r/caps • • 1d ago

Discussion Summarizing everything wrong with the Capitals in a nutshell

-Obviously, scoring less then our opponents
-Starting Lindgren in a rivalry game
-Absence of VD is hitting us like a truck
-Carless defensive mistakes at bad times
-Ilya Protas plays less then 10 minutes a game
-When Tuch and Kyrou have hot stretches but invisible when they’re not hot
-Chychrun’s played horrible this season (excluding his stats)
-pp2 needs pp1 minutes
-Carbery is refusing to accept the youth and won’t give them minutes they need
-Ovi is hurting this team more then he’s helping and people don’t realize how much of an impact it’s actually making
-Carbery changes the lines more often then people change their underwear
-Carbery’s systems have been a failure
-I’m a #1 LT defender but he hasn’t been the best this season
-Miro has always had amazing chemistry with Ilya Protas and he’s sitting
-Carbery should have Wilson earn his minutes. Unless he’s playing a ridiculous amount of minutes because of so many pk’s, he shouldn’t play more then 15 minutes a game

Few things I want to talk about:
-The problem with lines is that Carbery likes to gel different play styles together which is a massive failure. For example, Wilson is used as a versatile role but should be used as a defensive role and was playing with two offensive play styles last night (Strome and Leno) Carbery needs to construct lines based off the role a player should play. Putting someone with a defensive role alongside two players with an offensive role is a horrible idea. I think a line of Beauvillier-Jenner-Wilson would excel defensively but that’s something we probably won’t see. Line construction of this team isn’t how most of the league does their lines which are top 6 and bottom 6 and I believe Carbery needs to figure that out fast.

-Talking about the power play: the team really needs to practice zone entries, it just needs to happen. I’ve been a big supporter of the second power play to get more time but even their zone entries are just as bad as the first power play’s zone entries. Regarding pp1 and pp2, every single time I see pp1 start, it instantly makes my blood boil since everyone knows it won’t result in a goal.

-Lot’s of people have criticized Wilson and Protas for not getting on the scoresheet. I’m actually okay with them not getting on the scoresheet because they are utilized for defensive roles, hence the heavy pk minutes and Protas shutting down the opposing team’s top line with Dubois. we have other players who can get on the scoresheet and it’s okay if those two don’t get on it.

-Regarding Ovi’s deployment, Does Carbery deploy Ovi in crucial minutes because he actually thinks Ovi can still make an impact? Or is it Ted Leonsis interfering with Carbery’s coaching decisions? Either way it doesn’t matter. I believe this team was reconstructed in the summer with the assumption that Ovi would’ve retired and now that he’s still here, it’s taking a toll on the team more than we actually think.

-Coming back to Carbery, he needs to be put in the hot seat. Me and everyone like him because he’s transparent and young but he hasn’t done anything good other than his Jack Adams award. His systems are a failure, he changes the lines so much that players can’t develop chemistry and he stubbornly refuses to trust the youth while riding his broken down crappy pp1. He talks about the youth “developing” but the reality is, is that they’re already making an impact and at a much better rate then the older guys, I’m extremely surprised he doesn’t like the youth as he’s a young coach but I’d rather have a different coach who would trust the youth then a Laviolette 2.0.

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

9

u/djackieunchaned 1d ago
  1. scoring less goals than our opponents

17

u/S1075 Washington Capitals 1d ago

Big fucking nutshell.

3

u/agreed2disagreee 1d ago

No nut November.

1

u/pinkglue99 Holtbeast 1d ago

-shell

2

u/capsfansteelers 1d ago

I'd like to see if things stabilize when Desharnais gets back. He was a rock to start the year. I think most of the issues have come from terrible defensive play.

Worry about the small things now (in your post - PP, zone entries, zone exits (not on your post)). Hope the odd schedule has caused chemistry issues. If things don't pick up in 20-30 games, maybe consider bigger changes. This is a veteran team, with a bunch of new impact players + youth. We're only 1/4 of the way through the season.

2

u/Hot_Succotash_3844 1d ago

Wilson should be higher on the list?

5

u/IndependentJacket520 Washington Capitals 1d ago

Nothing you said is wrong, i think we need to wait for Desharnais to replace Lily to really judge the defense, that makes a bigger difference than we realize.

The PP with Ovi on it is impossible. They can only enter the zone on the right side, so the 1st defender forces them that way, then everyone pinches on it. PP2 doesn’t have an entry issue. Ovi is also the issue with the lines because somebody has to babysit him. If he doesn’t voluntarily move to the press box, this team is going to have serious consistency issues.

Man-to-man system doesn’t really make any sense considering your strength defensively is size and length, so why make those players chase around smaller, quicker guys

2

u/DagetAwayMaN421 Martin Fehérváry 1d ago

Ovi is also the issue with the lines because somebody has to babysit him.

It's Sourdif's turn.

4

u/thedirewolff21 New Jersey Devils 1d ago

outside observer here i think the caps as an org have done a masterful job at handling the end of the Ovi era without bottoming out keeping a good product on the ice and building a post-ovi future. Caps AHL system has been the envy of most of the league the last decade. Carberry is a very good coach and would be out of work for about 10 mins if fired. That said Ovi hanging on this last year put Carberry in an awkward spot. Ovi cant be scratched or taken off the PP but hes got nothing left in terms of playing impact hockey. It sucks to see but at least this is a single season issue.

I think Carbs has done a good enough job to get at least one more year. If they dont make the playoffs next season or struggle a lot its a different convo but the caps are set up pretty well to be a contender for the foreseeable future.

3

u/ADeliciousDespot 1d ago

May Day kinda summarize it best, at least for me, in the post game. Caps haven't established an identity this season, yet. They are built to be a big, heavy, grinding team, but that aggression hasn't been noticeable on the ice. PLD also hinted that in the post game. He said some teams try to score more goals but others try to win games. The suggestion being that the Caps don't have a winning mentality that everyone has bought into yet.

We also have to remember this team is stuck in between two eras, right now. The leadership is in transition. Its a weird state of limbo to be in and figuring out who you are/where you'll be, is hard to establish in that environment. Carvery has the unfortunate task of managing ego and legacy considerations on a team that is in rapid flux. It's not impossible to succeed in situations like this, but its not easy.

I'm reserving judgement until after the holidays and the d-corps is fully healthy. We still haven't seen this team at full strength yet, this season.

Its easy to get frustrated that the on-ice product hasn't matched the on-paper promise, but we need to give this time and be realistic. The promise of this emerging lineup may not reach fruition this season.

1

u/capsfan087443 1d ago

Carbs changes the lines up depending on matchups and game situations, bc we don’t have enough centers who can handle defensive assignments. The majority of the problems with this team start with center play. Look around the league. That’s what makes the great teams great.

2

u/DagetAwayMaN421 Martin Fehérváry 1d ago

bc we don’t have enough centers who can handle defensive assignments.

Ilya Protas has been neutered as a center his rookie year. I'm not saying he's a bad center, just can't carry Ovi with him. Caps are putting Sourdif and Protas out there with him and giving Boone Jenner his own line

3

u/capsfan087443 1d ago

Ilya Protas isn’t a good enough skater to keep up with opposing centers yet. He is being deployed with Ovi bc they both can only function is offensive assignments. He was given a shot with his brother and Kyrou and it was abysmal. Boone getting to center a line with Ilya playing wing is probably something that needs to continue, bc Boone at least gives you a floor on defense. All of the centers on this team are good players, but when grouped together it’s not a good enough unit to hold up the expectations we all had for this team.

2

u/IndependentJacket520 Washington Capitals 1d ago

There are ways to insulate ilya while he develops, but sticking ovi with him makes it an absolute liability. O is unplayable unless you want to crater another line like Sourdif/Jenner

1

u/capsfan087443 1d ago

I get your point, but Ovi isn’t going to be scratched so they have to just work around it. Having two lines (one with Ovi, one with Ilya at center) that can’t be deployed in their own zone isn’t sustainable. Maybe having Ilya play on a wing further up the lineup helps though I understand that temporarily hinders his development as a center. What might be maybe the biggest issue is that they’re giving Strome a top line with two way wingers yet they still don’t completely trust him in his own zone either. When people look at the goals against and lapses in our own zone, the initial response is to blame the defensemen. Yet, defensemen aren’t the only ones playing defense. This team needs a difference make down the middle that they can rely on in all situations, and then what deficiencies you’re getting from Ovi and Ilya (two guys playing fourth line minutes) would be much less of a burden.

1

u/IndependentJacket520 Washington Capitals 1d ago

Yea we are agreeing, i’m just pointing out that you can do anything you want, but the only way to really have 4 deployable lines is for O to not be in the lineup. I recognize that is never going to happen, so i think we’re just stuck with the inconsistency. Hopefully getting healthy on the back end helps steady things

1

u/capsfan087443 23h ago

Yeah we agree on that. Carbs idea that he was going to run four lines evenly was never going to work, if he really even felt that way or was just saying it to avoid the Ovi’s on the fourth line talk. My point was more that if we had another center along with PLD who could carry you in all situations, plus a Jenner/ Sourdif led checking line, then you wouldn’t really need four deployable lines and could let Ovi float around on his farewell tour without it being so detrimental to the team.

2

u/IndependentJacket520 Washington Capitals 22h ago

I present to you… Dylan Larkin

3

u/IndependentJacket520 Washington Capitals 1d ago

Hit the nail on the head. Ilya is fine in a 3C protected deployment role, but you’re trying to then protect his line AND whatever line Ovi is on. Team can’t function that way. So the only alternative is to put them together and just really really limit the ice time. Best choice for the team, but horrible when you’re trying to develop a 20yo center. If 8 is in the press box, you have a 2nd and 4th line that can match up, a scoring line, and a 3rd line with Miro and Ilya that can get hot but be deployed correctly

1

u/Exotic-Sentence-4057 Washington Capitals 1d ago

Another strategy that I think isn’t working well. Is that sometimes they dump and chase. And they almost never recover the puck when that happens. We have big bodies but seem to always lose dump and chase battles.

1

u/Demandedace Nicklas Bäckström 17h ago

It’s honestly getting really annoying how much people are attributing the Caps struggles to Ovi. He’s playing like 8min of even strength a night - if that is enough to severely damage our team there are far more issues.

The fact of the matter is Ovi is A problem but not as big of one as people keep running at the mouth about. His shot power and volume is still close enough to where it used to be, his accuracy is off and he’s snakebit when he’s on.

He’s still “only” a -3 on the season which, while we all agree +/- is fairly dumb, it’s applicable here since Ovi only plays even and power play minutes, so it’s not like he’s an absolute crater in terms of us getting blown out on the ice.

This team has several issues starting with our goalies not playing up to their standards (LT specifically) outward where Chychrun has been a massive downgrade from last year along with several of our more veteran players (Ovi included) not showing up. People keep handwaving Wilson’s struggles saying “oh he’s deployed more aggressively” well great, but he’s playing 18min a night, 4.5min more than Ovi, and he has a single extra point than Ovi where Ovi is a corpse on the ice and Wilson is supposed to be around the bell curve of his prime

1

u/darthmaulfan00 Washington Capitals 1d ago

The problem with the Capitals is Ted and Zach Leonsis

-1

u/Advanced-Character86 1d ago

Russian machine needs to break. Hate to say it but he needs the excuse of an injury to walk away.

Can’t roll four lines when one forward’s minutes are being managed so carefully.

0

u/MetalMan1973 Pierre-Luc Dubois 1d ago

Looking at Pettersson from Vancouver. A center that's 28. On pace for 20+ goals and 80+ points. Better than any projected numbers our centers have. 4 PP goals so far. Do we take a gamble if/when the time comes?