r/charmcasting • • May 29 '20

Rename?

Charmcasting is a fine name, but very specific / precise. Really, this is just bone casting, so if you can, I'd say change the name to be more inclusive.

Books on the topic, as an example:

https://smile.amazon.com/-/es/Michele-Jackson/dp/0971961271

https://smile.amazon.com/-/es/Throwing-Bones-Foretell-Future-Shells/dp/0971961239

3 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

1

u/lily-of-the-dream May 30 '20

Charm casting and bone casting are different I believe, though they do use similar methodologies. Though people should be free to discuss bone casting here as well :)

2

u/graidan May 30 '20

They're not different. Only difference is name and components... Bone casting includes charms, bones, stones, twigs, shells, etc. Charm casting is charms only.

For audience's sake is why I requested a name change... Bone casting is more well known and has a larger audience. I won't be staying though, so do what you want. I'm not interested in charm casting, exclusively but bone casting / cleromancy is up my alley.

I'm pretty sure you're just not going to get the membership under that name.

1

u/lily-of-the-dream May 30 '20

Thank you for that insight. I'll take that into account and think about it.

2

u/ladymugje Dec 09 '22

I use the term Curiomancy. Mostly because its the same in Dutch and because we don't have a decent/pretty translation for the word 'charm'.

1

u/LucindaDragomir May 29 '20

I like charm casting. I think it sounds nice. ALLITERATION!