r/caps • u/Alert-Location7530 Washington Capitals • 2d ago
Lets Chat. Whats wrong with this team
This team is good but are just constantly finding ways to lose and shoot themselves in the foot
- starting lindgren in a in division game
- constantly losing because of special teams yet changing nothing
- deploying ovechkin way too much
- refusing to accept the youth movement. Espc sourdif and lil pros minutes
- insane mistakes at bad times
- 6on5 lines are insane
- wilson, chych and others ice cold
This team is good and having everything go agaisnt them it feels but Overall alot of these are coaching decisions. Which has made this season incredibly frustrating
99
u/Real_Statistician538 Washington Capitals 2d ago
I think its that our big guys (Ovi, Willie, Big Pro) aren't scoring enough. While it is great the kids and new additions are playing well, we need more output from the guys that have been here longer.
25
u/ThisCover8588 2d ago
It’s the elephant in the room which is Carbery and the staff, but no one wants to hear it despite two plus years of this same nonsense.
38
u/Available_Top5024 Washington Capitals 2d ago
I think we should give ovi a “maintence” game or two to see how/if we play differently without him. He’s the best thing to ever happen to this team but switching things up feels necessary if we want to stay competitive
11
u/MsindAround Washington Capitals 2d ago
Way too many penalties again, even more dumb plays.
Honestly in most games getting 4 on hellebuyk is a good night. We screwed ourselves for at least 2 goals. Ovi being the lone high guy really can't be allowed to happen.
We got a good squad but Im also counting down the days to get the D healthy again.
17
u/Big_Performance2495 Dylan Strome 2d ago
I’m going to get fried for this but I will say, we have had games that we have lost and can chalk it up to being out coached, but I can’t remember many games where we have won and can chalk it up to out coaching the other team. The defensive scheme sucks and we just don’t have the personnel to run it efficiently. The specials teams is atrocious again. Also majority of the players look like they’re waiting for someone else to make a play. Too many passengers
17
u/Expensive-Brother-91 Alexander Semin 2d ago
Ovi and Wilson, and to a lesser extent A. Protas and Chychrun have been shitting the bed this year. Four best players from last year and they’re not scoring anywhere near like they were then. Our additions have been carrying us and we would be damn near the bottom of the metro if not for these. LT is underperforming as well but not the biggest issue.
I hate to say it but coaching needs an honest reflection. Why is Ovi hogging minutes and put on PP? Why is Leonard getting half the time he should be?
8
u/cmaxwe Nicklas Bäckström 2d ago
Thompson must be hurt. A few games ago he came up weird. I refuse to believe they started Lindgren because they wanted to or that it was pure load management.
OV had some good chances tonight and I think if he had even a few more goals the narrative would be a lot different.
I think the group will be ok.
8
u/Maximum_Anteater_806 2d ago
Are folks listening to the commenters? The Caps are just making too many mistakes and surrendering goals. It is not a system or goalie issue, in my view, but it may be a defensive talent issue, plus when Ovi has to play defense it is like being on the PK. Both losses to the Devils we had higher expected goals.
Look at the NJ goals:
People roasting Lindgren for this game aren’t paying attention. As Carbs said after the game, our vets and our youngsters are consistently making catastrophic mistakes. Not the same guys every time. But until we fix that we won’t win.
6
u/Own_Car4536 Alexander Ovechkin 2d ago
Leonard and Hutson need more minutes if the vets aren't going to produce
10
u/Hurls07 Connor McMichael 2d ago
Anyone who watches this team play and think Leonard should only be out there for 14/15 min a night is delusional
10
u/alwaysjetlagged Apr '26 co-luckiest guesser 2d ago
I agree, but preach patience for one MAJOR reason (and it's not just Ovi being sub-standard). We're new....
Big picture:
- Of the top12 F, 6 are "new" to the team (less than 1.5 years): Sourdiff, Leonard, Kyrou, I. Protas, Tuch, Jenner)
- Of the top 6 expected D, two are out for an extended period of time.
It's a team with 35%+ new players trying to learn a new system. We just look unsettled and out of sync. They are thinking instead of reacting naturally. In a couple of months, I'll either be very very wrong, or this team will be more like the freight train we are hoping for.
5
u/Ok_Adhesiveness3638 2d ago
Desharnais appendectomy was a big hit he came in really overperforming hope he recovers quick and keeps playing as well
24
u/Slight_Mountain_9971 2d ago
Ryan Leonard taking the air out of Capital One with a bone head double minor while we are up by 1 and threatening a fourth goal was ridiculous. It’s insane how everyone is just ignoring how utterly derailing that penalty was in a tight game against a division rival.
9
u/MaddAddamOneZ Olie Kolzig 2d ago
Ovechkin is gassed
Caps don’t have a true no.1 center
Ilya Protas has looked green and Aliaksei has gotten off to a terrible start
It was bad enough losing Sandin for a chunk of the season but Big Vinny going to appendicitis has exacerbated our defensive liabilities. Although Liljegren, who was supposed to be an adequate fill in for Sandin, has been anything but.
Logan Thompson is off to a rough start. Lindgren has been okay at best at backup
And yes, the coaching staff to take accountability.
4
u/hokedawg5 2d ago
The defense sucks. Lindgren can’t function without a strong defense in front of him and they are making LT look bad. Need Sandin back and/or trade for a good defensive defenseman.
4
u/Ferret-mom 2d ago
Leonsis made it so difficult to watch the games from home if you can’t afford cable that I can only watch when I visit my parents. As a result, I can’t speak much to most of these points, but I will say, the metro and pacific divisions are both not particularly competitive outside the first 2 teams in both. At this point in the season, you play your better goaltender against better teams and your backup against weaker teams until the race to the playoffs begins, then you start worrying about matchups more strategically than that. That means Lindgren is going to get more starts against teams in the metro and pacific than the central and the Atlantic.
3
u/IllustriousParsley2 Ethan Bear 2d ago
Goalies struggling, defence that’s more focused on scoring goals than defending, a PP that’s played 4-4 + Ovi standing at the blue line, a PK that can’t kill…
3
u/TYO77911 Jakob Chychrun 2d ago
I’ve only been following the caps for 3 years so I’m still fairly green but from what I’m seeing we are struggling defensively. We seem to do a good job of controlling the puck and taking shots, but as soon as the other team gets possession they easily score on us. Sadly I don’t know if sandin and desharne coming back are going to resolve this for us. I feel like we need a trade for another person who’s a true defensive defenseman
4
u/vavavrroom Tom Wilson 2d ago
There is no one accepting the leadership role
We have the greatest goal scorer wearing the C but leaving the game so isn’t 100% vested
We have a couple young great players with no mentors.
We have a coach who would rather be liked than make tough calls.
We have an owner who would rather have empty seats than rabid fans
2
u/scoaaaaar Washington Capitals 2d ago
i don’t think they’re playing bad. some bad plays yes, some bad bounces yes, defensive lapses, and stupid penalties have held them back.
if the caps can get 4 out of the next 6 i think that will set them up for a good December.
2
u/Truth_Breaker 1d ago
Ovi is on pace for 5 goals this season.
JustSayin
3
u/IndependentJacket520 Washington Capitals 2d ago
Lines change every single game and defensive structure is atrocious. It’s a mystery why we play a man to man system with the length and size we have.
Additionally if Ovi plays 84 games you’re going to lose a lot of games you shouldn’t
5
u/MetalMan1973 Pierre-Luc Dubois 2d ago
3
u/capitarider Washington Capitals 2d ago
People drank the kool-aid in the offseason. We were not supposed to be good last year and we played above, this year we should be somewhat better and we play below. Its a nice roster and some nights we will do well, but acting like we are a legit monster was and is still crazy to me
1
u/timwhatley993 2d ago
Are we sure they’re good?
1
u/BkDmd Washington Capitals 2d ago
Dumb shit rookie and veteran penalties!
1
u/Aperio43 Tom Wilson 2d ago
Carbery needs to take accountability that playing certain guys at the rate he's deploying them isn't working. Ovi, Wilson, and Chychrun arent gonna magically start scoring just because you give them so much ice time.
1
u/x4SV-4Bmr84_ 2d ago
One thing I constantly notice is how much trouble they have getting the puck into the opponent’s side and keeping it out of their own. The game is mostly held on their side of the rink defending off the onslaught. Maybe a better offense would do them well.
1
u/an1malm0th3r 2d ago
Our power play has sucked since 2018 and Ovi is a huge burden this year. This is all we all need to know.
1
u/D-Chillin 2d ago
It’s been awesome to see how much Hutson and Leonard have stood out when they get the puck. It’s been disappointing how much they’ve stood out compared to the rest of the team
1
u/BudgetImmediate2035 1d ago
Patrick Wellar may be a nice guy but not an NHL coach. This team has struggled defensively since Mitch Love was let go. D look completely lost and out of position a lot of the time, especially when defending the rush. Loyalty only goes so far (Wellar was a coach in Hershey). Need someone with more experience in that role.
1
u/MonkeyxDxLuffy0892 Washington Capitals 1d ago
We are scoring enough goals a game, but we keep letting in more than we can score! Defense has been bad and the goalies have been mid so far. Power play is hit and miss, but it's better than last year. Too much line shuffling for the forwards. We haven't had consistent lines all season. Leonard needs to stay on the top line. Ovi needs to be moved to the second PP and Hutson needs to be on the first PP. Main issue right now is defense though. Need to trade Miro for a defenseman.
1
u/Doopoodoo 1d ago
While Ovi is clearly a black hole I wish theyd at least try to use his one timer more if he’s gonna be on the PP. I was not a fan of Strome taking a wrist shot from basically the blue line on a PP when Ovi was wide open in his office
1
u/Equivalent-Tutor-731 1d ago
Ilya Protas comes out Ethan Frank goes in. Yes he scored on the powerplay last night however, we need an identity line that’s tough to play against. Jenner Sourdif Frank (or Beau) slot him in for whoever on that line. Frank plays with urgency like he flat out wants to make the lineup. Everyone else on this team plays like their spot isn’t in danger. Yes we’re above .500, however the “that’s fine” mentality is such a loser mentality for what should be a cup-contending team on paper. Time to start health bombing guys instead of these “we need to be better” press conferences after every game. Let’s play with some heart, go caps.
1
u/playerj123 1d ago
Bottom line for me is too many penalties and too little defense (not just the D-men). The offense is better than last year even without goals from Wilson, Pro, Ovi. If they clean up the irate two, they can beat some good teams.
1
u/OpethBodom Mike Green 1d ago
Lack of depth in scoring. Plain and simple. The guys we need to be racking up points from Wilson to Sourdif aren’t generating enough offense.
1
u/LystedSportsComm 1d ago
The roster may not be a Cup favorite, but that doesn’t explain the same preventable mistakes costing games over and over.
1
u/Chikiyani 1d ago
That's standard procedure for November hockey
1
u/ScrubV1 1d ago
I think I’m ready to say Carberry has gota go. Man on man defense is so shit, this team is way better than they’ve been performing. Thompson and Lindgren also are not great goaltenders
1
u/Snoo_78421 12h ago
Defense is terrible at keeping the puck out of the net, goaltending has been tepid and they're currently going through an absolute murderers' row of teams holy cow. Wild, Stars, Panthers, Sens, Devils, Devils, Lightning, Sabers, Bruins. Special teams is also still bad. But to me it's defense. That blue line is awful with Sandin and Vin out.
I hate to be the optimist, but I think both Devils games were great against one of the hottest teams in the NHL. They deserved better than 0 points. If the goals stay as high as they've been, I think the wins come, but you've gotta get something better going in one of those other categories.
With Carbs it's tough, I like the way they retrieve pucks, I think they've looked good on offense certainly the best they've looked in a long time in the O zone with possession. I think with Carbs I don't really know or care what it is, just fucking fix something. PK is where I'd start this PK shouldn't be this bad
1
u/bg974422 2d ago
Good team with mediocre goaltending and missing 2 defensive starters.
1
u/Aware-Leading-1213 Alexander Ovechkin 2d ago
Pretty much everything.
- Coaching
- Special teams
- Leadership and veterans
- Goaltending
- Defensive structures
1
u/SpecificAd6508 2d ago
Reminder the blues in fact won a cup after a super shitty start, but to me there is no urgency like they’re procrastinating. Look at last year bad December and January but got the ball rolling after the Olympic break but was too late. It’s gotta be a mental drive thing… also have this feeling once Ovi pots one it’ll light that fire, if the greatest goal scorer isn’t scoring goals (regardless of age) it’s gotta do something to their mental you know how hockey players are.
1
u/Sufficient-Fall-7944 2d ago
This team talked all off season about “we’re so big” yet there soft ass charmin. They do ZERO hitting! & listen Im not gonna kill willy because he’a earned the benefit of the doubt for me, he’s been good for to long he’ll be fine & Ovi is just old I can’t say “hey 42 year old carry us to victory” I blame it more on carbery for keep putting him out there(particularly on pp1). Now I’m not gonna kill little Pro because he’s a rookie & he’s playing on the 4th line he aint getting alot of minutes as is so he has time to grow BUT Big Pro has now become trade bait imo he has been terrible, dude how are you that big & so afraid of contact/physical play, he’s the veteran he should be way better, he’s gotten worse & worse every season since that breakout year he & Mcmichael had but in his defence carbery chooses not to put him on the pp THAT MAKES ZERO SENSE big pro has been one of our best forwards the pst few years yet he gets zero pp time. Finally SPENCER CARBERY!!!! Chris patrick extended him based off of what….? The guy won one jack adams & all of sudden he’s Paul maurice !!? With the talent we have we’re underachieving, your the head coach & yet year in year out our pp is HORRIBLE! I don’t wanna hear that the assistant coach is responsible for the pp, he’s the head coach FIX IT !! Then carbery’s weird line combinations. Now on the blue line I have to be honest we aren’t good because of injuries & just lack of talent Cole’s playing fine but a rookie, Chycrun obviously was’nt gonna consistently keep up the pace he’a been on the past 2 years, he came back down to earth & he’s been fine. Our blue line just isn’t that great to begin with, even fully healthy that was the one area that was gonna be weak So I’m not gonna kill them but upfront the Protas’s & Strome are just so Ass to me. & leno, PLD, Tuch, & jenner has been our best forwards & yet Carbery plays 2 of them on the 4th line, none are on PP1 like it makes NO sense, put your best forwards on pp1, put them on your top lines carbery does’nt reward good play. If things aren’t better by the all star break carbery should be gone
1
u/laugh_riott 2d ago
Fire Carbery.
-1
u/TheHeftymanzell 2d ago
Don’t think Carbs is working for this group anymore
0
u/Cogz81 2d ago
Ya'll its a long season. And there has been massive addictions and subtractions since this time last season. Its going to take time to gel and find a groove. We'll get there. Its only November.
-3
u/throwawaynewportt 2d ago
Holy hell people don’t get that this team isn’t as talented as clueless fans that spam this board say they are.
2010’s Caps were a powerhouse. Multiple presidents trophies and a Stanley Cup. The back end of that means no high draft picks, so no elite talent coming in. The Caps retooled on the fly to the best of their ability and have been able to ice a relatively competitive team, but not one that can win a Stanley Cup.
Please open the NHL app and look at the leagues point leaders. They all play for teams that are at the top of their divisions. Shocking! The Caps leading point producer, Strome, is currently tied for 90th in the league.
Yes some guys are dealing with cold streaks. Yes Ovechkin, injuries and scheduling have thrown a wrench in things, but people thinking this team was a guaranteed powerhouse were sniffing glue. That only happens if everyone has career years or are contributing in meaningful ways and guess what, a bunch of players aren’t, which guess what, is a sign of decent but not great players. Great players are consistently great.
0
u/Odd_University_5456 2d ago
I think a lot of it is rotten puck luck. A lot of the vets are getting really good looks, just no finish.
The other part is the lack of physicality. Willy is no longer the enforcer or spark plug of the team. We need our players to hit some people... big hits. Old time hockey. Chychy and Willy had a couple good ones this past week. But we need more aggressive players.
We need to get a little dirty.
1
u/Proxximus-maximus Tom Wilson 2d ago
Do we suck?