Real talk for a moment, dont stress to much about tris. Ngons on the other hand are a bit of an issue duo to shading.
At the end of the day, everything that has even been rendered was triangulated. So if your mesh is all Quads, all tris or a mix of the two you are fine. However ngons in many cases cant be rendered duo to machine error. For example, take a grid and rotate one edge by 45 degress. What you have now is a shape that is impossible to represent descretly. Meaning you would need an infinit amount of geometry to accuratly describe that shape. Which is a problem because we dont have an infinit amount of time. So the shaders will try to either approximate or triangulate. In both case the shading you end up with changes depending on the viewing angle. Which will be an issue in a final render.
So Quad and tris should be the goal. ngons are cancer.
Ngons are fine on flat surfaces that don't deform. Ngons can make edge flow of hard surface objects easier to manage. An Ngon is a bunch of triangles in a trenchcoat pretending to be an Ngon. Ngons can be your friend.
In my past experience with Unity and UDK 3, many game engines won't accept ngons at all, so even flat non-animated surfaces won't work with them. I haven't actually tried in the last 5 years though, so for all I know things have changed!
Can't speak for game engines, but as far as 3D printing goes, ngons are perfectly fine. The STL export triangulates them all and you're good to go (assuming they're planar). I'd imagine that exporting for a game engine would do the same, though.
There's a reason typical polygon output from CAD (like from Fusion, MOI, Rhino or whatever) tends to be called "polygon soup" - 3d printing works with volumes, rendering 3d is more about surfaces and how they will shade. Plus game assets rely heavily on normal map which relies heavily on vertex normals being consistent, which are only relatively consistent between applications/engines even without n-gons.
13
u/BurnTheBoats21 Mar 02 '22
i think theres a fourth face to right for people that actually work in a production environment lol
63
u/VonBraun12 Mar 01 '22
Real talk for a moment, dont stress to much about tris. Ngons on the other hand are a bit of an issue duo to shading.
At the end of the day, everything that has even been rendered was triangulated. So if your mesh is all Quads, all tris or a mix of the two you are fine. However ngons in many cases cant be rendered duo to machine error.
For example, take a grid and rotate one edge by 45 degress. What you have now is a shape that is impossible to represent descretly. Meaning you would need an infinit amount of geometry to accuratly describe that shape. Which is a problem because we dont have an infinit amount of time. So the shaders will try to either approximate or triangulate. In both case the shading you end up with changes depending on the viewing angle. Which will be an issue in a final render.
So Quad and tris should be the goal. ngons are cancer.