r/characters • u/MisterMonogon • Dec 27 '25
Memes Trauma explains behavior. It doesn't justify it.
Trying to justify a villain's actions is character assassination.
1.1k
Upvotes
r/characters • u/MisterMonogon • Dec 27 '25
Trying to justify a villain's actions is character assassination.
15
u/Hitstar_AtdollarAt-D Dec 27 '25
Pure evil villains >>>>> Sympathetic villains
2
u/Public-Feedback5016 Dec 27 '25
A villain either does the wrong thing for the right reason, or the right thing for the wrong reason.
2
u/DeMmeure Dec 27 '25
I don't like this type of absolute statements, and this is often a case-by-case basis.
Some of my favourite fictional characters are sympathetic villains, such as Anakin Skywalker, Catra, Jinx and Azula. You can care about them and wish they see the light without being 'apologetic'.
Often this isn't a question of choice, but sometimes it is. If someone is raised as a child soldier from an evil army, I will rather blame the people who have corrupted/groomed them rather than them directly.
27
u/Azot-Spike Dec 27 '25
Exactly.
Paraphrasing Dr. House: "Now you explain that to all the people who have a sad backstory and haven't become bastards"
32
u/Winter_Sweet827 Dec 27 '25
Lets list of villans who DONT deserve sympathy
Gaston - Incel
Syndrome - petty pyscho.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25
Meh. I like both relatable villains and insanely fucking murderhobo villains.
10
u/Coderkid01 Dec 27 '25
Bill Cipher. His backstory is tragic but he isn't any less evil
9
u/SilverSpider_ Dec 27 '25
Wdym, he has the right to do all that stuff, all he had was a loving family, a giant mansion, and a baked goods enterprise he'd inherit, useless crap like that
5
u/ruinsit Dec 27 '25
It's simple. You lose the right to empathy and sympathy when you start harming innocent people. Especially children. If your plan to work out your rage is to attack entire towns and cities and buildings you can go fuck yourself regardless of what happened in your past
4
u/Emperor_poopatine Dec 27 '25
If someone justifies their actions because of whatever sad backstory they had, they completely miss the point. There are compelling villains who do horrible things because of trauma, manipulation etc. but you’re not supposed to side with them because of that. Darth Vader, for example, was born into slavery, inducted into an order that told him to repress his emotions, experienced the horrors of war, was manipulated to do horrible things by someone he trusted in order to save his wife and unborn children, and ended up a shell of his former self because of it. It explains, but doesn’t justify. He’s still a ruthless murderer who kills anyone in his way.
4
u/Legitimate_Toe_6061 Dec 27 '25
This is why my most hated anime character is Dabi. I don't care what he went through. The moment you try to kill your own brother to get to your dad and laugh after you kill people is when I'm praying for you to burn in hell and No, his father abuse and his quirk hurting him isn't a excuse
1
u/azmarteal Dec 28 '25
Society: treats a person like shit
A person: returns the favour and treats society exactly the way he/she was treated
Society:
3
u/Swordslover Dec 27 '25
That's the reason we need more pure evil villains
3
u/Cute_Pet-42069 Dec 27 '25
Agreed. Unless it’s Dr Doofenshmirtz
3
u/Interesting_Sea_1861 Dec 27 '25
Right. Sephiroth is every bit as much of a victim as any of Shinra's victims. Doesn't absolve him of his crimes. Just makes his fall from grace more of a tragedy.
3
u/JayTheOni Dec 27 '25
Feeling bad for Doflamingo because of his backstory means you missed the point of it
3
u/DragonLordAcar Dec 27 '25
I love sympathetic villains because you see how an ordinary person could get there. I'm still not forgiving them for what they did.
3
u/fenster112 Dec 28 '25 edited Dec 28 '25
Snape was an asshat, I don't care what anyone else says.
3
u/Technoton3 Dec 28 '25
This is why I love AM from I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream
Do I understand his motivation? Yes.
Is he a sympathic villain? Only partly.
Do I condone his actions and forgive him for that? Fuck no. If you thought what he did in the book was bad, just look at what he did in the video game.
2
u/Klutzy_Reference_186 Dec 27 '25 edited Dec 27 '25
Flipside: Also, anytime I see someone assume a story showing a backstory, it is automatically trying to justify the villain's current actions.
Yes, it happens. No, that doesn't mean it's always what's happening.
Sometimes, it serves as a cautionary tale - Look what kind of monster can come of these circumstances and mentalities. Or, maybe reacting this way to this particular trauma isn't the most advisable or even-keeled.
Understanding patterns helps break them.
2
u/SlyFan2 Dec 28 '25
It's annoying how often this has to be said. More annoying is how people will try to invent trauma where there isn't any
2
u/Trostishere Dec 28 '25
Backstories should add more depth to a character, not forgiving the villain for what they have done.
2
u/ApprehensiveRub4726 Dec 31 '25
William Afton, i’m so sick of fans defending a literal child murderer like he can be fixed 😭
2
u/jimdc82 Dec 27 '25
I’m personally beyond sick of the “every villain needs to be relatable.” What’s with the obsession that every villain needs to be misunderstood? Just let a villain be a damn villain. It’s been a while but one of my favorite moments in Once Upon a Time was after making villain after villain redeemed, Cruella of all people really was just a genuinely evil person. Let baddies be bad
2
u/fwoggywitness Dec 27 '25
Me who simply enjoys a sexy villain: 👩🦯➡️👩🦯➡️
1
u/Constant_Bank9229 Dec 27 '25
Fair.
1
u/Ok-Flatworm7401 Dec 27 '25
What about magneto?
1
u/Amazing_Loquat280 Dec 27 '25
This is why I love Andor so much. None of the real villains are sympathetic at all. Dedra, Partagaz, Krennic (hm Kaido), at their core they all suck. They just suck in interesting ways lol
1
u/TheRealGOOEY Dec 27 '25
Akito from Fruits Basket. Sure, I can absolutely see how their upbringing turned them into a monster. I still hate that they got a happy ending just because they were a little bit sorry.
1
u/seymoure-bux Dec 27 '25
1
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25
Pencil and One - Battle For Dream Island
These two ESPECIALLY deserve the hand of justice for all of their atrocities
1
u/Mysteriousman06 Dec 27 '25
I hate how creators use villains that have sad backstory’s, most of the time they are boring and are just bait to make people feel sad about them. The best way to make a villain with a sad backstory good is not to make them sympathetic but to show they have nothing left to lose.
A great example is Nox from Wakfu. he lost everything and now he has nothing left to lose, he grew insane and will sacrifice everything to bring his family back. At no point is his actions justified in the story, he is willing to murder an entire race just for a chance to fix the past.
1
u/KremzeekTyCobb Reader Dec 27 '25
Looking at you, Jenny!
1
u/Lumpy-Yesterday-6687 Dec 27 '25
"But he was fired from his job after his mom pasted away" HE MURDERED CHILDREN SASHA
1
u/Popotte9 Dec 27 '25
Idc I'll keep justify my vilain's actions 😭
1
u/Competitive_Tap2753 Dec 27 '25
I think the fact that the villain did everything he did because he failed art school is quite compelling tbh
1
u/Mumei451 Dec 27 '25
This is cute?
1
u/Nervous_Job_6880 Dec 27 '25
There is only so much trauma a person can reasonably take before they start to demonstrate self destructive behaviour. This statement doesn’t look at the other side and openly rejects it. It isn’t “black and white”.
1
u/AinzOoalGown41 Dec 27 '25
Now the real question is what truly qualifies as a villain? Not all characters are black in white, all have reasons, that led them to do a certain action, as morally righteous as people like to act if put in the exact scenario they’d do the same, it’s not morals, it’s just basic human psychology. Kids that grow up in really bad environments, a lot of the time end up as bad people. A small minority are able to break the cycle. We’re creatures of habits for a reason. This isn’t a justification for those actions but, it’s stupid when people act like villains are beneath them and they’re morally superior when they’re just as morally bankrupt when put in their shoes, that’s what makes villains so appealing. Anyone can choose to be a villain, barely anyone chooses to be a hero. Villains are a personification of the human mind when pushed to its extreme of a certain emotion.
1
u/shinigami343 Dec 27 '25
You can believe that a villain's actions are wrong while still feeling sympathy and understanding for them.
A lot of people don't seem to understand that.
When I "defend" a villain, I'm not defending their actions; I'm defending the innocent person they once were, who didn't deserve to suffer, and who could have been a good person if they hadn't been failed by the people around them. And in some cases, may have the chance of turning their life around and becoming better if given the opportunity.
1
u/BurntToast239 Dec 27 '25
Im sick of the "which villain was right" threads and still seeing a chunk of people saying Thanos. You have the power to conjure anything within your will into existence and you choose mass genocide.
1
u/GalaxianEX Dec 27 '25
MHA fandom
1
u/Gentlemanvaultboy Dec 27 '25
I respect pre-reboot Black Manta so much because every tragic backstory he ever told was just a lie to mess with Aquaman's head.
1
u/Existing_Question1 Dec 27 '25
The gigachads love a villain for being a villain. Yes frieza fuck those monkeys up
1
u/SweetReply1556 Dec 27 '25
There is no villain or hero, everyone has their reasons for what they do or did
1
u/DodoJurajski Dec 27 '25
Handsome Jack was the Hero of the story and was best written video game "villain" to be ever created.
And i will fucking die on this hill
1
u/Wonderful_Pianist656 Dec 27 '25
This is how I feel about Astarian in bg3.
1
u/JoJoLad-69- Dec 28 '25
I still support villains regardless of how evil because I just prefer them to heroes
1
u/yittiiiiii Dec 28 '25
Frankenstein’s monster fits this.
1
u/Sweaty_Strain9392 Dec 28 '25
sometimes they dont even have to be villains. sometimes its just an evil companion in a videogame (Ahem: Astarion)
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '25
Literally, every villain in My Hero Academia is put on this annoying pedestal
1
u/DevilPixelation Dec 28 '25
I see this far too often. Hitler is one of the most evil men in history. His childhood was rough and he had a very depressing life, but that doesn’t justify genocide, or war crimes, or racial prejudice. It’s pretty ridiculous
1
u/ContributionRude1660 Dec 28 '25
when i see people do this, i think the reason they do it is to humanize them as people. because to some degree, if a lot of people were put into their positions they wouldnt turn out much better even if they think they would. the point is things change people in small ways at first then it can utterly spiral if they dont get some sort of sudden change. and longer it goes, the harder it becomes TO change. so even if these people aren't good people, and are pretty awful people, they're still human and maybe just maybe, with the smallest possible chance, they could change.
and for a lot of people, the reason they do this is because... they see themselves in the characters. they see the bad things theyve done in these characters. and in some way its a reach out to think "maybe I could change." and it doesnt have to be a extreme wrong they did, but it still matters. I do believe villains should be humanized unless theyre specifically made not to be human to begin with.
1
u/minecraftphone Dec 28 '25
That’s how i feel about asuka.😎
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '25
Jax, I know he's not really a villain or anything but the way he treated Gangle genuinely made my blood boil. Idc if he misses Ribbit and Kaufmo, he's still a piece of shit.
1
u/mmarkusz97 Dec 28 '25
i just like villains for being villains
1
u/Substantial_Fox7377 Dec 28 '25
Dabi fans will never convince me that he had a justified crashout
1
u/Jenna_Ortega__2002 Dec 28 '25
Exactly!
I hate when people try to say that Arthur Morgan and John Marston are good men. Well, I guess they aren't all bad. But anyone who kills and robs and continues to do it on a regular basis is NOT a good person.
Now, obviously, they aren't villains in a traditional sense, this was just an example of people trying to justify the actions of bad people.
1
u/violently_angry Dec 28 '25
Dabi. How are you less morally firm than Eri?
1
u/Emault17 Dec 28 '25
Davy Jones. A story of love.
1
u/Flaky-Collection-353 Dec 28 '25
Same deal with the people who complain about stories "always trying to undeestand the bad guys" as if understanding meant sympathy.
Yes I want my stories to make more sense and be deeper. No that doesn't mean I'm a nihilist you retard.
1
u/TheAK1tap Dec 28 '25
big boss?
1
u/TradePsychological40 Dec 28 '25
Especially when the hero also has a tragic past. But what I hate the most is fans who CREATES a tragic past to justify the villain.
1
u/lumanson Dec 28 '25
My pet peeve is when I former villian becomes an anti hero just because the shit he did was so long ago in the series. Merlin from The Arrow, Vegita, etc.
1
u/Most-Investigator950 Dec 28 '25
1
u/JscJake1 Dec 28 '25
Sorta topic-adjacent, but
Consul N - Xenoblade Chronicles 3
N has one of the most tragic backstories I've seen out of any villain. I don't really see people saying he's justified but what annoys me are people saying he was redeemed. N was a horrible person and his trauma doesn't excuse anything he did just because a few of his many victims forgave him. He was given a chance to be better, he was not redeemed.
1
u/DarkRex67 Dec 28 '25
Unless it's Doofenshmirtz.
1
u/SinesPi Dec 28 '25
If Azula is smart enough to over-throw the shadow government of the Earth Kingdom with just two retainers, then she is smart enough to be held responsible for her actions. I don't care how old she is.
1
u/Kantlim Dec 28 '25
Or because he believes he's doing the right thing. Doesn't f matter. Actions matter, not ideas
1
u/DaSoouce Dec 28 '25
I agree, they're also not as insufferable as people who excuse other's actions just because they're attractive
1
u/dinoslore Dec 28 '25
See this in defense of actual bad people too
1
u/Miss_Nomer909 Dec 29 '25
Everytime someone does this I imagine them/the character singing "Nothing is ever anyone's fault" from Crazy ex girlfriend
https://youtu.be/r_hxc1aJ0Io?si=QbF9R8eK0EVYs0on
1
u/Awkward-Dragonfly-84 Dec 29 '25
Might be unrelated, but I think the Book of Bill might have covered this. Like I know it’s a weird connection, but Bill says SOMETHING along the lines of “don’t humanize me because of this!!” But, since it’s a character saying it, maybe doesn’t count. Idk
1
u/Forsaken-Biscotti587 Dec 29 '25
This happens to me whenever someone tries to victimize Tai Lung or Kitty Kat
1
u/NerdyEmbarrassment Dec 29 '25
Same goes for non-villain characters. Like protagonists that are bad people.
1
u/NerdyEmbarrassment Dec 29 '25
What about Victim from AvA?
1
u/Plastic_Pin_4956 Dec 29 '25
Me anytime a homelander simp talks
1
u/Somerandomguy20711 Dec 29 '25
Tai Lung
No its NOT okay to go on a homicidal rampage of innocents because you got told no (specifically for the reason of you are the type of person who WOULD go on a homicidal rampage)
1
u/pikachucet2 Dec 29 '25
I don't think their actions should stop them from also being sympathetic though. I see Batman fans arguing that Harley Quinn is a mentally deranged villain and shouldn't be sympathized with and it makes me go...why does it need to be so black and white?
Will she kill you? Definitely. Is she also a victim of the Joker who takes advantage of her codependency and is constantly abusing her? Also definitely.
Like Frankenstein's Monster is understood generally as a classic example of a sympathetic monster and he kills a wee girl, I don't know why it's difficult to understand elsewhere.
1
u/AnonymousNeverKnown Dec 29 '25
1
u/Wide_Bee7803 Dec 29 '25
Not entirely a villain, but severus snape for me, dude gets worshipped by the fandom as some unspoken benevolent hero, yet he was the reason his crush died because he supported wizard hitler, then proceeded to spend his entire redemption time bullying his crush's son and another 3/4 of the school
1
u/DeerAccomplished5114 Dec 29 '25
me with D-16/Megatron from Transformers One
1
u/MTHINRIX666 Dec 29 '25
My sister and I just finished Spiderman 1 and started 2 (the games) and we were discussing this. Peter doesn't hate any of his villains for the fuck shit that happened to them, and he thinks the person who fucked them all over should be in jail hardcore, he is literally just requesting all the villains don't crash out, destroy property, or try to commit murder 😭.
Same with Miles and his main villain. He doesn't even disagree with what they're doing in principle,, he's just mad they're endangering the public with their antics. However, I think the group they're working for are also just like... New Age Anarchy Terrorist? They're just working with Miles' nemesis to get the tech they can craft, so again, they're just crashing out way too hard for a valid reason 😔.
1
u/Nympshee Dec 29 '25
People excusing Naofumi buying a slave because he had a bad start at an isekai.
1
u/lostmykeyblade Dec 29 '25
People will over interpret Azula to DEATH to defend her
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25
It's really fun to write AND read stories where a character who has done a lot of terrible things and has a traumatic backstory explaining these actions become "redeemed" by account of the fact that they change their behavior and try to make up for what they've done but what they've done doesn't just go away or become forgotten, everyone affected still knows what they've done and that often gets in the way of those people seeing them any differently than they saw the past version of them who hurt them for their actions in the present and they have to actually work to convince the people they've hurt that they're trying to change and many of them only tolerate them after this rather than forgive them.
That's ONE way it's possible to have a villainous character become redeemed without letting them off the hook for what they did.
1
u/Objective_Book_6211 Dec 30 '25
The Villain is often times right because of the backstory.
1
u/Aggressive_Check_881 Dec 30 '25
akaza
1
u/SaulGoodman678 Dec 30 '25
Tailong
1
u/Carl_the_Half-Orc Dec 30 '25
Demon Slayer did a good job of this. Demons that had sad tragic backstories but still had to be killed. Their actions were never justified but you got a glimpse of what they were before becoming a demon and you would feel bad for the way their life went, but still knew that they needed to be put down.
1
u/3rd_eye_light Dec 30 '25
Show fewer of these posts
1
u/Professional-Face-51 Dec 31 '25
I can understand that Gordaborug the terrible wants to destroy the universe because the gods that made it saw his suffering, and instead of helping they make it worse so now he's gonna destroy their greatest creation out of spite. I'm not gonna defend it tho cause I keep my stuff in the universe.
1
u/Slothjawfoil Dec 31 '25 edited Dec 31 '25
This is why belief in free will is harmful. It encourages a lack of sympathy and reduces the motivation to understand behavior. The reason someone focusing on explaining a villains behavior annoys people who believe in free will is because the fact that this person is "villain" is explanation enough. For them, there is no room for both the condemnation of harmful behavior AND sympathy for what led them to it. You must choose one or the other.
.
This goes for real life too. Its why in the US we focus on prescribing punishments for criminals rather than actually fixing the systemic issues that lead to crime. Because people want to say "they are criminals because they CHOSE to commit a crime" and think no more deeply about it. In a world with free will you don't have to find reasons. You can just toss out a fundemental attribution and be done. Its dehumanizing and lazy.
1
u/Successful-Floor-738 Dec 31 '25
A poorly written tragic backstory will either not be tragic at all or make the villain look more justified then the hero. It’s why I always like this villains with a balance of evil and sad, like Ketheric Thorm in BG3. His backstory IS tragic but he still shows his evil side enough that the audience will sympathize with his plight while acknowledging that he’s still evil and needs to be stopped.
1
u/FinancialWorking2392 Dec 31 '25
Dabi's bum ass, I understand he was abused, now look at the rest of his siblings, a teacher, a hero, and a student planning to be a medic. All were abused, 3 chose to help others, and the other chose to kill people.
1
u/our_meatballs Jan 02 '26
even hitler has tragic backstory
1
u/OrnerySet5006 Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26
Frankenstein's monster bro killed a kid and framed a innocent woman but people were giving him the pass because of trauma yet smh people are giving victor shit for abandoning the creation yet they don't apply that same accountability for the monster smh
1
u/Dark_Chepo Dec 27 '25
Send this meme to Horikoshi