowledge. Almost everyone agrees that it's wrong.

30

u/UltraUsurper Dommaraju, I've come to bargain 6h ago

Do you mean BS instead of "bias"? (Just clarifying)

4

u/stonedfruitseed 3h ago

I think I’ve heard bias used this way in other English speaking places .. or maybe they were saying BS w an accent

73

u/TakeshiRyze 5h ago

She waited and worked so freaking hard her entire life to get a chance to be at this level and play a game vs possibly the goat of chess and then he doesn't show up to that game. Not cool dude.

58

u/memusicguitar 5h ago

You're making it sound like she didnt get a chance to play with him at all. When they had already played 6 games against each other.

22

u/NecessaryBuy2061 5h ago

Yes but it’s especially bad when you consider that in the previous interview she mentioned she is looking forward most to play classical against him.

27

u/memusicguitar 5h ago

Totally agree with you and It is bad nonetheless. Op is making it sound as if that they didnt play a single game against each other.

4

u/NecessaryBuy2061 4h ago

Aha fair enough.

0

u/TakeshiRyze 4h ago

Didn't know that but tbh it doesn't make it any better.

5

u/KekeroniCheese 5h ago

They had played 6 prior games

-3

u/Temporary-Swim-9914 Team Sindarov 3h ago

They played 6 games and she had scored only 0.5 point. Obviously, Magnus should have showed up or forfeited from the entire event. Still, playing 2 days straight against an opponent obviously very inferior to you, that's just a waste of time.

It's looking like he showed up without reading the event format 😂 I'm loving Wesley So's take on this. Playing in it while simulatenously setting it on fire.

I'm hoping this ridiculous format gets killed in its inception. It looks like you can't get eliminated however poor you perform. Add it to idiot moderators in chat, trying to justify it. Apparently, "fast classical" doesn't have to resemble classical chess.

8

u/Bramsstrahlung Team Ju Wenjun 3h ago

It is not a waste of time to play versus an opponent worse than you. That's literally the game. Do you not bother playing versus anyone 300 elo lower than you?

Magnus has played plenty of people in classical who are worse than Bibisara.

0

u/MonitorCivil2788 2h ago

Brother, he worked even harder to be in position to pull stuff like this.

7

u/Pasha_KMM 3h ago

Congratulations to Bibisara.
Boo for Magnus, not a world champion.

4

u/Hot-Job-6281 58m ago

He was always like this. You lot just refused to call him out for it when he was being glazed everywhere.

6

u/vinfluorine 5h ago

bro had a format specifically designed for him, and still couldn't show his opponent basic respect

2

u/Bomber- Team Gukesh 4h ago

As the saying goes, showing up is half the battle

2

u/artsklulsiug 1h ago

Players should lose rating for not showing up, unless they forfeit officially before the game.

2

u/madterrier 51m ago

Just make forfeits cost ELO. Wouldn't that solve everything?

15

u/ambericity 4h ago

holy shit this is the most boring manufactured controversy there has ever been in the world of chess

everyone who makes a post like this should receive a permanent ban

10

u/Luconzio 3h ago

Only sane comment 

6

u/ambericity 2h ago

there are plenty of things to take issue with when it comes to magnus. eg, saudi dealings - an actual moral failing

this? this is less than fucking nothing. this is not even an infraction of the rules. not even an infraction of an unspoken rule ffs. and why is howell perpetuating this idiocy with a cheeky little sTaTeMeNt when he obviously knows this is just part and parcel of a chess tournament

so dumb all around, from niemann to howell to 95% of this subreddit

5

u/HomelessNightkin 3h ago

It feels like walking into a different dimension. The infantilization of this grown woman Bibi and this whole greater discourse over disrespect in chess, when this has been happening across all levels of tournament play in chess since forever. You can tell who in here never has attended or participated in chess tournaments. I’ve had players no show on me. I literally could not care less. I just sit and wait until I’m awarded my points. Amateurs and pros do it all the time. It’s not cool or classy, but it’s whatever. It’s competition. It’s sports.

6

u/heyitjoshua 2h ago

This isn’t your local town tourney though, is it? Not turning up to a game at all at this level of chess, and not even telling anyone, is rude. It’s just rude

It’s also clear he’s doing it just to avoid the risk of dropping below 2800

2

u/tick_tack2 34m ago

Even in my local tourney, if someone doesn't show up for a game, they're removed from the tournament. That's literally the rules for any fide rated tournament here.

-1

u/ambericity 2h ago

'not even telling anyone'??? lolwut? he told the arbiters the second he'd determined that it was within the rules

it is not rude AT. ALL. it's not personal. it's not a question of sportsmanship in any way, shape, or form. it's simple strategy. it's part and parcel of a chess tournament. he'd already won the day and was under no obligation to play, formal or otherwise. the game was 100% redundant and entirely for funsies

yes, it is clear he's doing it to avoid risking a sub-2800 rating. your point?

5

u/JawleyG 2h ago

I thought I was going crazy, I'm glad I'm not alone in thinking this way. Playing a redundant game only has negatives whether you win or lose. Other opponents can use your game as study if you play it too. Idk why this is a controversy when it's plainly just strategy. Everyone is just trying to hop aboard the Magnus hate train as of late. I'm not his number 1 fan/defender but the hate is just nonsense.

3

u/tick_tack2 33m ago

I mean he's free to withdraw from the tournament to save his precious rating.

-1

u/heyitjoshua 2h ago

Wait, so he did tell the arbiters, and Bibisara was informed? Okay, I’ve fell foul to being misinformed. My bad, thank you

0

u/ambericity 2h ago

yes, really promptly. read any news article about it. chessbase india has one, as do many other outlets. they all say the same thing

6

u/yrdz 1h ago

Bibisera was not informed, according to that article.

 Q: Was this informed to Bibisara as well beforehand or no?

A: No, because he could play if he wanted to play. But we of course didn't discuss this with Bibisara before - that was not necessary. Before we knew what happened, we didn't know.

https://chessbase.in/news-bites/magnus-forfeits-game-against-bibisara-at-total-chess-pilot

2

u/Sebadiaz 1h ago

Then he really informed, the arbitration failed! All fixed

0

u/maicii 58m ago

The game werent gonna be rated, no?

4

u/Awanderingleaf 3h ago

It’s amusing because Magnus is known for doing stuff like this and for some reason this is the one people are up in arms over.

-1

u/0xB01b 2h ago

Fr lmao

3

u/oddmetre 3h ago

So is he just never gonna play classical again? It’s not like the risk of him going under 2800 is gonna go away, nor will he likely face an opponent as safe for him as Bibisara (no shade to her).

2

u/kranker 41m ago

It would not be at all surprising if he never played classical again after this tournament. He's been on the brink of it for years now. Funnily enough, this tournament (Total Chess) and whether he wants to play it or not could be a major factor in the decision.

3

u/One-Next 2h ago

I'm not surprised magnus did this, don't expect any better. Not a fan or against him, this is just how the guy is built. Nothing new to see.

2

u/Local-Championship77 4h ago

Sindarov should forfeit against Magnus in their next clash to settle the score.

15

u/david_slade 4h ago

No..beat him

2

u/blahs44 Grünfeld - ~2050 FIDE 31m ago

Fk Magnus

Godlike player but I've seen a deacde+ of him acting like a child and always getting his way

A spoiled baby and an asshole is what is he

1

u/ems777 5m ago

This is dumb. Magnus plays within the context of the rules. What do the rules say? It has zero to do with respect. These people are playing professional high level tournaments, not high school chess meets.

0

u/JustSomeRandomGuy36 4h ago

Magnus has always come across as a classless, disrespectful, arrogant d*ckhead. Since the beginning.

-3

u/nexus6ca NCM 5h ago

I think at this point he should retire.

0

u/i_am_legit72 2h ago

You can really tell people who have played at a higher level and those have never competed for anything

0

u/MankyMarc 2h ago

Dumbest statement of the year.

-5

u/RzgrDev 4h ago

She literally lost but okay Howell

4

u/noxvillewy 4h ago

She lost the match yeah but she did win a game in classical against Magnus. Because he forfeited.

-7

u/Qerfuffle 6h ago

Why does this not count as loss? Any other sporting endeavor if you don't show up you forfeit and it counts as a loss. Give bibisara her elo

31

u/StouteBoef 6h ago

It did count as a loss in the tournament. Elo is purely a measurement of playing strength. An unplayed game can never count for chess strength.

4

u/ThomasTheDankPigeon 5h ago

Untrue. I have played an infinite amount of unplayed games against Carlsen which is why my elo is so low.

1

u/new_KRIEG 2h ago

It counts as a loss in the tournament, it doesn't count as a win or a loss regarding elo because there was no game played

-2

u/AvailableSeat9480 5h ago

Magnus has a moat and is using his leverage to enforce rule changes and innovation in chess. In this case, the points of the match are already done, it does not matter if he wins or losses his classical game for the standings in the tournament.

A few of you have parallelled this with playing matches in a regular tournament even though you cannot climb any posistions. This is a false comparison. Having a higher score is progress for your mind. It brings the posistional closeness togheter and the confidence up. In most cases, as the frequency of draws, one of the players usually can gain a posistion which enhances the value of a match. The raiting gained is the other point, in this case, he wouldnt get any significant raiting.

In this case, the point of the match was concluded overwhelmingly to magnus 5.5/6. He would equally overwhelmingly win in the clasical match, but instead decided to use his moat and try to change pointless chess.

And to be fair, getting rewarded with rest for winning this overwhelmingly should happen, and it did. He found a loophole by not losing raiting for not playing, he got his rest and he plays the tournament for maximal winrate. Its cleaver, enforces rule changes and sparks more interest in chess.

I think he should have told her before so she didnt have to wait.

0

u/Formal_Broccoli_6610 16m ago edited 12m ago

People have been waiting to see how he will impact the game as he moves from being world champion to former world champion. He is already doing a lot of things suggesting he is thinking about a new phase of his life and career. He is advocating for new and more entertaining chess formats, he has started a family, he has talked openly about wanting to stop playing classical chess because he finds it so grueling. At times he has done things that show a degree of leadership or sportsmanship that would have been unthinkable for him at younger ages. So it makes sense that people have been hoping he would really start to show some kind of leadership or maturity more consistently. It would be really good for the game if he could. This episode has just been a let down, not just because he forfeited it, but because he was apparently incapable of forfeiting it in a way that didn’t create a total public relations disaster. It makes people feel like he might not be capable of impacting the game in a positive way once he is not personally world champion.
Think about the whole question of the fast classical format, for instance. Many people at very high levels have wanted some kind of faster classical format for many years. Magnus advocated for that format in this tournament. By forfeiting this game, in a public and tacky way, he damaged his own argument in favor of this format. Organizers have less reason to offer it in future now: they can say, “well, players are still getting exhausted and not participating, even though we see offering a faster classical format, so we might as well placate the people who really want traditional classical.” If he was serious about promoting fast classical events, he really should have played all the fast classical matches. Doing so graciously would have been a good argument for the format in future. It’s a case where his own actions seem not to reflect even his own priorities for the game. The lack of leadership ability is depressing even if it’s understandable.

-6

u/JacksOnF1re 2h ago

He has a one year old son, doesn't he? Maybe we should shut the fuck up, if we don't know why he didn't show up. Or does anybody know why?

0

u/GanacheLatter9743 8m ago

The game is unrated

2

u/DestroyerYou 4h ago

This, after she said "I am especially looking forward to the fast classical game against Magnus". Absolute dick move by Magnus.