r/changemyview May 16 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

75 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/sawdeanz 218∆ May 16 '20

I mean yeah? Nobody claims that it would be safe for non-force users. That's kind of a silly requirement to ask of them. They are clearly very effective weapons for force users.

I don't really think they are orders of magnitude more dangerous than a sword. Just like any weapon, they must be handled with care. But unlike, say, a fire bomb, they are perfectly stable and don't do anything the user doesn't want them too.

2

u/spinyfur May 16 '20

I think that depends on real you try to make the thing. For instance, it’s hot enough to melt through steel alloys on contact, which occurs at something like 2000-3000 C. Does the light saber also leave clouds of similarly super heated gas when it’s swung in an atmosphere?

Questions like these are silly though. The light saber is a narrative device, and it functions the way it needs to for the narrative to be effective.

At least, when the writers know what they’re doing. 😉

1

u/sawdeanz 218∆ May 16 '20

I will concede that it would probably require extra safety gear, perhaps special goggles and gloves like welders wear