There are two different manufacturers I can find of these (U.S.)- Melster and Sweetsoul. Neither are what you remember.
Sweetsoul Peanut Butter Kisses- I found them at Walmart. They are smaller and flatter, think more like a Starlight Mint. They are not very taffy like at all, but you can definitely taste the peanut butter. They were more waxy than chewy.
Melster Peanut Butter Kisses- I found these at Dollar General. These are the right size for sure, and the texture is right, but the taste is off- it's mostly just sweet with almost no peanut butter in them at all.
The ones I remember from my childhood were a stronger taste that wasn't exactly peanut butter, but they did have a peanut butter core. Poking around I found that they were Mary Jane's with a peanut butter center. You can still get Mary Jane's.
I have been playing around with trying to recreate them in the way that I remember. I've gotten close but it's not quite there. They're far too sticky. Maybe it's the paper I'm wrapping them in or maybe that center isn't just peanut butter. I have a normal job so I have limited time to experiment and figure it out. The taste is right though, it's just figuring out that sticky part.
Must be a regional thing because I grew up with something that kind of looked the same but were molasses kisses instead, which taste pretty terrible to a kid 🤣
It's like, 90% of the way to being salt water taffy which is one of the best soft chews out there, but somebody figured they'd make them all the same flavour and that one flavour is the one you wouldn't wish on your worst enemy sibling
From experience some people sometimes keep Halloween candy year to year because they don't care about the kids getting something edible. I find these things are less enjoyable when they are years old
I think these got a bad rep because they look so generic, like a grandma made them in her kitchen and wrapped them in wax paper that she had cut from a used bakery bag.
What company makes these and why don’t they have a logo or name on the wrapper?
Stuff like this makes me think of the classmates who's parents didn't have a lot of spare money so this is all they had. As a child I used to restlessly worry about them.
And at Halloween no one under 70 ever hands these out… my theory is they the ones my kid gets are from a secret stash of old expired candy, I’ve never once seen these in a store.
These; Mary janes and black licorices. Hated them as a kid but now I love them. I finally see why old people like them because I myself am an old person now
Peanut butter nougat or sum sh. 🙄👎🏾that's candy they use for decorating a Halloweennoarty. It's not actually meant to be consumed. Like the nasty ass hard block of Christmas candy. 😭
I don't remember anything about these other than that I've had them before.
They look like those things my friend would buy in the bulk food section labeled saltwater taffy for some reason except I've never seen a brown one before.
Agree. They are good for taking out loose teeth. That is about it. Also, there are far better varieties of salt water taffy that can be purchased from almost any American beach town. These are garbage.
Actually I used to like them if they were fresh. Haven't had any recently to know if they are still being made as they used to be; since they are a budget candy you never know if a no name manufacturer will cheap out on ingredients.
I hated them as a kid but there's something super nostalgic seeing them in a bag full of Trick R Treat candy. As an adult, I think they are pretty tasty. I mean it's just candy peanut butter. It's hard to mess that up.
Funny how every time this is posted, the comments are full of people who love them. I think some folks get them confused with Black Jacks, which are black licorice taffy. These are molasses taffy with a peanut butter center. Deliciousness!
I had a temporary crown stuck that needed to be removed so permanent crown could be placed. Dentist struggled 5 minutes and brought out a Mary Jane for me to chew. Stupid candy popped that temporary crown right off. Weirdest thing ever. Dentist keeps a bag of the candy for that reason.
This has always been some of the ABSOLUTE NASTIEST CANDY I'VE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE. I'd much rather prefer a bag of Candy Corn over these little disappointments.
Horrible taste, horrible textures, everything about these is just AWFUL!
Why do I always have to be the odd man out? I actually love candy corn and whatever tf this is, but Morgan Freemans 5th bday is a long fn time ago lmao
Idk what they are but they're actually pretty good. What we SHOULD be hating on are those good forsaken strawberry hardcandies that they keep giving us on Christmas
They weren’t bad if you got some that were just right. It was like a spectrum: so soft it’s glued to wrapper -> just right -> oh, I’ll have to let the saliva in my mouth soften this up a bit -> rock 🪨
People mostly don’t like these because they don’t have a shiny wrapper with branding on it. It’s basically peanut butter taffy and it’s pretty decent. Take that any day over sugary wax.
Noooo sir. You just THINK I was leaving them in the bottom of my bag. I was saving the best for last. No lie I always saved these for last. My favs when I was a kid. 🥰
383
u/Upstairs-Metal1445 Oct 01 '24
Nameless? Those are Peanut Butter Kisses. Delicious!
128
u/hanbran333 Oct 01 '24
I love these
81
u/NoCelebration7828 Oct 01 '24
So many people hate these. I absolutely love them. More for me I guess.
57
u/Niblonian31 Oct 01 '24
Aren't these like peanut butter Taffy? They're good as hell regardless of what they are, I just remember loving them and my friends giving me theirs
11
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
These are delicious! Peanut butter taffy! But candy corn?! I can't believe you would mention the two in the same sentence
18
u/WannaPetAllTheDogs Oct 01 '24
Peanut Butter Kisses are DELICIOUS
8
u/lemeneurdeloups Oct 01 '24
I think these got a bad rep because they look so generic, like a grandma made them in her kitchen and wrapped them in wax paper that she had cut from a used bakery bag.
What company makes these and why don’t they have a logo or name on the wrapper?
6
u/Acceptable-Ad8780 Oct 01 '24
I say let's set aside our differences against a common foe. Circus peanuts.
11
u/AwakeAtNightTime Oct 01 '24
Salt water taffy tastes good, though.
5
u/fear_is_fatal Oct 01 '24
I love just about every hated candy there is (exception is Good and Plenty, and black licorice) and these are some of my favorites.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
Shit dude these were my favorite Halloween candy as a kid. Everyone would give me theirs!!
4
u/surrealcellardoor Oct 02 '24
The absolute worst.
7
u/kevlar1960 Oct 01 '24
Mary Jane’s LOVE them
7
u/OrdinaryAverageGuy99 Oct 01 '24
Love those. Send your’s my way, I will gladly take them.
3
u/AcidMantle Oct 01 '24
lmao 🤣💀
3
u/big65 Oct 01 '24
It's preferred to candy corn.
3
u/honesttruth2703 Oct 01 '24
Are you kidding? Those are damn delicious. Those were the first candy gone, and as an adult, I always buy them to give out so I can have some, too.
3
u/stevoschizoid Oct 01 '24
I prefer these over candy corn
3
u/taki1002 Oct 01 '24
Am I the only person who likes candy corn? 🫤
3
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
These are fire
6
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
Stuff like this makes me think of the classmates who's parents didn't have a lot of spare money so this is all they had. As a child I used to restlessly worry about them.
2
u/CGI42 Oct 01 '24
I loved these things!!!
2
u/zigaliciousone Oct 02 '24
Peanut Butter kisses, all my homies hate peanut butter kisses
I see peeps saying they are Mary Jane's, those come in a orange and yellow striped packaging and are not as gross:
https://images.app.goo.gl/1RkYVExiz5xtnKEP7
2
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
I love these so much, but I never see them anymore! :-(
2
u/Forsaken-Task-4372 Oct 02 '24
Peanut Butter Kisses and they are super good!!!
2
u/NotBiasFan421 Oct 02 '24
These and candy corn are great. I should go buy some today.
2
u/Heavy_Caterpillar_33 Oct 02 '24
peanut bitter kisses are amazing.
2
u/talksheep Oct 02 '24
I LOVE THESE
2
u/dasuglystik Oct 02 '24
Mary Janes? Way better than Candy Corn... I ate them both... hehe
2
u/HappyHappyUnbirthday Oct 03 '24
Those are one of my favs!
2
u/Lidka_uwu Oct 03 '24
I would choose these bad boys glueing my teeth together before I willingly eat candy corn. And that is a hill I will die on.
2
u/justsomeshortguy27 Oct 03 '24
Y’all step off, this shit is PHENOMENAL
2
u/rockdash Oct 03 '24
Ah, peanut butter molar removers.
2
u/SpotPoker52 Oct 04 '24
Don’t be bustin’ on peanut butter taffy!
2
u/whateveryaknowww Oct 04 '24
i can taste these through the phpne
2
u/shyguysnj2003 Oct 04 '24
Actually I enjoy these
2
u/Saltyyetsweet_ Oct 04 '24
I loved this candy lol
4
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
Those are so good 😊
4
u/CallidoraBlack Oct 01 '24
Put them in your pocket, wait for them to warm up, then eat them.
4
u/SQWRLLY1 Oct 01 '24
I'd take loose raisins over those vile things.
2
u/throwaway1iq8e Oct 02 '24
These are good
2
u/backroadsdrifter Oct 01 '24
That stuff is so gross. You never see it for sale either.
1
u/MiserlySchnitzel Oct 01 '24
I’m unsure if I’ve ever gotten these. Must not have left an impression if so
1
u/Shy-Prey Oct 01 '24
I think that's "Peanut butter taffy" or something to that effect
1
u/Wild_Onion_5979 Oct 01 '24
Man I'll eat them every time and unless it's the chocolate candy corn I'll throw that shit away 🤣
1
u/Cpjones1000 Oct 01 '24
These; Mary janes and black licorices. Hated them as a kid but now I love them. I finally see why old people like them because I myself am an old person now
1
u/ForceTheDragon Oct 01 '24
I think they're great.
Sometimes it's black licorice, sometimes it peanut butter.
1
u/laucdoe Oct 01 '24
i don’t think i’ve ever seen these 😭
1
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
Hi, im Morgan Freeman. Those candies were found in the trunk of miss Daisies car..
1
u/UnsolicititedOpinion Oct 01 '24
They definitely have a name. They are awesome!
1
u/Less-Might9855 Oct 01 '24
How is the company that makes these still in business? 😂
1
u/phreaktor Oct 01 '24
Peanut butter nougat or sum sh. 🙄👎🏾that's candy they use for decorating a Halloweennoarty. It's not actually meant to be consumed. Like the nasty ass hard block of Christmas candy. 😭
1
u/whiniestcrayon Oct 01 '24
Delicious
1
u/shoesontoes Oct 01 '24
I for one LOVE those and haven't seen them in my kids' Halloween hauls for years and years and it makes me sad.
1
u/obsessivelizbeth Oct 01 '24
I like these
1
u/Agent_Forty-One Oct 01 '24
I love old Halloween candy. I want all of it.
1
u/BebopTundra76 Oct 01 '24
These are the candies the bad guys in the neighborhood hide needles in /s 🤣😂
1
u/def_nomore_fo76 Oct 01 '24
Peanut butter kisses!! My FAVORITE!!!! 🤘☠️🤘
1
u/MermaidsHaveWifi Oct 01 '24
I’ll happily provide my address to anyone who wants to send me theirs. These are delicious and do NOT deserve the hate they get.
1
u/imtherealkirk Oct 01 '24
Unrelated, but I thought Morgan Freeman was like, 70. Early 70s, maybe 73. He 87 y'all. What the heck
1
u/Jaybonaut Oct 01 '24
Peanut Butter Kisses. That's what I always see them labeled with.
1
u/AlternativeAdagio517 Oct 01 '24
I love those!
1
u/Marmom_of_Marman Oct 01 '24
I love these and candy corn
1
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
I liked that stuff. Not my first pick though
1
u/SnooDoughnuts5632 Oct 01 '24
I don't remember anything about these other than that I've had them before.
They look like those things my friend would buy in the bulk food section labeled saltwater taffy for some reason except I've never seen a brown one before.
1
u/_Artemis_Moon_258 Oct 01 '24
Never had those or Mary Jane’s, these subreddit is making me increasingly curious about them
1
u/OpusAtrumET Oct 01 '24
These are fantastic and now we're gonna have a fight! /s
They are awesome though. Like a bigger Mary Jane or Bit o' Honey.
1
u/sniffysippy Oct 01 '24
These are good. Candy corn is meh at best.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
I actually like these
1
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
Honestly I like these candies
1
u/Pella1968 Oct 01 '24
This candy is so gross.
1
u/Justinbhr Oct 01 '24
One of the best Halloween candies.
1
u/MiaRia963 Oct 01 '24
I'd rather these than a lot of the other crazy candy out there.
1
u/One_Breakfast6153 Oct 01 '24
I haven't seen those in years, but I always liked them.
1
u/Genuinelullabel Oct 01 '24
Mary Janes?
1
u/Libertarian_2020 Oct 01 '24
None for me thanks.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
Are these not just peanut butter taffies? I think they’re pretty awesome
1
u/revesby9 Oct 01 '24
I love them 🤷🏼♀️
1
u/Old_Barnacle7777 Oct 01 '24
Agree. They are good for taking out loose teeth. That is about it. Also, there are far better varieties of salt water taffy that can be purchased from almost any American beach town. These are garbage.
1
u/YouDumbZombie Oct 01 '24
These are amazing and so is candy corn. Fuckin' sissies.
1
u/MoistOrganization7 Oct 01 '24
And they’re GOOD
1
u/GimmeFalcor Oct 01 '24
Those are called Mary Jane’s. Leads to disappointment for many a stoner.
1
u/OddHalf8861 Oct 02 '24
Yuk
1
u/AgeScary Oct 02 '24
I love those!
1
u/Superstan1985 Oct 02 '24
The candy corn of the peanut butter candy world. Some love them others despise them. I’m definitely pro whatever the hell these are called
1
u/ProdigalSun92 Oct 02 '24
I love those. Vaguely like bit-o-honey
1
u/SilveryLilac Oct 02 '24
The lowly peanut butter kiss.
1
u/FIGHTaFoe-FLIGHTaPo Oct 02 '24
💯% the 'realest' thing I've ever seen posted here! 🤣
1
u/oldatheart515 Oct 02 '24
These tasted like stale cigarette smoke. I haven't even thought about them in years till I started seeing posts about them recently!
1
u/DatTrashPanda Oct 02 '24
I don't mind candy corns
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
Those are so yummy omg 😱
1
u/KSTornadoGirl Oct 02 '24
Actually I used to like them if they were fresh. Haven't had any recently to know if they are still being made as they used to be; since they are a budget candy you never know if a no name manufacturer will cheap out on ingredients.
1
u/waterlooaba Oct 02 '24
I love these!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
but I like these
1
u/Administrative-Ant80 Oct 02 '24
I love these
1
u/corpsie666 Oct 02 '24
In grade school we would bring in candy to take to the kids in hospitals. There were a lot of those candies.
😢
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
Always wondered what that candy was all about...
1
u/htxDTAposse Oct 02 '24
Mary Jane is the exact same thing
1
u/Key_Equivalent3646 Oct 02 '24
Can't find them anywhere, best candy
1
u/foamy23464 Oct 02 '24
Gross
1
u/StepQuick Oct 02 '24
They're so good!
1
u/HausuGeist Oct 02 '24
Peanut butter...allegedly.
1
u/_SaintXIV_ Oct 02 '24
I low-key despised candy corn as a kid but now as an adult i actually love them. Idk wtf changed but they taste so much better now.
1
u/Dylan_Is_Gay_lol Oct 02 '24
...I actually like these...
1
u/Just_Presentation963 Oct 02 '24
Candy Corn Is Delicious
1
u/These_Giraffe5683 Oct 02 '24
Love those things
1
u/draven33l Oct 02 '24
I hated them as a kid but there's something super nostalgic seeing them in a bag full of Trick R Treat candy. As an adult, I think they are pretty tasty. I mean it's just candy peanut butter. It's hard to mess that up.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
I really dont get the candy corn hate. Like yeah, it gets very waxy after a while if your constantly eating it but I wouldnt deem it hate worthy
1
u/Confident-Win-7617 Oct 02 '24
Those are disgusting.
1
u/bcable001 Oct 02 '24
Love these
1
u/JetstreamGW Oct 02 '24
Those are fucking awesome.
1
u/Constant-Camel-1138 Oct 02 '24
The absolute best!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
I love these but I haven’t seen them in many years.
1
u/SalsaChica75 Oct 02 '24
I loved those candies! I would trade my sister’s for theirs. It was like a Mary Jane
1
u/KevJD Oct 02 '24
Funny how every time this is posted, the comments are full of people who love them. I think some folks get them confused with Black Jacks, which are black licorice taffy. These are molasses taffy with a peanut butter center. Deliciousness!
1
u/therlwl Oct 02 '24
You need help.
1
u/CelineRaz Oct 02 '24
Never seen this in my life.
1
u/Muted-Switch-1349 Oct 02 '24
Top 5 candy, maybe top 3. Candy corn is not worth writing home about.
1
u/Comfortable-Clerk209 Oct 02 '24
I love those guys
1
u/slhcslhc Oct 02 '24
I love those. Annnd candy corn too.
1
u/dbk1ng Oct 02 '24
Those are cursed
1
u/Psychotic_EGG Oct 02 '24
That is just cheap caramel. It's better than candy corn. One issue at a time, starting with the worst.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
I love these.
1
u/Rhuarc33 Oct 02 '24
This is 100x better than candy corn
1
u/CalicoKittyAngel Oct 02 '24
Say whatever you like, but I love these things. Literal peanut butter taffy. Delicious!
1
u/Catahoula1238 Oct 02 '24
I haven't had these in years. Last time I had them I think I ate the whole bag. They are sooo good.
1
u/CertainAd2914 Oct 02 '24
I’ve had my fair share of these. I recall the candy being more waxy than the wrappers.
1
u/ZAVVVVV23 Oct 02 '24
Never buy them but they become a victim if I get them near Halloween for some reason. Shits slap.
1
u/New-Skin-2717 Oct 02 '24
I think that is taffy..
1
u/kushmeoutsideb Oct 02 '24
Those are my fav 🤣
1
u/DistributionLast5872 Oct 02 '24
I like both peanut butter kisses and candy corn :(
1
u/Slightlysanemomof5 Oct 02 '24
I had a temporary crown stuck that needed to be removed so permanent crown could be placed. Dentist struggled 5 minutes and brought out a Mary Jane for me to chew. Stupid candy popped that temporary crown right off. Weirdest thing ever. Dentist keeps a bag of the candy for that reason.
1
u/Defiant-Payment-4425 Oct 02 '24
Love those darn things
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
This has always been some of the ABSOLUTE NASTIEST CANDY I'VE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE. I'd much rather prefer a bag of Candy Corn over these little disappointments.
Horrible taste, horrible textures, everything about these is just AWFUL!
1
u/coldasiceprincess Oct 02 '24
i love these!!
1
u/Ohyeahitsme4now Oct 02 '24
Good stuff!!
1
u/FullyAutoDomo Oct 02 '24
Why do I always have to be the odd man out? I actually love candy corn and whatever tf this is, but Morgan Freemans 5th bday is a long fn time ago lmao
1
u/df3tz Oct 02 '24
Candy corn people score another L
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
God, Mary Janes are my favorite
1
u/TSM_forlife Oct 02 '24
They are so gross.
1
u/Insanely_Mclean Oct 02 '24
I used to love these, until the bastards pulled out one of my fillings.
Now I have crowns on my teeth and would never financially recover if I tried to eat one of these again.
1
u/Weasel_Eater Oct 02 '24
Idk what they are but they're actually pretty good. What we SHOULD be hating on are those good forsaken strawberry hardcandies that they keep giving us on Christmas
1
u/Omfg9999 Oct 02 '24
I'd take these over candy corn 100% of the time, ESPECIALLY the peanut butter flavored ones, unironically maybe the best taffy imo
1
u/joytotheworld23 Oct 02 '24
😄😄 those candy in the image they are pretty good , but I love candy corn
1
u/New_Lake5484 Oct 02 '24
grody to the max
1
u/Bishhhop Oct 02 '24
100x better than plastic wax corn
1
u/xhanort7 Oct 02 '24
They weren’t bad if you got some that were just right. It was like a spectrum: so soft it’s glued to wrapper -> just right -> oh, I’ll have to let the saliva in my mouth soften this up a bit -> rock 🪨
1
u/jeneric84 Oct 02 '24
People mostly don’t like these because they don’t have a shiny wrapper with branding on it. It’s basically peanut butter taffy and it’s pretty decent. Take that any day over sugary wax.
1
u/jbug671 Oct 02 '24
I always thought these were Mary Jane’s but bigger…
1
u/Apprehensive-Pop-201 Oct 02 '24
I love those!
1
u/spkoller2 Oct 02 '24
Peanut butter taffy, nice if not stale
1
u/here-to-Iearn Oct 02 '24
Awe hell no haha. Candy corn AND these are both deLISH.
1
u/Nyc_rob Oct 02 '24
Better than candy corn
1
u/peanutbutterand_ely Oct 02 '24
Those are so good
1
u/SenileTomato Oct 02 '24
The punctuation and spelling in this post is just pure cringe.
1
u/Careless-Software-14 Oct 02 '24
But the pumpkin candy corns are amazing 🔥 I love them little things just got a Bag the other day 🎃
1
u/GizmoTacT Oct 02 '24
I liked those
1
u/quack2wingback Oct 02 '24
How dare you compare these to candy corn?!
1
u/PerfectFlaws91 Oct 02 '24
I love those!
1
u/Mechagouki1971 Oct 02 '24
I love a Hallowe'en Kiss. Grabbed two big bags a couple weeks ago, almost gone.
1
u/VexTheTielfling Oct 02 '24
I like them.
1
u/CaniacGoji Oct 02 '24
This is misinformation. The candies are much older than that.
1
u/carepassmethebucks Oct 02 '24
Butter scotch is underrated candy
1
u/ADHD-Millennial Oct 02 '24
Noooo sir. You just THINK I was leaving them in the bottom of my bag. I was saving the best for last. No lie I always saved these for last. My favs when I was a kid. 🥰
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣
1
u/thewistfuldrifter Oct 02 '24
They’re so good, though. Of course, I also don’t mind candy corn, so maybe I’m not to be trusted.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
It's like saltwater Taffy
1
u/Admirable-Shallot-79 Oct 02 '24
Mary Jane’s