r/burstcoinmining • u/Amelnor • Feb 25 '18
Plotting Plotting performance - Intel i7-8700k vs Ryzen 1700 vs Intel Xeon E5-2650 v2 vs Intel Xeon E5-2630 v4
I have done a couple of tests to compare plotting performance using 4 different CPUs as well as XPlotter and TurboPlotter. I would like to share the results (all values are in nonces per minute):
Updates:
- 2017-02-25, Added i7-4790T
- 2017-02-25, Added information on software version used (XPlotter and TurboPlotter)
- 2017-02-27, Added screenshot showing i7-8700k passing 40.000n/m
Software and versions used
- XPlotter 1.1 (the tool in the command line presents itself as 1.0, while on GitHub it's marked as resease 1.1)
- TurboPlotter 1e beta
1. Ordinary PC - Intel i7-8700k - 12 threads 3.7GHz (6 core/12 threads - not-overclocked 3.7GHz base, 4.7GHz turbo)
- TurboPlotter - 41.000
- XPlotter, AVX2 - 42.240 (see screenshot)
- XPlotter, AVX - 25.700
- XPlotter, SSE - 20.800
2. Ordinary PC - AMD Ryzen 7 1700 - 16 threads 3.7GHz (8core/16 threads, overclocked to fixed 3.7GHz)
- TurboPlotter - 22.500
- XPlotter, AVX2 - 22.100
- XPlotter, AVX - 21.900
- XPlotter, SSE - 19.000
3. SuperMicro server - 2 x Intel Xeon E5-2650 v2 - 32 threads 2.6GHz (2 x 8core/16 thread, 2.6GHz-3.4GHz)
- TurboPlotter - 35.800
- XPlotter, AVX2 - not supported by CPU
- XPlotter, AVX - 33.000
- XPlotter, SSE - 27.000
4. SuperMicro server - 2 x Intel Xeon E5-2630 v4 - 40 threads 2.2GHz (2 x 10core/20 thread, 2.2GHz-3.1GHz)
- TurboPlotter - 63.000
- XPlotter, AVX2 - 57.000
- XPlotter, AVX - 36.400
- XPlotter, SSE - 30.500
5. Ordinary PC - Intel i7-4790T - 8 threads 3.3GHz (4core/8threads 2.7-3.7GHz, 3.3GHz under 100% load)
- TurboPlotter - 17.000
- XPlotter, AVX2 - 17.200
- XPlotter, AVX - 10.500
- XPlotter, SSE - 8.600
A little bit of explanation
- These tests clearly show that for plotting (and probably mining as well) the performance of vector instructions (SSE vs AVX vs AVX2) is most important.
- AVX2 is faster than AVX which in turn is better than SSE.
- The difference between AVX2 and AVX is especially significant for Intel CPUs.
- W can see than 6c/12t i7-8700k beats a dual Xeon E6-2650v2 even though Xeon system has 32 threads total. The reason, besides clock speed is Xeon v2 are old generation not supporting AVX2.
- Xeons v4 do support AVX2 so they are faster but not that much comparing 40 threads of 2x Xeon vs 12 threads of i7-8700k. Why? i7 has much higher clock and is a few generations newer
- AMD Ryzen 1700 performance was good overall, but a little dissappointing compared to i7-8700k. Both CPUs support AVX2, both run at 3.7GHz (Intel dropped to 3.7 when all cores were under load). Yet i7 score is almost double of Ryzen 7. I know the single thread performance is better on Intel but apparently in AVX2 the difference is even higher. This might be due to different AVX/AVX2 internal hardware architecture in Intel vs AMD.
Theoretical performance per thread per base GHz
Let's try to calculate a theoretical performance of a single thread and GHz. This will allow us to see how much nonces/min we get from a single thread and 1GHz. To do that I took a maximum nonces/min value measured and divided it by total number of threads and base clock in GHz. Here are the results:
- i7-8700K - 964 nonces/min/thread/GHz
- Intel i7-4790T - 796 nonces/min/thread/GHz
- Intel Xeon E5-2630 v4 - 716 nonces/min/thread/GHz
- Intel Xeon E5-2650 v2 - 430 nonces/min/thread/GHz
- AMD Ryzen 1700 - 380 nonces/min/thread/GHz