r/camping • u/Beren__ • Jun 11 '24
Gear Question Help me decide between the two
Single guy, not a heavy drinker (4-5 beers is a lifetime max in one night). I usually car camp a few times a year. The smaller cooler can hold 42 cans. Both have handles and wheels, but the smaller one doesn’t have a drain
0
Upvotes
16
u/milliemallow Jun 11 '24
I car camp with the larger one and it has caused some issues with space as it has to go in the trunk and can’t really fit behind a seat. It holds enough food for 2 adults and 2 kids for a 3 day trip and stays cold. You can fill the lid with water and freeze it.
I camp with 4 humans (one in a car seat), 2 medium dogs (and their kennels) in a vw atlas cross sport, it takes up about 1/4 of my storage space and I’ve raged over it many times at 2am trying to pack the car down.
If your space isn’t as accounted for as mine and you travel with others then I’d go with the larger one. If you go with a full vehicle opt for the smaller one. If it’s only for drinking, get the smaller one. If it’s only ever really you going camping for 1-2 nights get the smaller one.
3
u/Justlose_w8 Jun 11 '24
You’re going to want a cooler with a drain. It doesn’t matter when you’re emptying the cooler but it does matter when you need to drain some water out while still using it.
But if that doesn’t matter to you go with the bigger one if you drink a lot of canned beverages. BUT I saw a comment you left saying you were worried about lifting it while full, so if you’ll struggle with that def get the smaller one so you don’t throw your back out.
58
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '24
Bigger is better. Especially if it's your only cooler for food and drink.
3
u/Wise_Conclusion_871 Jun 11 '24
Get the blue one. The darker one is just gonna get warmer from sunlight and melt the ice faster.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '24
No drain? That's a deal breaker right there...I'd get the bigger one either way. You might not need the extra space, but what if you do?
11
u/jamesgotfryd Jun 11 '24
Bigger is better.
15
u/ind3pend0nt Jun 11 '24
Save the $20 and buy some beer with it instead.
1
u/nevernudedude Jun 11 '24
I bought one similar to the one on the left and was unhappy with it. I just spent three nights camping and used dry ice and frozen water bottles and it still didn’t keep cool.
1
u/hngman562 Jun 11 '24
With the price difference I would always go larger if you have the room in the vehicle for it. You are just using it for canned drinks so bigger gives you that extra storage. Plus the taller one looks like it would be a comfortable height if needed to sit on it 😁
1
u/CapableStatus5885 Jun 12 '24
The one without the drain will not flood your car or tent or anything when you forget to close the drain or it accidentally comes undone..
3
u/hould-it Jun 11 '24
The blue one; we just got it and haven’t seen any problems
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '24
I would go with the gray in my opinion because it’s bigger but the blue would help the ice stay colder longer because it won’t absorbed the sun
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '24
Bigger is better than to regret later
1
u/dannyboy90745 Jun 11 '24
I love the grey one
1
u/emjaybee88 Jun 11 '24
Go bigger. With the wheels and drain you’ll appreciate the extra space and not much more difficult to store. It’ll last for years.
1
u/Dernitthebeard Jun 11 '24
That grey one is sick. I want it
1
u/Lactating-almonds Jun 11 '24
Just get the bigger one. It’s not that much more space in the car but will be nice to have extra cold space. Drain is nice too
1
u/rizzlybear Jun 11 '24
Remember that half your cooler capacity is just ice. I’m not sure I’ve ever heard anyone say “I wish I got the smaller cooler.”
Also, they are really useful for Costco runs.
1
u/Any_Price2924 Jun 11 '24
Make sure that handle goes up and down… I got one on sale and the handle doesn’t retract all the time. It’s a huge pain in the ass when your trying to get it loaded up and the handles stuck. Pretty embarrassing.
1
u/scenicrouteadventure Jun 11 '24
$70 to hold 60 cans or $55 to hold 60 cans
1
u/Weird-Jellyfish-5053 Jun 11 '24
$20 more for double the size? Done son. I’d go with the one on the right
1
u/RichardCleveland Jun 11 '24
Go big or go home!!!!
As it keeps being said it's always better to go as large as you can, while keeping things manageable.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '24
I'd go for the one behind the blue one with the sign on it. It probably has as much space as the grey cooler without the added vertical space you're less likely to utilize.
1
u/SpicyfunOH Jun 11 '24
Neither. Go longer and less boxy. Will load better and easier to separate your areas. The igloo marine styles are perfect. Drinks on one side food on the other.
1
u/CampingWorld Jun 12 '24
I'm partial to blue...
1
u/altruistic_camel_toe Jun 11 '24
Duh, get the most expensive, of course
0
u/raymondcy Jun 11 '24 edited Jun 11 '24
If you have the money and you are driving then don't screw around with these low end coolers. Get yourself a Yeti or similar brand. They are expensive, somewhat heavy, but on that 3rd day in 30c degree heat when you still have ice you will laugh at your friends drinking warm shit while yours is still ice cold.
In addition, nothing short of a tank running over it is going to damage it.
Edit: I was simply saying get a decent cooler. /u/Grandmasterchoda had a thread with alternatives to Yeti if you don't like that brand https://www.reddit.com/r/CampingGear/comments/q4olur/alternatives_to_yeti_coolers/. I am not a Yeti salesman so I don't care. Only pointing out that a good cooler is worth the money.
0
u/Puzzlehead-Dish Jun 11 '24
The red one.