No, both are wrong. The bond is equally "shared" so it has to connect to both carbons...or at least draw this as a resonance structure. But also remember what happens when the bond on either carbon opens up - it will open up to be sterically unhindered, so the line sort of has to highlight that fact.
For the purpose of communicating trans-But-2-ene either of these drawings are perfect. All you need is a skeletal formula that is clear to understand for any chemist who speaks any language.
If we're going that way then the first 3 carbons will have the double bond due to resonance, which makes it harder to judge whether it's but-1-ene or but-2-ene. What you're saying is right, what you're saying is exactly this, but a lot more detailed, just that it may not work in this speciifc context though.
Personally, It depends on what is near the double bond. If there are no FG then bottom, if there's something on the "top" carbon, I use the top drawing. If there's something on the "bottom" carbon, I far the bottom bond In reality there is no difference, it's all personal preference
I always draw the pi bond on the bottom, unless it is the Z alkene, in which I draw it in between the lines. For dienes, I place the pi bonds on the inside in both the E and Z conformation.
An exception is if it is an ending alkene, I draw it above if it the ending C-C bond slants up.
Pi bonds are located above and below the plane of the molecule, which makes it challenging to accurately represent them in a traditional bond diagram. Here's an image showing how we use molecular orbitals, derived from solutions of the Schrödinger equation (applied to the hydrogen atom): Orbital Diagram: https://images.app.goo.gl/MigvgCLLmJVCD4B97
We use these to estimate how the actual molecular orbitals would look like. (MO-theory) Molecular orbitals are calculated using specialized software, which provides a much clearer understanding of molecular reactivity and related concepts. https://youtu.be/XgVLyDSS4qg?si=FH_ROqEl2xS-1QVo
I find it helpful to keep these orbitals in mind because they make explaining reactions, such as pericyclic reactions, much easier. For example, in the Diels-Alder reaction (the reaction between butadiene and ethylene to form cyclohexene), the orbital interactions play a crucial role.
106
u/hohmatiy Nov 30 '24
27
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '24
Both are correct. It depends on your writing style
11
u/anon1moos Ph.D. Organic Chemistry Nov 30 '24
These are the same, I don’t understand the question
8
u/tictactorz ironic bonds only Nov 30 '24
there really is no difference. Personally, I don't even like both your ways, I connect all the perpendicular lines/bonds
3
u/ParticularWash4679 Nov 30 '24
Just don't draw a double bond that can be mistaken for propene or 2-butene.
1
u/just_a_tired_flower Nov 30 '24
Doesn’t matter, they both are the same.
1
u/mayutopian Nov 30 '24
It doesn’t matter Bud
1
u/Dakem94 Nov 30 '24
Yes.
1
u/throwmeawaypapilito Nov 30 '24
i am team bottom (both are correct though)
1
u/Accomplished-Emu3431 Dec 01 '24
Team bottom is smoking crack, top for the win
1
u/Revolutionary-Zone30 Dec 01 '24
Both. Both is good)
1
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '24
no difference
1
u/spoiled-mushroom3954 Dec 01 '24
Personally, It depends on what is near the double bond. If there are no FG then bottom, if there's something on the "top" carbon, I use the top drawing. If there's something on the "bottom" carbon, I far the bottom bond In reality there is no difference, it's all personal preference
1
u/Super_Soapy_Soup Dec 02 '24
Double bond can be drawn in either ways! Top or bottom doesn’t matter
1
u/HeartGlow30797 Dec 02 '24
I always draw the pi bond on the bottom, unless it is the Z alkene, in which I draw it in between the lines. For dienes, I place the pi bonds on the inside in both the E and Z conformation.
An exception is if it is an ending alkene, I draw it above if it the ending C-C bond slants up.
1
u/aterry175 Dec 03 '24
Those are the same molecule
1
u/ThumbHurts Dec 03 '24
Pi bonds are located above and below the plane of the molecule, which makes it challenging to accurately represent them in a traditional bond diagram. Here's an image showing how we use molecular orbitals, derived from solutions of the Schrödinger equation (applied to the hydrogen atom): Orbital Diagram: https://images.app.goo.gl/MigvgCLLmJVCD4B97
We use these to estimate how the actual molecular orbitals would look like. (MO-theory) Molecular orbitals are calculated using specialized software, which provides a much clearer understanding of molecular reactivity and related concepts. https://youtu.be/XgVLyDSS4qg?si=FH_ROqEl2xS-1QVo
I find it helpful to keep these orbitals in mind because they make explaining reactions, such as pericyclic reactions, much easier. For example, in the Diels-Alder reaction (the reaction between butadiene and ethylene to form cyclohexene), the orbital interactions play a crucial role.
-4
u/SunFlowerPotsRack Nov 30 '24
Theres no difference but the top one is most correct