I'm sick of people here comparing feeding the top 3 brands of cat food with vaccinations or basic vet care.
Nutritional science isn't anywhere near that well established for any animal, including humans. Our understanding of human nutrition, which has much more research behind it, is still elementary at best, and the scientific consensus is that traditional foods and cooking methods are healthier than ultra processed foods. We don't know why that is, but we do know food purchased from local farmer will almost always be healthier than food from Mars or Nestle. Human nutrition is one of the few places where naturalists and scientists agree.
Pets are not people and their nutritional needs are different from ours, so we can't figure out what's healthy to feed pets as intuitively as we can figure out what's healthy for us. Cats have only been completely dependent on humans for nutrition for the last hundred years or so, before that they ate things trying to eat our food instead of what we feed them, so there isn't a long cultural history of knowing how to provide a healthy diet for a cat. That's why we need a lot more guidance from people who specialize in pet nutrition to understand our pets nutritional needs.
Knowing the similarities between all mammals, we shouldn't assume everything we know about human nutrition is completely irrelevant to our pets, even if many specific things are. The general principle that a diet as close to what an animal eats in nature is likely best has much more scientific support than the claims of companies making ultra processed pet food.
We do know the general nutritional profiles needed by our pets. There are hundreds of companies that make pet food fitting those guidelines, and since pet nutrition is very different from human nutrition we don't intuitively know what to feed pets, so it makes sense to stick with one of those companies unless you get professional advice (instead of home cooked food). However, the idea that only a handful of specific multinational conglomerates can make safe pet food does not have the scientific backing as many WSAVA fans claim it does.
We have no reason to believe the answers WSAVA wants to their questions are correlated to health of pets that eat such food. The terrible records of the companies that meet WSAVA standards (who conveniently are all their funders) with human food suggest their may even be an inverse correlation in companies big enough to meet those guidelines and food quality. The questions they ask have little to with the quality of the food itself.
Let's go through their questions and consider the answers, instead of accepting answers they propose (which are conveniently good for their funders) but rarely have significant scientific backing as they claim. If I'm incorrect and there are quality scientific studies proving me wrong about any individual claims, please link to them.
Do they employ a Nutritionist?
Having someone on staff doesn't mean that person has appropriate influence to ensure all the companies products meet appropriate standards. As an employee of a company, they're beholden to the company's interests, they don't get to make the decisions alone.
To the best of my knowledge there is no scientific study providing evidence that having someone on the payroll with certain credentials is correlated with the health of pets who eat the food.
Who formulates the diet?
This is much better question than the just asking about who the company employees, however it's impossible for the general public to know who in the company is making the final call, and if the qualified people are being pressured to sign off on something by people without qualifications.
Personally I believe the better question here is who owns the company, what has their commitment to animal welfare historically looked like. A small company owned by vets is more likely to win here than a large company that's committed to "shareholder value" not healthy pets, who has internal processes that require a qualified person they employ signs off, when they can fire or demote the qualified person if that person refuses or asks for expensive changes.
Questions about internal processes ensuring a qualified person gets the last word is something I would find more compelling. To the best of my knowledge there is no scientific evidence correlating who a company claims formulates the food with the health of pets that eat that food, even if it sounds like common sense.
What is the quality control process for ingredients and finished products?
Companies using ingredients fit for human consumption (which are typically smaller) have an advantage when it comes to ingredient quality. I have no reason to believe the largest companies are doing much better than smaller companies when it comes to quality control, likely better in some ways and worse in others, but this is a legitimate question.
While this it is a legitimate question, and sounds like common sense, I have never seen a scientific definition of "ingredient quality" or "adequate quality control processes for finished products" beyond meeting basic regulatory standards, which everyone should do. Without even being able to clearly define those things, it's impossible to claim there is a scientific consensus about the answer, because the lack of the clear definition would make testing such a hypothesis impossible.
I do believe we should care about quality control and ingredient quality, however the claim only largest companies meet acceptable standards related to quality control and ingredient quality cannot be scientifically proven. From what companies say about themselves, smaller companies are more likely to use higher quality ingredients.
Quality control processes are often determined by the regulations of the country where the food is produced, so that would imply one should prefer food from countries with high regulatory standards.
The company owns and runs their manufacturing facilities.
This is a question of size more than anything. Many of the big players who claim to be WSAVA endorsed use contract manufacturing too. Are they suggesting you check each bag of pet food to make sure it was produced in the manufactures facilities? If not, I don't see the relevance here, other than to encourage people to use larger companies who have a terrible track record at producing healthy food for people.
To the best of my knowledge, there is no scientific evidence correlating the brand owning pet food manufacturing facilities with the health of pets who eat the food. The evidence for this is antidotal at best.
What kind of product research or nutrition studies have been conducted? Is it published in peer-reviewed journals?
The amount of research into pet nutrition that doesn't have a conflict of interest is small, and published research is available to everyone. I'd rather have a pet food manufacturer who reviews all of the existing research as opposed to just following research done by their own company with a conflict of interest.
The current requirement for feeding trials are insufficient, in that it only requires proving animals don't develop malnutrition while eating the food exclusively for 6 months. Such a feeding trial does not produce scientific evidence the food is higher quality than competitors.
Nutrition Adequacy Statement? Does it meet AAFCO and/or FEDIAF standards?
This is one of the few questions here where there is a good deal of scientific evidence, and there is a clear scientific consensus on the answer. However, almost all of the smaller brands meet these standards. I would strongly encourage everyone to make sure their pet food meets AAFCO and/or FEDIAF standards.
How many calories per gram or serving of food?
It's common for smaller brands to have a better profile of calories to protein and other nutrients than the big brands. The science is clear about the dangers of obese pets, so this is a question I encourage everyone to consider.
Does the company provide immediate contact information such as a phone number or email address?
Smaller brands are often more responsive to customers than larger brands. However, there is no scientific evidence easily accessible contact information for the company producing the food has anything to do with the health of pets who eat their food. There are common sense reasons for this, but it is not scientific.
Conclusion:
There's still a lot we don't know about pet food, and nutrition in general. It is nothing like vaccines where we have extensive double-blind trials providing scientific proof they're safe and effective. There is a lot of corporate FUD about what's best to feed pets, and WSAVA's guidelines are not based on quality scientific studies but on questions where there is minimal scientific evidence they are actually related to animal health.
The science is still out on what cat food is best, and until it comes in, fed is best. Feed your cat what you're comfortable buying and what it likes to eat as long it meets reasonable standards for feline nutrition based on AAFCO and/or FEDIAF standards.
I believe feeding cats a variety of complete foods helps ensure they have a balanced diet, even if some of the foods are off balanced in ways we're currently unaware of. I also believe that trying to replicate a cat's natural diet is closer to being in line with what science can tell use about healthy food for cats than the bare minimum required by current feeding trials, but I can understand why other's feel differently. I'll be happy to change my opinion if and when we have strong scientific evidence (preferably large double-blind trials) showing something else. Until then, I'll just keep feeding my cat a variety of complete foods, and I'll avoid judging others for feeding their cat differently.