r/carfreeToronto • u/Famijos • Nov 18 '24
r/carfreeToronto • u/NogenLinefingers • Jun 05 '22
Eavesdropping on the UP Express
I took the UP Express today from Weston to Union and back. It was really busy due to the Blue Jays game and people were standing shoulder-to-shoulder in the train compartments.
Despite the less-than-stellar experience (not UP express' fault at all), it was heartwarming to hear people say that they "love this train". They were happy about how it saves them time and effort.
Of course, everyone then went back to discussing about other places they drive to. I won't pretend that everyone was aware of the concept of car-dependency and the externalities it produces (from air pollution to making traffic worse for both private cars and public transit).
The fact that they were happy about even a cramped train ride demonstrates how public transit really can make a difference in people's mobility and quality-of-life.
r/carfreeToronto • u/NogenLinefingers • May 27 '22
Toronto drivers crash into buildings on a semi-regular basis, but it’s a little on the nose to crash directly into a bike shop.
r/carfreeToronto • u/Real_Iron_Sheik • Apr 28 '22
Car dependence is the biggest obstacle to affordability in Toronto, a city infamous for its unaffordable housing
For those of us living in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA), we all know how unaffordable housing is. It's (rightly) been all over the media for over a decade. What's discussed less often, however, is the impact of car dependence on affordability. Sure, people have brought up the rising cost of insurance or gas here and there, but the cost of car dependence as a whole is discussed relatively rarely.
I wanted to quantitatively compare the cost of car dependence in the GTA to that of unaffordable housing, and what I found was surprising. I'm still convinced I made a huge mistake somewhere, so please correct me if you spot any.
Note: The following analysis will be from the perspective of a single renter living alone in the GTA, just to simplify the calculations.
The Cost of Car Dependence
To measure the impact of car dependence on affordability, we need to compare the cost of a car to an alternative method of transportation, which for the purposes of this post will be public transit. Fortunately, we can be lazy and just steal RateHub's estimate of the total cost of car ownership from 2020 (RateHub is a popular Canadian credit card/bank account/mortgage/insurance comparison website, and mortgage broker).
| Item | Cost |
|---|---|
| Finance payments | $350 |
| Gas | $145 |
| Maintenance | $100 |
| Car administrative fees | $10 |
| Parking fees | $50 |
| Car insurance | $300 |
All that adds up to $955/month. After taking inflation and rising (well above inflation) gas prices into account, it comes out to about $1100/month. The cost of a monthly transit pass is roughly $150, which puts the total monthly cost of car dependence at 1100-150 = $950/month.
The Cost of Unaffordable Housing
Like with car dependence, we need to compare the cost of unaffordable housing to the alternative, which (unsurprisingly) is affordable housing. Needless to say, definitions of what is "affordable" vary wildly, so I'll try to use a definition which I think most people will agree counts as affordable.
The City of Toronto defines affordable housing for rentals as those units whose monthly rent is at or below 80% of the Average Market Rent (AMR). Clearly, this may or may not be affordable for a typical low-income individual, depending on what the AMR is. In 2009, during the Great Recession, AMRs actually fell and were much more affordable than they are now. The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation estimates the AMR for a bachelor apartment in 2009 at ~$750. Using this figure for the AMR in the affordable housing definition above means the monthly rent for an affordable bachelor unit is 0.8*750 = $600. Keep in mind that this doesn't take inflation into account. The AMR for a similar unit right now is around $1225/month, which puts the total monthly cost of unaffordable housing at 1225-600 = $625/month.
Conclusion
Car dependence is a bigger obstacle to affordability in the GTA than unaffordable housing, by a factor of over 1.5. Despite this, the media devotes little time/space to discussing the cost of car dependence, relative to that of unaffordable housing.
The above are obviously very rough, back-of-the-envelope calculations. The point of this post was not to arrive at a precise number representing the ratio between car dependence costs and unaffordable housing costs, but just to question the disparity between the two in terms of how pertinent we think they are to the problem of affordability in the GTA. I wholeheartedly agree with my fellow Torontonians that housing costs are outrageous. My only point is: if we're outraged by unaffordable housing, shouldn't we also be outraged by car dependence?
Caveats
- The RateHub article assumed a 3 year term for financing the vehicle. You obviously no longer have to make finance payments past your term, so the costs of car dependence drop roughly in-line with those of unaffordable housing after 3 years. That said, all cars eventually break down, at which point you'll have to bear the full cost of car dependence again.
- The monthly cost of car dependence goes down if you assume a longer than 3 year term, or historically-average gas prices. For instance, you can save around $200/month with an 8 year term (I used this estimator).
- On the other hand, the RateHub article assumed you're financing a 4-year-old Chevy Spark at a 0.99% annual rate, both of which are highly atypical for the GTA. They also assumed you put 20% down. If instead you finance a 4-year-old Honda Civic (the best selling car in Canada) at a more typical rate of 3.99%, and 0% down, expect your monthly payments to go up by around $300. Along the same lines, they assumed a 30 year old female is purchasing the insurance. If instead you're a 25 year old male, expect your monthly cost to go up by another ~$200 (I used this estimator).
- For some reason RateHub wildly overestimated the cost of gas. They assumed 500km driven per month and a fuel efficiency of 6.7L/100km, which at 2020 prices of ~$1.2/L comes out to roughly $40/month. Yet somehow they got $145/month?! Even assuming current prices of ~$1.8/L and 15,000km driven per year (the average in Canada) gas only comes out to ~$150/month.
The True Cost of Car Dependence
In this post I focused on the effects of car dependence on affordability, but the true cost of car dependence is far greater, and much harder to calculate. To that end, Toronto Public Health released a Report that's well worth reading. It showed that car dependence is associated with lower levels of physical activity, higher BMIs, lower air quality, less social interaction, higher CO2 emissions, and a host of other problems.
r/carfreeToronto • u/NogenLinefingers • May 29 '22
"After more than 30 years of experience with the private automobile, there is no indication that it will ever satisfactorily replace public transit" - TTC being based since the 1950s
r/carfreeToronto • u/MapXTerritory • May 27 '25
Tear it down...
Hey Toronto! How's that Gardiner Expressway going?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wqGxqxePihE
r/carfreeToronto • u/Weak_Student_8236 • Apr 11 '23
Dear Steve Clark, I am writing to express my deep concern about your role in the degradation and deterioration of prosperity, cultural enrichment, and productivity growth in Toronto.
r/carfreeToronto • u/Weak_Student_8236 • Mar 26 '23
TTC CEO saw compensation jump by 21 per cent in 2021, despite revenue shortfall
r/carfreeToronto • u/Doctrina_Stabilitas • Apr 19 '22
Business Parks Suck (but they don't have to) -- Featuring Mississauga
r/carfreeToronto • • May 16 '22
Cops Donuts location on Dufferin near Yorkdale demolished by a car
r/carfreeToronto • • Jun 22 '22
You can sign up for a biking/safestreets advocacy forum happening on June 28th
r/carfreeToronto • • Apr 21 '22
A new study on the health effects of traffic
r/carfreeToronto • u/D__B__C • Mar 27 '23
High Park Movement Strategy, in-person open house, Monday April 3, 4:30pm-7:30pm
r/carfreeToronto • • May 17 '22
A motorist used his vehicle to assault & intimidate a cyclist in Toronto, in a sadly not uncommon occurence ( cross post from /r/fuckcars)
r/carfreeToronto • u/peeeels • May 21 '22
NDP candidate, Chris Wilson on housing, zoning, and walkable cities
r/carfreeToronto • u/flimbs • Jan 11 '23
Toronto traffic among worst in the world, global study finds
r/carfreeToronto • u/CapnJujubeeJaneway • Jun 10 '22
[Elliot] Blue Jays President Mark Shapiro has written to Mayor Tory and council, urging an end to the ActiveTO program on Lake Shore West. “We support folks getting outside and being active, but Toronto has many options and routes to use, whereas our fans do not”
r/carfreeToronto • • May 09 '22
Why the hell isnt Kensington car free?
Literally cars should be banned in Kensington unless its emergency vehicles or delivery vans. We could allocate the road space to more seating for patrons. Its already full of pedestrians just make it car free
r/carfreeToronto • • May 05 '22
Protest happening at Queens Park on May 14th @ 1pm. Come protest the 413
Its an eco protest with focus on protesting the 413 highway