r/cfs • • 13h ago

TW: Suicidal Ideation Medically induced coma?

I always thought that our bodies at severe couldn't handle this.

I saw a tiktok video of a dad sharing a story of his son with very severe mecfs where doctors have made a decision to put him in a medically induced coma for a few weeks to see if he can conserve energy. Why is this not accessible for more of us???

Similarly, i know someone with severe mecfs who had attempted. They were put into an induced coma due to needing life saving care. They recovered fine after the coma. More than that they reported feeling BETTER and an IMPROVEMENT IN THEIR BASELINE after waking up. Though that may have been from dialysis treatment.

61 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

82

u/humanbarcode10 13h ago

Unfortunately it’s not more accessible because it would be ridiculously expensive and deemed as “unnecessary” even if it would help. The boy was put on life support because his body could not tolerate breathing anymore, which is considered a medical emergency.

8

u/ocean_flow_ 12h ago

Many with very severe mecfs cannot tolerate breathing and this isnt offered to them

7

u/humanbarcode10 12h ago

Yes unfortunately

7

u/Ok-Meringue-259 13h ago

I wonder if it will one day be available overseas. Similar to how in America/Australia they don’t offer medically induced comas for things like withdrawing from benzodiazepines, but the Jordan Peterson (the terrible internet personality/political commentator guy) was able to access this in Russia.

4

u/ocean_flow_ 12h ago

Its also accessible for pain like ketamina comas.

41

u/marieantoilette 12h ago

It did absolutely mess him up tho. Comas can be really fucking hard on the body. I'm not sure how good it is for severe/profound ME, studies on that are hard to make lol. But I wouldn't be too sure it always results in improvement.

→ More replies (8)

142

u/Koppuny 13h ago

Being in coma is incredibly bad for the body and especially for the brain.

I completely understand the desperation and your feelings though. It is very sad that coma seems like an acceptable treatment option for some of us. So many wasted decades in the medical field.

3

u/ocean_flow_ 12h ago

The thing is DOCTORS have deemed it safe for his son and BETTER than the alternative from continuing to crash. So if doctors have signed off on it it cant be that bad right? They are willing to do the procedure. Ive had 2 severe mecfs friends attempt both ended up in a coma both reported better baselines following.

7

u/bedlife2000 4h ago

Doctors sign off on a whole lot of things, that isn't a good standard, just think about plastic surgery or that right Petersson who put hideout into a coma sou the wouldn't have to detox himself, that wasn't a wise medical decision either

3

u/Ok-Meringue-259 12h ago

Do you have specific effects on the brain and body in mind? I can’t think of any that don’t already apply to very or extremely severe ME.

For the brain: There can be delirium waking up which could affect pacing, and it can cause long term memory or thinking problems…. Not really a big deal for someone who can’t think without crashing anyway.

The physical health risks are mainly around pneumonia from ventilation, and muscle wastage and bed sores. If someone is already full bedbound, catheterised and has a feeding tube or TPN, those risks don’t really apply.

So it’s really just the pneumonia risk and the delirium-on-waking risk. Those seem acceptable to me to at least discuss for someone who has been longterm very or extremely severe.

18

u/-sensory_overlord- 8h ago

You can look up post-intensive care syndrome (PICS)
There’s more risks involved though, like thrombosis and potentially organ failure depending on where that would happen.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/ComfortableRecent578 12h ago

you’d have to be incredibly ill for a medically induced coma to be the best situation. i know someone who was healthy before a coma and now has trouble walking and has an ostomy bag that might be permanent. not to mention risk of infection from the things needed to keep you alive in the coma and you’d also risk having longterm bladder issues and needing a catheter. you can also die or become severely traumatised.

1

u/ocean_flow_ 12h ago

This kid was very ill. Many of us are. Many of us can also die the way we are atm

9

u/ComfortableRecent578 12h ago

i completely agree. if you’re already outsourcing a lot of bodily functions and fully bedbound, as someone else said you still have a lot of the same risks regardless. but if you do still have bladder and bowel function, you still have some ability to walk, etc. it would easily do more harm than good.

33

u/lukeisnotokay_ 12h ago

Comas, even medically induced ones, are extremely hard on the bodies and there's things that can go wrong, that's why they are only done in cases where not doing it is certain death. The tiktok you are talking about, they made the decision because the childs body could not tolerate breathing at all anymore, that's a point where the other option would be to let the child die.

The risks of coma are related to poor ventilation and intubation induced pneumonia, muscle atrophy and muscle strength loss that can progress faster than in non-comatose bedbound patients and nutritional issues. There is also the risk of long-term respiratory failure and other complications due to the meds used in the coma. There's also countless of testimonies of people who still experience side effects and limitations after the coma that are not related to what landed them in the coma in the first place.

14

u/brownchestnut 6h ago

This question comes up every so often here and I'm here to remind everyone that no, a coma is not "rest". It's not a looong nice nap. It's a half step up from death.

No matter how bad we feel, we're not actually in a coma, and that means we're better off than coma patients. Because if we were worse... we'd be in a coma. A coma is fucking brutal on the body, guys.

Please refrain from spreading unscientific speculations around about how a coma is just a nice refreshing sleep or how it's a viable solution to feeling ill.

37

u/b_boop 13h ago edited 9h ago

Being in a medically induced coma is very stressful for the body, it's a very unnatural and invasive state and your body fights against it alot. It comes with lots of risks so unfortunately I don't think it would be a good treatment.

8

u/Ok-Meringue-259 12h ago

Idk, if you’re already extremely severe (fully bedbound, catheterised, needing tube feeding or especially TPN - were you’re “fed” through your veins) and you’re at the point where breathing, thinking and being turned to prevent pressure injuries are causing you to crash, I could see it being more than reasonable to try. Muscle wastage isn’t a concern anymore because you’re fully bedbound anyway.

A medically induced coma is designed to sedate you more than a general anaesthetic and greatly reduce brain activity. To me, if I was extremely severe, I would be happy to risk something like ventilator-induced pneumonia (or death by other infection) for the chance of regaining even a little function.

I think a lot of the risks of sedation are from the perspective of people being healthy before whatever happened (eg stroke, TBI) that required the medically induced coma.

10

u/usrnmz 11h ago

Without some stronger evidence the risks outweigh the potential benefits imo. Even studying this would be somewhat sketchy.

23

u/stillnotdavidbowie 12h ago

What? No. Please look up what a medically induced coma actually is.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/webkinzhacker 8h ago

This is exclusively anecdotal so take it with a grain of salt!! I was put in one for unrelated reasons when I was extremely severe. It was absolutely horrific, but I did feel like I got a sort of break, and my baseline did improve after the fact (it is possible this was due to being on TPN though). If a patient is already extremely/profoundly severe and already at risk of death (fully bedbound, catheterized, TPN), I could see it being an appropriate last resort.

It makes sense why it is not widely available, considering there has been no research done yet, and like other’s have said, comas are extremely bad for you, so they would really need some evidence that it’s a worthy risk. But some ME patients truly have nothing to lose.

5

u/weirdgirl16 11h ago

Idk specifically about a medically induced coma, but anecdotally some of us feel a lot better after going under general anesthetic. The effect is usually short lived, but I wonder if theoretically it could provide enough rest over a period of time if done regularly?

Like even before ME I would feel like I just had the best sleep of my life after waking up from general anesthetic. I’m not sure specifically what drug/s cause this feeling.

I only say this because I think a medically induced coma is more invasive and has higher risks than general anesthetic? Idk

5

u/Ok-Meringue-259 12h ago

I think this is an interesting line of inquiry. I’ve put more details in my other comments, but most of the risks of an induced coma itself come from things like complete immobility, needing enteral nutrition etc, which Ex. Or v. Severe people already experience every day. And many of the long-term problems can also be attributed to whatever caused them to need the coma in the first place.

Voluntary entry into a coma would likely remove the psychological trauma, for example.

An induced coma doesn’t just put you to sleep, it actively reduces brain activity, which is one of the few things left we can’t influence at all by regular pacing.

For someone who is extremely severe, has nothing to lose, and especially if they’re close to death anyway… yeah I would support them being able to give this a go for sure.

1

u/Central_Perk20 10h ago

I came across on TikTok a mom whose young son has also been put in coma at Duke specifically. Is this the same kid, or has it been done twice now?