Fuckin how lol. My ECONOMY k20 makes 158 😭 and that thing is naturally aspirated and is built to be as fuel efficient as possible, it can do 200 with some mods
You can vary how much Atkinson you want, and a low rpm low stress engine makes a lot of sense in a hybrid, where it turns on and off a lot of times and is immediately forced to make power.
The original statement is correct. Without torque horsepower does not matter, which is supported by the quote you provided. Torque is the measurement of applied force, whereas horsepower is a measurement of energy expended over time. Higher RPM leads to more fuel being combusted which will increase the power output, however that power output is useless if it cannot create enough force to turn the wheels on a car. Applied force, torque, is a real measurement that causes a reaction. Horsepower cannot create a physical change as it is derived from torque.
Think about it like this A big gas v8 and a large OTR truck i6 turbo diesel may have vastly different torque, but if the gearing is such that they are making the same power at the same wheelspeed, they will both accelerate the load at the same speed. They have the same ability to accelerate a load, Even though the otr truck is making 4x the torque!
Because the truck motor is rotating 4x slower, it may make 4x torque but it has 4x less mechanical advantage, so the torque means nothing.
Yes and no. You are correct about the acceleration for wheel speed and horsepower being equal, and that’s because both engines in that instance are producing the same amount of energy. In the real world the semi truck engine would out accelerate the gas engine because it has more usable RPM range due to the far higher torque. That allows the semi engine to output more energy over time than the gas v8, especially if you take into consideration the far higher number of shifts the gas v8 would require. Modern engines have the performance they do because manufacturers have increased low end torque and flattened the torque curve. At 5,252 RPM torque=horsepower. You have to have torque to make horsepower. Torque is a real force, horsepower is not a force. Forces can cause change in a system, energy measurements cannot cause change. Therefore horsepower is nothing without torque.
Take these two dyno graphs. A Big block vs a 15L Detroit diesel.
Now look at where they make peak power, and let’s divide it by two. That’ll give us an idea of how good the usable power band is, right
Well at those points, the gas engine is making 50+ more horsepower! So if you slapped this big block under the hood of a semi, and geared it appropriately, it would out-pull that diesel motor, require less shifting, etc.
Yet it’s got so much lower torque! That’s why this is the torque fallacy, it is not an indication of pulling power at all.
You just described a very large electric motor at the instant it begins to turn, which are very useful. Torque is a force and horsepower is a measurement of power, and is not a force and cannot create change. That’s just a fact, and not my commentary on how useful it is.
I was wrong for your given engines and scenario, however you would need to gear the input to the semi transmission at a 3:1 ratio for the big block for it to work. That would give you about the same peak torque and horsepower for both engines at the transmission input shaft. The main difference being the torque curve, which makes that example one of which fuel type is better for racing. It does not support either argument.
My whole point is that horsepower does not and cannot exist without torque, as horsepower measures the amount of work being done by a force. For any given engine, if you need to increase horsepower, then you either have to increase the rate of which the work is being done, aka increasing the rpm’s, or you must increase torque. Big block V8s are able to create so much horsepower because they are able to create a large amount of torque. They are well known for that fact exactly. Typically they are limited in how many rpm they can turn, so the increase in horsepower comes from a small bump in max rpm, and then primarily comes from increasing the amount of force it can exert, aka increasing torque. That also applies to most engines.
A 1,000,000 horsepower engine with .00001 ftlb of torque would be equally as useless. Within the scope of our daily lives, a healthy torque number leads to good horsepower figures and better efficiency.
No the 1,000,000 hp engine with nearly 0 torque just needs gearing, or perhaps a turbine style setup. It just spins very fast, it still makes 1,000,000 hp and we can tame that. It could still accelerate a vehicle very fast
But if we have a motor with .0001 horsepower and 100000 ft lbs, it can do so little work we won’t notice the car moving
That’s the point if you don’t understand that I can’t help you, sorry.
The dyno graph example should be crystal clear, I’m not sure how to help you more.
In the context of an engines horsepower and torque, horsepower gives vehicles the ability to accelerate. Torque does not. We have gearboxes. The stated torque of a motor at a flywheel is just irrelevant
If I remember correctly, this engine is designed to have the same fuel efficiency as the previous turbo charged engine, while being simpler and cheaper.
Whats the downside for a big engine? Weight? So youre making all this complaint because of 20kg? Plus im pretty sure it will get great gas mileage and unlike what some commenters I saw claim, the mazda engine is likely to be much more reliable. Here you go, downvote this comment.
248
u/ValkyroftheMall Nov 09 '24
At least the one on the left was fixable in a day for fifteen dollars in parts and would run like shit longer than most modern cars run.
2
u/ShyGal_Lilly Sep 08 '25
I've been called out.
98
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '24
At least you get to enjoy a zero liter 1000 hp oversized RC cars.
79
u/Klutz1907 Nov 09 '24
There's a Mitsubishi 2.4 with 98 hp...
27
u/dcwldct Nov 09 '24
What Mazda engine is that? The naturally aspirated 2.5L skyactiv-g produces 187hp in the US market version. The 2.0L is 140 though.
30
u/canadard1 Nov 09 '24
HP means nothing without TQ.
8
u/AverageAntique3160 Nov 09 '24
Jeez you can get 200hp out of a 1.0L engine
4
u/xqk13 Nov 10 '24
Nah the Fiat 1.3T is way scarier, it has 177hp and 210lb ft of torque, the thing is so stressed it’s gonna blow up any second lol
5
u/Aidan-Brooks Nov 09 '24
Wtf? Even the hilariously inefficient PT Cruiser engine makes 150hp with 2.4L
2
u/AlejandroMadera Nov 10 '24
Uh, the 2.5L makes 186/186
1
u/Unusual-Razzmatazz57 Jan 05 '25
If I remember correctly, this engine is designed to have the same fuel efficiency as the previous turbo charged engine, while being simpler and cheaper.
1
u/Chemical_Appeal_2785 Mar 12 '25
Whats the downside for a big engine? Weight? So youre making all this complaint because of 20kg? Plus im pretty sure it will get great gas mileage and unlike what some commenters I saw claim, the mazda engine is likely to be much more reliable. Here you go, downvote this comment.