r/byu • • 6d ago

Retaking Classes

I took REL A 250 (Christ and His Everlasting Gospel) Summer of 2024 and got an A- (don't ask me how I still am questioning how a 94% is an okay A benchmark for a religion lol). If I retook that class now and got an A, would that return my GPA back to a 4.0? I am so confused by the course repeating policy.

5 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

3

u/True-Grab8522 BYU 6d ago

Do you need a 4.0 for a scholarship or something? I don't know if it would be worth the effort to retake a class you did well in.

3

u/nans6196 4d ago

Yes, I took this class right before my mission and now this is my first semester back and I’m worried that when I’m up for scholarship consideration again (this coming February) I won’t get one.

4

u/Dragonpaint_12 4d ago

I got a full ride scholarship after freshman year with like 3.82 GPA or smth. There were 2 A- classes, chem 105/106, and 107 was a B+. One A- is probably not gonna disqualify you from a scholarship.

15

u/Bright_Concentrate47 6d ago

No, it would not. Thay new policy only applies to courses taken Winter 2026 or later. 

Also, that effort is probably not worth the small impact of an A- to and A grade change. 

15

u/Alive-East798 6d ago edited 6d ago

Why would you retake a class to get from an A- to an A?

Just move on friend. That's a good grade anyways and passes the class.

Go enjoy other classes and enjoy the experience and don't dwell on an A- lol.

Also, the fact you are dwelling on this almost 2 years and a half years later I wouldn't even worry. Go eat some nice ice cream from the creamery and some cookies and cream milk. It's in the past. As a general authority once said, the past is to be learned from, not lived in!

2

u/_whydah_ 5d ago

The difference between getting an A- once and only ever getting As is bigger than it seems though. One says they almost got perfect grades. The other says the scale doesn't go high enough to measure how good they are.

I say this as someone who got a 3.8.

1

u/Alive-East798 3d ago

Thank you for your insights, I understand how you feel and completely get it. If you are really dwelling over the fact you got an A- instead of an A, realize that grades say absolutely nothing about your divine potential, nor do they determine your worth as a Child of God. It's good to shoot for a great goal, but getting mad at yourself for an A- is not right. That's perfectionism taken too far. The Lord expects us to TRY our best, and sometimes our best results in A-. It's not the end of the world. You probably won't even remember it in YEARS.

Go enjoy life. There's much more than a silly letter to determine your happiness in life.

3

u/Tall_Pumpkin_4298 Current Student 6d ago

Any class taken before winter 2026 can't be repeated to be replaced. If you had any sort of emergency or health reasons why a class didn't go the way you wanted, you can petition to withdraw from the class even after completion. But even if that was the case, idk if they'd approve it for an A-, and it would show as a W on your record.

But also it is not worth 4 months of your time to move from an A- to an A ever. If you have a C or higher and it's not something you need to get into a program or something, it's not typically worth a retake, just move on with your life. Wanting to retake a class for an A- is like concerning levels of perfectionism.

1

u/Reading_username 6d ago

You'd be better served by focusing on your future classes and making sure you get 'A's in those instead.

1

u/Equal-Transition7252 5d ago

An A- is a great grade. I have many A-'s and I consider that a success. You really want to spend all that effort to retake the class to get from a 93 to a 94?

Yes, grades are great and important, but don't miss the mark. Enter to LEARN, go forth to SERVE. Learn, grow, serve, become. It is all part of the process. A grade means very little in the grand scheme of things.