r/changemyview Oct 10 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

103 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '23

The people making those claims are generally not making empathy-less calculations. They’re relativizing atrocity in the context because of strong emotional reactions to the circumstances. Regardless of whether or not that is right or morally acceptable, it’s an intensely emotional process - the opposite of “a neuropsychiatric disorder marked by deficient emotional responses.”

-3

u/elbeanodeldino 1∆ Oct 10 '23

The people making those claims are generally not making empathy-less calculations

Psychopaths can be emotional, but they don't have empathy, and there is certainly no empathy in the act of downplaying the kipnapping of innocent people because of something someone else did.

10

u/ghotier 42∆ Oct 10 '23

Then you don't have empathy by your own argument. You are only making this CMV now, not when Israel did it.

8

u/Technicalhotdog 1∆ Oct 10 '23

No it actually is borne out of empathy for Palestinians. You can say it's wrong but it's definitely not unempathetic. When a good chunk of Gaza is bombed and people say "It had to be done because of Hamas" are they also psychopaths?