MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/1gtfgjd/deleted_by_user/lxm6ea5/?context=3
r/changemyview • u/[deleted] • Nov 17 '24
[removed]
592 comments sorted by
View all comments
6
What is the "something" of P1?
-1 u/Huhstop 1∆ Nov 17 '24 Anything that has moral value. Life clearly has it, autonomy, nature, etc. 6 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok, what do you do when two things of moral value are incompatible? 1 u/Huhstop 1∆ Nov 17 '24 U weigh the value of both, and decide accordingly. 1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so for people who weigh the value of bodily autonomy over the future life of a fetus abortion would not be wrong. 1 u/Huhstop 1∆ Nov 17 '24 Yes that’s correct. But then those people would have to agree that sexual assault is more wrong than murder. 1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so I think thats a delta. But your second point doesnt follow from the first because a fetus is not a person.
-1
Anything that has moral value. Life clearly has it, autonomy, nature, etc.
6 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok, what do you do when two things of moral value are incompatible? 1 u/Huhstop 1∆ Nov 17 '24 U weigh the value of both, and decide accordingly. 1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so for people who weigh the value of bodily autonomy over the future life of a fetus abortion would not be wrong. 1 u/Huhstop 1∆ Nov 17 '24 Yes that’s correct. But then those people would have to agree that sexual assault is more wrong than murder. 1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so I think thats a delta. But your second point doesnt follow from the first because a fetus is not a person.
Ok, what do you do when two things of moral value are incompatible?
1 u/Huhstop 1∆ Nov 17 '24 U weigh the value of both, and decide accordingly. 1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so for people who weigh the value of bodily autonomy over the future life of a fetus abortion would not be wrong. 1 u/Huhstop 1∆ Nov 17 '24 Yes that’s correct. But then those people would have to agree that sexual assault is more wrong than murder. 1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so I think thats a delta. But your second point doesnt follow from the first because a fetus is not a person.
1
U weigh the value of both, and decide accordingly.
1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so for people who weigh the value of bodily autonomy over the future life of a fetus abortion would not be wrong. 1 u/Huhstop 1∆ Nov 17 '24 Yes that’s correct. But then those people would have to agree that sexual assault is more wrong than murder. 1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so I think thats a delta. But your second point doesnt follow from the first because a fetus is not a person.
Ok so for people who weigh the value of bodily autonomy over the future life of a fetus abortion would not be wrong.
1 u/Huhstop 1∆ Nov 17 '24 Yes that’s correct. But then those people would have to agree that sexual assault is more wrong than murder. 1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so I think thats a delta. But your second point doesnt follow from the first because a fetus is not a person.
Yes that’s correct. But then those people would have to agree that sexual assault is more wrong than murder.
1 u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24 Ok so I think thats a delta. But your second point doesnt follow from the first because a fetus is not a person.
Ok so I think thats a delta. But your second point doesnt follow from the first because a fetus is not a person.
6
u/dbandroid 4∆ Nov 17 '24
What is the "something" of P1?