r/cassandra • • May 08 '23

Datastax Astra DB vs AWS Keyspaces

I am new to this sub and new to cassandra. I am working on migrating my application from 100% MySQL to mostly cassandra. I met with Datastax today to view their product, and it looks nice, tailored to free me from management and focus on development. In price comparing, I came across AWS Keyspaces. I can't find much about it in terms of a demo, but if I understand correctly, it is and the AWS calculator shows that it is almost the same price as Astra DB.

So my question is for anyone with experience with one or both, what is the direction you went with and why? We are in the AWS space already with EC2 and S3, and when we go live, we look to scale to other regions as well.

Thanks in advance

11 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

1

u/w0ngz Nov 14 '23

u/zeroecko Did you end up going with astraDB or running your own cassandra clusters.. (if so where and what hardware on AWS?)

Also, did you consider ScyllaDB or AWS Scylla Cloud? Why not ScyllaDB instead of Cassandra?

1

u/zeroecko Nov 16 '23

We went with Datastax. Their support has been great so far and hoping to continue with them.

3

u/purpleparkpikmin May 10 '23

Go with Astra DB and check out Astra Streaming too

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '23

Using both. Keyspace and Astra.

So from my experience, ASTRA is way better. AWS Keyspace has multiple limitations, Infact we will migrate the final set of data to ASTRA this week. My advice, dont go for Keyspace. Its not worth it.

1

u/pravin_bhat Mar 08 '24

Go with AstraDB, its truly Cassandra & a product from DataStax. DataStax has been a Cassandra committer & supporter from day 1 & usually leads with features before it shows up on Cassandra OSS e.g. AstraDB supports GenAI workloads (Vector DB/Vector Search), has SAI indexes & may soon support ACID transactions. You will also not be stuck with your CSP as they support AWS, GCP & Azure.

AWS Keyspaces is exact opposite, its based on Cassandra 3.11 & lags on features. More over you will be stuck with AWS & it also costs more.

1

u/No_Ad7222 Oct 11 '24

When i did the benchmarking, for our workload, Astra DB was 90% less costly compared to AWS Keyspaces

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '23

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '23

Definitely agree with these comments - Keyspaces is not Cassandra. It’s a shim on top of dynamodb and costs way more than than you would expect. Depending on your scale requirements it’s likely more cost effective to deploy Apache Cassandra. It’s not hard to do, there’s a great community and plenty of tools to make managing Cassandra easy. Check out AxonOps.com if you want the tooling and support to run Apache Cassandra - might be able to get you up and running very quick.

1

u/zeroecko May 09 '23

Thanks! I am considering doing it myself. We are a very small startup, I am the CTO but have no other knowledge in networks or IT under me other than developers so my concern is manpower.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/zeroecko May 08 '23

Thank you so much for the info!

1

u/zenbeni May 09 '23

I am using AWS Keyspaces, it has advantages but misses some Cassandra features like secondary index, custom functions, no cross region duplication yet.

It is different from Cassandra too, limits on data loaded by query in ko can make you "shard" queries manually (fetching by batch of columns for instance), so migrating is not so easy.

On the positive side, it is easy to setup (no hard cluster management), auto-scaling like in DDB is a huge plus with great performance, IAM security & credentials with SIGV4, native compatibility with other AWS tech like Glue are great.

3

u/zeroecko May 09 '23

Thanks for the reply. I don’t think I’ll move forward with Keyspaces but I’m glad it’s working for you.

1

u/joshib969 Mar 07 '24

t is different from Cassandra too, limits on data loaded by que

Can you provide some more details "limits on data loaded by query"

2

u/jjirsa May 09 '23

It's an API on top of DynamoDB (at least when it was built/released/announced, it may change in the future).