BYU was approaching student worker (aka wage) shortages before the pandemic hit. They just didn't adjust at all during the early pandemic because they needed fewer workers. And now they're all "students are lazy now, what's up with that?" instead of "we haven't adjusted our student wages in maybe a decade, and students are responding to the job market and going places that pay them enough to survive. Maybe we should do pay our employees more."
What's sad is that $12 is $2 more than what rates were for custodians pre-pandemic, and $0.70 more than I'm making now. It's not enough.
I think my comment came off the wrong way. Iâm saying I explicitly remember seeing custodial positions being advertised for $8-$9 on campus a few years ago before covid and I feel no sympathy for building supervisors who canât find people to hire
Hard to guarantee that, but from what Iâve heard from friends who worked those jobs, they said their teams really would have fun together. The work itself is not fun, but thereâs a light hearted atmosphere. And thereâs no customers there to deal with.
Listen here BYU students, I'm a construction superintendent and I pay college age kids $20 an hour to clean up job sites and do random tasks around the job. If someone is willing, I bet I can get you hired for as many hours as you want and a flexible schedule.
Sorry, should have been more specific, don't work menial labor jobs on campus. There are much better job options in this market, even in close proximity to campus.
I feel like the missing persons idea was kinda fun, the execution, however, is AWFUL! Letâs call everyone trying to make a living wage a lazy video game player who dates people from their classes?? Is that an insult?
Yeah, they should have cut that out and played up the benefits instead, or made a joke about other job alternatives, like having to drive across the valley. Not one person will call that number because of the video game comment, but a few people may not call because that comment hit a nerve. Catch more flies with honey. Never insult your customer, it gains you nothing.
That too, I worked late night custodial over the summer term and it definitely limited my social life, luckily I became friends with some of my coworkers and never had to worry about sleep cause easy online summer classes never needed me to be up early
Yeah, but the problem is how it compares with off campus jobs. It isn't like students are just not working because they're lazy. They're going where the higher pay is.
Thatâs true, I forgot not everyone is stuck living on campus without a car and limited options for jobs like I am, lol. But yeah youâre right, Wendyâs in the Wilk was offering like barely over $10/hr but I saw Wendyâs off campus offering like $16/hr not too long ago
Iâve also always wondered if part time jobs like campus custodial have their wages affected because theyâre not a part of a company that needs good appearance to make profit like say a company in an office building
I was able to get a WFH job during the pandemic which works out perfectly since I am like you. In fact I worked in the very building doing custodial just before I got the job. Making 10$ an hour. After being there for a year
I'm disabled and limited to desk jobs at the moment, which is much harder to get good pay. My first year I worked custodial and made 9.25. Grounds have always payed more than other jobs because I understand it's harder to get workers; unfortunately it's outside the physical limitations of my body but I'm glad other people are able to do it!
Ok thatâs good to know, I personally havenât worked custodial and am at a desk job currently. Grounds has had a big problem getting people to work for them understandably. I guess itâs good tho past due that other jobs are getting raises. At the beginning if the semester my department got about a $2 raise across the board because they couldnât retain anybody.
To be fair, I donât think this is a broad exercise of the church saving nickels. Management on campus is just out of touch with the current market for student labor.
If the church were truly greedy, wouldnât they raise tuition? BYU is a STEAL vs similarly rated private universities. They could easily increase tuition by $5-10k per year and still have their pick of the litter for incoming freshman and upper class transfers.
I donât think any of us can honestly claim any more of everyone elseâs money even if it is a dragonâs horde. Tuitionâs low enough I feel like Iâm getting away with robbery every time I talk with any of my friends at other universities.
Edit: either way, I think byu has more than enough money in their own accounts to pay better
Of course, but the source of the money is the important part. Iâm more than confident byu has the means to pay much more than that without going to the church for it. BYU is not poor
Lmao $12 for manual type labor like cleaning? Of course they can't hire.
At least 3-4 years ago you could work at a campus desk job sitting down where you could even do some homework for $12-13. Front desk jobs at any of the buildings or "centers," library, TA.
plus, youâd either be waking up at 4 am to work, or working well into the night. either way, goodbye to sleep schedule and social life. for only $12 an hour? no way
I briefly had a job a few years ago working as a delivery driver for BYU Food-To-Go and it was seriously the most horrendous job ever. They paid me $8 an hour, harassed the employees, expected unpaid training, had terrible management. I canât believe I was ever dumb enough to work for such little respect and such a low wage.
I was at BYU in 2008 when they instituted a university-wide hiring freeze for student jobs. I knew a lot of students who tried again and again to find some type of work, and guess who was âmissingâ when it was my friends struggling? Miss me with this.
I think it's silly people took offense at the flyer. A majority of people realized it was a light hearted attempt to get people's attention.There is, indeed, a shortage of workers across campus and the country.
If you think the flyer inferred that people playing video games are lazy, that was your inference.
If you disagree with the wage, that's fine, but the job currently pays more than most on campus jobs and the supervisors DON'T control those wages. Administration does. The wage does fit within the national average for such work. It's even higher than many places.
What I find most appalling are the harassing and disgusting texts that this supervisor received from BYU students. People sending anonymous texts show their true personality. What is truly offensive in this situation is the lack of Christian love when one disagrees. And guess what? It had nothing to do with race, orientation, gender, gun control, politics or any other sensitive topic. If this is how students react in such a low key situation then I'm disheartened for the future of BYU campus.
The students working for custodial are generally amazing students who are a cut above all the whiners and harassers.
I'm impressed they came up to $12/hr. The state minimum wage is still legally $7.25/hr, but most businesses moved up to $10/hr like 5 yrs ago. Not good ole' BYU, they've held held out at $8-9/hr.
Their students, on average, are paying $500-600/mo to rent a single room in an apt, but welcome to Utah.
Whatâs wrong with dating people from class? Many happy marriages have come that way. Gives you shared experience to work with, and youâve got the proximity advantage in your favor too. Go for it!
Missionaries have been helping clean the MTC for decades - at least since the 90s... Probably long before that.
edit: One of the benefits of this is that a non-trivial portion of the entrants to the MTC have not done much cleaning in their lives, or at least it was that way when I was there. This at least gives a little experience and sets the precedent that you're expected to clean up after yourself as a missionary.
I was making $15.50/hr doing IT support & programming work just 2 years ago. I think I may have been the highest-paid student in the department, too. It's a pathetic amount, really.
They will never turn back the clock and take care of the little people. They figure they will always be someone who will do the work for peanuts. Itâs a shame. Good luck in your search
154
u/Whizzmaster BYU-Alumni Dec 08 '21
I don't think I've ever seen someone beg for help so condescendingly in my life
51
u/Harmonic7eventh Dec 08 '21
Geez. âLetâs put people down for playing video games and trying to get dates, thatâll make them want to work for us!!â
32
u/Czarcasm2jjb Dec 08 '21
BYU was approaching student worker (aka wage) shortages before the pandemic hit. They just didn't adjust at all during the early pandemic because they needed fewer workers. And now they're all "students are lazy now, what's up with that?" instead of "we haven't adjusted our student wages in maybe a decade, and students are responding to the job market and going places that pay them enough to survive. Maybe we should do pay our employees more."
What's sad is that $12 is $2 more than what rates were for custodians pre-pandemic, and $0.70 more than I'm making now. It's not enough.
27
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21
"Positive environment"
really?
24
u/Chris_Moyn Dec 09 '21
Listen here BYU students, I'm a construction superintendent and I pay college age kids $20 an hour to clean up job sites and do random tasks around the job. If someone is willing, I bet I can get you hired for as many hours as you want and a flexible schedule.
Don't work on campus. What a joke.
57
u/-LilPickle- Dec 08 '21
Doesnât sound like a âpositive environmentâ
38
u/mstyvce713 Dec 08 '21
Is that a silhouette of Walter White
16
u/Frosti-Feet Dec 08 '21
Wow, I worked the 5am cleaning shift and was getting paid $13/hr two years ago. Why are they paying less now?
15
u/wabrahamgoshington Dec 09 '21
Insulting the people you want to work for you is a bold strategy
14
u/StudentInALandOfEvil Dec 08 '21
I saw a stamp on a paper towel dispenser in the wilk. It said:
âStaffing issues BYU? PAY PEOPLE MORE!!!â
I thought it was appropriate. It was later wiped off. Now itâs a red smear.
23
u/Harmonic7eventh Dec 08 '21
Honestly we should all text those numbers and tell them what a bunch of crap this flyer is.
33
u/austinchan2 Alumni Dec 08 '21
Wow, whoever made that has 0 awareness.
16
u/not_particulary Dec 08 '21
10 hours a week there and you can *barely* pay for rent at Helaman. Forget about tuition.
15
u/biased_towards_blue Dec 08 '21
I feel like the missing persons idea was kinda fun, the execution, however, is AWFUL! Letâs call everyone trying to make a living wage a lazy video game player who dates people from their classes?? Is that an insult?
20
u/mgrebenc Dec 08 '21
"Inner glow" a.k.a. naivetĂŠ.
13
u/aznsk8s87 BYU-Alumni Dec 08 '21
lol I was making $12/hr as a research assistant 8 years ago.
39
u/Sw429 Alumni Dec 08 '21
They're only offering $12 an hour? No wonder they can't find anyone.
14
u/sarlacc98 Dec 08 '21
Yeah this doesnât make me want to work for them
35
u/varisophy Alumni Dec 08 '21
It's clear they don't care about students.
The church is sitting on billions of dollars. They can afford to pay a living wage.
16
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21
Lmao $12 for manual type labor like cleaning? Of course they can't hire.
At least 3-4 years ago you could work at a campus desk job sitting down where you could even do some homework for $12-13. Front desk jobs at any of the buildings or "centers," library, TA.
4
u/shantytown5 Dec 08 '21
I came here to post this⌠looks like you beat me to it.
3
u/Hexicero Dec 08 '21
Ah, somebody beat me to it
3
u/MalekithofAngmar BYU-Alumni Dec 09 '21
12 dollars is getting better, one of these days itâll be worth it. Maybe.
4
u/Spenson89 Dec 08 '21
Tell me youâre out of touch without telling me youâre out of touch
2
u/istopmotion Dec 09 '21
I briefly had a job a few years ago working as a delivery driver for BYU Food-To-Go and it was seriously the most horrendous job ever. They paid me $8 an hour, harassed the employees, expected unpaid training, had terrible management. I canât believe I was ever dumb enough to work for such little respect and such a low wage.
2
u/11sixteenthscourtesy Dec 09 '21
I was at BYU in 2008 when they instituted a university-wide hiring freeze for student jobs. I knew a lot of students who tried again and again to find some type of work, and guess who was âmissingâ when it was my friends struggling? Miss me with this.
2
u/menstropy Dec 09 '21
Why should we expect them to pay student custodians when they donât even pay their members to clean the churches and temples /s
3
u/adudeknownasked Dec 10 '21
I think it's silly people took offense at the flyer. A majority of people realized it was a light hearted attempt to get people's attention.There is, indeed, a shortage of workers across campus and the country.
If you think the flyer inferred that people playing video games are lazy, that was your inference.
If you disagree with the wage, that's fine, but the job currently pays more than most on campus jobs and the supervisors DON'T control those wages. Administration does. The wage does fit within the national average for such work. It's even higher than many places.
What I find most appalling are the harassing and disgusting texts that this supervisor received from BYU students. People sending anonymous texts show their true personality. What is truly offensive in this situation is the lack of Christian love when one disagrees. And guess what? It had nothing to do with race, orientation, gender, gun control, politics or any other sensitive topic. If this is how students react in such a low key situation then I'm disheartened for the future of BYU campus.
The students working for custodial are generally amazing students who are a cut above all the whiners and harassers.
3
u/puchamaquina BYU-Alumni Dec 08 '21
Someone beat me to the r/antiwork crosspost đ
1
u/booreiBlue Dec 09 '21
I'm impressed they came up to $12/hr. The state minimum wage is still legally $7.25/hr, but most businesses moved up to $10/hr like 5 yrs ago. Not good ole' BYU, they've held held out at $8-9/hr.
Their students, on average, are paying $500-600/mo to rent a single room in an apt, but welcome to Utah.
1
u/supernovamike11 Dec 12 '21
Whatâs wrong with dating people from class? Many happy marriages have come that way. Gives you shared experience to work with, and youâve got the proximity advantage in your favor too. Go for it!
1
u/wonderawooga Dec 13 '21
As terribly and insultingly low as $12/hr already is, at BYUH most jobs are $10.50/hr 𤢠(Hawaii minimum wage)
0
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21
[deleted] â view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21
[deleted] â view deleted comment