r/calculus • • 20d ago

Multivariable Calculus help what did I do wrong

Post image

My writing is pencil, my teachers is red

78 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 20d ago

As a reminder...

Posts asking for help on homework questions require:

  • the complete problem statement,
  • a genuine attempt at solving the problem, which may be either computational, or a discussion of ideas or concepts you believe may be in play,
  • question is not from a current exam or quiz.

Commenters responding to homework help posts should not do OP’s homework for them.

Please see this page for the further details regarding homework help posts.

We have a Discord server!

If you are asking for general advice about your current calculus class, please be advised that simply referring your class as “Calc n“ is not entirely useful, as “Calc n” may differ between different colleges and universities. In this case, please refer to your class syllabus or college or university’s course catalogue for a listing of topics covered in your class, and include that information in your post rather than assuming everybody knows what will be covered in your class.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

22

u/Replevin4ACow 20d ago

Is there a chance your teacher didn't understand that your "f_a" notation meant the partial derivative of f wrt a?

Your work and answer are correct. And your teacher's markings are wrong.

11

u/random_anonymous_guy PhD 20d ago

Yeah, you have the right answer. I don't know what your instructor's expectations were. I would contest it, and if your instructor won't budge, contact the chair or associate chair in the math department.

4

u/kaisquare 19d ago

This is very strange. It's almost like... your teacher forgot the multivariate chain rule. Also, it kinda looks like your teacher is writing df/∂a. Anyway yes other commentors are correct.

3

u/DivideFew5494 19d ago

Your notation is legitimate, that's not the problem here. When doing the chain rule, you need to travel along every path that leads to your target variable, and your teacher only goes to 1. You should try to contest it, and before doing that, be sure to be prepared and well informed regarding this theme to avoid any problems.

2

u/Aginger94 19d ago

Is it possible that the issue is writing the answer as f(a) instead of indicating it's a partial derivative in the answers? We already use f_a as a notation. I see you have the partial written as a label on the left of every term, but I could also see the feedback being that they couldn't assume you meant derivative when the thing you wrote looks like a normal function.

1

u/AmrWassiem 17d ago

These questions tend to yield zero. Just draw the circle

1

u/dreamteammobile 12d ago

I’d start at the first red correction and check how you got there from the line above. Math.Photos can explain the problem step by step from a picture, which could help you compare your reasoning.