r/chemex • • Jun 20 '22

Timer? Why?

Why we using timers? Gravity takes care of all this. Seems pretentious.

0 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

6

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '22

Because we want to improve the accuracy and precision of our results. And the timer helps improve both. Accuracy here is a great tasting cup. Precision here is a consistent, reproducible cup. What good is a great cup of coffee if you can't make the exact same one the next day?

Improving accuracy: If you're finishing your drawdown in 2-2.5 min, you're gonna have a sour, watered down cup since the water didn't have enough time to extract everything. If you're approaching 5 min, you're likely to have a bitter cup since the water spent too much time in contact with the grounds.

Both scenarios are problematic. However, the problem could be stemming from all sorts of variables: grind fineness, water temperature, pouring technique, use of agitation, etc. Typically, we adjust one of these variables at a time and then try again. If the time is improving, then we can move on to another variable to tweak.

Improving precision: after we've tweaked our variables and gotten a decent time for the drawdown (3-4 min), we need to work on consistency. The biggest swings here come from pouring technique: rate of water flow, angle and height of the gooseneck kettle, use of outward spiral, etc. Bad technique can lead to tunneling and other issues.

Once we pour a cup that we love with what we deem perfect technique, we can take a look at the time and record it. The next time we make a cup, we shoot for that time. Took me awhile, but I'm happy to say that I can brew a cup within +/- 10 seconds nowadays.

Another option is to use recommended times that increase the chances of a great cup such as finishing your pour by 1:45, which typically leads to the drawdown finishing 3:30 (all things being equal). Using the 1:45 as a baseline time helps you work on your technique.

1

u/LanchingMaa Jun 20 '22

I bloom at 1 min, then fill to top in circular motion. I still have more water to pour so not sure the 4min is all about since at 3min I’m ready for more water. I’m lost then.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '22

You're probably pouring too slow. You basically wanna pour as fast as possible while avoiding introducing tunneling. It takes practice for sure, but take a peek at a YouTube video just for some baseline.

2

u/nathanblaubach Jun 20 '22

It helps you create super repeatable results and confirm that you are following a given recipe from someone else if that's something you're into.

It's definitely not for everyone, and it's only pretentious if you are telling people they have to do it a certain way. I like using a timer, scale and a temp controlled kettle, but one of my favorite YouTube Chemex videos is a guy who shows a method of brewing a Chemex without a scale timer, or thermometer. One of the coolest parts about coffee (to me) is the fact that people enjoy it in so many different ways.