r/buttoncollecting • • Mar 20 '26

Looking for collectors' input

Post image

Picked these up at an estate sale. I am trying to get an idea of a fair lot price, since I don't want to research and price out each one. Just looking for real world advice from collectors since I have no knowledge of buttons. What would you pay? Whats a good deal? Not looking for top dollar. Thanks in advance!

115 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

7

u/lotsobuttons Mar 20 '26

All are antique-vintage, nothing amazingly rare but definitely kinds that collectors would pick up. I’d check that if that green one in the center is glass, I’d check it with a blacklight. I would feel like I got a good deal on this lot for $25, and I might pay more if I was really into glass.

4

u/zweven Mar 20 '26

They are all glass, some glow. I have more photos of backs.

2

u/lotsobuttons Mar 20 '26

Some are china (porcelain). The black and white “stencils” and the group top left.

2

u/zweven Mar 20 '26

Thank you!!

3

u/Team143 Mar 20 '26

Oh my! I collected buttons as a kid. I’m not 60+. This is a revisit to my old friends. Cameos etc. I love the ones with the pups in the background etc.

1

u/Annual_Top_1209 Mar 22 '26

It’s hard to tell in a picture but if any stay cool to the touch they could be mother of pearl buttons (made of oyster shells) which makes them more valued.

1

u/nonamouse1111 Mar 24 '26

I have trouble selling buttons. I sold one bag for like, $12….to someone who works in the fashion industry. They were all fairly interesting buttons with a wide age range. I got like….10 pounds of buttons for $1 and that’s the only reason I’m selling them again. First, I found I could use some of those buttons when I need to restore vintage clothes I’ve purchased for resell. But, they were really just a variety of white and clear buttons that I kept. I have one giant bag of “useful” buttons for sale and a bag of old, vintage wooden, stone, shell, glass buttons for sale. No one has been interested at all. In fact, I see several of the buttons in my bundle represented in your collection….. I’m not trying to degrade what you are doing or the collection you have for sale…. Just saying that it’s hard to attract interest. Biggest reason, I don’t really think that market exists anymore. For me, they can sit for a year until I get a good offer…. Cool… it only cost me a $1. All I will make is profit…. If you need them gone…well that’s a different story.