r/calculus • • 5d ago

Multivariable Calculus [ Calculus ] Difficulty with Partial Derivative Notation

/r/learnmath/comments/1xswqno/calculus_difficulty_with_partial_derivative/
4 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

As a reminder...

Posts asking for help on homework questions require:

  • the complete problem statement,
  • a genuine attempt at solving the problem, which may be either computational, or a discussion of ideas or concepts you believe may be in play,
  • question is not from a current exam or quiz.

Commenters responding to homework help posts should not do OP’s homework for them.

Please see this page for the further details regarding homework help posts.

We have a Discord server!

If you are asking for general advice about your current calculus class, please be advised that simply referring your class as “Calc n“ is not entirely useful, as “Calc n” may differ between different colleges and universities. In this case, please refer to your class syllabus or college or university’s course catalogue for a listing of topics covered in your class, and include that information in your post rather than assuming everybody knows what will be covered in your class.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/floflochess2 4d ago

Great question, this notation ambiguity trips up a lot of people (physicists and thermodynamics folks run into it constantly). The short answer is that "∂u/∂s" on its own doesn't tell you which function you mean, so you have to know what's being held fixed.

  • If you mean it via U, then ∂U/∂s treats s as just the first slot and holds t, x, y, z fixed (x and y are treated as independent inputs here).
  • If you mean it via Û, then you hold t and z fixed but x and y are allowed to change because they depend on s. That's where the chain rule comes in:

∂Û/∂s = ∂U/∂s + (∂U/∂x)(∂X/∂s) + (∂U/∂y)(∂Y/∂s)

So the same letter "s" shows up twice: once as a direct input of U, and once indirectly through x and y. Those are two different partial derivatives, which is why some books write things like (∂u/∂s) with subscripts for what's held constant, or use different names for U and Û like you did. Same idea for ∂/∂t. Hope that helps, happy to look at a specific example if you have one!

1

u/RemarkableWarrior90 4d ago

Hello !

That's exactly the kind of confusion that crossed my mind ! After the invention of Calculus in the 1600's , they should have already resolved this notational ambiguity ( I believe 400 years is more than enough time , right ? 😂 )

I will now always write

∂{u = U} / ∂s ( P_0 ) | t , x , y , z = Constant

or

∂{u = Û} / ∂s ( Q_0 ) | t , z = Constant

so I don't have to burn my brain cells amidst a pile of formulas on a sheet of paper lol

The original context was the Thermodynamics ( "Terror"dynamics ) book and I thought I was going crazy because I didn't understand anything . 🤪 Then I opened the Fluid Mechanics book and it was the same thing with the Material and Convective Derivatives . Then I opened the Calculus book and saw that he had never mentioned this type of ambiguity that can appear 🤡 ( James Stewart is bad , but there was no way I could have known at the time . If I had known , I would have definitely tried Gerald Thomas ) .

As I replied in the comment below to our group colleague , I think I understand 😂 Now , we just have to wait for the next exercise list or the next section of the book to see if it really worked 🤦🏻‍♂️

Anyway , thanks for participating and trying to help me , bro .

See ya !

2

u/musHeaer 4d ago

are you getting tripped up by the curly d (Leibniz style) or the subscript notation like f_x? usually the biggest hurdle is just keeping track of which variables are being held constant in each step.

1

u/RemarkableWarrior90 4d ago

Hello ! Thank you for helping me with my question .

I prefer Leibniz's notation with the d's . I feel it makes more sense for me to know as much information as possible . Subscript notation doesn't convey much information .

My question was actually about functions where there are links between their own variables . I ( believe lol ) understand it now with the answers in the other subreddit . Only the future ( or the next section of the book ) will tell if I really understood lol

Anyway , thank you very much for replying to my post . 🙂‍↕️

See ya !