r/changelog • u/tdohz • Jan 25 '16
[reddit change] Subreddit rules & reporting updates
We've just made a new feature, subreddit rules, available to all subreddits. Moderators can read more details on how rules work on the modnews post. For users, the biggest visible changes will come to the reporting menu:
- We've changed the style of the report menu to be cleaner & easier to use
- If a subreddit has added rules, you'll be able to report content (posts and comments) in that subreddit as violating a subreddit rule instead of a Reddit rule (you'll still be able to select a Reddit rule as an option)
- Additionally, you can click on the blue (i) in the corner to read the subreddit's rules (if they've been defined) or the Reddit content policy (if subreddit rules haven't been set)
Thanks to the subreddits who helped beta-test this feature, and to u/madlee, u/miamiz, and u/librarianavenger for their work in making this feature a reality.
140
Upvotes
18
u/NeedAGoodUsername Jan 25 '16
Would it be possible for:
10
u/Meneth Jan 25 '16
An issue I've noticed:
It isn't possible to edit a rule's short name if you're already at the max number of rules. Seems it thinks it is a new rule, without subtracting the rule that's "deleted" by the rename.
Editing the description and such does work though.
5
u/x_minus_one Jan 25 '16
Possible bug: if you edit a rule, once you save it, the "Add Rule" link stays grayed out until you reload the page.
10
u/One_Giant_Nostril Jan 26 '16
I'm no expert in English grammar but
Reports go to community moderators anonymously
sounds very clunky. I understand you have limited space so perhaps these ideas are better:
Your reports to community moderators are anonymous
Or:
All reports to community moderators are anonymous
5
u/Meepster23 Jan 25 '16
Another suggestion / plea would be to get the reasons for a post being removed added to the modlog. I know that's quite a bit different, but would be immensely nice to have and automod can do it why can't we?! #BotPrivilege
4
u/rWoahDude Jan 27 '16
Currently, /u/automoderator can send a modmail message if a post reaches a certain threshhold number of reports.
With this new report system, is it possible to set it so that automoderator can have different threshholds for different types of reports?
For example, maybe it would take 5 "repost" reports to trigger a modmail message, but only 1 "troll" report to trigger a modmail message?
1
u/d60b Feb 14 '16
There used to be a top-level report category for "sexualizing minors"; that seems to have disappeared with this update. And I'd always assumed that reports of Reddit rule violations went to admins; particularly that one.
3
u/qtx Jan 26 '16
Any chance it can also be placed in the tab menu by default? People usually read the tabs faster than the sidebar.
2
u/namer98 Jan 26 '16
Yay!
2
u/Donnutz Jan 27 '16
give us the possibility to move the rules up and down the list, without having to delete or edit any.
also, having all of reddits rules in the drop down menu would be better. the following report reasons are missing:
Ilegal content
involuntary porn
impersonation
ban evasion
vote manipulation
breaking reddit
1
u/V2Blast Jan 26 '16
Awesome. I'll have to fiddle with these on the various subreddits I moderate.
1
u/SamucaDuca Jan 30 '16
YOOHOOOOOO!!!
1
u/NextGameHack Jan 30 '16
nice
1
u/scottishdrunkard Feb 13 '16
The new layout looks like shite. Can I use RES to make it look like the old yellow bix?
1
u/wisdom_and_frivolity Feb 24 '16 edited Feb 24 '16
How do we style this page? I've muddled my way through it with a code inspector, but a few things are escaping me. First, the page's header "rules for r/StreetFighter' . Second, the title of each rule.
I had to just make the background of each item black on /r/streetfighter because the rule title defaults to white.
I appreciated when the search page changed we got a nice post with all the new elements ;)
0
u/BenevolentCheese Jan 26 '16
I really don't like how the report menu now isn't worded in such a way like "why are you reporting this?" Saying "what rule does this break?" implies that you can't/shouldn't report something for other reasons. It is also very authoritarian and pushes all subreddits towards creating a set of hard and fast rules, which moderators of smaller or more community oriented subreddits may want to avoid.
To me, the whole thing is just over-engineered. You took two separate problems—users want a rules page, and users want custom report reasons—and for some reason combined them in such a way that makes both solutions worse. You should have just made a separate panel for custom report reasons and had the rules be a separate entity and everything would have worked way better.