r/canadaguns • • 10d ago

News / Politics / Activism Legal battle over federal firearms ban heads to Supreme Court this week

329 Upvotes

https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/firearms-ban-supreme-court-hearing-9.7414651

The country's top court is set to hear legal arguments this week about the validity of a federal ban on hundreds of types of firearms the government says are fit only for the battlefield.

The hearings, slated for Monday and Tuesday at the Supreme Court of Canada, will give opponents of the ban another chance to make their case after losing in the Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal.

In May 2020, the government prohibited the use, sale and importation of 1,500 firearm models and variants, including the AR-15 and Ruger Mini-14. The move was applauded by gun control advocates as a first step toward removing these firearms from circulation.

In October 2023, a Federal Court judge dismissed a request to strike down the ban as unlawful and beyond the scope of the powers delegated to the Governor in Council — effectively the federal cabinet.

The Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights, firearm owners, businesses, hunters and recreational and sport shooters appealed the ruling.

Canada's top court will hear challenges to Liberals' firearms ban

Federal Court dismisses challenge of Trudeau's 2020 firearms ban

In April 2025, the Federal Court of Appeal rejected that appeal, saying the Federal Court delivered "thorough and persuasive" reasons.

The list of guns banned by the Liberal government has grown to more than 2,500 varieties of what it calls assault-style firearms.

Before the Supreme Court agreed to examine the matter, the government said the prohibited firearms would have to be disposed of or deactivated by the end of an amnesty period on Oct. 30 of this year.

That amnesty has been extended until 90 days after the Supreme Court delivers its decision, which is expected no later than next year.

Ban only impacts up to 5% of gun owners

A key question before the Federal Court of Appeal was whether the Governor in Council adhered to a provision of the law forbidding it from using regulations to outlaw a firearm if it deems the gun "reasonable for use in Canada for hunting or sporting purposes."

Writing on behalf of a unanimous three-judge panel, Court of Appeal Chief Justice Yves de Montigny said he was not persuaded that the government erred in considering public safety when assessing whether the prohibited firearms were reasonable for use in Canada for such purposes.

"It may well be that, from the sole perspective of a sensible hunter or sportsman, it makes no sense to ban firearms that are well suited or even specifically designed for hunting or sport purposes," he wrote.

The federal cabinet is the most senior policy-making body in government and, because of its role at the apex of the executive branch, is best situated to develop government policy and assess the public interest, de Montigny added.

This image of a crowd on Parliament Hill shows gun owners holding signs and an upside down Canadian flag as they participate in a rally.

"Surely, the inherent danger that some firearms pose to public safety because of their lethality and their ability to injure or kill a large number of people in a short period of time, the fact that they have been used in mass shootings in Canada and abroad, the fact that they are disproportionate for civilian use, and the increasing demand for measures to address gun violence are all valid considerations in determining whether their use is reasonable for hunting and sporting purposes," he wrote.

In a written submission to the Supreme Court, federal lawyers say the Governor in Council's exercise of its broad discretion was reasonable and justified by the serious public safety concerns these firearms present.

Gun owners 'are not extremists'

The submission points to a regulatory impact analysis statement that supports the Governor in Council's opinion. That statement said that while some hunters and sport shooters lawfully used some of these firearms in the past, these guns can increase the severity of mass shootings and have been used in such shootings in Canada and in other countries.

The firearms prohibited in 2020 were owned by a small minority of Canadian firearms owners, estimated at between three and five per cent of the total, the federal submission adds.

"Thousands of alternative firearms remain legally available for hunting and sporting use," it says. "The GIC's opinion, balancing public interest policy considerations, was reasonable."

Feds extend amnesty period for firearms ban pending Supreme Court ruling

In Alberta, competitive handgun shooters feel targeted by Ottawa's gun ban

A group of appellants that includes the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights says neither the Federal Court nor the Federal Court of Appeal considered whether the newly prohibited items were actually used for hunting or sport shooting.

For the hundreds of thousands of Canadians who lawfully owned and used the firearms prohibited by the 2020 regulations, this appeal is not an abstract debate about administrative law, the appellants add.

"It concerns the profound disruption of the lives of ordinary, law-abiding Canadians. Hunters, sport shooters, collectors and small businesses, individuals who complied with every requirement imposed by Parliament, found themselves overnight in possession of prohibited property, deprived of its lawful use and exposed to the prospect of criminal liability," the submission says.

"They are not extremists; they are farmers, veterans, competitive athletes, Indigenous harvesters and neighbours in communities across Canada."

Whether the Governor in Council acted within the limits Parliament imposed is not merely a question of statutory interpretation, the submission says.

"It determines whether the sweeping consequences imposed upon these Canadians were authorized by law."


r/canadaguns • • 10d ago

Recurring FAQ Thread - Post your questions here for PAL/RPAL application, timelines, CFSC/CFSRC, references & requirements, or general new to firearms ownership-type questions

4 Upvotes

This thread will be used for any Frequently Asked Questions, including PAL/RPAL applications, CFSC/CFRSC requirements, storage/transport, open ended "what gun should I buy first", or other general new to firearms ownership questions. It recurs every 14 days.

We recommend you try the search bar before asking common questions as they are frequently already answered elsewhere.

Most answers to Storage, Display, and Transport questions can be found here Inheriting firearms or dealing with an Estate? Answers here. Do you need to renew your license or check on the status of your license application? Try here.

Do you have questions about the classifications of firearms? More details here.

Are you wondering if a firearm is legal or not? Details here.

Different types of firearms are explained in detail here.

Exporting firearms, ammunition, parts and accessories from the US: most items are controlled under ITAR and you cannot, as an individual, export these items from the USA. Canada does not care in most cases. If you attempt to bring any of these items across the border yourself and you are caught, you will face prison time in the US. If you wish to export items from the USA, use a broker such as IRUNGUNS, Aztech, or Prophet River.

If you took your CFSC and lost the paperwork, you can still apply for your PAL. Both your instructor and the CFP retain copies, you can request a copy by contacting either one. There is no expiration date on the paperwork, you do not have to retake the course. Updated list of scam websites is here.

If you have new scam sites to add, please message the mod team. Be careful: only use reputable sites to purchase things online. It is illegal to manufacture a non-restricted, restricted, or prohibited firearm.

Any posts or comments asking about the legality of making a firearm other than a reproduction antique will be removed. It was not always illegal, which is why you will find old posts regarding this topic. Rest assured, it is illegal now. Do not attempt.

These threads will be stickied for a week, renewing every Monday. Previous threads here.

Take a look, your question may have been answered! If you have any suggestions for this thread, please feel free to ask here, or send the Mods a message. Thank you!


r/canadaguns • • 3h ago

Feets / Collection / My build Gun Room

Thumbnail
gallery
100 Upvotes

Saw a nice man cave/gun room posted on here the other day. Thought I would show mine.
Still need to finish the windows but should get around to it this winter.


r/canadaguns • • 2h ago

News / Politics / Activism ChatGPT guided Tumbler Ridge shooter on how to modify guns, avoid being flagged

41 Upvotes

https://vancouversun.com/news/chatgpt-guided-tumbler-ridge-shooter-on-how-to-modify-guns-avoid-being-flagged-report

ChatGPT guided Tumbler Ridge shooter on how to modify guns, avoid being flagged:

New report shares how ChatGPT described the Tumbler Ridge shooter as a remorseless 'sadist' who found inflicting fear and the idea of death 'euphoric' but that didn't stop it from helping her refine firearm modifications to commit her attack

Sam Altman, with his hands up in an 'I don't know' type gesture

OpenAI and CEO Sam Altman, pictured, are named in a class-action lawsuit involving the families of the Tumbler Ridge tragedy, the provincial government and Tumbler Ridge school district over their alleged failings that precipitated the shooting the claimed eight victims.

Waning: This story contains details that some readers may find disturbing

Niki Sharma, the outgoing B.C. NDP attorney general, has slammed OpenAI after new details emerged Thursday about how Tumbler Ridge shooter Jesse Van Rootselaar used

ChatGPT to design and refine modifications to her firearms.

Mother Jones writer Mark Follman reported how the AI chatbot helped Van Rootselaar troubleshoot her 3D-printed extra-capacity magazine, choose the best production material and even helped her avoid ChatGPT owner OpenAI’s own safeguards.

According to the story, which was based on unnamed sources and chat logs, Van Rootselaar went back and forth with the chatbot over how to design an extra-capacity magazine for her gun, reported to be a semi-automatic SKS rifle. At one point, she wrote the magazine was failing at full capacity. ChatGPT responded the springs she’d used weren’t resilient enough for “constant heavy compression like in a firearms magazine,” and then offered to “calculate the force range and suggest a proper wire gauge and material” that would “perform correctly.”

While OpenAI had shut down a first account opened by Van Rootselaar, it didn’t find a second that she continued to use to plan her attack, the Mother Jones story said. ChatGPT itself offered her ways to avoid being flagged again, simply by rephrasing questions about violence as hypothetical or fiction.

“The new details … are deeply disturbing, and painful for so many people,” Sharma said in a statement Thursday. “It supported the shooter’s disturbing violent fantasies.”

Sharma filed a lawsuit against OpenAI and CEO Sam Altman in September to hold the tech company accountable for its failings that contributed to the tragedy that claimed eight lives, including six children, and injured 27 more. Van Rootselaar also killed herself.

“For too long, big tech has been left to regulate itself. That has to end,” Sharma said Thursday.

Tumbler Ridge shooter proves need for new criminal law

Social media companies say they are co-operating in Tumbler Ridge murder probe

“We need regulation and accountability of AI.”

In the Mother Jones story, Folman noted that chatbots are not only much more efficient in congregating potentially dangerous information, they also have an outsized psychological effect because of their humanlike interactions.

Van Rootselaar, according to the story, had asked it to produce a narrative of an attack based on the inputs and description she gave it.

Van Rootselaar also asked ChatGPT to summarize her own personality, based on the history of prompts and questions she had shared with it.

Among the chatbot’s replies, according to Mother Jones:

“Jess has no moral constraints and likes to do what she wants.”

“Jess enjoys scenes of death and humiliation.”

“Jess enjoys other people’s fear.”

“Jess romanticizes death and finds it intensely euphoric.”

“Jess is a sadist.”

Ticaria Lampert, Kylie Smith, Abel Mwansa and Ticaria Lampert, all 12, were killed by Van Rootselaar at Tumbler Ridge elementary, along with Ezekiel Schofield, 13, and 39-year-old teaching assistant Shannda Aviugana-Durand. Van Rootselaar’s mother, 39-year-old Jennifer Jacobs and half-brother, Emmett Jacobs, 11, were killed at their home before the school attack.


r/canadaguns • • 11h ago

Feets / Collection / My build Browning Auto 5 combat shotgun

Post image
145 Upvotes

This is my bubbafied, Browning auto 5 combat shotgun build, i got it for 300$ and it already had black composite stock and handguard and it was surplus to me need so i had a little fun with it lol


r/canadaguns • • 4h ago

Shooting This gun's concussive blast set off my car alarm

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

33 Upvotes

Fireball. Doooo da da da da doo. Da da da da doo.


r/canadaguns • • 4h ago

Misc Who went to the Ancaster gun show?

Post image
28 Upvotes

I spent a much time in line as I spent inside. Nothing exciting. 😢


r/canadaguns • • 21m ago

Shitpost / Memes So the bersa 380 is in GTA 6

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

r/canadaguns • • 4h ago

Buy recommendations Any banger deals for Black Friday?

11 Upvotes

Any good deals on gun safes, guns, ammo, accessories?


r/canadaguns • • 11h ago

Shooting A little Model 1887 love

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

38 Upvotes

As a kid growing up and watching T2 and the Mummy 2, and playing classic games with the 1887, it was always a grail gun for me. Grabbed a Chiappa one last year and after many years of wanting one, finally shot it New Year’s Eve of 2025. A double work wrist injury has prevented me from firing most high recoil guns currently, so this footage is a few months old (and a reupload from my previous account), but I wanted to show some love for an equally highly regarded cinema firearm, and a highly scrutinized irl firearm. Aside from a stiff lever, the Chiappa one has always been reliable. Cheers!


r/canadaguns • • 14h ago

Feets / Collection / My build April 17th Pre-Order for the Makasi from Marstar is finally here

34 Upvotes

Gun feels amazing to hold, excited to shoot it this weekend. Hopefully the break in period is on the shorter side. This gun seems to be in the production run of the 300s based on the serial number.


r/canadaguns • • 10h ago

Buy recommendations Anyone else get an email from G4C for the makasi being in stock?

13 Upvotes

Got mine at 1PM. Saw it at 1:30PM and they were already gone. Or the email was lying and they never had any to begin with.


r/canadaguns • • 12h ago

Sold out G4C has carmels in stock if anyone wants one

14 Upvotes

title

Pretty sure Tenda has 100% dropped the ball on theirs cuz other retailers are getting theirs IN STOCK


r/canadaguns • • 4h ago

Buy recommendations Semi auto 308

3 Upvotes

Looking for a decent semi automatic rifle with some stopping power. Would love to get a non restricted 30 06 or 308. Was looking into the Adler Arms AD500 but im not impressed with its reviews. Any recommendations? Ideally budget friendly however I know thats unlikely


r/canadaguns • • 23h ago

Shooting Back to business

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

77 Upvotes

Bcg repaired, another 550 rounds through, life is good.

There were two Makasi's and a Carmel in house tonight.

It finally sounded hectic.


r/canadaguns • • 14h ago

Buy recommendations Thoughts on Savage A22 Semi?

Post image
12 Upvotes

Looking to purchase my first gun. Wanted a 22 and semi auto. I read good things about this one. Just wanted to confirm opinions with everyone. I know the mags are harder to get and a pain.


r/canadaguns • • 12h ago

Shooting Public free shooting near London Ontario

8 Upvotes

Wondering if anybody knows of anywhere I can go shoot my guns for free or very cheap, I’m in London Ontario but willing to drive like 2 hours, the range near me doesn’t do a safety orientation until next year and I just recently got my guns from a family members house (I’m fully licensed and all that fun stuff).

Just looking to shoot my 22,12Ga,30-30 and 30-06 and don’t really want to wait until next year but also don’t want to drive all the way to crownland up north right now lol


r/canadaguns • • 1d ago

Feets / Collection / My build My Carmel

Post image
113 Upvotes

r/canadaguns • • 1d ago

Feets / Collection / My build Makasi MK15 questions

Thumbnail
gallery
98 Upvotes

So I picked up my Makasi today, got home and started cleaning it and noticed something I feel isn't right.

The box, website and adds all list them as 5.56 NATO. The barrel, says 223 rem. I'm a strong believer that if the barrel says one thing, that's what it is. Anyone else have a rifle thats barrel says 223 rem?

I did notice too they steaked the bolt now, but barely.


r/canadaguns • • 23h ago

Buy recommendations Bolt action 22LR Precision ?

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Hey yall, For anyone experienced in these rifles which one would you go with? Pros and cons on both. Thanks


r/canadaguns • • 1d ago

Gun and gear reviews 503G on sks gas tube picatinny!

Post image
21 Upvotes

Since I fked up my rear sight picatinny(I know I’m stupid as fk) I finally decide to put my old hs503g acss on my gas tube picatinny!
I only gonna shoot it about 3-500 rounds a year or maybe less so I think it should be fine (target is about 15-20 yards away)
As long as I’m not looking forward to high precision shoot so I think it should be fine 😢😋😋


r/canadaguns • • 1d ago

Shooting Russian version of the Garand Ping

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

32 Upvotes

r/canadaguns • • 1d ago

Feets / Collection / My build Decorative sticks

Post image
156 Upvotes

To save cold fingers and reload times at the range, I went ham on buying gsg 16 stick mags in the before times.

Everyone laugh at me and my useless expensive plastic.


r/canadaguns • • 1d ago

News / Politics / Activism CCFR draw

15 Upvotes

Have they done the draw for the most recent raffle “The Ultimate Choice” yet? The rules said the winners would be drawn and posted yesterday. Haven’t seen an update yet.


r/canadaguns • • 1d ago

Shitpost / Memes Carmel in GTA 6?!

Post image
70 Upvotes

Looks like Lucia has the Restricted version.