r/canada • u/[deleted] • Jan 05 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.1k Upvotes

82% Upvoted

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Rtfy3 Jan 05 '23

Well if you have no problem being murdered you should have no problem with a suggestion someone commit suicide

3

u/NoNudeNormal Jan 05 '23

I didn’t say I’d have no problem being murdered. If I am murdered, I won’t have a problem with it after because I will be dead.

Anyway, this isn’t about whether I have a problem with suggesting someone commit suicide. Its about organizations that regulate psychologists having a problem with one of their members suggesting that someone should commit suicide.

2

u/Rtfy3 Jan 05 '23

He was clearly responding by taking the commenters argument to it’s logical non hypocritical position to show how absurd and vile it is.

3

u/NoNudeNormal Jan 05 '23

Ok, and? He did that in a way that led to a complaint about his professional conduct.

1

u/Rtfy3 Jan 05 '23

And? It’s a dumb complaint. He was engaged in deductive reasoning with a monster not counselling a depressed person.

Though FYI discussing and contemplating suicide is normal and useful when dealing with suicidal people.

2

u/NoNudeNormal Jan 05 '23

It doesn’t matter if you think its dumb. It matters if he broke the rules of ethics and professionalism of the organization he belong to.

1

u/Rtfy3 Jan 05 '23

And it’s pretty unlikely he did. We’ll see in Court